Contents


The Spike (1931)
A Hanging (1931)
Bookshop Memories (1936)
Shooting an Elephant (1936)
Down the Mine (1937) (From "The Road to Wigan Pier")
North and South (1937) (From "The Road to Wigan Pier")
Spilling the Spanish Beans (1937)
Marrakech (1939)
Boys' Weeklies and Frank Richards's Reply (1940)
Charles Dickens (1940)
Charles Reade (1940)
Inside the Whale (1940)
The Art of Donald McGill (1941)
The Lion and the Unicorn: Socialism and the English Genius (1941)
Review of Mein Kampf  (1940)
Wells, Hitler and the World State (1941)
Looking Back on the Spanish War (1942)
Rudyard Kipling (1942)
Mark Twain--The Licensed Jester (1943)
Poetry and the Microphone (1943)
W B Yeats (1943)
Arthur Koestler (1944)
Benefit of Clergy: Some Notes on Salvador Dali (1944)
Raffles and Miss Blandish (1944)
Antisemitism in Britain (1945)
Freedom of the Park (1945)
Future of a Ruined Germany (1945)
Good Bad Books (1945)
In Defence Of P. G. Wodehouse (1945)
Nonsense Poetry (1945)
Notes on Nationalism (1945)
Revenge is Sour (1945)
The Sporting Spirit (1945)
You and the Atomic Bomb (1945)
A Good Word for the Vicar of Bray (1946)
A Nice Cup of Tea (1946)
Books vs. Cigarettes (1946)
Confessions of a Book Reviewer (1946)
Decline of the English Murder (1946)
How the Poor Die (1946)
James Burnham and the Managerial Revolution (1946)
Pleasure Spots (1946)
Politics and the English Language (1946)
Politics vs. Literature: an Examination of Gulliver's Travels (1946)
Riding Down from Bangor (1946)
Some Thoughts on the Common Toad (1946)
The Prevention of Literature (1946)
Why I Write (1946)
Lear, Tolstoy and the Fool (1947)
Such, Such were the Joys (1947)
Writers and Leviathan (1948)
Reflections on Gandhi (1949)





THE SPIKE



It was late-afternoon. Forty-nine of us, forty-eight men and one woman,
lay on the green waiting for the spike to open. We were too tired to talk
much.
We just sprawled about exhaustedly, with home-made cigarettes stick-
ing out of our scrubby faces.
Overhead the chestnut branches were covered
with blossom, and beyond that great woolly clouds floated almost motion-
less in a clear sky.
Littered on the grass, we seemed dingy, urban riff-
raff. We defiled the scene, like sardine-tins and paper bags on the sea-
shore.


What talk there was ran on the Tramp Major of this spike. He was a devil,
everyone agreed, a tartar, a tyrant, a bawling, blasphemous, uncharitable
dog. You couldn't call your soul your own when he was about,
and many a
tramp had he kicked out in the middle of the night for giving a back an-
swer. When You, came to be searched, he fair held you upside down and
shook you.
If you were caught with tobacco there was hell to. Pay, and if
you went in with money (which is against the law) God help you.

I had eightpence on me. 'For the love of Christ, mate,' the old hands ad-
vised me, 'don't you take it in. You'd get seven days for going into the
spike with eightpence!'

So I buried my money in a hole under the hedge, marking the spot with a
lump of flint. Then we set about smuggling our matches and tobacco, for
it is forbidden to take these into nearly all spikes, and one is supposed
to surrender them at the gate.
We hid them in our socks, except for the
twenty or so per cent who had no socks, and had to carry the tobacco in
their boots, even under their very toes. We stuffed our ankles with con-
traband until anyone seeing us might have imagined an outbreak of elephant-
iasis.
But is an unwritten law that even the sternest Tramp Majors do not
search below the knee, and in the end only one man was caught. This was
Scotty, a little hairy tramp with a bastard accent sired by cockney out
of Glasgow.
His tin of cigarette ends fell out of his sock at the wrong
moment, and was impounded.


At six, the gates swung open and we shuffled in. An official at the gate
entered our names and other particulars in the register and took our bun-
dles away from us. The woman was sent off to the workhouse, and we others
into the spike.
It was a gloomy, chilly, limewashed place, consisting only
of a bathroom and dining-room and about a hundred narrow stone cells.
The
terrible Tramp Major met us at the door and herded us into the bathroom to
be stripped and searched.
He was a gruff, soldierly man of forty, who gave
the tramps no more ceremony than sheep at the dipping-pond, shoving them
this way and that and shouting oaths in their faces.
But when he came to
myself, he looked hard at me, and said:

'You are a gentleman?'

'I suppose so,' I said.


He gave me another long look. 'Well, that's bloody bad luck, guv'nor,' he
said, 'that's bloody bad luck, that is.'
And thereafter he took it into
his head to treat me with compassion, even with a kind of respect.


It was a disgusting sight, that bathroom. All the indecent secrets of our
underwear were exposed; the grime, the rents and patches, the bits of
string doing duty for buttons, the layers upon layers of fragmentary gar-
ments, some of them mere collections of holes, held together by dirt. The
room became a press of steaming nudity, the sweaty odours of the tramps
competing with the sickly, sub-faecal stench native to the spike. Some of
the men refused the bath, and washed only their 'toe-rags', the horrid,
greasy little clouts which tramps bind round their feet.
Each of us had
three minutes in which to bathe himself. Six greasy, slippery roller towels
had to serve for the lot of us.

When we had bathed our own clothes were taken away from us, and we were
dressed in the workhouse shirts, grey cotton things like nightshirts, reach-
ing to the middle of the thigh.
Then we were sent into the dining-room,
where supper was set out on the deal tables.
It was the invariable spike
meal, always the same, whether breakfast, dinner or supper--
half a pound of
bread, a bit of margarine, and a pint of so-called tea. It took us five min-
utes to gulp down the cheap, noxious food.
Then the Tramp Major served us
with three cotton blankets each, and drove us off to our cells for the night.

The doors were locked on the outside a little before seven in the evening,
and would stay locked for the next twelve hours.

The cells measured eight feet by five, and, had no lighting apparatus except
a tiny, barred window high up in the wall, and a spyhole in the door.
There
were no bugs, and we had bedsteads and straw palliasses, rare luxuries both.

In many spikes one sleeps on a wooden shelf, and in some on the bare floor,
with a rolled-up coat for pillow. With a cell to myself, and a bed, I was hop-
ing for a sound night's rest. But I did not get it, for there is always some-
thing wrong in the spike, and the peculiar shortcoming here, as I discovered
immediately, was
the cold. May had begun, and in honour of the season--a lit-
tle sacrifice to the gods of spring, perhaps--the authorities had cut off the
steam from the hot pipes. The cotton blankets were almost useless.
One spent
the night in turning from side to side, falling asleep for ten minutes and
waking half frozen, and watching for dawn.


As always happens in the spike, I had at last managed to fall comfortably
asleep when it was time to get up. The Tramp Major came marching down the
passage with his heavy tread, unlocking the doors and yelling to us to show
a leg. Promptly the passage was full of squalid shirt-clad figures rushing
for the bathroom, for
there was only one tub full of water between us all in
the morning
, and it was first come first served. When I arrived twenty tramps
had already washed their faces. I gave one glance at the black scum on top
of the water, and decided to go dirty for the day.


We hurried into our clothes, and then went to the dining-room to bolt our
breakfast. The bread was much worse than usual, because the military-minded
idiot of a Tramp Major had cut it into slices overnight, so that it was as
hard as ship's biscuit. But we were glad of our
tea after the cold, restless
night. I do not know what tramps would do without tea, or rather the stuff
they miscall tea. It
is their food, their medicine, their panacea for all e-
vils. Without the half gallon or so of it that they suck down a day, I truly
believe they could not face their existence.


After breakfast we had to undress again for the medical inspection, which is
a precaution against smallpox. It was three quarters of an hour before the
doctor arrived, and one had time now to look about him and see what manner of
men we were. It was an instructive sight. We stood
shivering naked to the
waist in two long ranks in the passage.
The filtered light, bluish and cold,
lighted us up with unmerciful clarity. No one can imagine, unless he has seen
such a thing, what pot-bellied, degenerate curs we looked. Shock heads, hairy,
crumpled faces, hollow chests, flat feet, sagging muscles--every kind of mal-
formation and physical rottenness were there. All were flabby and discoloured,
as all tramps are under their deceptive sunburn. Two or three figures seen
there stay ineradicably in my mind. Old 'Daddy', aged seventy-four, with his
truss, and his red, watering eyes, a herring-gutted starveling with sparse
beard and sunken cheeks, looking like the corpse of Lazarus in some primitive
picture: an imbecile, wandering hither and thither with vague giggles, coyly
pleased because his trousers constantly slipped down and left him nude.
But
few of us were greatly better than these; there were not ten decently built
men among us,
and half, I believe, should have been in hospital.

This being Sunday, we were to be kept in the spike over the week-end. As soon
as the doctor had gone we were herded back to the dining-room, and its door
shut upon us. It was a lime-washed, stone-floored room, unspeakably dreary
with its furniture of deal boards and benches, and its prison smell.
The win-
dows were so high up that one could not look outside, and the sole ornament
was a set of Rules threatening dire penalties to any casual who misconducted
himself. We packed the room so tight that one could not move an elbow without
jostling somebody. Already, at eight o'clock in the morning, we were bored
with our captivity. There was nothing to talk about except the petty gossip
of the road, the good and bad spikes, the charitable and uncharitable counties,
the iniquities of the police and the Salvation Army. Tramps hardly ever get
away from these subjects; they
talk, as it were, nothing but shop. They have
nothing worthy to be called conversation, because emptiness of belly leaves no
speculation in their souls. The world is too much with them. Their next meal
is never quite secure,
and so they cannot think of anything except the next
meal.


Two hours dragged by. Old Daddy, witless with age, sat silent, his back bent
like a bow and his inflamed eyes dripping slowly on to the floor.
George, a
dirty old tramp notorious for the queer habit of sleeping in his hat, grumbled
about a parcel of tommy that he had lost on the road.
Bill the moocher, the
best built man of us all, a Herculean sturdy beggar who smelt of beer even af-
ter twelve hours in the spike, told tales of mooching, of pints stood him in
the boozers
, and of a parson who had peached to the police and got him seven
days. William and, Fred, two young, ex-fishermen from Norfolk, sang a sad song
about Unhappy Bella, who was betrayed and died in the snow. The imbecile drive-
lled, about an imaginary toff, who had once given him two hundred and fifty-
seven golden sovereigns. So the time passed, with
dun talk and dull obscenities.
Everyone was smoking, except Scotty, whose tobacco had been seized, and he was
so miserable in his smokeless state that I stood him the makings of a cigarette.
We smoked furtively, hiding our cigarettes like schoolboys when we heard the
Tramp Major's step, for smoking though connived at, was officially forbidden.


Most of the tramps spent ten consecutive hours in this dreary room. It is hard
to imagine how they put up with it.
I have come to think that boredom is the
worst of all a tramp's evils, worse than hunger and discomfort, worse even than
the constant feeling of being socially disgraced. It is a silly piece of cruelty
to confine an ignorant man all day with nothing to do; it is like chaining a dog
in a barrel. Only an educated man, who has consolations within himself, can en-
dure confinement. Tramps, unlettered types as nearly all of them are, face their
poverty with blank, resourceless minds.
Fixed for ten hours on a comfortless
bench, they know no way of occupying themselves, and
if they think at all it is
to whimper about hard luck and pine for work. They have not the stuff in them to
endure the horrors of idleness. And so, since so much of their lives is spent in
doing nothing, they suffer agonies from boredom.


I was much luckier than the others, because at ten o'clock the Tramp Major pick-
ed me out for the most coveted of all jobs in the spike, the job of helping in
the workhouse kitchen. There was not really any work to be done there, and I was
able to make off and hide in a shed used for storing potatoes, together with some
workhouse paupers who were skulking to avoid the Sunday-morning service. There
was a stove burning there, and comfortable packing cases to sit on, and back num-
bers of the Family Herald, and even a copy of Raffles from the workhouse library.
It was paradise after the spike.


Also, I had my dinner from the workhouse table, and it was one of the biggest
meals I have ever eaten. A tramp does not see such a meal twice in the year, in
the spike or out of it. The paupers told me that they always gorged to the burst-
ing point on Sundays, and went hungry six days of the week. When the meal was over
the cook set me to do the washing-up, and told me to throw away the food that re-
mained.
The wastage was astonishing; great dishes of beef, and bucketfuls of bread
and vegetables, were pitched away like rubbish, and then defiled with tea-leaves.
I filled five dustbins to overflowing with good food.
And while I did so my follow
tramps were sitting two hundred yards away in the spike, their bellies half filled
with the spike dinner of the everlasting bread and tea, and perhaps two cold boil-
ed potatoes each in honour of Sunday.
It appeared that the food was thrown away
from deliberate policy, rather than that it should be given to the tramps.


At three I left the workhouse kitchen and went back to the spike. The, boredom in
that crowded, comfortless room was now unbearable. Even smoking had ceased, for
a tramp's only tobacco is picked-up cigarette ends, and, like a browsing beast,
he starves if he is long away from the pavement-pasture. To occupy the time I talk-
ed with
a rather superior tramp, a young carpenter who wore a collar and tie, and
was on the road, he said, for lack of a set of tools. He kept a little aloof from
the other tramps, and held himself more like a free man than a casual. He had
literary tastes, too, and carried one of Scott's novels on all his wanderings.
He told me he never entered a spike unless driven there by hunger, sleeping under
hedges and behind ricks in preference. Along the south coast he had begged by day
and slept in bathing-machines for weeks at a time.

We talked of life on the road. He criticized the system which makes a tramp spend
fourteen hours a day in the spike, and the other ten in walking and dodging the
police. He spoke of his own case--
six months at the public charge for want of
three pounds' worth of tools. It was idiotic,
he said.

Then I told him about the wastage of food in the workhouse kitchen, and what I
thought of it. And at that he changed his tune immediately. I saw that
I had awa-
kened the pew-renter who sleeps in every English workman.
Though he had been fam-
ished, along with the rest, he at once saw reasons why the food should have been
thrown away rather than given to the tramps. He admonished me quite severely.

'They have to do it,' he said.
'If they made these places too pleasant you'd have
all the scum of the country flocking into them. It's only the bad food as keeps
all that scum away. These tramps are too lazy to work, that's all that's wrong
with them. You don't want to go encouraging of them. They're scum.'


I produced arguments to prove him wrong, but he would not listen.
He kept repeat-
ing:


'You don't want to have any pity on these tramps--scum, they are. You don't want
to judge them by the same standards as men like you and me. They're scum, just
scum.'

It was interesting to see how subtly he disassociated himself from his fellow
tramps. He has been on the road six months, but
in the sight of God, he seemed to
imply, he was not a tramp. His body might be in the spike, but his spirit soared
far away, in the pure aether of the middle classes.


The clock's hands crept round with excruciating slowness. We were too bored even
to talk now,
the only sound was of oaths and reverberating yawns. One would force
his eyes away from the clock for what seemed an age, and then look back again to
see that the hands had advanced three minutes.
Ennui clogged our souls like cold
mutton fat. Our bones ached because of it.
The clock's hands stood at four, and
supper was not till six, and there was nothing left remarkable beneath the visit-
ing moon.


At last six o'clock did come, and the Tramp Major and his assistant arrived with
supper. The yawning tramps brisked up like lions at feeding-time. But the meal was
a dismal disappointment. The bread, bad enough in the morning, was now positively
uneatable; it was so hard that even the strongest jaws could make little impression
on it.
The older men went almost supperless, and not a man could finish his portion,
hungry though most of us were. When we had finished, the blankets were served out
immediately, and we were hustled off once more to the bare, chilly cells.

Thirteen hours went by. At seven we were awakened, and rushed forth to squabble
over the water in the bathroom, and bolt our ration of bread and tea.
Our time in
the spike was up, but we could not go until the doctor had examined us again, for
the authorities have a terror of smallpox and its distribution by tramps. The doc-
tor kept us waiting two hours this time, and it was ten o'clock before we finally
escaped.

At last it was time to go, and we were let out into the yard. How bright everything
looked, and how sweet the winds did blow, after the gloomy, reeking spike!
The
Tramp Major handed each man his bundle of confiscated possessions, and a hunk of
bread and cheese for midday dinner, and then we took the road, hastening to get
out of sight of the spike and its discipline,
This was our interim of freedom. Af-
ter a day and two nights of wasted time we had eight hours or so to take our recre-
ation, to scour the roads for cigarette ends, to beg, and to look for work.
Also,
we had to make our ten, fifteen, or it might be twenty miles to the next spike,
where the game would begin anew.

I disinterred my eightpence and took the road with Nobby, a respectable, downheart-
ed tramp who carried a spare pair of boots and visited all the Labour Exchanges.
Our late companions were scattering north, south, east and west, like bugs into a
mattress. Only the imbecile loitered at the spike gates, until the Tramp Major had
to chase him away.

Nobby and I set out for Croydon. It was a quiet road, there were no cars passing,
the
blossom covered the chestnut trees like great wax candles. Everything was so
quiet and smelt so clean
, it was hard to realize that only a few minutes ago we
had been packed with that band of
prisoners in a stench of drains and soft soap.
The others had all disappeared; we two seemed to be the only tramps on the road.

Then I heard a hurried step behind me, and felt a tap on my arm. It was little
Scotty, who had run panting after us. He pulled a rusty tin box from his pocket.
He wore a friendly smile, like a man who is repaying an obligation.

'Here y'are, mate,' he said cordially. 'I owe you some fag ends. You stood me a
smoke yesterday. The Tramp Major give me back my box of fag ends when we come out
this morning. One good turn deserves another--here y'are.'

And
he put four sodden, debauched, loathly cigarette ends into my hand.

First published in Adelphi, April 1931. Later reduced and reshaped to form
Chapters 27 and 35 of Down and Out in Paris and London
c


A HANGING



It was in Burma, a sodden morning of the rains. A sickly light, like yellow tin-
foil, was slanting over the high walls
into the jail yard. We were waiting outside
the condemned cells, a row of sheds fronted with double bars, like small animal
cages. Each cell measured about ten feet by ten and was quite bare within except
for a plank bed and a pot of drinking water. In some of them brown silent men were
squatting at the inner bars, with their blankets draped round them. These were the
condemned men, due to be hanged within the next week or two.

One prisoner had been brought out of his cell. He was
a Hindu, a puny wisp of a
man, with a shaven head and vague liquid eyes.
He had a thick, sprouting moustache,
absurdly too big for his body, rather like the moustache of a comic man on the films.
Six tall Indian warders were guarding him and getting him ready for the gallows.
Two of them stood by with rifles and fixed bayonets, while the others handcuffed
him, passed a chain through his handcuffs and fixed it to their belts, and lashed
his arms tight to his sides. They crowded very close about him, with their hands al-
ways on him in
a careful, caressing grip, as though all the while feeling him to
make sure he was there.
It was like men handling a fish which is still alive and
may jump back into the water. But he stood quite unresisting, yielding his arms limp-
ly to the ropes, as though he hardly noticed what was happening.

Eight o'clock struck and
a bugle call, desolately thin in the wet air, floated from
the distant barracks
. The superintendent of the jail, who was standing apart from
the rest of us, moodily prodding the gravel with his stick, raised his head at the
sound. He was an army doctor, with a grey toothbrush moustache and a gruff voice.
"For God's sake hurry up, Francis," he said irritably. "The man ought to have been
dead by this time.
Aren't you ready yet?"

Francis, the head jailer, a fat Dravidian in a white drill suit and gold spectacles,
waved his black hand. "Yes sir, yes sir," he bubbled. "All iss satisfactorily prepar-
ed. The hangman iss waiting. We shall proceed."


"Well, quick march, then. The prisoners can't get their breakfast till this job's o-
ver."

We set out for the gallows. Two warders marched on either side of the prisoner, with
their rifles at the slope; two others marched close against him, gripping him by arm
and shoulder, as though at once pushing and supporting him. The rest of us, magis-
trates and the like, followed behind. Suddenly, when we had gone ten yards, the pro-
cession stopped short without any order or warning.
A dreadful thing had happened--a
dog, come goodness knows whence, had appeared in the yard. It came bounding among us
with a loud volley of barks, and leapt round us wagging its whole body, wild with
glee at finding so many human beings together. It was a large woolly dog, half Aire-
dale, half pariah. For a moment it pranced round us, and then, before anyone could
stop it, it had made a dash for the prisoner, and jumping up tried to lick his face.
Everyone stood aghast, too taken aback even to grab at the dog.


“Who let that bloody brute in here?” said the superintendent angrily. “Catch it,
someone!”

A warder, detached from the escort, charged clumsily after the dog, but
it danced and
gambolled just out of his reach, taking everything as part of the game.
A young Eur-
asian jailer picked up a handful of gravel and tried to stone the dog away, but it
dodged the stones and came after us again.
Its yaps echoed from the jail walls. The
prisoner, in the grasp of the two warders, looked on incuriously, as though this was
another formality of the hanging. It was several minutes before someone managed to
catch the dog. Then we put my handkerchief through its collar and moved off once
more, with the dog still straining and whimpering.

It was about forty yards to the gallows. I watched the bare brown back of the prisoner
marching in front of me. He walked clumsily with his bound arms, but quite steadily,
with that
bobbing gait of the Indian who never straightens his knees. At each step his
muscles slid neatly into place, the lock of hair on his scalp danced up and down, his
feet printed themselves on the wet gravel.
And once, in spite of the men who gripped
him by each shoulder, he stepped slightly aside to avoid a puddle on the path.


It is curious, but till that moment I had never realized what it means to destroy a
healthy, conscious man. When I saw the prisoner step aside to avoid the puddle, I saw
the mystery, the unspeakable wrongness, of cutting a life short when it is in full tide.
This man was not dying, he was alive just as we were alive. All the organs of his body
were working –bowels digesting food, skin renewing itself, nails growing, tissues form-
ing – all toiling away in solemn foolery. His nails would still be growing when he stood
on the drop, when he was falling through the air with a tenth of a second to live. His
eyes saw the yellow gravel and the grey walls, and his brain still remembered, foresaw,
reasoned – reasoned even about puddles. He and we were a party of men walking together,
seeing, hearing, feeling, understanding the same world; and in two minutes, with a sud-
den snap, one of us would be gone – one mind less, one world less.


The gallows stood in a small yard, separate from the main grounds of the prison, and o-
vergrown with tall prickly weeds. It was a brick erection like three sides of a shed,
with planking on top, and above that two beams and a crossbar with the rope dangling.
The hangman, a grey-haired convict in the white uniform of the prison, was waiting be-
side his machine. He greeted us with a servile crouch as we entered. At a word from Fran-
cis the two warders, gripping the prisoner more closely than ever, half led, half pushed
him to the gallows and helped him clumsily up the ladder. Then the hangman limbed up and
fixed the rope round the prisoner’s neck.

We stood waiting, five yards away. The warders had formed in a rough circle round the gal-
lows. And then, when the noose was fixed,
the prisoner began crying out on his god. It
was a high, reiterated cry of “Ram! Ram! Ram! Ram!”, not urgent and fearful like a pray-
er or a cry for help, but steady, rhythmical, almost like the tolling of a bell. The dog
answered the sound with a whine.
The hangman, still standing on the gallows, produced a
small cotton bag like a flour bag and drew it down over the prisoner’s face. But the
sound, muffled by the cloth, still persisted, over and over again: “Ram! Ram! Ram! Ram!
Ram!”

The hangman climbed down and stood ready, holding the lever.
Minutes seemed to pass. The
steady, muffled crying from the prisoner went on and on, “Ram! Ram! Ram!” never falter-
ing for an instant. The superintendent, his head on his chest, was slowly poking the
ground with his stick; perhaps he was counting the cries, allowing the prisoner a fixed
number – fifty, perhaps, or a hundred. Everyone had changed colour. The Indians had gone
grey like bad coffee, and one or two of the bayonets were wavering. We looked at the lash-
ed, hooded man on the drop, and listened to his cries – each cry another second of life;
the same thought was in all our minds: oh, kill him quickly, get it over, stop that abom-
inable noise!


Suddenly the superintendent made up his mind. Throwing up his head he made a swift motion
with his stick. “Chalo!” he shouted almost fiercely.

There was a clanking noise, and then dead silence. The prisoner had vanished, and the rope
was twisting on itself. I let go of the dog, and it galloped immediately to the back of
the gallows; but when it got there it stopped short, barked, and then retreated into a cor-
ner of the yard, where it stood among the weeds, looking timorously out at us. We went
round the gallows to inspect the prisoner’s body. He was dangling with his toes pointed
straight downwards, very slowly revolving, as dead as a stone.

The superintendent reached out with his stick and poked the bare body; it oscillated,
slightly. “He’s all right,” said the superintendent. He backed out from under the gal-
lows, and blew out a deep breath. The moody look had gone out of his face quite suddenly.
He glanced at his wrist-watch. “Eight minutes past eight. Well, that’s all for this morn-
ing, thank God.”

The warders unfixed bayonets and marched away. The dog, sobered and conscious of having
misbehaved itself
, slipped after them. We walked out of the gallows yard, past the condemn-
ed cells with their waiting prisoners, into the big central yard of the prison. The con-
victs, under the command of warders armed with lathis, were already
receiving their break-
fast. They squatted in long rows, each man holding a tin pannikin, while two warders with
buckets marched round ladling out rice;
it seemed quite a homely, jolly scene, after the
hanging. An enormous relief had come upon us now that the job was done. One felt an im-
pulse to sing, to break into a run, to snigger.
All at once everyone began chattering
gaily.


The Eurasian boy walking beside me nodded towards the way we had come, with a knowing
smile
: “Do you know, sir, our friend (he meant the dead man), when he heard his appeal
had been dismissed, he pissed on the floor of his cell. From fright.
Kindly take one
of my cigarettes, sir. Do you not admire my new silver case, sir? From the boxwallah,
two rupees eight annas. Classy European style.”

Several people laughed – at what, nobody seemed certain.

Francis was walking by the superintendent, talking garrulously. “Well, sir, all hass
passed off with the utmost satisfactoriness. It wass
all finished – flick! like that.
It iss not always so – oah, no! I have known cases where the doctor wass obliged to go
beneath the gallows and pull the prisoner’s legs to ensure decease. Most disagreeable!”


“Wriggling about, eh? That’s bad,” said the superintendent.

“Ach, sir, it iss worse when they become refractory! One man, I recall, clung to the
bars of hiss cage when we went to take him out. You will scarcely credit, sir, that it
took six warders to dislodge him, three pulling at each leg. We reasoned with him. “My
dear fellow,” we said, “think of all the pain and trouble you are causing to us!” But
no, he would not listen! Ach, he wass very troublesome!”

I found that I was laughing quite loudly. Everyone was laughing. Even the superintend-
ent grinned in a tolerant way.
“You’d better all come out and have a drink,” he
said quite genially. “I’ve got a bottle of whisky in the car. We could do with it.”

We went through the big double gates of the prison, into the road.
“Pulling at his
legs!” exclaimed a Burmese magistrate suddenly, and burst into a loud chuckling.
We
all began laughing again. At that moment Francis’s anecdote seemed extraordinarily
funny. We all had a drink together, native and European alike, quite amicably. The
dead man was a hundred yards away.




Bookshop Memories



When I worked in a second-hand bookshop — so easily pictured, if you don't work in one,
as a kind of paradise where charming old gentlemen browse eternally among calf-bound
folios
— the thing that chiefly struck me was the rarity of really bookish people. Our
shop had an exceptionally interesting stock, yet I doubt whether ten per cent of our
customers knew a good book from a bad one.
First edition snobs were much commoner than
lovers of literature, but oriental students haggling over cheap textbooks were commoner
still, and
vague-minded women looking for birthday presents for their nephews were com-
monest of all.

Many of the people who came to us were of the kind who would be a nuisance anywhere
but have special opportunities in a bookshop. For example, the dear old lady who ‘wants a
book for an invalid' (a very common demand, that), and the other
dear old lady who read
such a nice book in 1897 and wonders whether you can find her a copy. Unfortunately she
doesn't remember the title or the author's name or what the book was about, but she does
remember that it had a red cover.
But apart from these there are two well-known types of
pest by whom every second-hand bookshop is haunted. One is
the decayed person smelling of
old breadcrusts who comes every day, sometimes several times a day, and tries to sell you
worthless books.
The other is the person who orders large quantities of books for which
he has not the smallest intention of paying.
In our shop we sold nothing on credit, but
we would put b
ooks aside, or order them if necessary, for people who arranged to fetch
them away later. Scarcely half the people who ordered books from us ever came back. It
used to puzzle me at first.
What made them do it? They would come in and demand some rare
and expensive book
, would make us promise over and over again to keep it for them, and
then would
vanish never to return. But many of them, of course, were unmistakable
paranoiacs. They used to talk in a grandiose manner about themselves and tell the most
ingenious stories to explain how they had happened to come out of doors without any money

— stories which, in many cases, I am sure they themselves believed. In a town like London
there are always
plenty of not quite certifiable lunatics walking the streets, and they
tend to gravitate towards bookshops, because a bookshop is one of the few places where
you can hang about for a long time without spending any money. In the end one gets to
know these people almost at a glance.
For all their big talk there is something
moth-eaten and aimless about them.
Very often, when we were dealing with an obvious
paranoiac,
we would put aside the books he asked for and then put them back on the
shelves the moment he had gone. None of them, I noticed, ever attempted to take books
away without paying for them; merely to order them was enough — it gave them, I suppose,
the illusion that they were spending real money.

Like most second-hand bookshops we had various sidelines. We sold second-hand
typewriters, for instance, and also stamps — used stamps, I mean.
Stamp-collectors
are a strange, silent, fish-like breed, of all ages, but only of the male sex; women,
apparently, fail to see the peculiar charm of gumming bits of coloured paper into albums.

We also sold sixpenny horoscopes compiled by somebody who claimed to have foretold the
Japanese earthquake. They were in sealed envelopes and I never opened one of them myself,
but the people who bought them often came back and told us how ‘true’ their horoscopes
had been.
(Doubtless any horoscope seems ‘true’ if it tells you that you are highly
attractive to the opposite sex and your worst fault is generosity.)
We did a good deal of
business in children's books, chiefly ‘remainders’. Modern books for children are rather
horrible things, especially when you see them in the mass. Personally I would sooner give
a child a copy of Petrenius Arbiter than Peter Pan, but even Barrie seems manly and
wholesome compared with some of his later imitators. At Christmas time we spent a
feverish ten days struggling with Christmas cards and calendars, which are tiresome
things to sell but good business while the season lasts.
It used to interest me to see
the brutal cynicism with which Christian sentiment is exploited.
The touts from the
Christmas card firms used to come round with their catalogues as early as June. A phrase
from one of their invoices sticks in my memory. It was:
‘2 doz. Infant Jesus with
rabbits’.


But our principal sideline was a lending library — the usual ‘twopenny no-deposit’
library of five or six hundred volumes, all fiction. How the book thieves must love those
libraries! It is the easiest crime in the world to borrow a book at one shop for
twopence, remove the label and sell it at another shop for a shilling. Nevertheless
booksellers generally find that it pays them better to have a certain number of books
stolen (we used to lose about a dozen a month) than to frighten customers away by
demanding a deposit.


Our shop stood exactly on the frontier between Hampstead and Camden Town, and we were
frequented by all types from baronets to bus-conductors. Probably our library subscribers
were a fair cross-section of London's reading public. It is therefore worth noting that
of all the authors in our library the one who ‘went out’ the best was — Priestley?
Hemingway? Walpole? Wodehouse? No, Ethel M. Dell, with Warwick Deeping a good second
and Jeffrey Farnol, I should say, third. Dell's novels, of course, are read solely by women,
but by women of all kinds and ages and not, as one might expect, merely by
wistful
spinsters and the fat wives of tobacconists.
It is not true that men don't read novels,
but it is true that there are whole branches of fiction that they avoid. Roughly
speaking, what one might call the average novel — the ordinary, good-bad, Gals-
worthy-and-water stuff which is the norm of the English novel — seems to exist only
for women.
Men read either the novels it is possible to respect, or detective stories.
But their consumption of detective stories is terrific. One of our subscribers to my
knowledge read four or five detective stories every week for over a year, besides others
which he got from another library. What chiefly surprised me was that he never read the
same book twice.
Apparently the whole of that frightful torrent of trash (the pages read
every year would, I calculated, cover nearly three quarters of an acre) was stored for
ever in his memory.
He took no notice of titles or author's names, but he could tell by
merely glancing into a book whether be had ‘had it already’.


In a lending library you see people's real tastes, not their pretended ones, and one
thing that strikes you is how completely the ‘classical’ English novelists have dropped
out of favour. It is simply useless to put Dickens, Thackeray, Jane Austen, Trollope,
etc. into the ordinary lending library; nobody takes them out. At the mere sight of a
nineteenth-century novel people say, ‘Oh, but that's old!’ and shy away immediately. Yet
it is always fairly easy to sell Dickens, just as it is always easy to sell Shakespeare.
Dickens is one of those authors whom people are ‘always meaning to’ read, and, like the
Bible, he is widely known at second hand. People know by hearsay that Bill Sikes was a
burglar and that Mr Micawber had a bald head, just as they know by hearsay that Moses was
found in a basket of bulrushes and saw the ‘back parts’ of the Lord.
Another thing that
is very noticeable is the growing unpopularity of American books. And another — the
publishers get into a stew about this every two or three years — is the unpopularity of
short stories. The kind of person who asks the librarian to choose a book for him nearly
always starts by saying ‘I don't want short stories’, or ‘I do not desire little
stories’, as a German customer of ours used to put it.
If you ask them why, they
sometimes explain that it is too much fag to get used to a new set of characters with
every story; they like to ‘get into’ a novel which demands no further thought after the
first chapter. I believe, though, that the writers are more to blame here than the
readers. Most modern short stories, English and American, are utterly lifeless and
worthless, far more so than most novels. The short stories which are stories are popular
enough, vide D. H. Lawrence, whose short stories are as popular as his novels.


Would I like to be a bookseller de métier? On the whole — in spite of my employer's
kindness to me, and some happy days I spent in the shop — no.

Given a good pitch and the right amount of capital, any educated person ought to be able
to make a small secure living out of a bookshop. Unless one goes in for ‘rare’ books it
is not a difficult trade to learn, and you start at a great advantage if you know
anything about the insides of books. (Most booksellers don't. You can get their measure
by having a look at the trade papers where they advertise their wants. If you don't see
an ad. for Boswell's Decline and Fall you are pretty sure to see one for The Mill on the
Floss by T. S. Eliot.) Also
it is a humane trade which is not capable of being vulgarized
beyond a certain point. The combines can never squeeze the small independent bookseller
out of existence as they have squeezed the grocer and the milkman.
But the hours of work
are very long — I was only a part-time employee, but my employer put in a seventy-hour
week, apart from constant expeditions out of hours to buy books — and
it is an unheal-
thy life. As a rule a bookshop is horribly cold in winter, because if it is too warm the
windows get misted over, and a bookseller lives on his windows. And books give off more
and nastier dust than any other class of objects yet invented, and the top of a book is
the place where every bluebottle prefers to die.


But the real reason why I should not like to be in the book trade for life is that while
I was in it I lost my love of books. A bookseller has to tell lies about books, and that
gives him a distaste for them; still worse is the fact that he is constantly dusting them
and hauling them to and fro. There was a time when I really did love books — loved the
sight and smell and feel of them, I mean, at least if they were fifty or more years old.
Nothing pleased me quite so much as
to buy a job lot of them for a shilling at a country
auction. There is a peculiar flavour about the battered unexpected books you pick up in
that kind of collection: minor eighteenth-century poets, out-of-date gazeteers, odd
volumes of forgotten novels, bound numbers of ladies’ magazines of the sixties. For
casual reading — in your bath, for instance, or late at night when you are too tired to
go to bed, or in the odd quarter of an hour before lunch — there is nothing to touch a
back number of the Girl's Own Paper.
But as soon as I went to work in the bookshop I
stopped buying books.
Seen in the mass, five or ten thousand at a time, books were boring
and even slightly sickening.
Nowadays I do buy one occasionally, but only if it is a book
that I want to read and can't borrow, and I never buy junk.
The sweet smell of decaying
paper appeals to me no longer. It is too closely associated in my mind with paranoiac
customers and dead bluebottles.




Shooting an Elephant



In Moulmein, in lower Burma, I was hated by large numbers of people – the only time in
my life that I have been important enough for this to happen to me. I was sub-divis-
ional police officer of the town, and
in an aimless, petty kind of way anti-European
feeling was very bitter. No one had the guts to raise a riot, but if a European woman
went through the bazaars alone somebody would probably spit betel juice over her dress.

As a police officer I was an obvious target and was baited whenever it seemed safe to
do so.
When a nimble Burman tripped me up on the football field and the referee (ano-
ther Burman) looked the other way,
the crowd yelled with hideous laughter. This hap-
pened more than once. In the end
the sneering yellow faces of young men that met me
everywhere, the insults hooted after me when I was at a safe distance, got badly on
my nerves.
The young Buddhist priests were the worst of all. There were several thou-
sands of them in the town and none of them seemed to have anything to do except stand
on street corners and jeer at Europeans.

All this was perplexing and upsetting. For at that time I had already made up my mind
that imperialism was an evil thing and the sooner I chucked up my job and got out of it
the better. Theoretically – and secretly, of course – I was all for the Burmese and all
against their oppressors, the British.
As for the job I was doing, I hated it more
bitterly than I can perhaps make clear. In a job like that you see the dirty work of
Empire at close quarters. The wretched prisoners huddling in the stinking cages of the
lock-ups, the grey, cowed faces of the long-term convicts, the scarred buttocks of the
men who had been Bogged with bamboos
– all these oppressed me with an intolerable sense
of guilt. But I could get nothing into perspective. I was young and ill-educated and I
had had to think out my problems in the utter silence that is imposed on every Englishman
in the East. I did not even know that the British Empire is dying, still less did I know
that it is a great deal better than the younger empires that are going to supplant it.
All I knew was that
I was stuck between my hatred of the empire I served and my rage
against the evil-spirited little beasts who tried to make my job impossible. With one
part of my mind I thought of the British Raj as an unbreakable tyranny, as something
clamped down, in saecula saeculorum, upon the will of prostrate peoples; with another
part I thought that the greatest joy in the world would be to drive a bayonet into a
Buddhist priest’s guts.
Feelings like these are the normal by-products of imperialism;
ask any Anglo-Indian official, if you can catch him off duty.


One day something happened which in a roundabout way was enlightening. It was a tiny
incident in itself, but it gave me a better glimpse than I had had before of the real
nature of imperialism – the real motives for which despotic governments act. Early one
morning the sub-inspector at a police station the other end of the town rang me up on
the phone and said that an elephant was ravaging the bazaar. Would I please come and
do something about it? I did not know what I could do, but I wanted to see what was
happening and I got on to a pony and started out. I took my rifle, an old 44 Winchester
and much too small to kill an elephant, but I thought the noise might be useful in
terrorem.
Various Burmans stopped me on the way and told me about the elephant’s doings.
It was not, of course, a wild elephant, but a tame one which had gone “must.” It had been
chained up, as tame elephants always are when their attack of “must” is due,
but on the
previous night it had broken its chain and escaped. Its mahout, the only person who could
manage it when it was in that state, had set out in pursuit, but had taken the wrong
direction and was now twelve hours’ journey away, and in the morning the elephant had
suddenly reappeared in the town. The Burmese population had no weapons and were quite
helpless against it. It had already destroyed somebody’s bamboo hut,
killed a cow and
raided some fruit-stalls and devoured the stock; also it had met the municipal rubbish
van
and, when the driver jumped out and took to his heels, had turned the van over and
inflicted violences upon it.


The Burmese sub-inspector and some Indian constables were waiting for me in the quarter
where the elephant had been seen.
It was a very poor quarter, a labyrinth of squalid
bamboo huts, thatched with palmleaf, winding all over a steep hillside. I remember that
it was a cloudy, stuffy morning
at the beginning of the rains. We began questioning the
people as to where the elephant had gone and, as usual, failed to get any definite
information. That is invariably the case in the East; a story always sounds clear enough
at a distance, but the nearer you get to the scene of events the vaguer it becomes.
Some
of the people said that the elephant had gone in one direction, some said that he had
gone in another, some professed not even to have heard of any elephant. I had almost made
up my mind that the whole story was a pack of lies, when we heard yells a little distance
away.
There was a loud, scandalized cry of “Go away, child! Go away this instant!” and an
old woman with a switch in her hand came round the corner of a hut,
violently shooing
away a crowd of naked children
. Some more women followed, clicking their tongues and
exclaiming; evidently there was something that the children ought not to have seen. I
rounded the hut and saw
a man’s dead body sprawling in the mud. He was an Indian, a black
Dravidian coolie, almost naked, and he could not have been dead many minutes. The people
said that the elephant had come suddenly upon him round the corner of the hut, caught him
with its trunk, put its foot on his back and ground him into the earth. This was the
rainy season and the ground was soft, and his face had scored a trench a foot deep and a
couple of yards long. He was lying on his belly with arms crucified and head sharply
twisted to one side. His face was coated with mud, the eyes wide open, the teeth bared
and grinning with an expression of unendurable agony. (Never tell me, by the way, that
the dead look peaceful. Most of the corpses I have seen looked devilish.) The friction of
the great beast’s foot had stripped the skin from his back
as neatly as one skins a
rabbit. As soon as I saw the dead man I sent an orderly to a friend’s house nearby to
borrow an elephant rifle.
I had already sent back the pony, not wanting it to go mad with
fright and throw me if it smelt the elephant.

The orderly came back in a few minutes with a rifle and five cartridges, and meanwhile
some Burmans had arrived and told us that the elephant was in the paddy fields below,
only a few hundred yards away. As I started forward practically the whole population of
the quarter flocked out of the houses and followed me. They had seen the rifle and were
all shouting excitedly that I was going to shoot the elephant. They had not shown much
interest in the elephant when he was merely ravaging their homes, but it was different
now that he was going to be shot.
It was a bit of fun to them, as it would be to an
English crowd; besides they wanted the meat.
It made me vaguely uneasy. I had no
intention of shooting the elephant – I had merely sent for the rifle to defend myself if
necessary – and it is always unnerving to have a crowd following you. I marched down the
hill, looking and feeling a fool, with the rifle over my shoulder and an ever-growing
army of people jostling at my heels. At the bottom, when you got away from the huts,
there was a
metalled road and beyond that a miry waste of paddy fields a thousand yards
across, not yet ploughed but soggy from the first rains and dotted with coarse grass.
The
elephant was standing eight yards from the road, his left side towards us. He took not
the slightest notice of the crowd’s approach. He was tearing up bunches of grass, beating
them against his knees to clean them and stuffing them into his mouth.

I had halted on the road. As soon as I saw the elephant I knew with perfect certainty
that I ought not to shoot him.
It is a serious matter to shoot a working elephant – it is
comparable to destroying a huge and costly piece of machinery
– and obviously one ought
not to do it if it can possibly be avoided. And at that distance,
peacefully eating, the
elephant looked no more dangerous than a cow.
I thought then and I think now that his
attack of “must” was already passing off; in which case he would merely wander harmlessly
about until the mahout came back and caught him. Moreover, I did not in the least want to
shoot him. I decided that I would watch him for a little while to make sure that he did
not turn savage again, and then go home.

But at that moment I glanced round at the crowd that had followed me. It was
an immense
crowd, two thousand at the least and growing every minute.
It blocked the road for a long
distance on either side.
I looked at the sea of yellow faces above the garish
clothes-faces all happy and excited over this bit of fun
, all certain that the elephant
was going to be shot. They were watching me as they would watch
a conjurer about to
perform a trick. They did not like me, but with the magical rifle in my hands I was
momentarily worth watching. And suddenly I realized that I should have to shoot the
elephant after all. The people expected it of me and I had got to do it; I could feel
their two thousand wills pressing me forward, irresistibly. And it was at this moment, as
I stood there with the rifle in my hands, that I first grasped the hollowness, the
futility of the white man’s dominion in the East. Here was I, the white man with his gun,
standing in front of the unarmed native crowd – seemingly the leading actor of the piece;
but in reality I was only an absurd puppet pushed to and fro by the will of those yellow
faces behind. I perceived in this moment that when the white man turns tyrant it is his
own freedom that he destroys. He becomes a sort of hollow, posing dummy, the
conventionalized figure of a sahib.
For it is the condition of his rule that he shall
spend his life in trying to impress the “natives,” and so in every crisis he has got to
do what the “natives” expect of him.
He wears a mask, and his face grows to fit it. I had
got to shoot the elephant. I had committed myself to doing it when I sent for the rifle.
A sahib has got to act like a sahib;
he has got to appear resolute, to know his own mind
and do definite things.
To come all that way, rifle in hand, with two thousand people
marching at my heels, and then
to trail feebly away, having done nothing – no, that was
impossible. The crowd would laugh at me. And my whole life, every white man’s life in the
East, was one long struggle not to be laughed at.


But I did not want to shoot the elephant. I watched him beating his bunch of grass
against his knees, with that preoccupied grandmotherly air that elephants have. It seemed
to me that it would be murder to shoot him.
At that age I was not squeamish about killing
animals, but I had never shot an elephant and never wanted to. (Somehow it always seems
worse to kill a large animal.) Besides, there was the beast’s owner to be considered.
Alive, the elephant was worth at least a hundred pounds; dead, he would only be worth the
value of his tusks, five pounds, possibly.
But I had got to act quickly. I turned to some
experienced-looking Burmans who had been there when we arrived, and asked them how the
elephant had been behaving. They all said the same thing: he took no notice of you if you
left him alone, but he might charge if you went too close to him.

It was perfectly clear to me what I ought to do. I ought to walk up to within, say,
twenty-five yards of the elephant and test his behavior. If he charged, I could shoot; if
he took no notice of me, it would be safe to leave him until the mahout came back. But
also I knew that
I was going to do no such thing. I was a poor shot with a rifle and the
ground was soft mud into which one would sink at every step. If the elephant charged and
I missed him, I should have about as much chance as a toad under a steam-roller.
But even
then I was not thinking particularly of my own skin, only of the watchful yellow faces
behind. For at that moment, with the crowd watching me, I was not afraid in the ordinary
sense, as I would have been if I had been alone. A white man mustn’t be frightened in
front of “natives”; and so, in general, he isn’t frightened. The sole thought in my mind
was that
if anything went wrong those two thousand Burmans would see me pursued, caught,
trampled on and reduced to a grinning corpse like that Indian up the hill. And if that
happened it was quite probable that some of them would laugh. That would never do.


There was only one alternative. I shoved the cartridges into the magazine and lay down on
the road to get a better aim.
The crowd grew very still, and a deep, low, happy sigh, as
of people who see the theatre curtain go up at last, breathed from innumerable throats.

They were going to have their bit of fun after all. The rifle was a beautiful German
thing with cross-hair sights. I did not then know that in shooting an elephant one would
shoot to cut an imaginary bar running from ear-hole to ear-hole. I ought, therefore, as
the elephant was sideways on, to have aimed straight at his ear-hole, actually I aimed
several inches in front of this, thinking the brain would be further forward.

When I pulled the trigger I did not hear the bang or feel the kick – one never does when
a shot goes home – but
I heard the devilish roar of glee that went up from the crowd. In
that instant, in too short a time, one would have thought, even for the bullet to get
there, a mysterious, terrible change had come over the elephant. He neither stirred nor
fell, but every line of his body had altered. He looked suddenly stricken, shrunken,
immensely old, as though the frightful impact of the bullet had paralysed him without
knocking him down. At last, after what seemed a long time – it might have been five
seconds, I dare say – he sagged flabbily to his knees. His mouth slobbered. An enormous
senility seemed to have settled upon him. One could have imagined him thousands of years
old. I fired again into the same spot. At the second shot he did not collapse but climbed
with desperate slowness to his feet and stood weakly upright, with legs sagging and head
drooping. I fired a third time. That was the shot that did for him. You could see the
agony of it jolt his whole body and knock the last remnant of strength from his legs. But
in falling he seemed for a moment to rise
, for as his hind legs collapsed beneath him he
seemed to tower upward like a huge rock toppling,
his trunk reaching skyward like a tree.
He trumpeted, for the first and only time.
And then down he came, his belly towards me,
with a crash that seemed to shake the ground even where I lay.

I got up. The Burmans were already racing past me across the mud.
It was obvious that the
elephant would never rise again, but he was not dead. He was breathing very rhythmically
with long rattling gasps, his great mound of a side painfully rising and falling. His
mouth was wide open – I could see far down into caverns of pale pink throat. I waited a
long time for him to die, but his breathing did not weaken. Finally I fired my two
remaining shots into the spot where I thought his heart must be. The thick blood welled
out of him like red velvet, but still he did not die. His body did not even jerk when the
shots hit him, the tortured breathing continued without a pause. He was dying, very
slowly and in great agony, but in some world remote from me where not even a bullet could
damage him further. I felt that I had got to put an end to that dreadful noise. It seemed
dreadful to see the great beast lying there, powerless to move and yet powerless to die,
and not even to be able to finish him. I sent back for my small rifle and poured shot
after shot into his heart and down his throat. They seemed to make no impression. The
tortured gasps continued as steadily as the ticking of a clock.


In the end I could not stand it any longer and went away. I heard later that it took him
half an hour to die. Burmans were bringing dash and baskets even before I left, and I was
told they had stripped his body almost to the bones by the afternoon.

Afterwards, of course, there were endless discussions about the shooting of the elephant.
The owner was furious, but he was only an Indian and could do nothing. Besides, legally I
had done the right thing, for a mad elephant has to be killed, like a mad dog, if its
owner fails to control it. Among the Europeans opinion was divided. The older men said I
was right, the younger men said it was a damn shame to shoot an elephant for killing a
coolie, because an elephant was worth more than any damn Coringhee coolie. And afterwards
I was very glad that the coolie had been killed; it put me legally in the right and it
gave me a sufficient pretext for shooting the elephant. I often wondered whether any of
the others grasped that I had done it solely to avoid looking a fool.


Published by New Writing, 2, Autumn 1936



Down the Mine



Our civilization, pace Chesterton, is founded on coal, more completely than one
realizes until one stops to think about it.
The machines that keep us alive, and
the machines that make machines, are all directly or indirectly dependent upon
coal. In the metabolism of the Western world the coal-miner is second in importance
only to the man who ploughs the soil. He is a sort of caryatid upon whose shoulders
nearly everything that is not grimy is supported.
For this reason the actual
process by which coal is extracted is well worth watching, if you get the chance
and are willing to take the trouble.

When you go down a coal-mine it is important to try and get to the coal face when
the ‘fillers’ are at work. This is not easy, because when the mine is working
visitors are a nuisance and are not encouraged, but if you go at any other time, it
is possible to come away with a totally wrong impression. On a Sunday, for
instance, a mine seems almost peaceful. The time to go there is
when the machines
are roaring and the air is black with coal dust
, and when you can actually see what
the miners have to do. At those times
the place is like hell, or at any rate like
my own mental picture of hell. Most of the things one imagines in hell are if there
— heat, noise, confusion, darkness, foul air, and, above all, unbearably cramped
space.
Everything except the fire, for there is no fire down there except the
feeble beams of Davy lamps and electric torches which scarcely penetrate the
clouds of coal dust.


When you have finally got there — and getting there is a job in itself: I will explain
that in a moment — you crawl through the last line of pit props and see opposite
you a shiny black wall three or four feet high. This is the coal face. Overhead is
the smooth ceiling made by the rock from which the coal has been cut;
underneath is
the rock again, so that the gallery you are in is only as high as the ledge of coal
itself, probably not much more than a yard.
The first impression of all,
overmastering everything else for a while, is the frightful, deafening din from the
conveyor belt which carries the coal away. You cannot see very far, because
the fog
of coal dust throws back the beam of your lamp
, but you can see on either side of
you the line of half-naked kneeling men, one to every four or five yards, driving
their shovels under the fallen coal and flinging it swiftly over their left
shoulders. They are feeding it on to the conveyor belt, a moving rubber belt a
couple of feet wide which runs a yard or two behind them. Down this belt a
glittering river of coal races constantly. In a big mine it is carrying away
several tons of coal every minute. It bears it off to some place in the main roads
where it is shot into tubs holding half a tun, and thence dragged to the cages and
hoisted to the outer air.

It is impossible to watch the ‘fillers’ at work without feelling a pang of envy for
their toughness. It is a dreadful job that they do, an almost superhuman job by the
standard of an ordinary person. For they are not only shifting monstrous quantities
of coal, they are also doing it in a position that doubles or trebles the work.

They have got to remain kneeling all the while — they could hardly rise from their
knees without hitting the ceiling — and you can easily see by trying it what a
tremendous effort this means.
Shovelling is comparatively easy when you are
standing up, because you can use your knee and thigh to drive the shovel along;
kneeling down, the whole of the strain is thrown upon your arm and belly muscles.
And the other conditions do not exactly make things easier. There is the heat — it
varies, but in some mines it is suffocating — and the coal dust that stuffs up your
throat and nostrils and collects along your eyelids, and the unending rattle of the
conveyor belt, which in that confined space is rather like the rattle of a machine
gun. But the fillers look and work as though they were made of iron. They really do
look like iron hammered iron statues — under the smooth coat of coal dust which
clings to them from head to foot. It is only when you see miners down the mine and
naked that you realize what splendid men, they are.
Most of them are small (big men
are at a disadvantage in that job) but nearly all of them have
the most noble
bodies; wide shoulders tapering to slender supple waists, and small pronounced
buttocks and sinewy thighs, with not an ounce of waste flesh anywhere.
In the
hotter mines they wear only a pair of thin drawers, clogs and knee-pads; in the
hottest mines of all, only the clogs and knee-pads. You can hardly tell by the look
of them whether they are young or old. They may be any age up to sixty or even
sixty-five, but when they are black and naked they all look alike. No one could do
their work who had not a young man's body, and a figure fit for a guardsman at
that, just a few pounds of extra flesh on the waist-line, and the constant bending
would be impossible. You can never forget that spectacle once you have seen it —
the
line of bowed, kneeling figures, sooty black all over, driving their, huge
shovels under the coal with stupendous force and speed.
They are on the job for
seven and a half hours, theoretically without a break, for there is no time ‘off’.
Actually they, snatch a quarter of an hour or so at some time during the shift to
eat the food they have brought with them, usually
a hunk of bread and dripping and
a bottle of cold tea.
The first time I was watching the ‘fillers’ at work I put my
hand upon some dreadful slimy thing among the coal dust. It was a chewed quid of
tobacco.
Nearly all the miners chew tobacco, which is said to be good against
thirst.


Probably you have to go down several coal-mines before you can get much grasp of
the processes that are going on round you. This is chiefly because the mere effort
of getting from place to place; makes it difficult to notice anything else, In some
ways it is even disappointing, or at least is unlike what you have, expected. You
get into the cage, which is a steel box about as wide as a telephone box and two
or three times as long. It holds ten men, but they pack it like pilchards in a tin,
and a tall man cannot stand upright in it.
The steel door shuts upon you, and
somebody working the winding gear above drops you into the void. You have the usual
momentary qualm in your belly and a bursting sensation in the cars, but not much
sensation of movement
till you get near the bottom, when the cage slows down so
abruptly that you could swear it is going upwards again. In the middle of the run
the cage probably touches sixty miles an hour; in some of the deeper mines it
touches even more. When you crawl out at the bottom you are perhaps four hundred
yards underground. That is to say
you have a tolerable-sized mountain on top of
you; hundreds of yards of solid rock, bones of extinct beasts, subsoil, flints,
roots of growing things, green grass and cows grazing on it — all this suspended
over your head and held back only by wooden props as thick as the calf of your leg.

But because of the speed at which the cage has brought you down, and the complete
blackness through which you have travelled, you hardly feel yourself deeper down
than you would at the bottom of the Piccadilly tube.


What is surprising, on the other hand, is the immense horizontal distances that
have to be travelled underground
. Before I had been down a mine I had vaguely
imagined the miner stepping out of the cage and getting to work on a ledge of coal
a few yards away. I had not realized that before he even gets to work he may have
had to creep along passages as long as from London Bridge to Oxford Circus.
In the
beginning, of course, a mine shaft is sunk somewhere near a seam of coal;
But as
that seam is worked out and fresh seams are followed up, the workings get further
and further from the pit bottom. If it is a mile from the pit bottom to the coal
face, that is probably an average distance; three miles is a fairly normal one;
there are even said to be a few mines where it is as much as five miles. But these
distances bear no relation to distances above ground. For in all that mile or three
miles as it may be, there is
hardly anywhere outside the main road, and not many
places even there, where
a man can stand upright.

You do not notice the effect of this till you have gone a few hundred yards. You
start off, stooping slightly, down the dim-lit gallery, eight or ten feet wide and
about five high, with the
walls built up with slabs of shale, like the stone walls
in Derbyshire. Every yard or two there are wooden props holding up the beams and
girders; some of the girders have buckled into fantastic curves under which you
have to duck. Usually it is
bad going underfoot — thick dust or jagged chunks of
shale, and in some mines where there is water it is as mucky as a farm-yard.
Also
there is the track for the coal tubs, like a miniature railway track with sleepers
a foot or two apart, which is tiresome to walk on.
Everything is grey with shale
dust; there is a dusty fiery smell
which seems to be the same in all mines. You see
mysterious machines of which you never learn the purpose, and bundles of tools
slung together on wires
, and sometimes mice darting away from the beam of the
lamps.
They are surprisingly common, especially in mines where there are or have
been horses. It would be interesting to know how they got there in the first place;
possibly by falling down the shaft — for they say a mouse can fall any distance
uninjured, owing to its surface area being so large relative to its weight. You
press yourself against the wall to make way for lines of tubs jolting slowly
towards the shaft, drawn by an endless steel cable operated from the surface. You
creep through sacking curtains and thick wooden
doors which, when they are opened,
let out fierce blasts of air. These doors are an important part of the ventilation
system.
The exhausted air is sucked out of one shaft by means of fans, and the
fresh air enters the other
of its own accord. But if left to itself the air will
take the shortest way round, leaving the deeper workings unventilated; so all the
short cuts have to be partitioned off.


At the start to walk stooping is rather a joke, but it is a joke that soon wears
off. I am handicapped by being exceptionally tall, but when the roof falls to four
feet or less it is a tough job for anybody except a dwarf or a child. You not only
have to bend double, you have also got to keep your head up all the while so as to
see the beams and girders and dodge them when they come. You have, therefore, a
constant crick in the neck, but this is nothing to the pain in your knees and
thighs. After half a mile it
becomes (I am not exaggerating) an unbearable agony.
You begin to wonder whether you will ever get to the end — still more, how on earth
you are going to get back. Your pace grows slower and slower. You come to a stretch
of a couple of hundred yards where it is all exceptionally low and you have to work
yourself along in a squatting position. Then suddenly the roof opens out to a
mysterious height — scene of and old fall of rock, probably — and for twenty whole
yards you can stand upright. The relief is overwhelming. But after this there is
another low stretch of a hundred yards and then a succession of beams which you
have to crawl under. You go down on all fours; even this is a relief after the
squatting business. But when you come to the end of the beams and try to get up
again, you find that your knees have temporarily struck work and refuse to lift
you. You call a halt, ignominiously, and say that you would like to rest for a
minute or two. Your guide (a miner) is sympathetic. He knows that your muscles are
not the same as his.
‘Only another four hundred yards,’ he says encouragingly; you
feel that he might as well say another four hundred miles. But finally you do
somehow creep as far as the coal face. You have gone a mile and taken the best part
of an hour; a miner would do it in not much more than twenty minutes. Having got
there, you have to sprawl in the coal dust and get your strength back for several
minutes before you can even watch the work in progress with any kind of
intelligence.


Coming back is worse than going, not only because you are already tired out but
because the journey back to the shaft is slightly uphill. You get through the low
places at the speed of a tortoise, and you have no shame now about calling a halt
when your knees give way. Even the lamp you are carrying becomes a nuisance and
probably when you stumble you drop it; whereupon, if it is a Davy lamp, it goes
out. Ducking the beams becomes more and more of an effort, and sometimes you forget
to duck. You try walking head down as the miners do, and then you bang your
backbone.
Even the miners bang their backbones fairly often. This is the reason why
in very hot mines, where it is necessary to go about half naked, most of the miners
have what they call ‘buttons down the back’ — that is, a permanent scab on each
vertebra.
When the track is down hill the miners sometimes fit their clogs, which
are hollow under-neath, on to the trolley rails and slide down.
In mines where the
‘travelling’ is very bad all the miners carry sticks about two and a half feet
long, hollowed out below the handle. In normal places you keep your hand on top of
the stick and in the low places you slide your hand down into the hollow. These
sticks are a great help, and the wooden crash-helmets — a comparatively recent
invention — are a godsend. They look like a French or Italian steel helmet, but
they are made of some kind of pith and very light, and so strong, that you can take
a violent blow on the head without feeling it. When finally you get back to the
surface you have been perhaps three hours underground and travelled two miles, and
you are more exhausted than you would be by a twenty-five-mile walk above ground.
For a week afterwards your thighs are so stiff that coming downstairs is quite a
difficult feat; you have to work your way down in a peculiar sidelong manner,
without bending the knees. Your miner friends notice the stiffness of your walk and
chaff you about it. (‘How'd ta like to work down pit, eh?’ etc.) Yet even a miner
who has been long away from work — from illness, for instance — when he comes back
to the pit, suffers badly for the first few days.


It may seem that I am exaggerating, though no one who has been down an
old-fashioned pit (most of the pits in England are old-fashioned) and actually gone
as far as the coal face, is likely to say so. But what I want to emphasize is this.
Here is this frightful business of crawling to and fro, which to any normal person
is a hard day's work in itself; and it is not part of the miner's work at all, it
is merely an extra, like the City man's daily ride in the Tube.
The miner does that
journey to and fro, and sandwiched in between there are seven and a half hours of
savage work.
I have never travelled much more than a mile to the coal face; but
often it is three miles, in which case I and most people other than coal-miners
would never get there at all. This is the kind of point that one is always liable
to miss. When you think of the coal-mine
you think of depth, heat, darkness,
blackened figures hacking at walls of coal; you don't think, necessarily, of those
miles of creeping to and fro.
There is the question of time, also. A miner's
working shift of seven and a half hours does not sound very long, but one has got
to add on to it at least an hour a day for ‘travelling’, more often two hours and
sometimes three. Of course, the ‘travelling’ is not technically work and the miner
is not paid for it; but it is as like work as makes no difference. It is easy to
say that miners don't mind all this. Certainly, it is not the same for them as it
would be for you or me. They have done it since childhood,
they have the right
muscles hardened, and they can move to and fro underground with a startling and
rather horrible agility. A miner puts his head down and runs, with a long swinging
stride, through places where I can only stagger. At the workings you see them on
all fours, skipping round the pit props almost like dogs.
But it is quite a mistake
to think that they enjoy it. I have talked about this to scores of miners and they
all admit that the ‘travelling’ is hard work; in any case when you hear them
discussing a pit among themselves the ‘travelling’ is always one of the things they
discuss.
It is said that a shift always returns from work faster than it goes;
nevertheless the miners all say that it is the coming away after a hard day's work,
that is especially irksome. It is part of their work and they are equal to it, but
certainly it is an effort. It is comparable, perhaps, to climbing a smallish
mountain before and after your day's work.


When you have been down in two or three pits you begin to get some grasp of the
processes that are going on underground. (I ought to say, by the way, that I know
nothing whatever about the technical side of mining: I am merely describing what I
have seen.) Coal lies in thin seams between enormous layers of rock, so that
essentially the process of getting it out is like scooping the central layer from a
Neapolitan ice. In the old days the miners used to cut straight into the coal with
pick and crowbar — a very slow job because
coal, when lying in its virgin state, is
almost as hard as rock.
Nowadays the preliminary work is done by an
electrically-driven coal-cutter, which in principle is an
immensely tough and
powerful band-saw
, running horizontally instead of vertically, with teeth a couple
of inches long and half an inch or an inch thick. It can move backwards or forwards
on its own power, and the men operating it can rotate it this way or that.
Incidentally it
makes one of the most awful noises I have ever heard, and sends
forth clouds of coal dust which make it impossible to see more than two to three
feet and almost impossible to breathe.
The machine travels along the coal face
cutting into the base of the coal and undermining it to the depth of five feet or
five feet and a half; after this it is comparatively easy to extract the coal to
the depth to which it has been undermined. Where it is ‘difficult getting’,
however, it has also to be loosened with explosives. A man with
an electric drill,
like a rather small version of the drills used in street-mending, bores holes at
intervals in the coal, inserts blasting powder, plugs it with clay,
goes round the
corner if there is one handy (he is supposed to retire to twenty-five yards
distance) and touches off the charge with an electric current. This is not intended
to bring the coal out, only to loosen it. Occasionally, of course, the charge is
too powerful, and then it not only brings the coal out but brings the roof down as
well.

After the blasting has been done the ‘fillers’ can tumble the coal out, break it up
and shovel it on to the conveyor belt.
It comes out first in monstrous boulders
which may weigh anything up to twenty tons.
The conveyor belt shoots it on to tubs,
and the tubs are shoved into the main road and hitched on to an endlessly revolving
steel cable which drags them to the cage. Then they are hoisted, and at the surface
the coal is sorted by being run over screens, and if necessary is washed as well.
As far as possible the ‘dirt’ — the shale, that is — is used for making the roads
below. All what cannot be used is sent to the surface and dumped; hence the

monstrous ‘dirt-heaps’, like hideous grey mountains, which are the characteristic
scenery of the coal areas.
When the coal has been extracted to the depth to which
the machine has cut, the coal face has advanced by five feet. Fresh props are put
in to hold up the newly exposed roof,
and during the next shift the conveyor belt
is taken to pieces, moved five feet forward and re-assembled. As far as possible
the three operations of cutting, blasting and extraction are done in three separate
shifts, the cutting in the afternoon, the blasting at night (there is a law, not
always kept, that forbids its being done when other men are working near by)
, and
the ‘filling’ in the morning shift, which lasts from six in the morning until half
past one.

Even when you watch the process of coal-extraction you probably only watch it
for a short time, and it is not until you begin making a few calculations that you
realize what a stupendous task the ‘fillers’ are performing. Normally each man
has to clear a space four or five yards wide. The cutter has undermined the coal
to the depth of five feet, so that if the seam of coal is three or four feet high,
each man has to cut out, break up and load on to the belt something between seven
and twelve cubic yards of coal. This is to say, taking a cubic yard as weighing
twenty-seven hundred-weight, that each man is shifting coal at a speed approaching
two tons an hour. I have just enough experience of pick and shovel work to be able
to grasp what this means. When I am digging trenches in my garden, if I shift two
tons of earth during the afternoon, I feel that I have earned my tea.
But earth is
tractable stuff compared with coal, and I don't have to work kneeling down, a
thousand feet underground, in suffocating heat and swallowing coal dust with every
breath I take; nor do I have to walk a mile bent double before I begin.
The miner's
job would be as much beyond my power as it would be to perform on a flying trapeze
or to win the Grand National. I am not a manual labourer and please God I never
shall be one, but there are some kinds of manual work that I could do if I had to.
At a pitch I could be a tolerable road-sweeper or an inefficient gardener or even a
tenth-rate farm hand. But by no conceivable amount of effort or training could I
become a coal-miner, the work would kill me in a few weeks.


Watching coal-miners at work, you realize momentarily what different universes
people inhabit.
Down there where coal is dug is a sort of world apart which one
can quite easily go through life without ever hearing about. Probably majority of
people would even prefer not to hear about it. Yet
it is the absolutely necessary
counterpart of our world above. Practically everything we do, from eating an ice to
crossing the Atlantic, and from baking a loaf to writing a novel, involves the use
of coal,
directly or indirectly. For all the arts of peace coal is needed; if war
breaks out it is needed all the more. In time of revolution the miner must go on
working or the revolution must stop, for revolution as much as reaction needs coal.
Whatever may be happening on the surface,
the hacking and shovelling have got to
continue without a pause,
or at any rate without pausing for more than a few weeks
at the most. In order
that Hitler may march the goose-step, that the Pope may
denounce Bolshevism, that the cricket crowds may assemble at Lords, that the poets
may scratch one another's backs,
coal has got to be forthcoming. But on the whole
we are not aware of it; we all know that we ‘must have coal’, but we seldom or
never remember what coal-getting involves. Here am I sitting writing in front of my
comfortable coal fire. It is April but I still need a fire. Once a fortnight the
coal cart drives up to the door and
men in leather jerkins carry the coal indoors
in stout sacks smelling of tar and shoot it clanking into the coal-hole under the
stairs.
It is only very rarely, when I make a definite mental-effort, that I
connect this coal with that far-off labour in the mines. It is just ‘coal’ —
something that I have got to have;
black stuff that arrives mysteriously from
nowhere in particular, like manna except that you have to pay for it.
You could
quite easily drive a car right across the north of England and never once remember
that
hundreds of feet below the road you are on the miners are hacking at the coal.
Yet in a sense it is the miners who are driving your car forward. Their lamp-lit
world down there is as necessary to the daylight world above as the root is to the
flower.


It is not long since conditions in the mines were worse than they are now. There
are still living a few very old women who in their youth have worked underground,
with the
harness round their waists, and a chain that passed between their legs,
crawling on all fours and dragging tubs of coal. They used to go on doing this even
when they were pregnant. And even now, if coal could not be produced without
pregnant women dragging it to and fro, I fancy we should let them do it rather than
deprive ourselves of coal.
But-most of the time, of course, we should prefer to
forget that they were doing it. It is so with all types of manual work; it keeps us
alive, and we are oblivious of its existence. More than anyone else, perhaps,
the
miner can stand as the type of the manual worker, not only because his work is so
exaggeratedly awful, but also because it is so vitally necessary and yet so remote
from our experience, so invisible, as it were, that we are capable of forgetting it
as we forget the blood in our veins. In a way it is even humiliating to watch
coal-miners working. It raises in you a momentary doubt about your own status as an
‘intellectual’ and a superior person generally. For it is brought home to you, at
least while you are watching, that it is only because miners sweat their guts out
that superior persons can remain superior. You and I and the editor of the Times
Lit. Supp., and the poets and the Archbishop of Canterbury and Comrade X, author of
Marxism for Infants — all of us really owe the comparative decency of our lives to
poor drudges underground, blackened to the eyes, with their throats full of coal
dust, driving their shovels forward with arms and belly muscles of steel.




North And South



As you travel northward your eye, accustomed to the South or East, does not notice
much difference until you are beyond Birmingham.
In Coventry you might as well be
in Finsbury Park, and the Bull Ring in Birmingham is not unlike Norwich Market, and
between all the towns of the Midlands there stretches a villa-civilization
indistinguishable from that of the South.
It is only when you get a little further
north, to the pottery towns and beyond, that you begin to encounter the real
ugliness of industrialism — an ugliness so frightful and so arresting that you are
obliged, as it were, to come to terms with it.

A slag-heap is at best a hideous thing, because it is so planless and functionless.
It is something just dumped on the earth, like the emptying of a giant's dust-bin.
On the outskirts of the mining towns there are frightful landscapes where your
horizon is ringed completely round by jagged grey mountains, and underfoot is mud
and ashes and over-head the steel cables where tubs of dirt travel slowly across
miles of country. Often the slag-heaps are on fire, and at night you can see the
red rivulets of fire winding this way and that, and also the slow-moving blue
flames of sulphur, which always seem on the point of expiring and always spring out
again. Even when a slag-heap sinks, as it does ultimately, only an evil brown grass
grows on it, and it retains its hummocky surface. One in the slums of Wigan, used
as a playground, looks like a choppy sea suddenly frozen; 'the flock mattress'
, it
is called locally. Even centuries hence when the plough drives over the places
where coal was once mined, the sites of ancient slag-heaps will still be
distinguishable from an aeroplane.


I remember a winter afternoon in the dreadful environs of Wigan. All round was the
lunar landscape of slag-heaps
, and to the north, through the passes, as it were,
between the mountains of slag, you could see the
factory chimneys sending out
their plumes of smoke. The canal path was a mixture of cinders and frozen mud,
criss-crossed by the imprints of innumerable clogs, and all round, as far as the
slag-heaps in the distance, stretched the 'flashes'—pools of stagnant water that
had seeped into the hollows caused by the subsidence of ancient pits. It was
horribly cold. The 'flashes' were covered with ice the colour of raw umber, the
bargemen were muffled to the eyes in sacks, the lock gates wore beards of ice. It
seemed a world from which vegetation had been banished; nothing existed except
smoke, shale, ice, mud, ashes, and foul water. But even Wigan is beautiful compared
with Sheffield. Sheffield, I suppose, could justly claim to be called the ugliest
town in the Old World:
its inhabitants, who want it to be pre-eminent in
everything, very likely do make that claim for it. It has a population of half a
million and it contains fewer decent buildings than the average East Anglian
village of five hundred.
And the stench! If at rare moments you stop smelling
sulphur it is because you have begun smelling gas. Even the shallow river that runs
through the town is-usually bright yellow with some chemical or other.
Once I
halted in the street and counted the factory chimneys I could see; there were
thirty-three of them, but there would have been far more if the air had not been
obscured by smoke. One scene especially lingers in my mind.
A frightful patch of
waste ground (somehow, up there, a patch of waste ground attains a squalor that
would be impossible even in London) trampled bare of grass and littered with
newspapers and old saucepans. To the right an isolated row of gaunt four-roomed
houses, dark red, blackened by smoke. To the left an interminable vista of factory
chimneys, chimney beyond chimney, fading away into a dim blackish haze.
Behind me
a railway embankment made of the slag from furnaces.
In front, across the patch of
waste ground, a cubical building of red and yellow brick, with the sign 'Thomas
Grocock, Haulage Contractor'.

At night, when you cannot see the hideous shapes of the houses and the black-
ness of everything, a town like Sheffield assumes a kind of sinister magnificence.
Sometimes the drifts of smoke are rosy with sulphur, and serrated flames, like
circular saws, squeeze themselves out from beneath the cowls of the foundry
chimneys. Through the open doors of foundries you see fiery serpents of iron being
hauled to and fro by redlit boys, and you hear the whizz and thump of steam hammers
and the scream of the iron under the blow. The pottery towns are almost equally
ugly in a pettier way. Right in among the rows of tiny blackened houses, part of
the street as it were, are the 'pot banks'—conical brick chimneys like gigantic
burgundy bottles buried in the soil and belching their smoke almost in your face.
You come upon monstrous clay chasms hundreds of feet across and almost as deep,
with little rusty tubs creeping on chain railways up one side, and on the other
workmen clinging like samphire-gatherers and cutting into the face of the cliff
with their picks. I passed that way in snowy weather, and even the snow was black.

The best thing one can say for the pottery towns is that they are fairly small and
stop abruptly. Less than ten miles away you can stand in un-defiled country, on the
almost naked hills, and the pottery towns are only a smudge in the distance.

When you contemplate such ugliness as this, there are two questions that strike
you. First, is it inevitable? Secondly, does it matter?

I do not believe that there is anything inherently and unavoidably ugly about
industrialism.
A factory or even a gasworks is not obliged of its own nature to be
ugly, any more than a palace or a dog-kennel or a cathedral. It all depends on the
architectural tradition of the period. The industrial towns of the North are ugly
because they happen to have been built at a time when
modern methods of
steel-construction and smoke-abatement were unknown
, and when everyone was
too busy making money to think about anything else. They go on being ugly largely
because the Northerners have got used to that kind of thing and do not notice it.
Many of the people in Sheffield or Manchester, if they smelled the air along the
Cornish cliffs, would probably declare that it had no taste in it. But
since the war,
industry has tended to shift southward and in doing so has grown almost comely. The
typical post-war factory is not a gaunt barrack or an awful chaos of blackness and
belching chimneys; it is a glittering white structure of concrete, glass, and
steel, surrounded by green lawns and beds of tulips.
Look at the factories you pass
as you travel out of London on the G.W.R.; they may not be aesthetic triumphs but
certainly they are not ugly in the same way as the Sheffield gasworks.
But in any
case, though the ugliness of industrialism is the most obvious thing about it and
the thing every newcomer exclaims against, I doubt whether it is centrally
important.
And perhaps it is not even desirable, industrialism being what it is,
that it should learn to disguise itself as something else. As Mr Aldous Huxley has
truly remarked,
a dark Satanic mill ought to look like a dark Satanic mill and not
like the temple of mysterious and splendid gods.
Moreover, even in the worst of
the industrial towns one sees a great deal that is not ugly in the narrow aesthetic
sense.
A belching chimney or a stinking slum is repulsive chiefly because it
implies warped lives and ailing children. Look at it from a purely aesthetic
standpoint and it may, have a certain macabre appeal. I find that anything out-
rageously strange generally ends by fascinating me even when I abominate it. The
landscapes of Burma, which, when I was among them, so appalled me as to assume
the qualities of nightmare, afterwards stayed so hauntingly in my mind
that I was
obliged to write a novel about them to get rid of them.
(In all novels about the
East the scenery is the real subject-matter.) It would probably be quite easy to
extract a sort of beauty, as Arnold Bennett did, from the blackness of the
industrial towns;
one can easily imagine Baudelaire, for instance, writing a poem
about a slag-heap. But the beauty or ugliness of industrialism hardly matters. Its
real evil lies far deeper and is quite uneradicable. It is important to remember
this, because there is always a temptation to think that industrialism is harmless
so long as it is clean and orderly.


But when you go to the industrial North you are conscious, quite apart from the
unfamiliar scenery, of entering a strange country. This is partly because of
certain real differences which do exist, but still more because of
the North-South
antithesis which has been rubbed into us
for such a long time past. There exists
in England a curious cult of Northernness, sort of Northern snobbishness. A
Yorkshireman in the South will always take care to let you know that he regards
you as an inferior. If you ask him why, he will explain that
it is only in the North
that life is 'real' life, that the industrial work done in the North is the only
'real' work, that the North is inhabited by 'real' people, the South merely by
rentiers and their parasites. The Northerner has 'grit', he is grim, 'dour',
plucky, warm-hearted, and democratic; the Southerner is snobbish, effeminate, and
lazy
— that at any rate is the theory. Hence the Southerner goes north, at any rate
for the first time,
with the vague inferiority-complex of a civilized man venturing
among savages, while the Yorkshireman, like the Scotchman, comes to London in the
spirit of a barbarian out for loot.
And feelings of this kind, which are the result
of tradition, are not affected by visible facts. Just as an Englishman five feet
four inches high and twenty-nine inches round the chest feels that as an Englishman
he is the physical superior of Carnera (Carnera being a Dago), so also with the
Northerner and the Southerner. I remember a weedy little Yorkshireman, who would
almost certainly have run away if a fox-terrier had snapped at him, telling me that
in the South of England he felt 'like a wild invader'.
But the cult is often
adopted by people who are not by birth Northerners themselves. A year or two ago a
friend of mine, brought up in the South but now living in the North, was driving me
through Suffolk in a car. We passed through a rather beautiful village. He glanced
disapprovingly at the cottages and said:

'Of course most of
the villages in Yorkshire are hideous; but the Yorkshiremen are
splendid chaps.
Down here it's just the other way about—beautiful villages and
rotten people.
All the people in those cottages there are worthless, absolutely
worthless.'

I could not help inquiring whether he happened to know anybody in that village. No,
he did not know them; but because this was East Anglia they were obviously
worthless.
Another friend of mine, again a Southerner by birth, loses no
opportunity of praising the North to the detriment of the South. Here is an extract
from one of his letters to me:


I am in Clitheroe, Lancs...I think
running water is much more attractive in moor
and mountain country than in the fat and sluggish South. 'The smug and silver
Trent,' Shakespeare says; and the South-er the smugger,
I say.

Here you have an interesting example of the Northern cult. Not only are you and I
and everyone else in the South of England written off as 'fat and sluggish', but
even water when it gets north of a certain latitude, ceases to be H2O and becomes
something mystically superior. But the interest of this passage is that its writer
is an extremely intelligent man of 'advanced' opinions who would have nothing but
con-tempt for nationalism in its ordinary form. Put to him some such proposition as
'One Britisher is worth three foreigners', and he would repudiate it with horror.
But when it is a question of North versus South, he is quite ready to generalize.
All nationalistic distinctions — all claims to be better than somebody else because
you have a different-shaped skull or speak a different dialect—are entirely
spurious, but they are important so long as people believe in them. There is no
doubt about the Englishman's inbred conviction that those who live to the south of
him are his inferiors; even our foreign policy is governed by it to some extent.
I
think, therefore, that it is worth pointing out when and why it came into being.

When nationalism first became a religion, the English looked at the map, and,
noticing that their island lay very high in the Northern Hemisphere,
evolved the
pleasing theory that the further north you live the more virtuous you become.
The
histories I was given when I was a little boy generally started off by explaining
in the naivest way that
a cold climate made people energetic while a hot one made
them lazy, and hence the defeat of the Spanish Armada.
This nonsense about the
superior energy of the English (actually the laziest people in Europe) has been
current for at least a hundred years.
'Better is it for us', writes a Quarterly
Reviewer of 1827,
'to be condemned to labour for our country's good than to
luxuriate amid olives, vines, and vices.'
'Olives, vines, and vices' sums up the
normal English attitude towards the Latin races. In the mythology of Carlyle,
Creasey, etc.,
the Northerner ('Teutonic', later 'Nordic') is pictured as a hefty,
vigorous chap with blond moustaches and pure morals, while the Southerner is sly,
cowardly, and licentious.
This theory was never pushed to its logical end, which
would have meant assuming that the finest people in the world were the Eskimos,

but it did involve admitting that the people who lived to the north of us were su-
perior to ourselves. Hence, partly, the cult of Scotland and of Scotch things
which has so deeply marked English life during the past fifty years. But it was the
industrialization of the North that gave the North-South antithesis its peculiar
slant. Until comparatively recently the northern part of England was the backward
and feudal part, and such industry as existed was concentrated in London and the
South-East.
In the Civil War for instance, roughly speaking a war of money versus
feudalism, the North and West were for the King and the South and East for the
Parliament.
But with the increasing use of coal industry passed to the North, and
there grew up a new type of man, the self-made Northern business man—the Mr
Rouncewell and Mr Bounderby of Dickens.
The Northern business man, with his hateful
'get on or get out' philosophy
, was the dominant figure of the nineteenth century,
and as
a sort of tyrannical corpse he rules us still. This is the type edified by
Arnold Bennett — the type who starts off with half a crown and ends up with fifty
thousand pounds, and
whose chief pride is to be an even greater boor after he has
made his money
than before. On analysis his sole virtue turns out to be a talent
for making money. We were bidden to admire him because
though he might be
narrow-minded, sordid, ignorant, grasping, and uncouth, he had 'grit', he 'got on';

in other words, he knew how to make money.


This kind of cant is nowadays a pure anachronism, for the Northern business man
is no longer prosperous. But traditions are not killed by facts, and the tradition
of Northern' grit' lingers. It is still dimly felt that a Northerner will 'get on', i.e.
make money, where a Southerner will fail. At the back of the mind of every York-
shireman and every Scotchman who comes to London is a sort of Dick Whittington
picture of himself as
the boy who starts off by selling newspapers and ends up as
Lord Mayor. And that, really, is at the bottom of his bumptiousness.
But where one
can make a great mistake is in imagining that this feeling extends to the genuine
working class. When I first went to Yorkshire, some years ago, I imagined that I
was going to a country of boors. I was used to the London Yorkshireman with his
interminable harangues and his pride in the supposed raciness of his dialect ('"A
stitch in time saves nine", as we say in the West Riding'), and I expected to meet
with a good deal of rudeness. But I met with nothing of the kind, and least of all
among the miners. Indeed the Lancashire and Yorkshire miners treated me with a
kindness and courtesy that were even embarrassing; for if there is one type of man
to whom I do feel myself inferior, it is a coal-miner. Certainly no one showed any
sign of despising me
for coming from a different part of the country. This has its
importance when one remembers that the English regional snobberies are nation-
alism in miniature; for it suggests that place-snobbery is not a working-class
characteristic.


There is nevertheless a real difference between North and South, and there is at
least
a tinge of truth in that picture of Southern England as one enormous Brighton
inhabited by lounge-lizards. For climatic reasons the parasitic dividend-drawing
class tend to settle in the South.
In a Lancashire cotton-town you could probably
go for months on end without once hearing an 'educated' accent, whereas there can
hardly be a town in the South of England where you could throw a brick without
hitting the niece of a bishop. Consequently, with no petty gentry to set the pace,
the bourgeoisification of the working class, though it is taking place in the
North, is taking place more slowly. All the
Northern accents, for instance, persist
strongly, while the Southern ones are collapsing before the movies and the B.B.C.

Hence your 'educated' accent stamps you rather as a foreigner than as a chunk of
the petty gentry; and this is an immense advantage, for it makes it much easier to
get into contact with the working class.

But is it ever possible to be really intimate with the working class? I shall have
to discuss that later; I will only say here that I do not think it is possible. But
undoubtedly it is easier in the North than it would be in the South to meet
working-class people on approximately equal terms. It is fairly easy to live in a
miner's house and be accepted as one of the family; with, say, a farm labourer in
the Southern counties it probably would be impossible. I have seen just enough of
the working class to avoid idealizing them, but I do know that you can learn a
great deal in a working-class home, if only you can get there. The essential point
is that your middle-class ideals and prejudices are tested by contact with others
which are not necessarily better but are certainly different.

Take for instance the different attitude towards the family. A working-class family
hangs together as a middle-class one does, but
the relationship is far less
tyrannical. A working man has not that deadly weight of family prestige hanging
round his neck like a millstone.
I have pointed out earlier that a middle-class
person goes utterly to pieces under the influence of poverty; and this is generally
due to the behaviour of his family—to the fact that he has scores of relations
nagging and badgering him night and day for failing to 'get on'.
The fact that the
working class know how to combine and the middle class don't is probably due to
their different conceptions of family loyalty.
You cannot have an effective trade
union of middle-class workers, because in times of strikes almost every
middle-class wife would be egging her husband on to blackleg and get the other
fellow's job.
Another working-class characteristic, disconcerting at first, is
their plain-spokenness towards anyone they regard as an equal. If you offer a
working man something he doesn't want, he tells you that he doesn't want it; a
middle-class person would accept it to avoid giving offence. And again, take the
working-class attitude towards 'education'. How different it is from ours, and how
immensely sounder!
Working people often have a vague reverence for learning in
others, but where 'education' touches their own lives they see through it and
reject it by a healthy instinct. The time was when
I used to lament over quite
imaginary pictures of lads of fourteen dragged protesting from their lessons and
set to work at dismal jobs. It seemed to me dreadful that the doom of a 'job'
should descend upon anyone at fourteen
. Of course I know now that there is not one
working-class boy in a thousand who does not pine for the day when he will leave
school. He wants to be doing real work, not wasting his time on ridiculous rubbish
like history and geography.
To the working class, the notion of staying at school
till you are nearly grown-up seems merely contemptible and unmanly. The idea of a
great big boy of eighteen, who ought to be bringing a pound a week home to his
parents, going to school in a ridiculous uniform and even being caned for not doing
his lessons! Just fancy a working-class boy of eighteen allowing himself to be
caned!
He is a man when the other is still a baby. Ernest Pontifex, in Samuel
Butler's Way of All Flesh, after he had had a few glimpses of real life, looked
back on his public school and university education and found it a 'sickly,
debilitating debauch'. There is much in middle-class life that looks sickly and
debilitating when you see it from a working-class angle.


In a working-class home — I am not thinking at the moment of the unemployed,
but of comparatively prosperous homes—
you breathe a warm, decent, deeply hu-
man atmosphere
which it is not so easy to find elsewhere. I should say that a
manual worker, if he is in steady work and drawing good wages—an 'if which gets
bigger and bigger—has a better chance of being happy than an 'educated' man.

His home life seems to fall more naturally into a sane and comely shape. I have
often been struck by the peculiar easy completeness, the perfect symmetry as it
were, of a working-class interior at its best. Especially on winter evenings after
tea, when the fire glows in the open range and dances mirrored in the steel fen-
der, when Father, in shirt-sleeves, sits in the rocking chair at one side of the fire
reading the racing finals, and Mother sits on the other with her sewing, and the
children are happy with a pennorth of mint humbugs, and the dog lolls roasting
himself on the rag mat—it is a good place to be in
, provided that you can be not
only in it but sufficiently of it to be taken for granted.


This scene is still reduplicated in a majority of English homes, though not in so
many as before the war. Its happiness depends mainly upon one question—whether
Father is in work. But notice that the picture I have called up, of a working-class
family sitting round the coal fire after kippers and strong tea, belongs only to
our own moment of time and could not belong either to the future or the past. Skip
forward two hundred years into the Utopian future, and the scene is totally
different. Hardly one of the things I have imagined will still be there.
In that
age when there is no manual labour and everyone is 'educated'
, it is hardly likely
that Father will still be a rough man with enlarged hands who likes to sit in
shirt-sleeves and says 'Ah wur coomin' oop street'. And
there won't be a coal fire
in the grate, only some kind of invisible heater. The furniture will be made of
rubber, glass, and steel. If there are still such things as evening papers there
will certainly be no racing news in them, for gambling will be meaningless in a
world where there is no poverty and the horse will have vanished from the face of
the earth. Dogs, too, will have been suppressed on grounds of hygiene. And there
won't be so many children, either, if the birth-controllers have their way. But
move backwards into the Middle Ages and you are in a world almost equally foreign.
A windowless hut, a wood fire which smokes in your face because there is no
chimney, mouldy bread, 'Poor John', lice, scurvy, a yearly child-birth and a yearly
child-death, and the priest terrifying you with tales of Hell.


Curiously enough it is not the triumphs of modern engineering, nor the radio, nor
the cinematograph, nor the five thousand novels whiich are published yearly, nor
the crowds at Ascot and the Eton and Harrow match, but the memory of working-
class interiors—especially as I sometimes saw them in my childhood before the war,
when England was still prosperous—that reminds me that our age has not been al-
together a bad one to live in.




Spilling the Spanish Beans


I

The Spanish war has probably produced a richer crop of lies than any event since
the Great War of 1914-18, but I honestly doubt, in spite of all those hecatombs of
nuns who have been raped and crucified before the eyes of “Daily Mail” reporters,
whether it is the pro-Fascist newspapers that have done the most harm. It is the
left-wing papers, the “News Chronicle” and the “Daily Worker,” with their far
subtler methods of distortion, that have prevented the British public from grasping
the real nature of the struggle.


The fact which these papers have so carefully obscured is that
the Spanish
Government
(including the semi-autonomous Catalan Government) is far more afraid
of the revolution than of the Fascists.
It is now almost certain that the war will end
with some kind of compromise, and there is even reason to doubt whether the
Government, which let Bilbao fail without raising a finger, wishes to be too
victorious; but
there is no doubt whatever about the thoroughness with which it is
crushing its own revolutionaries. For some time past a reign of terror – forcible
suppression of political parties, a stifling censorship of the Press, ceaseless
espionage and mass-imprisonment without trial
– has been in progress. When I left
Barcelona in late June the
jails were bulging; indeed, the regular jails had long
since overflowed and the prisoners were being huddled into empty shops and any
other temporary dump that could be found for them.
But the point to notice is that
the people who are in prison now are not Fascists but revolutionaries; they are
there not because their opinions are too much to the Right, but because they are
too much to the Left. And the people responsible for putting them there are those
dreadful revolutionaries at whose very name Garvin quakes in his galoshes – the
Communists.

Meanwhile the war against Franco continues, but, except for the poor devils in the
front-line trenches, nobody in Government Spain thinks of it as the real war.
The
real struggle is between revolution and counter-revolution; between the workers
who are vainly trying to hold on to a little of what they won in 1936, and the
Liberal-Communist bloc who are so successfully taking it away from them.
It is
unfortunate that so few people in England have yet caught up with the fact that
Communism is now a counter-revolutionary force; that Communists everywhere are in
alliance with bourgeois reformism
and using the whole of their powerful machinery
to crush or discredit any party that shows signs of revolutionary tendencies. Hence
the grotesque spectacle of Communists assailed as wicked ‘Reds’ by right-wing
intellectuals who are in essential agreement with them.
Mr Wyndham Lewis, for
instance, ought to love the Communists, at least temporarily. In Spain the
Communist-Liberal alliance has been almost completely victorious. Of all that the
Spanish workers won for themselves in 1936 nothing solid remains, except for a few
collective farms and a certain amount of land seized by the peasants last year; and
presumably even the peasants will be sacrificed later, when there is no longer any
need to placate them.
To see how the present situation arose, one has got to look
back to the origins of the civil war.

Franco’s bid for power differed from those of Hitler and Mussolini in that it was a
military insurrection, comparable to a foreign invasion, and therefore had not much
mass backing, though Franco has since been trying to acquire one. Its
chief
supporters, apart from certain sections of Big Business, were the land-owning
aristocracy and the huge, parasitic Church.
Obviously a rising of this kind will
array against it various forces which are not in agreement on any other point. The
peasant and the worker hate feudalism and clericalism; but so does the “liberal”
bourgeois, who is not in the least opposed to a more modern version of Fascism, at
least so long as it isn’t called Fascism.
The “liberal” bourgeois is genuinely
liberal up to the point where his own interests stop. He stands for the degree of
progress implied in the phrase “la carrière ouverte aux talents.” For clearly he
has no chance to develop in a feudal society where the worker and the peasant are
too poor to buy goods, where industry is burdened with huge taxes to pay for
bishops’ vestments, and where every lucrative job is given as a matter of course to
the friend of the catamite of the duke’s illegitimate son.
Hence, in the face of
such a blatant reactionary as Franco, you get for a while a situation in which the
worker and the bourgeois, in reality deadly enemies, are fighting side by side.
This uneasy alliance is known as the
Popular Front (or, in the Communist Press, to
give it a spuriously democratic appeal, People’s Front). It is
a combination with
about as much vitality, and about as much right to exist, as a pig with two heads
or some other Barnum and Bailey monstrosity.


In any serious emergency the contradiction implied in the Popular Front is bound to
make itself felt. For even when the worker and the bourgeois are both fighting
against Fascism, they are not fighting for the same things;
the bourgeois is
fighting for bourgeois democracy, i.e., capitalism, the worker, in so far as he
understands the issue, for Socialism.
And in the early days of the revolution the
Spanish workers understood the issue very well. In the areas where Fascism was
defeated they did not content themselves with driving the rebellious troops out of
the towns; they also took the opportunity of seizing land and factories and setting
up the rough beginnings of a workers’ government by means of local committees,
workers’ militias, police forces, and so forth. They made the mistake, however
(possibly because most of
the active revolutionaries were Anarchists with a
mistrust of all parliaments
), of leaving the Republican Government in nominal
control.
And, in spite of various changes in personnel, every subsequent Government
had been of approximately the same bourgeois-reformist character. At the beginning
this seemed not to matter, because the Government, especially in Cataloñia, was
almost powerless and the bourgeoisie had to lie low or even (this was still
happening when I reached Spain in December) to disguise themselves as workers.
Later, as power slipped from the hands of the Anarchists into the hands of the
Communists and right-wing Socialists, the Government was able to reassert itself,
the bourgeoisie came out of hiding and the old division of society into rich and
poor reappeared, not much modified. Henceforward every move, except a few dictated
by military emergency, was directed towards undoing the work of the first few
months of revolution. Out of the many illustrations I could choose, I will cite
only one, the
breaking-up of the old workers’ militias, which were organized on a
genuinely democratic system, with officers and men receiving the same pay and
mingling on terms of complete equality
, and the substitution of the Popular Army
(once again, in Communist jargon, “People’s Army”), modelled as far as possible on
an ordinary
bourgeois army, with a privileged officer-caste, immense differences of
pay
, etc., etc. Needless to say, this is given out as a military necessity, and
almost certainly it does make for military efficiency, at least for a short period.
But the undoubted purpose of the change was to strike a blow at equalitarianism.
In
every department the same policy has been followed, with the result that only a
year after the outbreak of war and revolution you get what is in effect an ordinary
bourgeois State, with, in addition, a reign of terror to preserve the status quo.

This process would probably have gone less far if the struggle could have taken
place without foreign interference. But the military weakness of the Government
made this impossible. In the face of Franco’s foreign mercenaries they were obliged
to turn to Russia for help, and though the quantity of arms supplied by Russia has
been greatly exaggerated (in my first three months in Spain I saw only one Russian
weapon, a solitary machine-gun), the mere fact of their arrival brought the
Communists into power. To begin with, the Russian aeroplanes and guns, and the good
military qualities of the International Brigades (not necessarily Communist but
under Communist control), immensely raised the Communist prestige. But, more
important, since Russia and Mexico were the only countries openly supplying arms,
the
Russians were able not only to get money for their weapons, but to extort terms
as well. Put in their crudest form, the terms were: “Crush the revolution or you
get no more arms.”
The reason usually given for the Russian attitude is that if
Russia appeared to be abetting the revolution, the Franco-Soviet pact (and the
hoped-for alliance with Great Britain) would be imperilled; it may be, also, that
the spectacle of a genuine revolution in Spain would rouse unwanted echoes in
Russia.
The Communists, of course, deny that any direct pressure has been exerted
by the Russian Government. But this, even if true, is hardly relevant, for the
Communist Parties of all countries can be taken as carrying out Russian policy; and
it is certain that the Spanish Communist Party, plus the right-wing Socialists whom
they control, plus
the Communist Press of the whole world, have used all their
immense and ever-increasing influence upon the side of counter-revolution.

II

In the first half of this article I suggested that the real struggle in Spain, on
the Government side, has been between revolution and counter-revolution; that the
Government, though anxious enough to avoid being beaten by Franco, has been even
more anxious to undo the revolutionary changes with which the outbreak of war was
accompanied.

Any Communist would reject this suggestion as mistaken or wilfully dishonest. He
would tell you that it is nonsense to talk of the Spanish Government crushing the
revolution, because the revolution never happened; and that our job at present is
to defeat Fascism and defend democracy. And in this connection it is most important
to see just how the Communist anti-revolutionary propaganda works. It is a mistake
to think that this has no relevance in England, where the Communist Party is small
and comparatively weak. We shall see its relevance quickly enough if England enters
into an alliance with the U.S.S.R.; or perhaps even earlier, for the influence of
the Communist Party is bound to increase – visibly is increasing – as more and more
of the capitalist class realise that latter-day Communism is playing their game.


Broadly speaking, Communist propaganda depends upon terrifying people with the
(quite real) horrors of Fascism. It also involves
pretending – not in so many
words, but by implication – that Fascism has nothing to do with capitalism. Fascism
is just a kind of meaningless wickedness, an aberration, “mass sadism,” the sort of
thing that would happen if you suddenly let loose an asylum-ful of homicidal
maniacs.
Present Fascism in this form, and you can mobilise public opinion against
it, at any rate for a while, without provoking any revolutionary movement. You can
oppose Fascism by bourgeois “democracy,” meaning capitalism. But meanwhile
you have
got to get rid of the troublesome person who points out that Fascism and bourgeois
‘democracy’ are Tweedledum and Tweedledee. You do it at the beginning by calling
him an impracticable visionary.
You tell him that he is confusing the issue, that
he is splitting the anti-Fascist forces, that this is not the moment for
revolutionary phrase-mongering, that for the moment we have got to fight against
Fascism without inquiring too closely what we are fighting for. Later,
if he still
refuses to shut up, you change your tune and call him a traitor.
More exactly, you
call him a Trotskyist.


And what is a Trotskyist? This terrible word – in Spain at this moment you can be
thrown into jail and kept there indefinitely, without trial, on the mere rumour
that you are a Trotskyist
– is only beginning to be bandied to and fro in England.
We shall be hearing more of it later. The word “Trotskyist” (or “Trotsky-Fascist”)
is generally used to mean a disguised Fascist who poses as an ultra-revolutionary
in order to split the Left-wing forces. But it derives its peculiar power from the
fact that it means three separate things. It can mean one who, like Trotsky, wishes
for world revolution; or a member of the actual organization of which Trotsky is
head (the only legitimate use of the word); or the disguised Fascist already
mentioned. The three meanings can be telescoped one into the other at will. Mean-
ing
No. 1 may or may not carry with it meaning No. 2, and meaning No. 2 almost
invariably carries with it meaning No. 3. Thus: “XY. has been heard to speak
favourably of world-revolution; therefore he is a Trotskyist; therefore he is a
Fascist.” In Spain, to some extent even in England, anyone professing revolutionary
Socialism (i.e., professing the things the Communist Party professed until a few
years ago) is under suspicion of being a Trotskyist in the pay of Franco or Hitler.

The accusation is a very subtle one, because in any given case, unless one happened
to know the contrary, it might be true. A Fascist spy probably would disguise
himself as a revolutionary.
In Spain, everyone whose opinions are to the Left of
those of the Communist Party is sooner or later discovered to be a Trotskyist, or
at least, a traitor.
At the beginning of the war the P.O.U.M., an Opposition
Communist party roughly corresponding to the English I.L.P., was an accepted party
and supplied a minister to the Catalan Government; later it was expelled from the
Government; then it was denounced as Trotskyist; then it was suppressed, every
member that the police could lay their hands on being flung into jail.

Until a few months ago the Anarcho-Syndicalists were described as “working loyally”
beside the Communists. Then the Anarcho-Syndicalists were levered out of the
Government; then it appeared that they were not working so loyally; now they are in
the process of becoming traitors. After that will come the turn of the Left-wing
Socialists. Caballero, the Left-wing Socialist ex-premier, until May, 1937, the
idol of the Communist Press, is already in outer darkness, a Trotskyist and “enemy
of the people”. And so the game continues.
The logical end is a régime in which
every opposition party and newspaper is suppressed and every dissentient of any
importance is in jail.
Of course, such a régime will be Fascism. It will not be the
same as the Fascism Franco would impose, it will even be better than Franco’s
Fascism to the extent of being worth fighting for, but it will be Fascism.
Only,
being operated by Communists and Liberals, it will be called something different.

Meanwhile, can the war be won? The Communist influence has been against
revolutionary chaos
and has therefore, apart from the Russian aid, tended to
produce greater military efficiency. If the Anarchists saved the Government from
August to October, 1936, the Communists have saved it from October onwards. But in
organizing the defence they have succeeded in killing enthusiasm (inside Spain, not
outside).
They made a militarized conscript army possible, but they also made it
necessary. It is significant that as early as January of this year voluntary
recruiting had practically ceased. A revolutionary army can sometimes win by
enthusiasm, but a conscript army has got to win with weapons,
and it is unlikely
that the Government will ever have a large preponderance of arms unless France
intervenes or unless Germany and Italy decide to make off with the Spanish colonies
and leave Franco in the lurch.
On the whole, a deadlock seems the likeliest thing.

And does the Government seriously intend to win? It does not intend to lose, that
is certain. On the other hand, an outright victory, with Franco in flight and the
Germans and Italians driven into the sea, would raise difficult problems, some of
them too obvious to need mentioning. There is no real evidence and one can only
judge by the event, but I suspect that what the Government is playing for is a
compromise that would leave the war situation essentially in being. All prophecies
are wrong, therefore this one will be wrong, but I will take a chance and say that
though the war may end quite soon or may drag on for years, it will end with Spain
divided up, either by actual frontiers or into economic zones. Of course, such a
compromise might be claimed as a victory by either side, or by both.


All that I have said in this article would seem entirely commonplace in Spain, or
even in France. Yet in England, in spite of the intense interest the Spanish war
has aroused, there are very few people who have even heard of the enormous struggle
that is going on behind the Government lines. Of course, this is no accident. There
has been a quite deliberate conspiracy (I could give detailed instances) to prevent
the Spanish situation from being understood. People who ought to know better have
lent themselves to the deception on the ground that if you tell the truth about
Spain it will be used as Fascist propaganda.

It is easy to see where such cowardice leads. If the British public had been given
a truthful account of the Spanish war they would have had an opportunity of
learning what Fascism is and how it can be combatted. As it is,
the “News
Chronicle” version of Fascism as a kind of homicidal mania peculiar to Colonel
Blimps bombinating in the economic void has been established more firmly than ever.

And thus we are one step nearer to the great war “against Fascism” (cf. 1914,
“against militarism”) which will allow Fascism, British variety, to be slipped over
our necks during the first week.


New English Weekly, 29 July and 2 September 1937



Marrakech



As the corpse went past the flies left the restaurant table in a cloud and rushed
after it,
but they came back a few minutes later.

The little crowd of mourners - all men and boys, no women — threaded their way across
the market-place between the piles of pomegranates and the taxis and the camels,
wailing a short chant over and over again.
What really appeals to the flies is that
the corpses here are never put into coffins, they are merely wrapped in a piece of
rag
and carried on a rough wooden bier on the shoulders of four friends. When the
friends get to the burying-ground
they hack an oblong hole a foot or two deep, dump
the body in it and fling over it a little of the dried-up, lumpy earth, which is
like broken brick. No gravestone, no name, no identifying mark of any kind. The
burying-ground is merely a huge waste of hummocky earth
, like a derelict
building-lot. After a month or two no one can even be certain where his own
relatives are buried.

When you walk through a town like this —
two hundred thousand inhabitants, of whom
at least twenty thousand own literally nothing except the rags they stand up in —
when you see how the people live, and still more how easily they die, it is always
difficult to believe that you are walking among human beings. All colonial empires
are in reality founded upon that fact. The people have brown faces — besides, there
are so many of them! Are they really the same flesh as yourself? Do they even have
names? Or are they merely a kind of undifferentiated brown stuff, about as
individual as bees or coral insects? They rise out of the earth, they sweat and
starve for a few years, and then they sink back into the nameless mounds of the
graveyard and nobody notices that they are gone. And even the graves themselves
soon fade back into the soil. Sometimes, out for a walk, as you break your way
through the prickly pear, you notice that it is rather bumpy underfoot, and only a
certain regularity in the bumps tells you that you are walking over skeletons.


I was feeding one of the gazelles in the public gardens.

Gazelles are almost the only animals that look good to eat when they are still
alive, in fact, one can hardly look at their hindquarters without thinking of mint
sauce. The gazelle I was feeding seemed to know that this thought was in my mind,
for though it took the piece of bread I was holding out it obviously did not like
me. It nibbled rapidly at the bread, then lowered its head and tried to butt me,
then took another nibble and then butted again. Probably its idea was that if it
could drive me away the bread would somehow remain hanging in mid-air.


An Arab navvy working on the path nearby lowered his heavy hoe and sidled towards
us. He looked from the gazelle to the bread and from the bread to the gazelle, with
a sort of quiet amazement, as though he had never seen anything quite like this
before. Finally he
said shyly in French:

‘I could eat some of that bread.’

I tore off a piece and he stowed it gratefully in some secret place under his rags.
This man is an employee of the Municipality.

When you go through the Jewish quarters you gather some idea of what the medieval
ghettoes were probably like. Under their Moorish rulers the Jews were only allowed
to own land in certain restricted areas, and after centuries of this kind of
treatment they have ceased to bother about overcrowding. Many of the streets are a
good deal less than six feet wide,
the houses are completely windowless, and
sore-eyed children cluster everywhere in unbelievable numbers, like clouds of
flies. Down the centre of the street there is generally running a little river of
urine.


In the bazaar huge families of Jews, all dressed in the long black robe and little
black skull-cap, are working in dark fly-infested booths that look like caves.
A
carpenter sits cross-legged at a prehistoric lathe, turning chair-legs at lightning
speed. He works the lathe with a bow in his right hand and guides the chisel with
his left foot, and
thanks to a lifetime of sitting in this position his left leg is
warped out of shape.
At his side his grandson, aged six, is already starting on the
simpler parts of the job.

I was just passing the coppersmiths’ booths when somebody noticed that I was
lighting a cigarette.
Instantly, from the dark holes all round, there was a
frenzied rush of Jews, many of them old grandfathers with flowing grey beards, all
clamouring for a cigarette. Even a blind man somewhere at the back of one of the
booths heard a rumour of cigarettes and came crawling out, groping in the air
with
his hand. In about a minute I had used up the whole packet. None of these people, I
suppose, works less than twelve hours a day, and every one of them looks on a
cigarette as a more or less impossible luxury.

As the Jews live in self-contained communities they follow the same trades as the
Arabs, except for agriculture. Fruit-sellers, potters, silversmiths, blacksmiths,
butchers, leather-workers, tailors, water-carriers, beggars, porters — whichever
way you look you see nothing but Jews. As a matter of fact there are thirteen
thousand of them, all living in the space of a few acres. A good job Hitler isn't
here. Perhaps he is on his way, however. You hear the usual dark rumours about the
Jews, not only from the Arabs but from the poorer Europeans.

‘Yes, mon vieux, they took my job away from me and gave it to a Jew. The Jews!
They're the real rulers of this country, you know. They've got all the money. They
control the banks, finance — everything.’

‘But,’ I said, ‘isn't it a fact that the average Jew is a labourer working for
about a penny an hour?’


‘Ah, that's only for show! They're all money-lenders really. They're cunning, the
Jews.’


In just the same way, a couple of hundred years ago, poor old women used to be
burned for witchcraft when they could not even work enough magic to get themselves
a square meal.

All people who work with their hands are partly invisible, and the more important
the work they do, the less visible they are. Still, a white skin is always fairly
conspicuous. In northern Europe, when you see a labourer ploughing a field, you
probably give him a second glance. In a hot country, anywhere south of Gibraltar or
east of Suez, the chances are that you don't even see him. I have noticed this
again and again. In a tropical landscape one's eye takes in everything except the
human beings. It takes in the dried-up soil, the prickly pear, the palm-tree and
the distant mountain, but it always misses the peasant hoeing at his patch. He is
the same colour as the earth, and a great deal less interesting to look at.


It is only because of this that the starved countries of Asia and Africa are
accepted as tourist resorts. No one would think of running cheap trips to the
Distressed Areas.
But where the human beings have brown skins their poverty is
simply not noticed. What does Morocco mean to a Frenchman? An orange-grove or a
job in government service.
Or to an Englishman? Camels, castles, palm-trees, For-
eign Legionnaires, brass trays and bandits.
One could probably live here for years
without noticing that for nine-tenths of the people the reality of life is an
endless, back-breaking struggle to wring a little food out of an eroded soil.


Most of Morocco is so desolate that no wild animal bigger than a hare can live on
it.
Huge areas which were once covered with forest have turned into a treeless
waste where the soil is exactly like broken-up brick. Nevertheless a good deal of
it is cultivated, with frightful labour. Everything is done by hand. Long lines of
women, bent double like inverted capital Ls, work their way slowly across the
fields, tearing up the prickly weeds with their hands, and the peasant gathering
lucerne for fodder pulls it up stalk by stalk instead of reaping it, thus saving an
inch or two on each stalk. The plough is a wretched wooden thing
, so frail that one
can easily carry it on one's shoulder, and fitted underneath with a rough iron
spike which stirs the soil to a depth of about four inches. This is as much as the
strength of the animals is equal to. It is usual to plough with a cow and a donkey
yoked together. Two donkeys would not be quite strong enough, but on the other hand
two cows would cost a little more to feed.
The peasants possess no harrows, they
merely plough the soil several times over in different directions, finally leaving
it in rough furrows, after which the whole field has to be shaped with hoes into
small oblong patches, to conserve water.
Except for a day or two after the rare
rainstorms there is never enough water. Along the edges of the fields
channels are
hacked out to a depth of thirty or forty feet to get at the tiny trickles which run
through the subsoil.


Every afternoon a file of very old women passes down the road outside my house,
each carrying a load of firewood.
All of them are mummified with age and the sun,
and all of them are tiny.
It seems to be generally the case in primitive
communities that the women, when they get beyond a certain age, shrink to the size
of children. One day a poor old creature who could not have been more than four
feet tall crept past me under a vast load of wood. I stopped her and put a five-sou
piece (a little more than a farthing) into her hand.
She answered with a shrill
wail, almost a scream, which was partly gratitude but mainly surprise. I suppose
that from her point of view, by taking any notice of her, I seemed almost to be
violating a law of nature. She accepted her status as
an old woman, that is to say
as
a beast of burden. When a family is travelling it is quite usual to see a father
and a grown-up son riding ahead on donkeys, and an old woman following on foot,
carrying the baggage.

But what is strange about these people is their invisibility. For several weeks,
always at about the same time of day, the file of old women had hobbled past the
house with their firewood, and
though they had registered themselves on my eyeballs
I cannot truly say that I had seen them.
Firewood was passing — that was how I saw
it. It was only that one day I happened to be walking behind them, and
the curious
up-and-down motion of a load of wood drew my attention to the human being
underneath it. Then for the first time I noticed the poor old earth-coloured
bodies, bodies reduced to bones and leathery skin, bent double under the crushing
weight.
Yet I suppose I had not been five minutes on Moroccan soil before I noticed
the overloading of the donkeys and was infuriated by it. There is no question that
the donkeys are damnably treated.
The Moroccan donkey is hardly bigger than a St
Bernard dog, it
carries a load which in the British army would be considered too
much for a fifteen-hands mule, and very often its pack-saddle is not taken off its
back for weeks together. But what is peculiarly pitiful is that it is the most
willing creature on earth, it follows its master like a dog and does not need
either bridle or halter. After a dozen years of devoted work it suddenly drops
dead, whereupon its master tips it into the ditch and the village dogs have torn
its guts out before it is cold.

This kind of thing makes one's blood boil, whereas — on the whole — the plight of
the human beings does not. I am not commenting, merely pointing to a fact. People
with brown skins are next door to invisible.
Anyone can be sorry for the donkey
with its galled back
, but it is generally owing to some kind of accident if one
even notices the old woman under her load of sticks.




As the storks flew northward the Negroes were marching southward — a long, dusty
column, infantry, screw-gun batteries and then more infantry, four or five thousand
men in all, winding up the road with a clumping of boots and a clatter of iron
wheels.

They were
Senegalese, the blackest Negroes in Africa, so black that sometimes it is
difficult to see whereabouts on their necks the hair begins. Their splendid bodies
were hidden in reach-me-down khaki uniforms, their feet squashed into boots that
looked like blocks of wood, and every tin hat seemed to be a couple of sizes too
small. It was very hot and the men had marched a long way. They
slumped under the
weight of their packs and the curiously sensitive black faces were glistening with
sweat.


As they went past a tall, very young Negro turned and caught my eye. But
the look
he gave me was not in the least the kind of look you might expect. Not hostile, not
contemptuous, not sullen, not even inquisitive. It was the shy, wide-eyed Negro
look, which actually is a look of profound respect. I saw how it was. This wretched
boy, who is a French citizen and has therefore been dragged from the forest to
scrub floors and catch syphilis in garrison towns, actually has feelings of
reverence before a white skin.
He has been taught that the white race are his
masters, and he still believes it.

But there is one thought which every white man (and in this connection it doesn't
matter twopence if he calls himself a Socialist) thinks when he sees a black army
marching past.
‘How much longer can we go on kidding these people? How long before
they turn their guns in the other direction?’


It was curious, really. Every white man there has this thought stowed somewhere or
other in his mind. I had it, so had the other onlookers, so had the officers on
their sweating chargers and the white NCOs marching in the ranks. It was a kind of
secret which we all knew and were too clever to tell; only the Negroes didn't know
it. And really
it was almost like watching a flock of cattle to see the long
column, a mile or two miles of armed men, flowing peacefully up the road, while the
great white birds drifted over them in the opposite direction, glittering like
scraps of paper.




Boys' Weeklies and Frank Richards's Reply



You never walk far through any poor quarter in any big town without
coming upon a small newsagent's shop. The general appearance of these
shops is always very much the same: a few posters for the DAILY MAIL and
the NEWS OF THE WORLD outside,
a poky little window with sweet-bottles
and packets of Players, and a dark interior smelling of liquorice allsorts
and festooned from floor to ceiling with vilely printed twopenny papers,
most of them with lurid cover-illustrations in three colours.


Except for the daily and evening papers, the stock of these shops hardly
overlaps at all with that of the big news-agents. Their main selling line
is
the twopenny weekly, and the number and variety of these are almost
unbelievable. Every hobby and pastime--cage-birds, fretwork, carpen-
tering, bees, carrier-pigeons, home conjuring, philately, chess--has at
least one paper devoted to it
, and generally several. Gardening and live-
stock-keeping must have at least a score between them. Then there
are the sporting papers, the radio papers, the children's comics, the
various snippet papers such as TIT-BITS, the large range of papers
devoted to the movies and
all more or less exploiting women's legs, the
various trade papers, the women's story-papers (the ORACLE, SECRETS,
PEG'S PAPER, etc. etc.), the needlework papers--these so numerous that a
display of them alone will often fill an entire window--and in addition
the long series of
'Yank Mags' (FIGHT STORIES, ACTION STORIES, WESTERN
SHORT STORIES, etc.), which are
imported shop-soiled from America and
sold at twopence halfpenny or threepence.
And the periodical proper
shades off into the fourpenny novelette, the ALDINE BOXING NOVELS, the
BOYS' FRIEND LIBRARY, the SCHOOLGIRLS' OWN LIBRARY and many others.

Probably the contents of these shops is the best available indication of
what the mass of the English people really feels and thinks. Certainly
nothing half so revealing exists in documentary form.
Best-seller novels,
for instance, tell one a great deal, but the novel is aimed almost exclu-
sively at people above the £4-a-week level. The movies are probably
a very unsafe guide to popular taste, because the film industry is
virtually a monopoly, which means that it is not obliged to study its
public at all closely.
The same applies to some extent to the daily
papers, and most of all to the radio. But it does not apply to the weekly
paper with a smallish circulation and specialized subject-matter. Papers
like the EXCHANGE AND MART, for instance, or CAGE-BIRDS, or the ORACLE,
or the PREDICTION, or the MATRIMONIAL TIMES, only exist because there is
a definite demand for them, and they reflect the minds of their readers
as a great national daily with a circulation of millions cannot possibly
do.


Here I am only dealing with a single series of papers, the boys' twopenny
weeklies, often inaccurately described as
'penny dreadfuls'. Falling
strictly within this class there are at present ten papers, the
GEM,
MAGNET, MODERN BOY
, TRIUMPH and CHAMPION, all owned by the Amalgamated
Press, and the
WIZARD, ROVER, SKIPPER, HOTSPUR and ADVENTURE, all owned
by D. C. Thomson & Co. What the circulations of these papers are, I do
not know. The editors and proprietors refuse to name any figures, and in
any case the circulation of a paper carrying serial stories is bound to
fluctuate widely. But there is no question that the combined public of
the ten papers is a very large one. They are on sale in every town in
England, and nearly every boy who reads at all goes through a phase of
reading one or more of them. The GEM and MAGNET, which are much the
oldest of these papers, are of rather different type from the rest, and
they have evidently lost some of their popularity during the past few
years.
A good many boys now regard them as old fashioned and 'slow'.
Nevertheless I want to discuss them first, because they are more
interesting psychologically than the others, and also because
the mere
survival of such papers into the nineteen-thirties is a rather startling
phenomenom.


The GEM and MAGNET are sister-papers (characters out of one paper
frequently appear in the other), and were both started more than thirty
years ago. At that time, together with Chums and the old B[oy's] O[wn]
P[aper], they were the leading papers for boys, and they remained domi-
nant till quite recently. Each of them carries every week a fifteen--or
twenty-thousand-word school story, complete in itself, but usually more
or less connected with the story of the week before. The Gem in addition
to its school story carries one or more adventure serial. Otherwise the
two papers are so much alike that they can be treated as one, though the
MAGNET has always been the better known of the two, probably because
it
possesses a really first-rate character in the fat boy. Billy Bunter.

The stories are stories of what purports to be public-school life, and
the schools (Greyfriars in the MAGNET and St Jim's in the GEM) are
represented as ancient and fashionable foundations
of the type of Eton or
Winchester. All the leading characters are fourth-form boys aged fourteen
or fifteen, older or younger boys only appearing in very minor parts.
Like Sexton Blake and Nelson Lee, these boys continue week after week
and year after year, never growing any older.
Very occasionally a new boy
arrives or a minor character drops out, but in at any rate the last
twenty-five years the personnel has barely altered. All the principal
characters in both papers--Bob Cherry, Tom Merry, Harry Wharton, Johnny
Bull, Billy Bunter and the rest of them--were at Greyfriars or St Jim's
long before the Great War, exactly the same age as at present, having
much the same kind of adventures and talking almost exactly the same
dialect. And not only the characters but the whole atmosphere of both Gem
and Magnet has been preserved unchanged, partly by means of very
elaborate stylization.
The stories in the Magnet are signed 'Frank
Richards' and those in the GEM, 'Martin Clifford', but a series lasting
thirty years could hardly be the work of the same person every week.
Consequently they have to be written in a style that is easily imitated
--an extraordinary, artificial, repetitive style, quite different from any-
thing else now existing in English literature. A couple of extracts will
do as illustrations. Here is one from the MAGNET:


Groan!

'Shutup, Bunter!'

Groan!


Shutting up was not really in Billy Bunter's line. He seldom shut up,
though often requested to do so. On the present awful occasion the fat
Owl of Greyfriars was less inclined than ever to shut up. And he did not
shut up! He groaned, and groaned, and went on groaning.

Even groaning did not fully express Bunter's feelings. His feelings, in
fact, were inexpressible.

There were six of them in the soup! Only one of the six uttered sounds of
woe and lamentation. But that one, William George Bunter, uttered enough
for the whole party and a little over.

Harry Wharton & Go. stood in a wrathy and worried group. They were landed
and stranded, diddled, dished and done!
etc., etc., etc.


Here is one from the Gem:


'Oh cwumbsl'

'Oh gum!'

'Oooogh!'

'Urrggh!'

Arthur Augustus sat up dizzily. He grabbed his handkerchief and pressed
it to his damaged nose. Tom Merry sat up, gasping for breath. They looked
at one another.

'Bai Jove! This is a go, deah boy!' gurgled Arthur Augustus. 'I have been
thwown into quite a fluttah! Oogh! The wottahsl The wuffians! The feahful
outsidahs!
Wow!' etc., etc., etc.


Both of these extracts are entirely typical: you would find something
like them in almost every chapter of every number, to-day or twenty-five
years ago. The first thing that anyone would notice is the
extraordinary
amount of tautology (the first of these two passages contains a hundred
and twenty-five words and could be compressed into about thirty),
seemingly designed to spin out the story, but actually playing its part
in creating the atmosphere. For the same reason various facetious
expressions are repeated over and over again; 'wrathy', for instance, is
a great favourite, and so is 'diddled, dished and done'. 'Oooogh!',
'Grooo!' and 'Yaroo!' (stylized cries of pain) recur constantly, and so
does 'Ha! ha! ha!', always given a line to itself, so that sometimes a
quarter of a column or there-abouts consists of 'Ha! ha! ha!' The slang
('Go and cat coke!', 'What the thump!', 'You frabjous ass!'
, etc. etc.)
has never been altered, so that the boys are now using slang which is at
least thirty years out of date. In addition, the various nicknames are
rubbed in on every possible occasion. Every few lines we are reminded
that Harry Wharton & Co. are 'the Famous Five', Bunter is always 'the fat
Owl' or 'the Owl of the Remove', Vernon-Smith is always 'the Bounder of
Greyfriars', Gussy (the Honourable Arthur Augustus D'Arcy) is always 'the
swell of St Jim's', and so on and so forth.
There is a constant, untiring
effort to keep the atmosphere intact and to make sure that every new
reader learns immediately who is who.
The result has been to make
Greyfriars and St Jim's into an extraordinary little world of their own,
a world which cannot be taken seriously by anyone over fifteen, but which
at any rate is not easily forgotten.
By a debasement of the Dickens
technique a series of stereotyped 'characters' has been built up
, in
several cases very successfully. Billy Bunter, for instance, must be one
of the best-known figures in English fiction; for the mere number of
people who know him he ranks with Sexton Blake, Tarzan, Sherlock Holmes
and a handful of characters in Dickens.

Needless to say, these stories are fantastically unlike life at a real
public school. They run in cycles of rather differing types, but in
general they are the
clean-fun, knock-about type of story, with interest
centring round horseplay, practical jokes, ragging roasters, fights,
canings, football, cricket and food. A constantly recurring story is one
in which a boy is accused of some misdeed committed by another and is
too much of a sportsman to reveal the truth. The 'good' boys are 'good' in
the clean-living Englishman tradition--they keep in hard training, wash
behind their ears, never hit below the belt etc.
, etc.,--and by way of
contrast there is a series of 'bad' boys, Racke, Crooke, Loder and others,
whose badness consists in betting, smoking cigarettes and frequenting
public-houses. All these boys are constantly on the verge of expulsion,

but as it would mean a change of personnel if any boy were actually
expelled, no one is ever caught out in any really serious offence.
Stealing, for instance, barely enters as a motif. Sex is completely
taboo, especially in the form in which it actually arises at public
schools. Occasionally girls enter into the stories, and very rarely there
is something approaching a mild flirtation, but it is entirely in the
spirit of clean fun. A boy and a girl enjoy going for bicycle rides
together--that is all it ever amounts to. Kissing, for instance, would
be regarded as 'soppy'. Even the bad boys are presumed to be completely
sexless. When the GEM and MAGNET were started, it is probable that there
was a deliberate intention to get away from the guilty sex-ridden
atmosphere that pervaded so much of the earlier literature for boys. In
the nineties the BOYS' OWN PAPER, for instance, used to have its
correspondence columns full of terrifying warnings against masturbation,
and books like ST WINIFRED'S and TOM BROWN'S SCHOOL-DAYS were
heavy with homosexual feeling, though no doubt the authors were not fully
aware of it. In the GEM and MAGNET sex simply does not exist
as a pro-
blem. Religion is also taboo; in the whole thirty years' issue of the two
papers the word 'God' probably does not occur, except in 'God save the
King'. On the other hand, there has always been a very strong
'temperance' strain. Drinking and, by association, smoking are regarded
as rather disgraceful even in an adult ('shady' is the usual word), but
at the same time as something irresistibly fascinating, a sort of
substitute for sex. In their moral atmosphere the GEM and MAGNET have a
great deal in common with the Boy Scout movement, which started at about
the same time.


All literature of this kind is partly plagiarism. Sexton Blake, for
instance, started off quite frankly as an imitation of Sherlock Holmes,
and still resembles him fairly strongly; he has hawk-like features, lives
in Baker Street, smokes enormously and puts on a dressing-gown when he
wants to think.
The GEM and MAGNET probably owe something to the old
school-story writers who were flourishing when they began, Gunby Hadath,
Desmond Coke and the rest, but they owe more to nineteenth-century
models. In so far as Greyfriars and St Jim's are like real schools at
all, they are much more like Tom Brown's Rugby than a modern public
school. Neither school has an O.T.G., for instance, games are not
compulsory, and the boys are even allowed to wear what clothes they like.
But without doubt the main origin of these papers is STALKY & CO. This
book has had an immense influence on boys' literature, and it is one of
those books which have a sort of traditional reputation among people who
have never even seen a copy of it.
More than once in boys' weekly papers
I have come across a reference to STALKY & CO. in which the word was
spelt 'Storky'. Even the name of the chief comic among the Greyfriars
masters, Mr Prout, is taken from STALKY & CO., and so is much of the
slang; 'jape', 'merry','giddy', 'bizney' (business), 'frabjous', 'don't' for
'doesn't'--all of them out of date even when GEM and MAGNET started.
There are also traces of earlier origins. The name 'Greyfriars' is prob-
ably taken from Thackeray, and Gosling, the school porter in the
MAGNET, talks in an imitation of Dickens's dialect.


With all this, the supposed 'glamour' of public-school life is played for
all it is worth. There is
all the usual paraphernalia--lock-up,
roll-call, house matches, fagging, prefects, cosy teas round the study
fire, etc. etc.--and constant reference to the 'old school', the 'old
grey stones' (both schools were founded in the early sixteenth century)
,
the 'team spirit' of the 'Greyfriars men'. As for the snob-appeal, it is
completely shameless. Each school has a titled boy or two whose titles
are constantly thrust in the reader's face; other boys have the names of
well-known aristocratic families, Talbot, Manners, Lowther. We are for
ever being reminded that Gussy is the Honourable Arthur A. D'Arcy, son of
Lord Eastwood, that Jack Blake is heir to 'broad acres', that Hurree
Jamset Ram Singh (nicknamed Inky) is the
Nabob of Bhanipur, that
Vernon-Smith's father is a millionaire.
Till recently the illustrations
in both papers always depicted the boys in clothes imitated from those of
Eton; in the last few years Greyfriars has changed over to blazers and
flannel trousers, but St Jim's still sticks to the Eton jacket, and Gussy
sticks to his top-hat.
In the school magazine which appears every week as
part of the MAGNET, Harry Wharton writes an
article discussing the
pocket-money received by the 'fellows in the Remove', and reveals that
some of them get as much as five pounds a week! This kind of thing is a
perfectly deliberate incitement to wealth-fantasy.
And here it is worth
noticing a rather curious fact, and that is that the school story is a
thing peculiar to England. So far as I know, there are extremely few
school stories in foreign languages. The reason, obviously, is that
in
England education is mainly a matter of status. The most definite
dividing line between the petite-bourgeoisie and the working class is
that the former pay for their education, and within the bourgeoisie there
is another unbridgeable gulf between the 'public' school and the
'private' school. It is quite clear that there are tens and scores of
thousands of people to whom every detail of life at a 'posh' public
school is wildly thrilling and romantic. They happen to be outside that
mystic world of quadrangles and house-colours, but they can yearn after
it, day-dream about it, live mentally in it for hours at a stretch.
The
question is, Who are these people? Who reads the GEM and MAGNET?


Obviously one can never be quite certain about this kind of thing. All I
can say from my own observation is this. Boys who are likely to go to
public schools themselves generally read the GEM and MAGNET, but they
nearly always stop reading them when they are about twelve; they may
continue for another year from force of habit, but by that time they have
ceased to take them seriously. On the other hand, the boys at very cheap
private schools, the schools that are designed for people who can't
afford a public school but consider the Council schools 'common', con-
tinue reading the GEM and MAGNET for several years longer. A few years
ago I was a teacher at two of these schools myself. I found that not only
did virtually all the boys read the GEM and MAGNET, but that they were
still taking them fairly seriously when they were fifteen or even
sixteen. These boys were the sons of shopkeepers, office employees and
small business and professional men, and obviously it is this class that
the GEM and MAGNET are aimed at. But they are certainly read by
working-class boys as well. They are generally on sale in the poorest
quarters of big towns, and I have known them to be
read by boys whom one
might expect to be completely immune from public-school 'glamour'.
I have
seen a young coal miner, for instance, a lad who had already worked a
year or two underground, eagerly reading the GEM. Recently I offered a
batch of English papers to some British legionaries of the French Foreign
Legion in North Africa; they picked out the GEM and MAGNET first. Both
papers are much read by girls, and
the Pen Pals department
of the GEM shows that it is read in every corner of the British Empire, by
Australians, Canadians, Palestine Jews, Malays, Arabs, Straits Chinese
,
etc., etc. The editors evidently expect their readers to be aged round
about fourteen, and the
advertisements (milk chocolate, postage stamps,
water pistols, blushing cured, home conjuring tricks, itching powder, the
Phine Phun Ring which runs a needle into your friend's hand
, etc., etc.)
indicate roughly the same age;
there are also the Admiralty
advertisements, however, which call for youths between seventeen and
twenty-two. And there is no question that these papers are also read by
adults. It is quite common for people to write to the editor and say that
they have read every number of the GEM or MAGNET for the past thirty
years. Here, for instance, is a letter from a lady in Salisbury:


I can say of your splendid yarns of Harry Wharton & Co. of Greyfriars,
that they never fail to reach a high standard. Without doubt they are the
finest stories of their type on the market to-day, which is saying a good
deal. They seem to bring you face to face with Nature.
I have taken the
Magnet from the start, and have followed the adventures of Harry Wharton
& Co. with rapt interest. I have no sons, but two daughters, and there's
always a rush to be the first to read the grand old paper. My husband,
too, was a staunch reader of the Magnet until he was suddenly taken away
from us.


It is well worth getting hold of some copies of the GEM and MAGNET,
especially the GEM, simply to have a look at the correspondence columns.
What is truly startling is the intense interest with which the pettiest
details of life at Greyfriars and St Jim's are followed up.
Here, for
instance, are a few of the questions sent in by readers:

What age is Dick Roylance?' 'How old is St Jim's?' 'Can you give me a
list of the Shell and their studies?' 'How much did D'Arcy's monocle
cost?'
'How is it that fellows like Crooke are in the Shell and decent
fellows like yourself are only in the Fourth?'
'What are the Form
captain's three chief duties?' 'Who is the chemistry master at St Jim's?'
(From a girl) 'Where is St Jim's situated?
COULD you tell me how to get
there, as I would love to see the building? Are you boys just "phoneys",
as I think you are?'


It is clear that many of the boys and girls who write these letters are
living a complete fantasy-life. Sometimes a boy will write, for instance,
giving his age, height, weight, chest and bicep measurements and asking
which member of the Shell or Fourth Form he most exactly resembles.
The
demand for a list of the studies on the Shell passage, with an exact
account of who lives in each, is a very common one. The editors, of
course, do everything in their power to keep up the illusion. In the GEM
Jack Blake is supposed to write answers to correspondents,
and in the
MAGNET a couple of pages is always given up to the school magazine (the
GREYFRIARS HERALD, edited by Harry Wharton), and there is another page
in which one or other character is written up each week. The stories run
in cycles, two or three characters being kept in the foreground for
several weeks at a time. First there will be a series of rollicking
adventure stories, featuring the Famous Five and Billy Bunter; then a run
of stories turning on mistaken identity, with Wibley (the make-up wizard)
in the star part; then a run of more serious stories in which Vernon-
Smith is trembling on the verge of expulsion. And here one comes upon
the real secret of the GEM and MAGNET and the probable reason why
they continue to be read in spite of their obvious out-of-dateness.


It is that the characters are so carefully graded as to give almost every
type of reader a character he can identify himself with. Most boys'
papers aim at doing this, hence the boy-assistant (Sexton Blake's Tinker,
Nelson Lee's Nipper, etc.) who usually accompanies the explorer,
detective or what-not on his adventures. But in these cases there is only
one boy, and usually it is much the same type of boy.
In the GEM and
MAGNET there is a model for very nearly everybody. There is the normal
athletic, high-spirited boy (Tom Merry, Jack Blake, Frank Nugent), a
slightly rowdier version of this type (Bob Cherry), a more aristocratic
version (Talbot, Manners), a quieter, more serious version (Harry
Wharton), and a stolid, 'bulldog' version (Johnny Bull). Then there is
the reckless, dare-devil type of boy (Vernon-Smith), the definitely
'clever', studious boy (Mark Linley, Dick Penfold), and the eccentric boy
who is not good at games but possesses some special talent (Skinner
Wibley). And there is the scholarship-boy (Tom Redwing), an important
figure in this class of story because he makes it possible for boys from
very poor homes to project themselves into the public-school atmosphere.

In addition there are Australian, Irish, Welsh, Manx, Yorkshire and
Lancashire boys to play upon local patriotism. But the subtlety of
characterization goes deeper than this. If one studies the correspondence
columns one sees that there is probably NO character in the GEM and
MAGNET whom some or other reader does not identify with, except the
out-and-out comics, Coker, Billy Bunter, Fisher T. Fish (the money-
grabbing American boy) and, of course, the masters.
Bunter, though
in his origin he probably owed something to the fat boy in PICKWICK, is
a real creation. His tight trousers against which boots and canes are
constantly thudding, his astuteness in search of food
, his postal order
which never turns up, have made him famous wherever the Union Jack
waves. But he is not a subject for day-dreams. On the other hand, another
seeming figure of fun, Gussy (the Honourable Arthur A. D'Arcy, 'the swell
of St Jim's'), is evidently much admired. Like everything else in the GEM
and MAGNET,
Gussy is at least thirty years out of date. He is the 'knut'
of the early twentieth century or even the 'masher' of the nineties ('Bai
Jove, deah boy!' and 'Weally, I shall be obliged to give you a feahful
thwashin'!'), the monocled idiot
who made good on the fields of Mons and
Le Gateau. And his evident popularity goes to show how deep the
snob-appeal of this type is.
English people are extremely fond of the
titled ass (cf. Lord Peter Wimscy) who always turns up trumps in the
moment of emergency.
Here is a letter from one of Gussy's girl admirers;

I think you're too hard on Gussy. I wonder he's still in existence, the
way you treat him. He's my hero. Did you know I write lyrics? How's this
--to the tune of 'Goody Goody'?

Gonna get my gas-mask, join the ARP.
'Cos I'm wise to all those bombs you drop on me.
Gonna dig myself a trench
Inside the garden fence;
Gonna seal my windows up with tin
So the tear gas can't get in;
Gonna park my cannon right outside the kerb
With a note to Adolf Hitler: 'Don't disturb!'
And if I never fall in Nazi hands
That's soon enough for me

Gonna get my gas-mask, join the ARP
.

P.S.--Do you get on well with girls?

I quote this in full because (dated April 1939) it is interesting as
being probably the earliest mention of Hitler in the GEM. In the GEM
there is also a heroic fat boy. Fatty Wynn, as a set-off against Bunter.
Vernon-Smith, 'the Bounder of the Remove', a Byronic character, always on
the verge of the sack, is another great favourite. And even some of the
cads probably have their following. Loder, for instance,
'the rotter of
the Sixth', is a cad, but he is also a highbrow and given to saying
sarcastic things about football and the team spirit.
The boys of the
Remove only think him all the more of a cad for this, but a certain type
of boy would probably identify with him. Even
Racke, Grooke & Co. are
probably admired by small boys who think it diabolically wicked to smoke
cigarettes.
(A frequent question in the correspondence column; 'What
brand of cigarettes does Racke smoke?')


Naturally the politics of the GEM and MAGNET are Conservative, but in a
completely pre-1914 style, with no Fascist tinge. In reality
their basic
political assumptions are two: nothing ever changes, and foreigners are
funny. In the GEM of 1939 Frenchmen are still Froggies and Italians are
still Dagoes.
Mossoo, the French master at Greyfriars, is the usual
comic-paper Frog, with pointed beard, pegtop trousers, etc. Inky, the
Indian boy, though a rajah, and therefore possessing snob-appeal, is also
the comic babu of the PUNCH tradition. (
"The rowfulness is not the
proper caper, my esteemed Bob," said Inky. "Let dogs delight in the
barkfulness and bitefulness, but the soft answer is the cracked pitcher
that goes longest to a bird in the bush, as the English proverb remarks."
)
Fisher T. Fish is the old-style stage Yankee ("Waal, I guess", etc.)
dating from a peroid of Anglo-American jealousy. Wun Lung, the
Chinese boy (he has rather faded out of late, no doubt because some of
the MAGNET'S readers are Straits Chinese), is the nineteenth-century
pantomime Chinaman, with saucer-shaped hat, pigtail and pidgin-English.
The assumption all along is not only that foreigners are comics who are
put there for us to laugh at, but that they can be classified in much the
same way as insects.
That is why in all boys' papers, not only the GEM
and MAGNET, a Chinese is invariably portrayed with a pigtail. It is the
thing you recognize him by, like the Frenchman's beard or the Italian's
barrel-organ. In papers of this kind it occasionally happens that when
the setting of a story is in a foreign country some attempt is made to
describe the natives as individual human beings, but as a rule it is
assumed that foreigners of any one race are all alike and will conform
more or less exactly to the following patterns:



FRENCHMAN: Excitable. Wears beard, gesticulates wildly.
SPANIARD, Mexican, etc.: Sinister, treacherous.
ARAB, Afghan, etc.: Sinister, treacherous.
CHINESE: Sinister, treacherous. Wears pigtail.
ITALIAN: Excitable. Grinds barrel-organ or carries stiletto.
SWEDE, Dane, etc.: Kind-hearted, stupid.
NEGRO: Comic, very faithful.



The working classes only enter into the GEM and MAGNET as comics or
semi-villains (race-course touts, etc.).
As for class-friction, trade
unionism, strikes, slumps, unemployment, Fascism and civil war--not a
mention.
Somewhere or other in the thirty years' issue of the two papers
you might perhaps find the word 'Socialism', but you would have to look a
long time for it. If the Russian Revolution is anywhere referred to, it
will be indirectly, in the word
'Bolshy' (meaning a person of violent
disagreeable habits)
. Hitler and the Nazis are just beginning to make
their appearance, in the sort of reference I quoted above. The war-crisis
of September 1938 made just enough impression to produce a story in which
Mr Vernon-Smith, the Bounder's millionaire father, cashed in on the
general panic by buying up country houses in order to sell them to
'crisis
scuttlers'
. But that is probably as near to noticing the European situation
as the GEM and MAGNET will come, until the war actually starts.
That does not mean that these papers are unpatriotic--quite the
contrary! Throughout the Great War the GEM and MAGNET were perhaps the
most consistently and cheerfully patriotic papers in England. Almost
every week the boys caught a spy or pushed a conchy into the army, and
during the rationing period 'EAT LESS BREAD' was printed in large type on
every page.
But their patriotism has nothing whatever to do with
power-politics or 'ideological' warfare. It is more akin to family
loyalty, and actually it gives one a valuable clue to the attitude of
ordinary people, especially the huge untouched block of the middle class
and the better-off working class. These people are patriotic to the
middle of their bones, but they do not feel that what happens in foreign
countries is any of their business. When England is in danger they rally
to its defence as a matter of course, but in between-times they are not
interested. After all, England is always in the right and England always
wins, so why worry? It is an attitude that has been shaken during the
past twenty years, but not so deeply as is sometimes supposed. Failure to
understand it is one of the reasons why Left Wing political parties are
seldom able to produce an acceptable foreign policy.


The mental world of the GEM and MAGNET, therefore, is something like
this:

The year is 1910--or 1940, but it is all the same. You are at
Greyfriars, a rosy-cheeked boy of fourteen in posh tailor-made clothes
,
sitting down to tea in your study on the Remove passage after an exciting
game of football which was won by an odd goal in the last half-minute.
There is a cosy fire in the study, and outside the wind is whistling. The
ivy clusters thickly round the old grey stones. The King is on his throne
and the pound is worth a pound. Over in Europe the comic foreigners are
jabbering and gesticulating, but the grim grey battleships of the British
Fleet are steaming up the Channel and at the outposts of Empire the
monocled Englishmen are holding the niggers at bay. Lord Mauleverer has
just got another fiver and we are all settling down to a tremendous tea
of sausages, sardines, crumpets, potted meat, jam and doughnuts.
After
tea we shall sit round the study fire having a good laugh at Billy Bunter
and discussing the team for next week's match against Rook-wood.
Everything is safe, solid and unquestionable. Everything will be the
same for ever and ever. That approximately is the atmosphere.


But now turn from the GEM and MAGNET to the more up-to-date papers which
have appeared since the Great War. The truly significant thing is that
they have more points of resemblance to the GEM and MAGNET than points of
difference. But it is better to consider the differences first.

There are eight of these newer papers, the MODERN BOY, TRIUMPH, CHAMPION,
WIZARD, ROVER, SKIPPER, HOTSPUR and ADVENTURE. All of these have appeared
since the Great War, but except for the MODERN BOY none of them is less
than five years old. Two papers which ought also to be mentioned briefly
here; though they are not strictly in the same class as the rest, are the
DETECTIVE WEEKLY and the THRILLER, both owned by the Amalgamated Press.
The DETECTIVE WEEKLY has taken over Sexton Blake. Both of these papers
admit a certain amount of sex-interest into their stories, and though
certainly read by boys; they are not aimed at them exclusively. All the
others are boys' papers pure and simple, and they are sufficiently alike
to be considered together.
There does not seem to be any notable
difference between Thomson's publications and those of the Amalgamated
Press.

As soon. as one looks at these papers one sees their technical
superiority to the GEM and MAGNET. To begin with, they have the great
advantage of not being written entirely by one person. Instead of one
long complete story, a number of the WIZARD or HOTSPUR consists of half a
dozen or more serials, none of which goes on for ever. Consequently
there
is far more variety and far less padding, and none of the tiresome
stylization and facetiousness
of the GEM and MAGNET. Look at these two
extracts, for example:


Billy Bunter groaned.

A quarter of an hour had elapsed out of the two hours that Bunter was
booked for extra French.

In a quarter of an hour there were only fifteen minutes! But every one of
those minutes seemed inordinately long to Bunter. They seemed to crawl by
like tired snails.

Looking at the clock in Classroom No. 10 the fat Owl could hardly believe
that only fifteen minutes had passed. It seemed more like fifteen hours,
if not fifteen days!

Other fellows were in extra French as well as Bunter. They did not
matter. Bunter did!
(The Magnet)

* * *

After a terrible climb, hacking out handholds in the smooth ice every
step of the way up. Sergeant Lionheart Logan of the Mounties was now
clinging like a human fly to the face of an icy cliff, as smooth and
treacherous as a giant pane of glass.

An Arctic blizzard, in all its fury, was buffeting his body, driving the
blinding snow into his face, seeking to tear his fingers loose from their
handholds and dash him to death on the jagged boulders which lay at the
foot of the cliff a hundred feet below.


Crouching among those boulders were eleven villainous trappers who had
done their best to shoot down Lionheart and his companion, Constable Jim
Rogers--until the blizzard had blotted the two Mounties out of sight
from below.
(The Wizard)


The second extract gets you some distance with the story, the first takes
a hundred words to tell you that Bunter is in the detention class.

Moreover, by not concentrating on school stories (in point of numbers the
school story slightly predominates in all these papers, except the
THRILLER and DETECTIVE WEEKLY), the WIZARD, HOTSPUR, etc., have
far greater opportunities for sensationalism. Merely looking at the cover
illustrations of the papers which I have on the table in front of me,
here are some of the things I see.
On one a cowboy is clinging by his
toes to the wing of an aeroplane in mid-air and shooting down another
aeroplane with his revolver. On another a Chinese is swimming for his
life down a sewer with a swarm of ravenous-looking rats swimming after
him. On another an engineer is lighting a stick of dynamite while a steel
robot feels for him with its claws. On another a man in airman's costume
is fighting barehanded against a rat somewhat larger than a donkey. On
another a nearly naked man of terrific muscular development has just
seized a lion by the tail and flung it thirty yards over the wall of an
arena, with the words, 'Take back your blooming lion!'
Clearly no school
story can compete with this kind of thing. From time to time the school
buildings may catch fire or the French master may turn out to be the head
of an international anarchist gang, but in a general way the interest
must centre round cricket, school rivalries, practical jokes, etc.
There
is not much room for bombs, death-rays, sub-machine guns, aeroplanes,
mustangs, octopuses, grizzly bears or gangsters.


Examination of a large number of these papers shows that, putting aside
school stories, the favourite subjects are Wild West, Frozen North,
Foreign Legion, crime (always from the detective's angle), the Great War
(Air Force or Secret Service, not the infantry), the Tarzan motif in
varying forms, professional football, tropical exploration, historical
romance (Robin Hood, Cavaliers and Round-heads, etc.) and scientific
invention. The Wild West still leads, at any rate as a setting, though
the Red Indian seems to be fading out.
The one theme that is really new
is the scientific one. Death-rays, Martians, invisible men, robots,
helicopters and interplanetary rockets figure largely: here and there
there are even far-off rumours of psychotherapy and ductless glands.

Whereas the GEM and MAGNET derive from Dickens and Kipling, the WIZARD,
CHAMPION, MODERN BOY, etc., owe a great deal to H. G. Wells, who, rather
than Jules Verne, is the father of 'Scientifiction'. Naturally it is the
magical Martian aspect of science that is most exploited, but one or two
papers include serious articles on scientific subjects, besides
quantities of informative snippets. (Examples: 'A Kauri tree in
Queensland, Australia, is over 12,000 years old'; 'Nearly 50,000
thunderstorms occur every day'; 'Helium gas costs £1 per 1000 cubic
feet'; 'There are over 500 varieties of spiders in Great Britain';
'London firemen use 14,000,000 gallons of water annually', etc., etc.)
There is a marked advance in intellectual curiosity
and, on the whole, in
the demand made on the reader's attention. In practice the GEM and MAGNET
and the post-war papers are read by much the same public, but
the mental
age aimed at seems to have risen by a year or two years--an improvement
probably corresponding to the improvement in elementary education since
1909.


The other thing that has emerged in the post-war boys' papers, though not
to anything like the extent one would expect, is
bully-worship and the
cult of violence.


If one compares the GEM and MAGNET with a genuinely modern paper, the
thing that immediately strikes one is the absence of the leader-principle.
There is no central dominating character; instead there are fifteen
or twenty characters, all more or less on an equality, with whom
readers of different types can identify. In the more MODERN papers
this is not usually the case. Instead of identifying with a schoolboy of
more or less his own age, the reader of the SKIPPER, HOTSPUR, etc., is
led to identify with a G-man, with a Foreign Legionary, with some variant
of
Tarzan, with an air ace, a master spy, an explorer, a pugilist--at
any rate with some single all-powerful character who dominates everyone
about him and whose usual method of solving any problem is a sock on the
jaw. This character is intended as a superman, and as physical strength
is the form of power that boys can best understand, he is usually a sort
of human gorilla;
in the Tarzan type of story he is sometimes actually a
giant, eight or ten feet high. At the same time the scenes of violence in
nearly all these stories are remarkably harmless and unconvincing. There
is a great difference in tone between even the most bloodthirsty English
paper and the threepenny Yank Mags, FIGHT STORIES, ACTION STORIES,
etc. (not strictly boys' papers, but largely read by boys).
In the Yank Mags
you get real blood-lust, really gory descriptions of the all-in,
jump-on-his-testicles style fighting, written in a jargon that has been
perfected by people who brood endlessly on violence. A paper like FIGHT
STORIES, for instance, would have very little appeal except to sadists
and masochists. You can see the comparative gentleness of the English
civilization
by the amateurish way in which prize-fighting is always
described
in the boys' weeklies. There is no specialized vocabulary. Look
at these four extracts, two English, two American;


When the gong sounded, both men were breathing heavily and each had great
red marks on his chest. Bill's chin was bleeding, and Ben had a cut over
his right eye.

Into their corners they sank, but when the gong clanged again they were
up swiftly, and they went like tigers at each other.
(ROVER)

* * *

He walked in stolidly and smashed a clublike right to my face. Blood
spattered and I went back on my heels, but surged in and ripped my right
under the heart. Another right smashed full on Ben's already battered
mouth, and, spitting out the fragments of a tooth, he crashed a flailing
left to my body.
(FIGHT STORIES)

* * *

It was amazing to watch the Black Panther at work. His muscles rippled
and slid under his dark skin. There was all the power and grace of a
giant cat in his swift and terrible onslaught.


He volleyed blows with a bewildering speed for so huge a fellow. In a
moment Ben was simply blocking with his gloves as well as he could. Ben
was really a past-master of defence. He had many fine victories behind
him. But the Negro's rights and lefts crashed through openings that
hardly any other fighter could have found.
(WIZARD)

* * *

Haymakers which packed the bludgeoning weight of forest monarchs crashing
down under the ax hurled into the bodies of the two heavies as they
swapped punches.
(FIGHT STORIES)


Notice how much more knowledgeable the American extracts sound. They
are written for devotees of the prize-ring, the others are not. Also, it
ought to be emphasized that on its level the moral code of the English
boys' papers is a decent one. Crime and dishonesty are never held up to
admiration, there is none of the cynicism and corruption of the American
gangster story. The huge sale of the Yank Mags in England shows that
there is a demand for that kind of thing, but very few English writers
seem able to produce it. When hatred of Hitler became a major emotion
in America, it was interesting to see
how promptly'anti-Fascism' was
adapted to pornographic purposes
by the editors of the Yank Mags. One
magazine which I have in front of me is given up to a long, complete
story,
'When Hell Game to America', in which the agents of a 'blood-
maddened European dictator' are trying to conquer the U.S.A. with
death-rays and invisible aeroplanes. There is the frankest appeal to
sadism, scenes in which the Nazis tie bombs to women's backs and fling
them off heights to watch them blown to pieces in mid-air, others in
which they tie naked girls together by their hair and prod them with
knives to make them dance, etc., etc. The editor comments solemnly
on all this, and uses it as a plea for tightening up restrictions against
immigrants.
On another page of the same paper: 'LIVES OF THE HOTCHA
CHORUS GIRLS. Reveals all the intimate secrets and fascinating pastimes
of the famous Broadway Hotcha girls. NOTHING IS OMITTED. Price 10c.' 'HOW
TO LOVE. 10c.' 'FRENCH PHOTO RING. 25c.' 'NAUGHTY NUDIES TRANSFERS.
From the outside of the glass you see a beautiful girl, innocently dressed.
Turn it around and look through the glass and oh! what a difference! Set
of 3 transfers 25c.,' etc., etc., etc. There is nothing at all like this
in any English paper likely to be read by boys. But the process of
Americanization is going on all the same. The American ideal, the
'he-man', the 'tough guy', the gorilla who puts everything right by
socking everybody on the jaw
, now figures in probably a majority of boys'
papers. In one serial now running in the SKIPPER he is
always portrayed
ominously enough, swinging a rubber truncheon.


The development of the WIZARD, HOTSPUR, etc., as against the earlier
boys' papers, boils down to this:
better technique, more scientific
interest, more bloodshed, more leader-worship.
But, after all, it is the
LACK of development that is the really striking thing.


To begin with, there is no political development whatever. The world of
the SKIPPER and the CHAMPION is still the pre-1914 world of the MAGNET
and the GEM. The Wild West story, for instance, with its cattle-rustlers,
lynch-law and other paraphernalia belonging to the eighties, is a
curiously archaic thing. It is worth noticing that in papers of this type
it is always taken for granted that adventures only happen at the ends of
the earth, in tropical forests, in Arctic wastes, in African deserts, on
Western prairies, in Chinese opium dens--everywhere in fact, except the
places where things really DO happen.
That is a belief dating from thirty
or forty years ago,
when the new continents were in process of being
opened up. Nowadays, of course, if you really want adventure, the place
to look for it is in Europe. But apart from the picturesque side of the
Great War, contemporary history is carefully excluded. And except that
Americans are now admired instead of being laughed at, foreigners are
exactly the same figures of fun that they always were. If a Chinese
character appears, he is still the sinister pigtailed opium-smuggler of
Sax Rohmer; no indication that things have been happening in China since
1912--no indication that a war is going on there, for instance. If a
Spaniard appears, he is still a 'dago' or 'greaser' who rolls cigarettes
and stabs people in the back; no indication that things have been
happening in Spain. Hitler and the Nazis have not yet appeared, or are
barely making their appearance.
There will be plenty about them in a
little while, but it will be from a strictly patriotic angle (Britain versus
Germany), with the real meaning of the struggle kept out of sight
as much as possible. As for the Russian Revolution, it is extremely
difficult to find any reference to it in any of these papers. When Russia
is mentioned at all it is usually in an information snippet (example:
'There are 29,000 centenarians in the USSR.'), and any reference to
the Revolution is indirect and twenty years out of date. In one story in
the ROVER, for instance, somebody has a tame bear, and as it is a Russian
bear, it is nicknamed Trotsky--obviously an echo of the 1917-23 period
and not of recent controversies.
The clock has stopped at 1910. Britannia
rules the waves, and no one has heard of slumps, booms, unemployment,
dictatorships, purges or concentration camps.


And in social outlook there is hardly any advance. The snobbishness is
somewhat less open than in the GEM and MAGNET--that is the most one can
possibly say. To begin with, the school story, always partly dependent on
snob-appeal, is by no means eliminated. Every number of a boys' paper
includes at least one school story, these stories slightly outnumbering
the Wild Westerns. The very elaborate fantasy-life of the GEM and MAGNET
is not imitated and there is more emphasis on extraneous adventure, but
the social atmosphere (old grey stones) is much the same. When a new
school is introduced at the beginning of a story we are often told in
just those words that 'it was a very posh school'. From time to time a
story appears which is ostensibly directed AGAINST snobbery. The
scholarship-boy (cf. Tom Redwing in the MAGNET) makes fairly frequent
appearances, and what is essentially the same theme is sometimes
presented in this form: there is great rivalry between two schools, one
of which considers itself more 'posh' than the other, and there are
fights, practical jokes, football matches, etc., always ending in the
discomfiture of the snobs. If one glances very superficially at some of
these stories it is possible to imagine that a democratic spirit has
crept into the boys' weeklies, but when one looks more closely one sees
that they merely reflect the bitter jealousies that exist within the
white-collar class. Their real function is to allow the boy who goes to a
cheap private school (NOT a Council school) to feel that his school is
just as 'posh' in the sight of God as Winchester or Eton. The sentiment
of school loyalty ('We're better than the fellows down the road'), a
thing almost unknown to the real working class, is still kept up.
As
these stories are written by many different hands, they do, of course,
vary a good deal in tone. Some are reasonably free from snobbishness, in
others money and pedigree are exploited even more shamelessly than in the
GEM and MAGNET. In one that I came across an actual MAJORITY of the boys
mentioned were titled.

Where working-class characters appear, it is usually either as comics
(jokes about tramps, convicts, etc.), or as prize-fighters, acrobats,
cowboys, professional footballers and Foreign Legionaries--in other
words, as adventurers.
There is no facing of the facts about
working-class life, or, indeed, about WORKING life of any description.
Very occasionally one may come across a realistic description of, say,
work in a coal-mine, but in all probability it will only be there as the
background of some lurid adventure.
In any case the central character is
not likely to be a coal-miner. Nearly all the time the boy who reads
these papers--in nine cases out often a boy who is going to spend his
life working in a shop, in a factory or in some subordinate job in an
office
--is led to identify with people in positions of command, above
all with people who are never troubled by shortage of money. The Lord
Peter Wimsey figure, the seeming idiot who drawls and wears a monocle but
is always to the fore in moments of danger, turns up over and over again.
(This character is a great favourite in Secret Service stories.) And, as
usual, the heroic characters all have to talk B.B.C.; they may talk
Scottish or Irish or American, but no one in a star part is ever
permitted to drop an aitch.
Here it is worth comparing the social
atmosphere of the boys' weeklies with that of the women's weeklies,
the ORACLE, the FAMILY STAR, PEG'S PAPER, etc.

The women's papers are aimed at an older public and are read for the most
part by girls who are working for a living. Consequently they are on the
surface much more realistic.
It is taken for granted, for example, that
nearly everyone has to live in a big town and work at a more or less dull
job. Sex, so far from being taboo, is THE subject.
The short, complete
stories, the special feature of these papers, are generally of the 'came
the dawn' type: the heroine narrowly escapes losing her 'boy' to a
designing rival, or the 'boy' loses his job and has to postpone marriage,
but presently gets a better job. The changeling-fantasy (a girl brought
up in a poor home is 'really' the child of rich parents) is another
favourite. Where sensationalism comes in, usually in the serials, it
arises out of the more domestic type of crime, such as bigamy, forgery or
sometimes murder; no Martians, death-rays or international anarchist
gangs. These papers are at any rate aiming at credibility, and they have
a link with real life in their correspondence columns, where genuine
problems are being discussed. Ruby M. Ayres's column of advice in the
ORACLE, for instance, is extremely sensible and well written. And yet the
world of the ORACLE and PEG'S PAPER is a pure fantasy-world.
It is the
same fantasy all the time; pretending to be richer than you are.
The
chief impression that one carries away from almost every story in these
papers is of a frightful, overwhelming 'refinement'. Ostensibly the
characters are working-class people, but their habits, the interiors of
their houses, their clothes, their outlook and, above all, their speech
are entirely middle class.
They are all living at several pounds a week
above their income. And needless to say, that is just the impression that
is intended. The idea is to give the bored factory-girl or worn-out
mother of five a dream-life
in which she pictures herself--not actually
as a duchess (that convention has gone out) but as, say, the wife of a
bank-manager. Not only is a five-to-six-pound-a-week standard of life set
up as the ideal, but it is tacitly assumed that that is how working-class
people really DO live.
The major facts aree simply not faced. It is
admitted, for instance, that people sometimes lose their jobs; but then
the dark clouds roll away and they get better jobs instead. No mention of
un-employment as something permanent and inevitable, no mention of the
dole, no mention of trade unionism. No suggestion anywhere that there can
be anything wrong with the system AS A SYSTEM; there are only individual
misfortunes, which are generally due to somebody's wickedness
and can in
any case be put right in the last chapter. Always the dark clouds roll
away, the kind employer raises Alfred's wages, and there are jobs for
everybody except the drunks.
It is still the world of the WIZARD and the
GEM, except that there are orange-blossoms instead of machine-guns.

The outlook inculcated by all these papers is that of a rather except-
ionally stupid member of the Navy League in the year 1910.
Yes, it
may be said, but what does it matter? And in any case, what else do you
expect?

Of course no one in his senses would want to turn the so-called penny
dreadful into a realistic novel or a Socialist tract. An adventure story
must of its nature be more or less remote from real life. But, as I have
tried to make clear,
the unreality of the WIZARD and the GEM is not so
artless as it looks. These papers exist because of a specialized demand,
because boys at certain ages find it necessary to read about Martians,
death-rays, grizzly bears and gangsters. They get what they are looking
for, but they get it wrapped up in the illusions which their future
employers think suitable for them.
To what extent people draw their ideas
from fiction is disputable. Personally I believe that most people are
influenced far more than they would care to admit by novels, serial
stories, films and so forth, and that from this point of view the worst
books are often the most important, because they are usually the ones
that are read earliest in life. It is probable that many people who would
consider themselves extremely sophisticated and 'advanced' are actually
carrying through life an imaginative background which they acquired in
childhood from (for instance) Sapper and lan Hay. If that is so, the
boys' twopenny weeklies are of the deepest importance. Here is the stuff
that is read somewhere between the ages of twelve and eighteen by a very
large proportion, perhaps an actual majority, of English boys, including
many who will never read anything else except newspapers; and along with
it they are absorbing a set of beliefs which would be regarded as
hopelessly out of date in the Central Office of the Conservative Party.

All the better because it is done indirectly, there is being pumped into
them the conviction that the major problems of our time do not exist,
that there is nothing wrong with LAISSEZ-FAIRE capitalism, that
foreigners are un-important comics and that the British Empire is a sort
of charity-concern which will last for ever.
Considering who owns these
papers, it is difficult to believe that this is un-intentional.
Of the
twelve papers I have been discussing (i.e. twelve including the THRILLER
and DETECTIVE WEEKLY) seven are the property of the Amalgamated Press,
which is one of the biggest press-combines in the world and controls more
than a hundred different papers. The GEM and MAGNET, therefore, are
closely linked up with the DAILY TELEGRAPH and the FINANCIAL TIMES.
This in itself would be enough to rouse certain suspicions, even if it
were not
obvious that the stories in the boys' weeklies are politically
vetted. So it appears that if you feel the need of a fantasy-life in
which you travel to Mars and fight lions bare-handed (and what boy
doesn't?), you can only have it by delivering yourself over, mentally, to
people like Lord Camrose. For there is no competition. Throughout the
whole of this run of papers the differences are negligible, and on this
level no others exist. This raises the question,
why is there no such
thing as a left-wing boys' paper?

At first glance such an idea merely makes one slightly sick. It is so
horribly easy to imagine what a left-wing boys' paper would be like
, if
it existed. I remember in 1920 or 1921 some optimistic person handing
round Communist tracts among a crowd of public-school boys.
The tract I
received was of the question-and-answer kind:

Q,. 'Can a Boy Communist be a Boy Scout, Comrade?'
A. 'No, Comrade.'
Q,. 'Why, Comrade?'
A. 'Because, Comrade, a Boy Scout must salute the Union Jack, which is
the symbol of tyranny and oppression,'
etc., etc.

Now suppose that at this moment somebody started a left-wing paper
deliberately aimed at boys of twelve or fourteen. I do not suggest that
the whole of its contents would be exactly like the tract I have quoted
above, but does anyone doubt that they would be SOMETHING like it?

Inevitably such a paper would either consist of dreary up-lift or it
would be under Communist influence and given over to adulation of Soviet
Russia;
in either case no normal boy would ever look at it. Highbrow
literature apart, the whole of the existing left-wing Press, in so far as
it is at all vigorously 'left', is one long tract. The one Socialist
paper in England which could live a week on its merits AS A PAPER is the
DAILY HERALD: and how much Socialism is there in the DAILY HERALD? At
this moment, therefore, a paper with a 'left' slant and at the same time
likely to have an appeal to ordinary boys in their teens is something
almost beyond hoping for.


But it does not follow that it is impossible. There is no clear reason
why every adventure story should necessarily be mixed up with
snobbishness and gutter patriotism. For, after all, the stories in the
HOTSPUR and the MODERN BOY are not Conservative tracts; they are merely
adventure stories with a Conservative bias. It is fairly easy to imagine
the process being reversed. It is possible, for instance, to imagine a
paper as thrilling and lively as the HOTSPUR, but with subject-matter and
'ideology' a little more up to date. It is even possible (though this
raises other difficulties) to imagine a women's paper at the same
literary level as the ORACLE, dealing in approximately the same kind of
story, but taking rather more account of the realities of working-class
life. Such things have been done before, though not in England. In the
last years of the Spanish monarchy there was a large output in Spain of
left-wing novelettes, some of them evidently of anarchist origin.

Unfortunately at the time when they were appearing I did not see their
social significance, and I lost the collection of them that I had, but no
doubt copies would still be procurable. In get-up and style of story they
were very similar to the English fourpenny novelette, except that their
inspiration was 'left'. If, for instance, a story described police
pursuing anarchists through the mountains, it would be from the point of
view of the anarchist and not of the police. An example nearer to hand is
the Soviet film CHAPAIEV, which has been shown a number of times in
London. Technically, by the standards of the time when it was made,
CHAPAIEV is a first-rate film, but mentally, in spite of the unfamiliar
Russian background, it is not so very remote from Hollywood. The one
thing that lifts it out of the ordinary is the remarkable performance by
the actor who takes the part of the White officer (the fat one)--a
performance which looks very like an inspired piece of gagging. Otherwise
the atmosphere is familiar. All the usual paraphernalia is there--heroic
fight against odds, escape at the last moment, shots of galloping horses,
love interest, comic relief. The film is in fact a fairly ordinary one,
except that its tendency is 'left'.
In a Hollywood film of the Russian
Civil War the Whites would probably be angels and the Reds demons. In the
Russian version the Reds are angels and the Whites demons. That is also a
lie, but, taking the long view, it is a less pernicious lie than the
other.

Here several difficult problems present themselves. Their general nature
is obvious enough, and I do not want to discuss them. I am merely
pointing to the fact that, in England, popular imaginative literature is
a field that left-wing thought has never begun to enter. ALL fiction from
the novels in the mushroom libraries downwards is censored in the
interests of the ruling class. And boys' fiction above all, the blood-
and-thunder stuff which nearly every boy devours at some time or
other, is sodden in the worst illusions of 1910. The fact is only
unimportant if one believes that what is read in childhood leaves no
impression behind. Lord Camrose and his colleagues evidently believe
nothing of the kind, and, after all, Lord Camrose ought to know.




Charles Dickens


I


Dickens is one of those writers who are well worth stealing. Even the
burial of his body in Westminster Abbey was a species of theft, if you
come to think of it.

When Chesterton wrote his introductions to the Everyman Edition of
Dickens's works, it seemed quite natural to him to credit Dickens with
his own highly individual brand of medievalism, and more recently a
Marxist writer, Mr. T. A. Jackson, has made spirited efforts to turn
Dickens into a blood-thirsty revolutionary. The Marxist claims him as
'almost' a Marxist, the Catholic claims him as 'almost' a Catholic, and
both claim him as a champion of the proletariat (or 'the poor', as
Chesterton would have put it). On the other hand, Nadezhda Krupskaya, in
her little book on Lenin, relates that towards the end of his life
Lenin
went to see a dramatized version of THE CRICKET ON THE HEARTH, and found
Dickens's 'middle-class sentimentality' so intolerable that he walked out
in the middle of a scene.

Taking 'middle-class' to mean what Krupskaya might be expected to mean
by it, this was probably a truer judgement than those of Chesterton and
Jackson. But it is worth noticing that the dislike of Dickens implied in
this remark is something unusual. Plenty of people have found him
unreadable, but very few seem to have felt any hostility towards the
general spirit of his work.
Some years later Mr. Bechhofer Roberts
published a full-length attack on Dickens in the form of a novel (THIS
SIDE IDOLATRY), but it was a merely personal attack, concerned for the
most part with Dickens's treatment of his wife. It dealt with incidents
which not one in a thousand of Dickens's readers would ever hear about,
and which no more invalidates his work than the second-best bed
invalidates HAMLET. All that the book really demonstrated was that a
writer's literary personality has little or nothing to do with his
private character. It is quite possible that in private life Dickens was
just the kind of insensitive egoist that Mr. Bechhofer Roberts makes him
appear. But in his published work there is implied a personality quite
different from this, a personality which has won him far more friends
than enemies. It might well have been otherwise, for
even if Dickens was
a bourgeois, he was certainly a subversive writer, a radical, one might
truthfully say a rebel.
Everyone who has read widely in his work has felt
this. Gissing, for instance, the best of the writers on Dickens, was
anything but a radical himself, and he disapproved of this strain in
Dickens and wished it were not there, but it never occurred to him to
deny it.
In OLIVER TWIST, HARD TIMES, BLEAK HOUSE, LITTLE DORRIT,
Dickens attacked English institutions with a ferocity that has never since
been approached. Yet he managed to do it without making himself hated,
and, more than this, the very people he attacked have swallowed him so
completely that he has become a national institution himself. In its
attitude towards Dickens the English public has always been a little like
the elephant which feels a blow with a walking-stick as a delightful
tickling. Before I was ten years old I was having Dickens ladled down my
throat
by schoolmasters in whom even at that age I could see a strong
resemblance to Mr. Creakle, and one knows without needing to be told that
lawyers delight in Sergeant Buzfuz and that LITTLE DORRIT is a favourite
in the Home Office. Dickens seems to have succeeded in attacking
everybody and antagonizing nobody. Naturally this makes one wonder
whether after all there was something unreal in his attack upon society.

Where exactly does he stand, socially, morally, and politically? As
usual, one can define his position more easily if one starts by deciding
what he was NOT.

In the first place he was NOT, as Messrs. Chesterton and Jackson seem
to imply, a 'proletarian' writer. To begin with, he does not write about the
proletariat, in which he merely resembles the overwhelming majority of
novelists, past and present.
If you look for the working classes in
fiction, and especially English fiction, all you find is a hole. This state-
ment needs qualifying, perhaps. For reasons that are easy enough to
see, the agricultural labourer (in England a proletarian) gets a fairly
good showing in fiction
, and a great deal has been written about
criminals, derelicts and, more recently, the working-class intelli-
gentsia. But the ordinary town proletariat, the people who make the
wheels go round, have always been ignored by novelists. When they do
find their way between the covers of a book, it is nearly always as
objects of pity or as comic relief. The central action of Dickens's
stories almost invariably takes place in middle-class surroundings. If
one examines his novels in detail one finds that his real subject-matter
is the London commercial bourgeoisie and their hangers-on--lawyers,
clerks, tradesmen, innkeepers, small craftsmen, and servants. He has no
portrait of an agricultural worker, and only one (Stephen Blackpool in
HARD TIMES) of an industrial worker.
The Plornishes in LITTLE DORRIT are
probably his best picture of a working-class family--the Peggottys, for
instance, hardly belong to the working class--but on the whole he is not
successful with this type of character. If you ask any ordinary reader
which of Dickens's proletarian characters he can remember, the three he
is almost certain to mention are Bill Sykes, Sam Weller, and Mrs. Gamp. A
burglar, a valet, and a drunken midwife--not exactly a representative
cross-section of the English working class.

Secondly, in the ordinarily accepted sense of the word, Dickens is not a
'revolutionary' writer. But his position here needs some defining.

Whatever else
Dickens may have been, he was not a hole-and-corner
soul-saver, the kind of well-meaning idiot who thinks that the world will
be perfect if you amend a few bylaws and abolish a few anomalies.
It is
worth
comparing him with Charles Reade, for instance. Reade was a much
better-informed man than Dickens, and in some ways more public-spirited.
He really hated the abuses he could understand, he showed them up in a
series of novels which for all their absurdity are extremely readable,
and he probably helped to alter public opinion on a few minor but
important points. But
it was quite beyond him to grasp that, given the
existing form of society, certain evils CANNOT be remedied. Fasten upon
this or that minor abuse, expose it, drag it into the open, bring it
before a British jury, and all will be well that is how he sees it.
Dickens at any rate never imagined that you can cure pimples by cutting
them off. In every page of his work one can see a consciousness that
society is wrong somewhere at the root.
It is when one asks 'Which root?'
that one begins to grasp his position.


The truth is that Dickens's criticism of society is almost exclusively
moral. Hence the utter lack of any constructive suggestion anywhere in
his work. He attacks the law, parliamentary government, the educational
system and so forth, without ever clearly suggesting what he would put in
their places. Of course it is not necessarily the business of a novelist,
or a satirist, to make constructive suggestions, but the point is that
Dickens's attitude is at bottom not even DEStructive.
There is no clear
sign that he wants the existing order to be overthrown, or that he
believes it would make very much difference if it WERE overthrown. For in
reality his target is not so much society as 'human nature'. It would be
difficult to point anywhere in his books to a passage suggesting that the
economic system is wrong AS A SYSTEM. Nowhere, for instance, does he make
any attack on private enterprise or private property. Even in a book like
OUR MUTUAL FRIEND, which turns on the power of corpses to interfere with
living people by means of idiotic wills
, it does not occur to him to
suggest that individuals ought not to have this irresponsible power. Of
course one can draw this inference for oneself, and one can draw it again
from the remarks about Bounderby's will at the end of HARD TIMES, and
indeed from the whole of Dickens's work one can infer the evil of
LAISSEZ-FAIRE capitalism; but Dickens makes no such inference himself. It
is said that
Macaulay refused to review HARD TIMES because he disapproved
of its 'sullen Socialism'. Obviously Macaulay is here using the word
'Socialism' in the same sense in which, twenty years ago, a vegetarian
meal or a Cubist picture used to be referred to as 'Bolshevism'. There is
not a line in the book that can properly be called Socialistic; indeed,
its tendency if anything is pro-capitalist, because its whole moral is
that capitalists ought to be kind, not that workers ought to be
rebellious.
Bounderby is a bullying windbag and Gradgrind has been
morally blinded, but if they were better men, the system would work well
enough that, all through, is the implication. And so far as social
criticism goes, one can never extract much more from Dickens than this,
unless one deliberately reads meanings into him.
His whole 'message' is
one that at first glance looks like an enormous platitude: If men would
behave decently the world would be decent.


Naturally this calls for a few characters who are in positions of
authority and who DO behave decently.
Hence that recurrent Dickens
figure,
the good rich man. This character belongs especially to Dickens's
early optimistic period. He is usually a 'merchant' (we are not
necessarily told what merchandise he deals in), and he is always a
superhumanly kind-hearted old gentleman who 'trots' to and fro, raising
his employees' wages, patting children on the head, getting debtors out
of jail and in general, acting the fairy godmother. Of course he is a
pure dream figure, much further from real life than, say, Squeers or
Micawber. Even Dickens must have reflected occasionally that anyone who
was so anxious to give his money away would never have acquired it in the
first place.
Mr. Pickwick, for instance, had 'been in the city', but it
is difficult to imagine him making a fortune there. Nevertheless this
character runs like a connecting thread through most of the earlier
books. Pickwick, the Cheerybles, old Chuzzlewit, Scrooge--it is the same
figure over and over again, the good rich man, handing out guineas.
Dickens does however show signs of development here. In the books of the
middle period the good rich man fades out to some extent. There is no one
who plays this part in A TALE OF TWO CITIES, nor in GREAT EXPECTATIONS--
GREAT EXPECTATIONS is, in fact, definitely an attack on patronage--and
in HARD TIMES it is only very doubtfully played by Gradgrind after his
reformation. The character reappears in a rather different form as
Meagles in LITTLE DORRIT and John Jarndyce in BLEAK HOUSE--one might
perhaps add Betsy Trotwood in DAVID COPPERFIELD. But in these books
the
good rich man has dwindled from a 'merchant' to a RENTIER. This is
significant. A RENTIER is part of the possessing class, he can and,
almost without knowing it, does make other people work for him, but he
has very little direct power. Unlike Scrooge or the Cheerybles, he cannot
put everything right by raising everybody's wages. The seeming inference
from the rather despondent books that Dickens wrote in the fifties is
that by that time he had grasped the helplessness of well-meaning
individuals in a corrupt society.
Nevertheless in the last completed
novel, OUR MUTUAL FRIEND (published 1864-5), the good rich man comes
back in full glory in the person of Boffin. Boffin is a proletarian by origin
and only rich by inheritance, but he is the usual DEUS EX MACHINA,
solving everybody's problems by showering money in all directions. He
even 'trots', like the Cheerybles. In several ways OUR MUTUAL FRIEND is
a return to the earlier manner, and not an unsuccessful return either.
Dickens's thoughts seem to have come full circle. Once again, individual
kindliness is the remedy for everything.

One crying evil of his time that Dickens says very little about is child
labour.
There are plenty of pictures of suffering children in his books,
but usually they are suffering in schools rather than in factories.
The
one detailed account of child labour that he gives is the description in
DAVID COPPERFIELD of little David washing bottles in Murdstone & Grinby's
warehouse. This, of course, is autobiography. Dickens himself, at the age
of ten, had worked in Warren's blacking factory in the Strand, very much
as he describes it here. It was a terribly bitter memory to him, partly
because he felt the whole incident to be discreditable to his parents,

and he even concealed it from his wife till long after they were married.
Looking back on this period, he says in DAVID COPPERFIELD:



It is a matter of some surprise to me, even now, that I can have been so
easily thrown away at such an age. A child of excellent abilities and
with strong powers of observation, quick, eager, delicate, and soon hurt
bodily or mentally, it seems wonderful to me that nobody should have made
any sign in my behalf. But none was made; and I became, at ten years old,
a little labouring hind in the service of Murdstone & Grinby.



And again, having described the rough boys among whom he worked:


No words can express the secret agony of my soul as I sunk into this
companionship. . . and felt my hopes of growing up to be a learned and
distinguished man crushed in my bosom.



Obviously it is not David Copperfield who is speaking, it is Dickens
himself. He uses almost the same words in the autobiography that he began
and abandoned a few months earlier.
Of course Dickens is right in saying
that a gifted child ought not to work ten hours a day pasting labels on
bottles, but what he does not say is that NO child ought to be condemned
to such a fate, and there is no reason for inferring that he thinks it.
David escapes from the warehouse, but Mick Walker and Mealy Potatoes
and the others are still there,
and there is no sign that this troubles
Dickens particularly. As usual, he displays no consciousness that the
STRUCTURE of society can be changed. He despises politics, does not
believe that any good can come out of Parliament--he had been a
Parliamentary shorthand writer, which was no doubt a disillusioning
experience--and
he is slightly hostile to the most hopeful movement of
his day, trade unionism. In HARD TIMES trade unionism is represented as
something not much better than a racket, something that happens because
employers are not sufficiently paternal. Stephen Blackpool's refusal to
join the union is rather a virtue in Dickens's eyes.
Also, as Mr. Jackson
has pointed out, the apprentices' association in BARNABY RUDGE, to which
Sim Tappertit belongs, is probably a hit at the illegal or barely legal
unions of Dickens's own day, with their secret assemblies, passwords and
so forth. Obviously he wants the workers to be decently treated, but
there is no sign that he wants them to take their destiny into their own
hands, least of all by open violence.


As it happens, Dickens deals with revolution in the narrower sense in two
novels, BARNABY RUDGE and A TALE OF TWO CITIES.
In BARNABY RUDGE
it is a case of rioting rather than revolution. The Gordon Riots of 1780,
though they had religious bigotry as a pretext, seem to have been little
more than a pointless outburst of looting. Dickens's attitude to this kind
of thing is sufficiently indicated by the fact that his first idea was to
make the ringleaders of the riots three lunatics escaped from an asylum.
He was dissuaded from this, but the principal figure of the book is in
fact a village idiot. In the chapters dealing with the riots Dickens
shows a most profound horror of mob violence. He delights in describing
scenes in which the 'dregs' of the population behave with atrocious
bestiality.
These chapters are of great psychological interest, because
they show how deeply he had brooded on this subject. The things he
describes can only have come out of his imagination, for no riots on
anything like the same scale had happened in his lifetime.
Here is one of
his descriptions, for instance:


If Bedlam gates had been flung open wide, there would not have issued
forth such maniacs as the frenzy of that night had made. There were men
there who danced and trampled on the beds of flowers as though they trod
down human enemies, and wrenched them from their stalks, like savages who
twisted human necks. There were men who cast their lighted torches in the
air, and suffered them to fall upon their heads and faces, blistering the
skin with deep unseemly burns. There were men who rushed up to the fire,
and paddled in it with their hands as if in water; and others who were
restrained by force from plunging in, to gratify their deadly longing. On
the skull of one drunken lad--not twenty, by his looks--who lay upon
the ground with a bottle to his mouth, the lead from the roof came
streaming down in a shower of liquid fire, white hot, melting his head
like wax. . . But of all the howling throng not one learnt mercy from, or
sickened at, these sights; nor was the fierce, besotted, senseless rage
of one man glutted.



You might almost think you were reading a description of 'Red' Spain by a
partisan of General Franco. One ought, of course, to remember that when
Dickens was writing, the London 'mob' still existed. (Nowadays there is
no mob, only a flock.)
Low wages and the growth and shift of population
had brought into existence a huge, dangerous slum-proletariat, and until
the early middle of the nineteenth century there was hardly such a thing
as a police force. When the brickbats began to fly there was nothing
between shuttering your windows and ordering the troops to open fire. In
A TALE OF TWO CITIES he is dealing with a revolution which was really
about something, and Dickens's attitude is different, but not entirely
different.
As a matter of fact, A TALE OF TWO CITIES is a book which
tends to leave a false impression behind, especially after a lapse of
time.

The one thing that everyone who has read A TALE OF TWO CITIES remem-
bers is the
Reign of Terror. The whole book is dominated by the guillotine--
tumbrils thundering to and fro, bloody knives, heads bouncing into the
basket, and sinister old women knitting as they watch.
Actually these
scenes only occupy a few chapters, but they are written with terrible
intensity, and t
he rest of the book is rather slow going. But A TALE OF
TWO CITIES is not a companion volume to THE SCARLET PIMPERNEL. Dickens
sees clearly enough that the French Revolution was bound to happen and
that many of the people who were executed deserved what they got. If, he
says, you behave as the French aristocracy had behaved, vengeance will
follow. He repeats this over and over again.
We are constantly being
reminded that while 'my lord' is lolling in bed, with four liveried
footmen serving his chocolate and the peasants starving outside,
somewhere in the forest a tree is growing which will presently be sawn
into planks for the platform of the guillotine, etc., etc., etc. The
inevitability of the Terror, given its causes, is insisted upon in the
clearest terms:



It was too much the way. . . to talk of this terrible Revolution as if it
were the only harvest ever known under the skies that had not been sown--
as if nothing had ever been done, or omitted to be done, that had led to
it--as if observers of the wretched millions in France, and of the
misused and perverted resources that should have made them prosperous,
had not seen it inevitably coming, years before, and had not in plain
terms recorded what they saw.



And again:


All the devouring and insatiate monsters imagined since imagination could
record itself, are fused in the one realization, Guillotine. And yet there
is not in France, with its rich variety of soil and climate, a blade, a leaf,
a root, a spring, a peppercorn, which will grow to maturity under con-
ditions more certain than those that have produced this horror. Crush
humanity out of shape once more, under similar hammers, and it will
twist itself into the same tortured forms.



In other words, the French aristocracy had dug their own graves. But
there is no perception here of what is now called historic necessity.
Dickens sees that the results are inevitable, given the causes, but he
thinks that the causes might have been avoided.
The Revolution is
something that happens because centuries of oppression have made the
French peasantry sub-human. If the wicked nobleman could somehow have
turned over a new leaf, like Scrooge, there would have been no
Revolution, no JACQUERIE, no guillotine--and so much the better.
This is
the opposite of the 'revolutionary' attitude. From the 'revolutionary'
point of view the class-struggle is the main source of progress, and
therefore
the nobleman who robs the peasant and goads him to revolt is
playing a necessary part, just as much as the Jacobin who guillotines the
nobleman.
Dickens never writes anywhere a line that can be interpreted as
meaning this. Revolution as he sees it is merely a monster that is
begotten by tyranny and always ends by devouring its own instruments. In
Sydney Carton's vision at the foot of the guillotine, he foresees Defarge
and the other leading spirits of the Terror all perishing under the same
knife--which, in fact, was approximately what happened.


And Dickens is very sure that revolution is a monster. That is why
everyone remembers the revolutionary scenes in A TALE OF TWO CITIES;
they have the quality of nightmare, and it is Dickens's own nightmare. Again
and again
he insists upon the meaningless horrors of revolution--the
mass-butcheries, the injustice, the ever-present terror of spies, the
frightful blood-lust of the mob. The descriptions of the Paris mob--the
description, for instance, of the crowd of murderers struggling round the
grindstone to sharpen their weapons before butchering the prisoners in
the September massacres
--outdo anything in BARNABY RUDGE. The
revolutionaries appear to him simply as degraded savages--in fact, as
lunatics. He broods over their frenzies with a curious imaginative
intensity.
He describes them dancing the 'Carmagnole', for instance:


There could not be fewer than five hundred people, and they were dancing
like five thousand demons. . . They danced to the popular Revolution song,
keeping a ferocious time that was like a gnashing of teeth in unison. . .
They advanced, retreated, struck at one another's hands, clutched at one
another's heads, spun round alone, caught one another, and spun around in
pairs, until many of them dropped. . . Suddenly they stopped again, paused,
struck out the time afresh, forming into lines the width of the public
way, and, with their heads low down and their hands high up, swooped
screaming off. No fight could have been half so terrible as this dance.
It was so emphatically a fallen sport--a something, once innocent,
delivered over to all devilry.



He even credits some of these wretches with a taste for guillotining
children. The passage I have abridged above ought to be read in full. It
and others like it show how deep was Dickens's horror of revolutionary
hysteria. Notice, for instance that touch, 'with their heads low down and
their hands high up', etc., and the evil vision it conveys.
Madame
Defarge is a truly dreadful figure, certainly Dickens's most successful
attempt at a MALIGNANT character. Defarge and others are simply 'the
new oppressors who have risen in the destruction of the old', the
revolutionary courts are presided over by 'the lowest, cruellest and
worst populace', and so on and so forth. All the way through Dickens
insists upon the nightmare insecurity of a revolutionary period, and in
this he shows a great deal of prescience. 'A law of the suspected, which
struck away all security for liberty or life, and delivered over any good
and innocent person to any bad and guilty one; prisons gorged with people
who had committed no offence, and could obtain no hearing'
--it would
apply pretty accurately to several countries today.


The apologists of any revolution generally try to minimize its horrors;
Dickens's impulse is to exaggerate them
--and from a historical point of
view he has certainly exaggerated. Even the Reign of Terror was a much
smaller thing than he makes it appear. Though he quotes no figures, he
gives the impression of a frenzied massacre lasting for years, whereas in
reality the whole of the Terror, so far as the number of deaths goes, was
a joke compared with one of Napoleon's battles. But
the bloody knives and
the tumbrils rolling to and fro create in his mind a special sinister
vision
which he has succeeded in passing on to generations of readers.
Thanks to Dickens,
the very word 'tumbril' has a murderous sound; one
forgets that a tumbril is only a sort of farm-cart. To this day, to the
average Englishman, the French Revolution means no more than a pyramid of
severed heads. It is a strange thing that Dickens, much more in sympathy
with the ideas of the Revolution than most Englishmen of his time
, should
have played a part in creating this impression.

If you hate violence and don't believe in politics, the only remedy
remaining is education. Perhaps society is past praying for, but there is
always hope for the individual human being, if you can catch him young
enough. This belief partly accounts for Dickens's preoccupation with
childhood.


No one, at any rate no English writer, has written better about childhood
than Dickens.
In spite of all the knowledge that has accumulated since,
in spite of the fact that children are now comparatively sanely treated,
no novelist has shown the same power of entering into the child's point
of view. I must have been about nine years old when I first read
DAVID
COPPERFIELD. The mental atmosphere of the opening chapters was so
immediately intelligible to me that I vaguely imagined they had been
written BY A CHILD. And yet when one re-reads the book as an adult and
sees the Murdstones, for instance, dwindle from gigantic figures of doom
into semi-comic monsters, these passages lose nothing. Dickens has been
able to stand both inside and outside the child's mind, in such a way
that the same scene can be wild burlesque or sinister reality, according
to the age at which one reads it.
Look, for instance, at the scene in
which David Copperfield is unjustly suspected of eating the mutton chops;
or the scene in which Pip, in GREAT EXPECTATIONS, coming back from Miss
Havisham's house and finding himself completely unable to describe what
he has seen, takes refuge in a series of outrageous lies--which, of
course, are eagerly believed.
All the isolation of childhood is there.
And how accurately he has recorded the mechanisms of the child's mind,
its visualizing tendency, its sensitiveness to certain kinds of
impression.
Pip relates how in his childhood his ideas about his dead
parents were derived from their tombstones:



The shape of the letters on my father's, gave me an odd idea that he was
a square, stout, dark man, with curly black hair. From the character and
turn of the inscription, 'ALSO GEORGIANA, WIFE OF THE ABOVE', I drew a
childish conclusion that my mother was freckled and sickly. To five
little stone lozenges, each about a foot and a half long, which were
arranged in a neat row beside their grave, and were sacred to the memory
of five little brothers of mine. . . I am indebted for a belief I
religiously entertained that they had all been born on their backs with
their hands in their trouser-pockets, and had never taken them out in
this state of existence.



There is a similar passage in DAVID COPPERFIELD. After biting Mr.
Murdstone's hand, David is sent away to school and obliged to wear on his
back a placard saying, 'Take care of him. He bites.' He looks at the door
in the playground where the boys have carved their names, and from the
appearance of each name he seems to know in just what tone of voice the
boy will read out the placard:



There was one boy--a certain J. Steerforth--who cut his name very deep
and very often, who, I conceived, would read it in a rather strong voice,
and afterwards pull my hair. There was another boy, one Tommy Traddles,
who I dreaded would make game of it, and pretend to be dreadfully
frightened of me. There was a third, George Demple, who I fancied would
sing it.



When I read this passage as a child, it seemed to me that those were
exactly the pictures that those particular names would call up. The
reason, of course, is the sound-associations of the words (Demple--
'temple'; Traddles--probably 'skedaddle'). But how many people, before
Dickens, had ever noticed such things? A sympathetic attitude towards
children was a much rarer thing in Dickens's day than it is now.
The
early nineteenth century was not a good time to be a child. In Dickens's
youth children were still being 'solemnly tried at a criminal bar, where
they were held up to be seen', and it was not so long since boys of
thirteen had been hanged for petty theft. The doctrine of 'breaking the
child's spirit' was in full vigour,
and THE FAIRCHILD FAMILY was a
standard book for children till late into the century.
This evil book is
now issued in pretty-pretty expurgated editions,
but it is well worth
reading in the original version. It gives one some idea of the lengths to
which child-discipline was sometimes carried.
Mr. Fairchild, for
instance, when he catches his children quarrelling, first thrashes them,
reciting Dr. Watts's 'Let dogs delight to bark and bite' between blows of
the cane, and then takes them to spend the afternoon beneath a gibbet
where the rotting corpse of a murderer is hanging. In the earlier part of
the century scores of thousands of children, aged sometimes as young as
six, were literally worked to death in the mines or cotton mills, and
even at the fashionable public schools boys were flogged till they ran
with blood for a mistake in their Latin verses. One thing which Dickens
seems to have recognized, and which most of his contemporaries did not,
is the sadistic sexual element in flogging.
I think this can be inferred
from DAVID COPPERFIELD and NICHOLAS NICKLEBY. But mental cruelty
to a child infuriates him as much as physical,
and though there is a fair
number of exceptions, his schoolmasters are generally scoundrels.

Except for the universities and the big public schools, every kind of
education then existing in England gets a mauling at Dickens's hands.
There is Doctor Blimber's Academy, where little boys are blown up with
Greek until they burst, and the revolting charity schools of the period,
which produced specimens like Noah Claypole and Uriah Heep, and Salem
House, and Dotheboys Hall, and the disgraceful little dame-school kept by
Mr. Wopsle's great-aunt.
Some of what Dickens says remains true even
today. Salem House is the ancestor of the modern 'prep school', which
still has a good deal of resemblance to it; and as for Mr. Wopsle's
great-aunt, some old fraud of much the same stamp is carrying on at this
moment in nearly every small town in England. But, as usual, Dickens's
criticism is neither creative nor destructive. He
sees the idiocy of an
educational system founded on the Greek lexicon and the wax-ended cane;
on the other hand, he has no use for the new kind of school that is
coming up in the fifties and sixties, the 'modern' school, with its
gritty insistence on 'facts'. What, then, DOES he want? As always, what
he appears to want is a moralized version of the existing thing--the old
type of school, but with no caning, no bullying or underfeeding, and not
quite so much Greek.
Doctor Strong's school, to which David Copperfield
goes after he escapes from Murdstone & Grinby's, is simply Salem House
with the vices left out and a good deal of 'old grey stones' atmosphere
thrown in:



Doctor Strong's was an excellent school, as different from Mr. Creakle's
as good is from evil. It was very gravely and decorously ordered, and on
a sound system; with an appeal, in everything, to the honour and good
faith of the boys. . . which worked wonders. We all felt that we had a part
in the management of the place, and in sustaining its character and
dignity. Hence, we soon became warmly attached to it--I am sure I did
for one, and I never knew, in all my time, of any boy being otherwise--
and learnt with a good will, desiring to do it credit. We had noble games
out of hours, and plenty of liberty; but even then, as I remember, we
were well spoken of in the town, and rarely did any disgrace, by our
appearance or manner, to the reputation of Doctor Strong and Doctor
Strong's boys.



In the woolly vagueness of this passage one can see Dickens's utter lack
of any educational theory. He can imagine the MORAL atmosphere of a good
school, but nothing further. The boys 'learnt with a good will', but what
did they learn?
No doubt it was Doctor Blimber's curriculum, a little
watered down. Considering the attitude to society that is everywhere
implied in Dickens's novels, it comes as rather a shock to learn that he
sent his eldest son to Eton and sent all his children through the
ordinary educational mill. Gissing seems to think that he may have done
this because he was painfully conscious of being under-educated himself.
Here perhaps Gissing is influenced by his own love of classical learning.
Dickens had had little or no formal education, but he lost nothing by
missing it, and on the whole he seems to have been aware of this. If he
was unable to imagine a better school than Doctor Strong's, or, in real
life, than Eton, it was probably due to an intellectual deficiency rather
different from the one Gissing suggests.


It seems that in every attack Dickens makes upon society he is always
pointing to a change of spirit rather than a change of structure.
It is
hopeless to try and pin him down to any definite remedy, still more to
any political doctrine. His approach is always along the moral plane, and
his attitude is sufficiently summed up in that remark about
Strong's
school being as different from Creakle's 'as good is from evil'. Two
things can be very much alike and yet abysmally different. Heaven and
Hell are in the same place. Useless to change institutions without a
'change of heart'
--that, essentially, is what he is always saying.

If that were all, he might be no more than a cheer-up writer, a
reactionary humbug. A 'change of heart' is in fact THE alibi of people
who do not wish to endanger the STATUS QUO. But Dickens is not a humbug,
except in minor matters, and the strongest single impression one carries
away from his books is that of a hatred of tyranny. I said earlier that
Dickens is not IN THE ACCEPTED SENSE a revolutionary writer. But it is
not at all certain that a merely moral criticism of society may not be
just as 'revolutionary'
--and revolution, after all, means turning things
upside down--as the politico-economic criticism which is fashionable at
this moment. Blake was not a politician, but there is more understanding
of the nature of capitalist society in a poem like 'I wander through each
charted street' than in three-quarters of Socialist literature.
Progress
is not an illusion, it happens, but it is slow and invariably disappointing.

There is always a new tyrant waiting to take over from the old--gen-
erally not quite so bad, but still a tyrant. Consequently two viewpoints
are always tenable. The one, how can you improve human nature until
you have changed the system? The other, what is the use of changing
the system before you have improved human nature? They appeal to
different individuals, and they probably show a tendency to alternate in
point of time. The moralist and the revolutionary are constantly under-
mining one another. Marx exploded a hundred tons of dynamite beneath
the moralist position, and we are still living in the echo of that
tremendous crash.
But already, somewhere or other, the sappers are at
work and fresh dynamite is being tamped in place to blow Marx at the
moon. Then Marx, or somebody like him, will come back with yet more
dynamite, and so the process continues, to an end we cannot yet foresee.
The central problem--how to prevent power from being abused--remains
unsolved. Dickens, who had not the vision to see that private property is
an obstructive nuisance, had the vision to see that. 'If men would behave
decently the world would be decent' is not such a platitude as it sounds.



II


More completely than most writers, perhaps, Dickens can be explained
in terms of his social origin, though actually his family history was not
quite what one would infer from his novels. His father was a clerk in
government service, and through his mother's family he had connexions
with both the Army and the Navy. But from
the age of nine onwards he
was brought up in London in commercial surroundings, and generally in an
atmosphere of struggling poverty.
Mentally he belongs to the small urban
bourgeoisie, and he happens to be an exceptionally fine specimen of this
class, with all the 'points', as it were, very highly developed. That is
partly what makes him so interesting. If one wants a modern equivalent,
the nearest would be H. G. Wells, who has had a rather similar history
and who obviously owes something to Dickens as novelist.
Arnold Bennett
was essentially of the same type, but, unlike the other two, he was a
midlander, with an industrial and noncomformist rather than commercial
and Anglican background.


The great disadvantage, and advantage, of the
small urban bourgeois is
his limited outlook. He
sees the world as a middle-class world, and
everything outside these limits is either laughable or slightly wicked.
On the one hand, he has no contact with industry or the soil; on the
other, no contact with the governing classes. Anyone who has studied
Wells's novels in detail will have noticed that though he hates the
aristocrat like poison, he has no particular objection to the plutocrat,
and no enthusiasm for the proletarian. His
most hated types, the people
he believes to be responsible for all human ills, are kings, landowners,
priests, nationalists, soldiers, scholars and peasants.
At first sight a
list beginning with kings and ending with peasants looks like a mere
omnium gatherum, but in reality all these people have a common factor.
All of them are archaic types,
people who are governed by tradition and
whose eyes are turned towards the past--the opposite, therefore, of the
rising bourgeois who has put his money on the future and sees the past
simply as a dead hand.


Actually, although Dickens lived in a period when the bourgeoisie was
really a rising class, he displays this characteristic less strongly than
Wells. He
is almost unconscious of the future and has a rather sloppy
love of the picturesque (the 'quaint old church', etc.).
Nevertheless his
list of most hated types is like enough to Wells's for the similarity to
be striking. He is vaguely on the side of the working class--has a sort
of generalized sympathy with them because they are oppressed--but he
does not in reality know much about them; they come into his books
chiefly as servants, and comic servants at that. At the other end of the
scale he loathes the aristocrat and--going one better than Wells in this
loathes the big bourgeois as well. His real sympathies are bounded by Mr.
Pickwick on the upper side and Mr. Barkis on the lower.
But the term
'aristocrat', for the type Dickens hates, is vague and needs defining.


Actually Dickens's target is not so much the great aristocracy, who
hardly enter into his books, as their
petty offshoots, the cadging
dowagers who live up mews in Mayfair,
and the bureaucrats and
professional soldiers. All through his books there are
countless hostile
sketches of these people
, and hardly any that are friendly. There are
practically no friendly pictures of the landowning class, for instance.
One might make a doubtful exception of Sir Leicester Dedlock; otherwise
there is only Mr. Wardle (who is a stock figure the 'good old squire')
and Haredale in BARNABY RUDGE, who has Dickens's sympathy because
he is a persecuted Catholic. There are no friendly pictures of soldiers (i.e.
officers), and none at all of naval men. As for his bureaucrats, judges
and magistrates, most of them would feel quite at home in the Circum-
locution Office. The only officials whom Dickens handles with any
kind of friendliness are, significantly enough, policemen.


Dickens's attitude is easily intelligible to an Englishman, because it is
part of the English puritan tradition, which is not dead even at this
day. The class Dickens belonged to, at least by adoption, was growing
suddenly rich
after a couple of centuries of obscurity. It had grown up
mainly in the big towns, out of contact with agriculture, and politically
impotent;
government, in its experience, was something which either
interfered or persecuted. Consequently it was a class with no tradition
of public service and not much tradition of usefulness.
What now strikes
us as remarkable about the new moneyed class of the nineteenth cen-
tury is their complete irresponsibility; they see everything in terms of
individual success, with hardly any consciousness that the community
exists. On the other hand, a Tite Barnacle, even when he was neglect-
ing his duties, would have some vague notion of what duties he was
neglecting. Dickens's attitude is never irresponsible, still less does he
take the money-grubbing Smilesian line; but
at the back of his mind there
is usually a half-belief that the whole apparatus of government is un-
necessary. Parliament is simply Lord Coodle and Sir Thomas Doodle, the
Empire is simply Major Bagstock and his Indian servant, the Army is
simply Colonel Chowser and Doctor Slammer, the public services are simply
Bumble and the Circumlocution Office--and so on and so forth. What he
does not see, or only intermittently sees, is that Coodle and Doodle and
all the other corpses left over from the eighteenth century ARE perform-
ing a function which neither Pickwick nor Boffin would ever bother
about.

And of course this narrowness of vision is in one way a great advantage
to him, because it is fatal for a caricaturist to see too much. From
Dickens's point of view 'good' society is simply a collection of village
idiots. What a crew! Lady Tippins! Mrs. Gowan! Lord Verisopht! The
Honourable Bob Stables! Mrs. Sparsit (whose husband was a Powler)! The
Tite Barnacles! Nupkins! It is practically a case-book in lunacy.
But at
the same time his remoteness from the landowning-military-bureaucratic
class incapacitates him for full-length satire. He only succeeds with
this class when he depicts them as mental defectives. The accusation
which used to be made against Dickens in his lifetime, that he 'could not
paint a gentleman', was an absurdity, but it is true in this sense, that
what he says against the 'gentleman' class is seldom very damaging. Sir
Mulberry Hawk, for instance, is a wretched attempt at the wicked-baronet
type. Harthouse in HARD TIMES is better, but he would be only an ordinary
achievement for Trollope or Thackeray.
Trollope's thoughts hardly move
outside the 'gentleman' class, but Thackeray has the great advantage of
having a foot in two moral camps.
In some ways his outlook is very
similar to Dickens's. Like Dickens,
he identifies with the puritanical
moneyed class against the card-playing, debt-bilking aristocracy.
The
eighteenth century, as he sees it, is sticking out into the nineteenth in
the person of the wicked Lord Steyne. VANITY FAIR is a full-length
version of what Dickens did for a few chapters in LITTLE DORRIT. But by
origins and upbringing Thackeray happens to be somewhat nearer to the
class he is satirizing. Consequently he can produce such comparatively
subtle types as, for instance, Major Pendennis and Rawdon Crawley. Major
Pendennis is a shallow old snob, and
Rawdon Crawley is a thick-headed
ruffian who sees nothing wrong in living for years by swindling
tradesmen;
but what Thackery realizes is that according to their tortuous
code they are neither of them bad men. Major Pendennis would not sign a
dud cheque, for instance; Rawdon certainly would, but on the other hand
he would not desert a friend in a tight corner. Both of them would behave
well on the field of battle
--a thing that would not particularly appeal
to Dickens. The result is that at the end one is left with a kind of
amused tolerance for Major Pendennis and with
something approaching
respect for Rawdon; and yet one sees, better than any diatribe could make
one, the utter rottenness of that kind of cadging, toadying life on the
fringes of smart society.
Dickens would be quite incapable of this. In
his hands both Rawdon and the Major would dwindle to traditional
caricatures. And, on the whole, his attacks on 'good' society are rather
perfunctory.
The aristocracy and the big bourgeoisie exist in his books
chiefly as a kind of 'noises off', a haw-hawing chorus somewhere in the
wings
, like Podsnap's dinner-parties. When he produces a really subtle
and damaging portrait, like John Dorrit or Harold Skimpole, it is
generally of some rather middling, unimportant person.

One very striking thing about Dickens, especially considering the time he
lived in, is his lack of vulgar nationalism. All peoples who have reached
the point of becoming nations tend to despise foreigners, but there is
not much doubt that the
English-speaking races are the worst offenders.
One can see this from the fact that as soon
as they become fully aware
of any foreign race they invent an insulting nickname for it. Wop, Dago,
Froggy, Squarehead, Kike, Sheeny, Nigger, Wog, Chink, Greaser,
Yellowbelly
--these are merely a selection. Any time before 1870 the list
would have been shorter, because the map of the world was different from
what it is now, and there were only three or four foreign races that had
fully entered into the English consciousness. But towards these, and
especially
towards France, the nearest and best-hated nation, the English
attitude of patronage was so intolerable that English 'arrogance' and
'xenophobia' are still a legend.
And of course they are not a completely
untrue legend even now. Till very recently nearly
all English children
were brought up to despise the southern European races, and history as
taught in schools was mainly a list of battles won by England.
But one
has got to read, say, the QUARTERLY REVIEW of the thirties to know what
boasting really is. Those were the days when the English built up their
legend of themselves as 'sturdy islanders' and 'stubborn hearts of oak'
and when it was accepted as a kind of scientific fact that one Englishman
was the equal of three foreigners.
All through nineteenth-century novels
and comic papers there runs the traditional figure of the 'Froggy'--a
small ridiculous man with a tiny beard and a pointed top-hat, always
jabbering and gesticulating, vain, frivolous and fond of boasting of his
martial exploits, but generally taking to flight when real danger
appears.
Over against him was John Bull, the 'sturdy English yeoman', or
(a more public-school version) the 'strong, silent Englishman'
of Charles
Kingsley, Tom Hughes and others.

Thackeray, for instance, has this outlook very strongly, though there are
moments when he sees through it and laughs at it. The one historical fact
that is firmly fixed in his mind is that the English won the battle of
Waterloo. One never reads far in his books without coming upon some
reference to it. The English, as he sees it, are invincible because of
their tremendous physical strength, due mainly to living on beef. Like
most Englishmen of his time, he has the curious illusion that the English
are larger than other people (Thackeray, as it happened, was larger than
most people)
, and therefore he is capable of writing passages like this:


I say to you that you are better than a Frenchman. I would lay even money
that you who are reading this are more than five feet seven in height,
and weigh eleven stone; while a Frenchman is five feet four and does not
weigh nine.
The Frenchman has after his soup a dish of vegetables, where
you have one of meat. You are a different and superior animal--a
French-beating animal
(the history of hundreds of years has shown you to
be so)
, etc. etc.


There are similar passages scattered all through Thackeray's works.
Dickens would never be guilty of anything of that kind. It would be an
exaggeration to say that he nowhere pokes fun at foreigners, and of
course like nearly all nineteenth-century Englishmen, he is untouched by
European culture. But never anywhere does he indulge in the typical
English boasting, the 'island race',
'bulldog breed', 'right little,
tight little island' style of talk.
In the whole of A TALE OF TWO CITIES
there is not a line that could be taken as meaning, 'Look how these
wicked Frenchmen behave!' The only place where he seems to display a
normal hatred of foreigners is in the American chapters of MARTIN
CHUZZLEWIT. This, however, is simply the reaction of a generous mind
against cant. If Dickens were alive today he would make a trip to Soviet
Russia and come back to the book rather like Gide's RETOUR DE L'URSS.
But he is remarkably free from the idiocy of regarding nations as
individuals. He seldom even makes jokes turning on nationality. He does
not exploit the comic Irishman and the comic Welshman,
for instance, and
not because he objects to stock characters and ready-made jokes, which
obviously he does not. It is perhaps more significant that he shows no
prejudice against Jews. It is true that he takes it for granted (OLIVER
TWIST and GREAT EXPECTATIONS) that a receiver of stolen goods will
be a Jew, which at the time was probably justified. But the 'Jew joke',
endemic in English literature until the rise of Hitler, does not appear
in his books, and in OUR MUTUAL FRIEND he makes a pious though not
very convincing attempt to stand up for the Jews.


Dickens's lack of vulgar nationalism is in part the mark of a real
largeness of mind, and in part results from his negative, rather
unhelpful political attitude.
He is very much an Englishman but he is
hardly aware of it--certainly the thought of being an Englishman does
not thrill him. He has no imperialist feelings, no discernible views on
foreign politics, and is untouched by the military tradition. Tempera-
mentally he is much nearer to the small noncomformist tradesman
who looks down on the 'redcoats', and thinks that war is wicked--a
one-eyed view, but after all, war is wicked. It is noticeable that
Dickens hardly writes of war, even to denounce it. With all his
marvellous powers of description, and of describing things he had never
seen, he never describes a battle, unless one counts the attack on the
Bastille in A TALE OF TWO CITIES. Probably the subject would not strike
him as interesting, and in any case
he would not regard a battlefield as
a place where anything worth settling could be settled.
It is one up to
the lower-middle-class, puritan mentality.



III


Dickens had grown up near enough to poverty to be terrified of it, and
in spite of his generosity of mind, he is not free from the special
prejudices of the shabby-genteel. It is usual to claim him as a 'popular'
writer, a champion of the 'oppressed masses'. So he is, so long as he
thinks of them as oppressed; but there are two things that condition his
attitude. In the first place, he is a south-of-England man, and a Cockney
at that, and therefore out of touch with the bulk of the real oppressed
masses, the industrial and agricultural labourers.
It is interesting to
see how Chesterton, another Cockney, always presents Dickens as the
spokesman of 'the poor', without showing much awareness of who 'the
poor' really are. To Chesterton 'the poor' means small shopkeepers and
servants. Sam Weller, he says, 'is the great symbol in English literature
of the populace peculiar to England'; and Sam Weller is a valet! The
other point is that
Dickens's early experiences have given him a horror
of proletarian roughness. He shows this unmistakably whenever he writes
of the very poorest of the poor, the slum-dwellers. His descriptions of
the London slums are always full of undisguised repulsion:



The ways were foul and narrow; the shops and houses wretched; and people
half naked, drunken, slipshod and ugly. Alleys and archways, like so many
cesspools, disgorged their offences of smell, and dirt, and life, upon
the straggling streets; and the whole quarter reeked with crime, and
filth, and misery,
etc. etc.


There are many similar passages in Dickens. From them one gets the
impression of
whole submerged populations whom he regards as being
beyond the pale.
In rather the same way the modern doctrinaire Socialist
contemptuously writes off
a large block of the population as
'lumpenproletariat'.

Dickens also shows less understanding of criminals than one would expect
of him. Although he is well aware of the social and economic causes of
crime, he often seems to feel that when a man has once broken the law he
has put himself outside human society. There is a chapter at the end of
DAVID COPPERFIELD in which David visits the prison where Latimer and
Uriah Heep are serving their sentences.
Dickens actually seems to regard
the horrible 'model' prisons, against which Charles Reade delivered his
memorable attack in IT IS NEVER TOO LATE TO MEND, as too humane. He
complains that the food is too good! As soon as he comes up against crime
or the worst depths of poverty, he shows traces of the 'I've always kept
myself respectable' habit of mind.
The attitude of Pip (obviously the
attitude of Dickens himself) towards Magwitch in GREAT EXPECTATIONS
is extremely interesting.
Pip is conscious all along of his ingratitude
towards Joe, but far less so of his ingratitude towards Magwitch
. When he
discovers that the person who has loaded him with benefits for years is
actually a transported convict,
he falls into frenzies of disgust. 'The
abhorrence in which I held the man, the dread I had of him, the repug-
nance with which I shrank from him, could not have been exceeded if
he had been some terrible beast'
, etc. etc. So far as one can discover
from the text, this is not because when Pip was a child he had been
terrorized by Magwitch in the churchyard; it is because Magwitch is a
criminal and a convict. There is an even more 'kept-myself-respectable'
touch in the fact that Pip feels as a matter of course that he cannot
take Magwitch's money.
The money is not the product of a crime, it has
been honestly acquired; but it is an ex-convict's money and therefore
'tainted'.
There is nothing psychologically false in this, either. Psycho-
logically the latter part of GREAT EXPECTATIONS is about the best
thing Dickens ever did; throughout this part of the book one feels 'Yes,
that is just how Pip would have behaved.' But the point is that in the
matter of Magwitch, Dickens identifies with Pip, and his attitude is at
bottom snobbish. The result is that
Magwitch belongs to the same queer
class of characters as Falstaff and, probably, Don Quixote--characters
who are more pathetic than the author intended.


When it is a question of the non-criminal poor, the ordinary, decent,
labouring poor, there is of course nothing contemptuous in Dickens's
attitude. He has the sincerest admiration for people like the Peggottys
and the Plornishes. But it is questionable whether he really regards them
as equals. It is of the greatest interest to read Chapter XI of DAVID
COPPERFIELD and side by side with it the autobiographical fragments
(parts of this are given in Forster's LIFE), in which Dickens expresses
his feelings about the blacking-factory episode a great deal more
strongly than in the novel. For more than twenty years afterwards the
memory was so painful to him that he would go out of his way to avoid
that part of the Strand. He says that to pass that way 'made me cry,
after my eldest child could speak.' The text makes it quite clear that
what hurt him most of all, then and in retrospect, was the enforced
contact with 'low' associates:



No words can express the secret agony of my soul as I sunk into this
companionship; compared these everyday associates with those of my
happier childhood. But I held some station at the blacking warehouse
too. . . I soon became at least as expeditious and as skilful with my hands
as either of the other boys. Though perfectly familiar with them, my
conduct and manners were different enough from theirs to place a space
between us. They, and the men, always spoke of me as 'the young
gentleman'. A certain man. . . used to call me 'Charles' sometimes in
speaking to me; but I think it was mostly when we were very
confidential. . . Poll Green uprose once, and rebelled against the
'young-gentleman' usage; but Bob Fagin settled him speedily.



It was as well that there should be 'a space between us', you see.
However much Dickens may admire the working classes, he does not wish
to resemble them. Given his origins, and the time he lived in, it could
hardly be otherwise. In the early nineteenth century class animosities
may have been no sharper than they are now, but the surface differences
between class and class were enormously greater. The 'gentleman' and the
'common man' must have seemed like different species of animal. Dickens
is quite genuinely on the side of the poor against the rich, but it would
be next door to impossible for him not to think of a working-class
exterior as a stigma. In one of Tolstoy's fables the peasants of a
certain village judge every stranger who arrives from the state of his
hands. If his palms are hard from work, they let him in; if his palms are
soft, out he goes. This would be hardly intelligible to Dickens; all his
heroes have soft hands. His younger heroes--Nicholas Nickleby, Martin
Chuzzlewit, Edward Chester, David Copperfield, John Harmon--are usually
of the type known as 'walking gentlemen'. He likes a bourgeois exterior
and a bourgeois (not aristocratic) accent. One curious symptom of this is
that he will not allow anyone who is to play a heroic part to speak like
a working man. A comic hero like Sam Weller, or a merely pathetic figure
like Stephen Blackpool, can speak with a broad accent, but the JEUNE
PREMIER always speaks the equivalent of B.B.C. This is so, even when it
involves absurdities. Little Pip, for instance, is brought up by people
speaking broad Essex, but talks upper-class English from his earliest
childhood; actually he would have talked the same dialect as Joe, or at
least as Mrs. Gargery. So also with Biddy Wopsle, Lizzie Hexam, Sissie
Jupe, Oliver Twist--one ought perhaps to add Little Dorrit. Even Rachel
in HARD TIMES has barely a trace of Lancashire accent, an impossibility
in her case.


One thing that often gives the clue to a novelist's real feelings on the
class question is the attitude he takes up
when class collides with sex.
This is a thing too painful to be lied about
, and consequently it is one
of the points at which the 'I'm-not-a-snob' pose tends to break down.

One sees that at its most obvious
where a class-distinction is also a
colour-distinction.
And something resembling the colonial attitude
('native' women are fair game, white women are sacrosanct) exists in a
veiled form in all-white communities, causing bitter resentment
on both
sides. When this issue arises, novelists often revert to crude
class-feelings which they might disclaim at other times.
A good example
of 'class-conscious' reaction is a rather forgotten novel, THE PEOPLE OF
CLOPTON, by Andrew Barton.
The author's moral code is quite clearly mixed
up with class-hatred.
He feels the seduction of a poor girl by a rich man
to be something atrocious, a kind of defilement, something quite
different from her seduction by a man in her own walk of life.
Trollope
deals with this theme twice (THE THREE CLERKS and THE SMALL HOUSE AT
ALLINGTON) and, as one might expect, entirely from the upper-class angle.
As he sees it,
an affair with a barmaid or a landlady's daughter is
simply an 'entanglement'
to be escaped from. Trollope's moral standards
are strict, and he does not allow the seduction actually to happen, but
the implication is always that
a working-class girl's feelings do not
greatly matter.
In THE THREE CLERKS he even gives the typical
class-reaction by
noting that the girl 'smells'. Meredith (RHODA FLEMING)
takes more the 'class-conscious' viewpoint. Thackeray, as often, seems to
hesitate.
In PENDENNIS (Fanny Bolton) his attitude is much the same as
Trollope's; in A SHABBY GENTEEL STORY it is nearer to Meredith's.


One could divine a great deal about Trollope's social origin, or
Meredith's, or Barton's, merely from their handling of the class-sex
theme. So one can with Dickens, but what emerges, as usual, is that he
is more inclined to identify himself with the middle class than with the
proletariat. The one incident that seems to contradict this is the tale
of the young peasant-girl in Doctor Manette's manuscript in A TALE OF TWO
CITIES. This, however, is merely a costume-piece put in to explain the
implacable hatred of Madame Defarge, which Dickens does not pretend to
approve of. In DAVID COPPERFIELD, where he is dealing with a typical
nineteenth-century seduction, the class-issue does not seem to strike him
as paramount. It is a law of Victorian novels that sexual misdeeds must
not go unpunished, and so Steerforth is drowned on Yarmouth sands, but
neither Dickens, nor old Peggotty, nor even Ham, seems to feel that Steer-
forth has added to his offence by being the son of rich parents. The Steer-
forths are moved by class-motives, but the Peggottys are not—not even in
the scene between Mrs. Steerforth and old Peggotty; if they were, of course,
they would probably turn against David as well as against Steerforth.



In Our Mutual Friend Dickens treats the episode of Eugene Wrayburn
and Lizzie Hexam very realistically and with no appearance of class
bias. According to the 'Unhand me, monster!' tradition, Lizzie ought
either to 'spurn' Eugene or to be ruined by him and throw herself
off Waterloo Bridge: Eugene ought to be either a heartless betrayer
or a hero resolved upon defying society. Neither behaves in the
least like this. Lizzie is frightened by Eugene's advances and
actually runs away from him, but hardly pretends to dislike them;
Eugene is attracted by her, has too much decency to attempt seducing
her and dare not marry her because of his family. Finally they are
married
and no one is any the worse, except Mrs. Twemlow, who will
lose a few dinner engagements. It is all very much as it might have
happened in real life. But a 'class-conscious' novelist would have
given her to Bradley Headstone.


But when it is the other way about—when it is a case of a poor man
aspiring to some woman who is 'above' him Dickens instantly retreats
into the middle-class attitude. He is rather fond of the Victorian
notion of a woman (woman with a capital W) being 'above' a man. Pip
feels that Estella is 'above' him, Esther Summerson is 'above'
Guppy, Little Dorrit is 'above' John Chivery, Lucy Manette is
'above' Sydney Carton. In some of these the 'above'-ness is merely
moral, but in others it is social. There is a scarcely mistakable
class-reaction when David Copperfield discovers that Uriah Heep is
plotting to marry Agnes Wickfield. The disgusting Uriah suddenly
announces that he is in love with her:

'Oh, Master Copperfield, with what a pure affection do I love the
ground my Agnes walks on.'

I believe I had the delirious idea of seizing the red-hot poker out
of the fire, and running him through with it. It went from me with a
shock, like a ball fired from a rifle: but the image of Agnes,
outraged by so much as a thought of this red-headed animal's,
remained in my mind (when I looked at him, sitting all awry as if
his mean soul griped his body) and made me giddy...'I believe Agnes
Wickfield to be as far above you (David says later on), and as far
removed from all your aspirations, as the moon herself.'


Considering how Heep's general lowness—his servile manners, dropped
aitches and so forth—has been rubbed in throughout the book, there
is not much doubt about the nature of Dickens's feelings. Heep, of
course, is playing a villainous part, but even villains have sexual
lives; it is the thought of the 'pure' Agnes in bed with a man who
drops his aitches that really revolts Dickens. But his usual
tendency is to treat a man in love with a woman who is 'above' him
as a joke. It is one of the stock jokes of English literature, from
Malvolio onwards. Guppy in Bleak House is an example, John Chivery
is another, and there is a rather ill-natured treatment of this
theme in the 'swarry' in Pickwick Papers. Here Dickens describes
the Bath footmen as living a kind of fantasy-life, holding
dinner-parties in imitation of their 'betters' and deluding
themselves that their young mistresses are in love with them. This
evidently strikes him as very comic. So it is in a way, though
one
might question whether it is not better for a footman even to have
delusions of this kind than simply to accept his status in the
spirit of the catechism.


In his attitude towards servants Dickens is not ahead of his age. In
the nineteenth century the revolt against domestic service was just
beginning, to the great annoyance of everyone with over £500 a year.
An enormous number of the jokes in nineteenth-century comic papers
deals with the uppishness of servants. For years
Punch ran a series
of jokes called 'Servant Gal-isms', all turning on the then
astonishing fact that a servant is a human being.
Dickens is
sometimes guilty of this kind of thing himself. His books abound
with the ordinary comic servants; they are dishonest (Great
Expectations
), incompetent (David Copperfield), turn up their noses
at good food (Pickwick Papers), etc. etc.—all rather in the spirit
of the suburban housewife with one downtrodden cook-general. But
what is
curious, in a nineteenth-century radical, is that when he
wants to draw a sympathetic picture of a servant, he creates what is
recognizably a feudal type.
Sam Weller, Mark Tapley, Clara Peggotty
are all of them feudal figures. They belong to the genre of the 'old
family retainer';
they identify themselves with their master's
family and are at once doggishly faithful and completely familiar.
No doubt Mark Tapley and Sam Weller are derived to some extent from
Smollett, and hence from Cervantes;
but it is interesting that
Dickens should have been attracted by such a type. Sam Weller's
attitude is definitely medieval. He gets himself arrested in order
to follow Mr. Pickwick into the Fleet, and afterwards refuses to get
married because he feels that Mr. Pickwick still needs his services.

There is a characteristic scene between them:

'Vages or no vages, board or no board, lodgin' or no lodgin', Sam
Veller, as you took from the old inn in the Borough, sticks by you,
come what may...'

'My good fellow', said Mr. Pickwick, when Mr. Weller had sat down
again, rather abashed at his own enthusiasm, 'you are bound to
consider the young woman also.'

'I do consider the young 'ooman, sir', said Sam. 'I have considered
the young 'ooman. I've spoke to her. I've told her how I'm
sitivated; she's ready to vait till I'm ready, and I believe she
vill. If she don't, she's not the young 'ooman I take her for, and I
give up with readiness.
'

It is easy to imagine what the young woman would have said to this
in real life. But notice the feudal atmosphere.
Sam Weller is ready
as a matter of course to sacrifice years of his life to his master,
and he can also sit down in his master's presence. A modern
manservant would never think of doing either.
Dickens's views on the
servant question do not get much beyond wishing that master and
servant would love one another. Sloppy in Our Mutual Friend, though
a wretched failure as a character, represents the same kind of
loyalty as Sam Weller.
Such loyalty, of course, is natural, human,
and likeable; but so was feudalism.


What Dickens seems to be doing, as usual, is to reach out for an
idealized version of the existing thing. He was writing at a time
when domestic service must have seemed a completely inevitable evil.
There were no labour-saving devices, and there was huge inequality
of wealth. It was an age of enormous families, pretentious meals and
inconvenient houses, when the slavey drudging fourteen hours a day
in the basement kitchen was something too normal to be noticed. And
given the fact of servitude, the feudal relationship is the only
tolerable one.
Sam Weller and Mark Tapley are dream figures, no less
than the Cheerybles. If there have got to be masters and servants,
how much better that the master should be Mr. Pickwick and the
servant should be Sam Weller. Better still, of course, if servants
did not exist at all—but this Dickens is probably unable to imagine.
Without a high level of mechanical development, human equality is
not practically possible; Dickens goes to show that it is not
imaginable either.


IV

It is not merely a coincidence that Dickens never writes about
agriculture and writes endlessly about food.
He was a Cockney, and
London is the centre of the earth in rather the same sense that the
belly is the centre of the body. It is a city of consumers, of
people who are deeply civilized but not primarily useful.
A thing
that strikes one when one looks below the surface of Dickens's books
is that, as nineteenth-century novelists go, he is rather ignorant.
He knows very little about the way things really happen.
At first
sight this statement looks flatly untrue and it needs some
qualification.

Dickens had had vivid glimpses of 'low life'—life in a debtor's
prison, for example—and he was also a popular novelist and able to
write about ordinary people. So were all the characteristic English
novelists of the nineteenth century. They felt at home in the world
they lived in, whereas
a writer nowadays is so hopelessly isolated
that the typical modern novel is a novel about a novelist. Even when
Joyce, for instance, spends a decade or so in patient efforts to
make contact with the 'common man', his 'common man' finally turns
out to be a Jew, and a bit of a highbrow at that.
Dickens at least
does not suffer from this kind of thing. He has no difficulty in
introducing the common motives, love, ambition, avarice, vengeance
and so forth.
What he does not noticeably write about, however, is
work.

In Dickens's novels anything in the nature of work happens
off-stage. The only one of his heroes who has a plausible profession
is David Copperfield, who is first a shorthand writer and then a
novelist, like Dickens himself. With most of the others, the way
they earn their living is very much in the background. Pip, for
instance, 'goes into business' in Egypt; we are not told what
business, and Pip's working life occupies about half a page of the
book. Clennam has been in some unspecified business in China, and
later goes into another barely specified business with Doyce;
Martin
Chuzzlewit is an architect, but does not seem to get much time for
practising. In no case do their adventures spring directly out of
their work. Here the contrast between Dickens and, say, Trollope is
startling. And one reason for this is undoubtedly that Dickens knows
very little about the professions his characters are supposed to
follow. What exactly went on in Gradgrind's factories?
How did
Podsnap make his money? How did Merdle work his swindles? One
knows that Dickens could never follow up the details of Parliamentary
elections and Stock Exchange rackets as Trollope could. As soon as
he has to deal with trade, finance, industry or politics he takes
refuge in vagueness, or in satire. This is the case even with legal
processes, about which actually he must have known a good deal.
Compare any lawsuit in Dickens with the lawsuit in Orley Farm, for
instance.

And this partly accounts for the needless ramifications of Dickens's
novels, the awful Victorian 'plot'. It is true that not all his
novels are alike in this. A Tale of Two Cities is a very good and
fairly simple story, and so in its different ways is Hard Times; but
these are just the two which are always rejected as 'not like
Dickens'—and incidentally they were not published in monthly
numbers. The two first-person novels are also good stories, apart
from their subplots. But the typical Dickens novel, Nicholas
Nickleby, Oliver Twist, Martin Chuzzlewit, Our Mutual Friend
, always
exists round a framework of melodrama.
The last thing anyone ever
remembers about the books is their central story. On the other hand,
I suppose no one has ever read them without carrying the memory of
individual pages to the day of his death. Dickens sees human beings
with the most intense vividness, but sees them always in private
life, as 'characters', not as functional members of society;
that is
to say, he sees them statically. Consequently his greatest success
is The Pickwick Papers, which is not a story at all, merely a series
of sketches; there is little attempt at development—the characters
simply go on and on, behaving like idiots, in a kind of eternity. As
soon as he tries to bring his characters into action, the melodrama
begins. He cannot make the action revolve round their ordinary
occupations; hence the crossword puzzle of coincidences, intrigues,
murders, disguises, buried wills, long-lost brothers, etc. etc. In
the end even people like Squeers and Micawber get sucked into the
machinery.

Of course it would be absurd to say that Dickens is a vague or
merely melodramatic writer.
Much that he wrote is extremely factual,
and in the power of evoking visual images he has probably never been
equalled. When Dickens has once described something you see it for
the rest of your life. But in a way the concreteness of his vision
is a sign of what he is missing. For, after all, that is what the
merely casual onlooker always sees—the outward appearance, the
non-functional, the surfaces of things. No one who is really
involved in the landscape ever sees the landscape. Wonderfully as he
can describe an appearance, Dickens does not often describe a
process.
The vivid pictures that he succeeds in leaving in one's
memory are nearly always the pictures of things seen in leisure
moments, in the coffee-rooms of country inns or through the windows
of a stage-coach; the kind of things he notices are inn-signs, brass
door-knockers, painted jugs, the interiors of shops and private
houses, clothes, faces and, above all, food. Everything is seen from
the consumer-angle. When he writes about Cokestown
he manages to
evoke, in just a few paragraphs, the atmosphere of a Lancashire town
as a slightly disgusted southern visitor would see it. 'It had a
black canal in it, and a river that ran purple with evil-smelling
dye, and vast piles of buildings full of windows where there was a
rattling and a trembling all day long, where the piston of the steam-
engine worked monotonously up and down, like the head of an
elephant in a state of melancholy madness
.'


That is as near as Dickens ever gets to the machinery of the mills.
An engineer or a cotton-broker would see it differently; but then
neither of them would be capable of that impressionistic touch about
the heads of the elephants.

In a rather different sense
his attitude to life is extremely
unphysical. He is a man who lives through his eyes and ears rather
than through his hands and muscles.
Actually his habits were not so
sedentary as this seems to imply. In spite of rather poor health and
physique, he was active to the point of restlessness; throughout his
life he was a remarkable walker, and he could at any rate carpenter
well enough to put up stage scenery. But he was not one of those
people who feel a need to use their hands. It is difficult to
imagine him digging at a cabbage-patch, for instance. He gives no
evidence of knowing anything about agriculture, and obviously knows
nothing about any kind of game or sport. He has
no interest in
pugilism
, for instance. Considering the age in which he was writing,
it is astonishing how little physical brutality there is in
Dickens's novels.
Martin Chuzzlewit and Mark Tapley, for instance,
behave with the most remarkable mildness towards the Americans who
are constantly menacing them with revolvers and bowie-knives. The
average English or American novelist would have had them handing out
socks on the jaw and exchanging pistol-shots in all directions.
Dickens is too decent for that; he sees the stupidity of violence,
and he also belongs to a cautious urban class which does not deal in
socks on the jaw, even in theory
. And his attitude towards sport is
mixed up with social feelings. In England, for mainly geographical
reasons, sport, especially field-sports, and snobbery are
inextricably mingled. English Socialists are often flatly
incredulous when told that Lenin, for instance, was devoted to
shooting. In their eyes, shooting, hunting, etc., are simply
snobbish observances of the landed gentry; they forget that these
things might appear differently in a huge virgin country like
Russia. From Dickens's point of view almost any kind of sport
is at best a subject for satire. Consequently one side of
nineteenth-century life—the boxing, racing, cock-fighting,
badger-digging, poaching, rat-catching side of life, so wonderfully
embalmed in Leech's illustrations to Surtees—is outside his scope.


What is more striking, in a seemingly 'progressive' radical, is that
he is not mechanically minded. He shows no interest either in the
details of machinery or in the things machinery can do. As Gissing
remarks, Dickens nowhere describes a railway journey with anything
like the enthusiasm he shows in describing journeys by stage-coach.
In nearly all of his books one has a curious feeling that one is
living in the first quarter of the nineteenth century, and in fact,
he does tend to return to this period. Little Dorrit, written in the
middle fifties, deals with the late twenties; Great Expectations
(1861) is not dated, but evidently deals with the twenties and
thirties.
Several of the inventions and discoveries which have
made the modern world possible (the electric telegraph, the
breech-loading gun, India-rubber, coal gas, wood-pulp paper) first
appeared in Dickens's lifetime, but he scarcely notes them in his
books
. Nothing is queerer than the vagueness with which he speaks
of Doyce's 'invention' in Little Dorrit. It is represented as something
extremely ingenious and revolutionary, 'of great importance to his
country and his fellow-creatures', and it is also an important minor
link in the book; yet we are never told what the 'invention' is! On
the other hand, Doyce's physical appearance is hit off with the
typical Dickens touch; he has a peculiar way of moving his thumb,
a way characteristic of engineers. After that, Doyce is firmly
anchored in one's memory; but, as usual, Dickens has done it by
fastening on something external.


There are people (Tennyson is an example) who lack the mechanical
faculty but can see the social possibilities of machinery. Dickens
has not this stamp of mind. He shows very little consciousness of
the future.
When he speaks of human progress it is usually in terms
of moral progress—men growing better; probably he would never admit
that men are only as good as their technical development allows them
to be.
At this point the gap between Dickens and his modern
analogue, H.G. Wells, is at its widest. Wells wears the future round
his neck like a mill-stone, but Dickens's unscientific cast of mind
is just as damaging in a different way. What it does is to make any
positive attitude more difficult for him. He is hostile to the
feudal, agricultural past and not in real touch with the industrial
present. Well, then, all that remains is the future (meaning
Science, 'progress', and so forth), which hardly enters into his
thoughts. Therefore, while attacking everything in sight, he has no
definable standard of comparison.
As I have pointed out already, he
attacks the current educational system with perfect justice, and
yet, after all, he has no remedy to offer except kindlier
schoolmasters. Why did he not indicate what a school might have
been? Why did he not have his own sons educated according to some
plan of his own, instead of sending them to public schools to be
stuffed with Greek? Because he lacked that kind of imagination.
He
has an infallible moral sense, but very little intellectual
curiosity.
And here one comes upon something which really is an
enormous deficiency in Dickens, something, that really does make the
nineteenth century seem remote from us—that
he has no idea of work.

With the doubtful exception of David Copperfield (merely Dickens
himself), one cannot point to a single one of his central characters
who is primarily interested in his job. His heroes work in order to
make a living and to marry the heroine, not because they feel a
passionate interest in one particular subject. Martin Chuzzlewit,
for instance, is not burning with zeal to be an architect; he might
just as well be a doctor or a barrister. In any case, in the typical
Dickens novel, the deus ex machina enters with a bag of gold in the
last chapter and the hero is absolved from further struggle.
The
feeling 'This is what I came into the world to do. Everything else
is uninteresting. I will do this even if it means starvation', which
turns men of differing temperaments into scientists, inventors,
artists, priests, explorers and revolutionaries—this motif is almost
entirely absent from Dickens's books. He himself, as is well known,
worked like a slave and believed in his work as few novelists have
ever done.
But there seems to be no calling except novel-writing
(and perhaps acting) towards which he can imagine this kind of
devotion. And, after all, it is natural enough, considering his
rather negative attitude towards society. In the last resort
there
is nothing he admires except common decency. Science is
uninteresting and machinery is cruel and ugly (the heads of the
elephants).
Business is only for ruffians like Bounderby. As for
politics—leave that to the Tite Barnacles. Really there is no
objective except to marry the heroine, settle down, live solvently
and be kind.
And you can do that much better in private life.

Here, perhaps, one gets a glimpse of Dickens's secret imaginative
background. What did he think of as the most desirable way to live?
When Martin Chuzzlewit had made it up with his uncle, when Nicholas
Nickleby had married money, when John Harman had been enriched by
Boffin what did they do?

The answer evidently is that
they did nothing. Nicholas Nickleby
invested his wife's money with the Cheerybles and 'became a rich and
prosperous merchant', but as he immediately retired into Devonshire,
we can assume that he did not work very hard. Mr. and Mrs. Snodgrass
'purchased and cultivated a small farm, more for occupation than
profit.' That is the spirit in which most of Dickens's books end—a
sort of
radiant idleness. Where he appears to disapprove of young
men who do not work (Harthouse, Harry Gowan, Richard Carstone,
Wrayburn before his reformation) it is because they are cynical and
immoral or because they are a burden on somebody else;
if you are
'good', and also self-supporting, there is no reason why you should
not spend fifty years in simply drawing your dividends.
Home life is
always enough. And, after all, it was the general assumption of his
age.
The 'genteel sufficiency', the 'competence', the 'gentleman of
independent means' (or 'in easy circumstances')—the very phrases
tell one all about the strange, empty dream of the eighteenth- and
nineteenth-century middle bourgeoisie. It was a dream of complete
idleness.
Charles Reade conveys its spirit perfectly in the ending
of Hard Cash. Alfred Hardie, hero of Hard Cash, is the typical
nineteenth-century novel-hero (public-school style), with gifts
which Reade describes as amounting to 'genius'. He is an old Etonian
and a scholar of Oxford, he knows most of the Greek and Latin
classics by heart, he can box with prizefighters and win the Diamond
Sculls at Henley. He goes through incredible adventures in which, of
course, he behaves with faultless heroism, and then, at the age of
twenty-five, he inherits a fortune, marries his Julia Dodd and
settles down in the suburbs of Liverpool, in the same house as his
parents-in-law:


They all lived together at Albion Villa, thanks to Alfred...Oh, you
happy little villa! You were as like Paradise as any mortal dwelling
can be. A day came, however, when your walls could no longer hold
all the happy inmates. Julia presented Alfred with a lovely boy;
enter two nurses and the villa showed symptoms of bursting. Two
months more, and Alfred and his wife overflowed into the next villa.
It was but twenty yards off; and there was a double reason for the
migration. As often happens after a long separation, Heaven bestowed
on Captain and Mrs. Dodd another infant to play about their knees
,

etc. etc. etc.

This is the type of the Victorian happy ending—a vision of a huge,
loving family of
three or four generations, all crammed together in
the same house and constantly multiplying, like a bed of oysters.
What is striking about it is the utterly soft, sheltered, effortless
life that it implies. It is not even a violent idleness
, like Squire
Western's.


That is the significance of Dickens's urban background and his non
interest in the blackguardly-sporting military side of life. His
heroes, once they had come into money and 'settled down', would not
only do no work; they would not even ride, hunt, shoot, fight duels,
elope with actresses or lose money at the races. They would
simply
live at home in feather-bed respectability, and preferably next door
to a blood-relation living exactly the same life:


The first act of Nicholas, when he became a rich and prosperous
merchant, was to buy his father's old house. As time crept on, and
there came gradually about him a group of lovely children, it was
altered and enlarged; but none of the old rooms were ever pulled
down, no old tree was ever rooted up, nothing with which there was
any association of bygone times was ever removed or changed.


Within a stone's-throw was another retreat enlivened by children's
pleasant voices too; and here was Kate...the same true, gentle
creature, the same fond sister, the same in the love of all about
her, as in her girlish days.

It is the same
incestuous atmosphere as in the passage quoted from
Reade. And evidently this is Dickens's ideal ending. It is perfectly
attained in Nicholas Nickleby, Martin Chuzzlewit and Pickwick, and
it is approximated to in varying degrees in almost all the others.
The exceptions are Hard Times and Great Expectations
—the latter
actually has a 'happy ending', but it contradicts the general
tendency of the book, and it was put in at the request of Bulwer
Lytton.

The ideal to be striven after, then, appears to be something like
this:
a hundred thousand pounds, a quaint old house with plenty of
ivy on it, a sweetly womanly wife, a horde of children, and no work.
Everything is safe, soft, peaceful and, above all, domestic. In the
moss-grown churchyard down the road are the graves of the loved ones
who passed away before the happy ending happened. The servants are
comic and feudal, the children prattle round your feet, the old
friends sit at your fireside, talking of past days, there is the
endless succession of enormous meals, the cold punch and sherry
negus, the feather beds and warming-pans, the Christmas parties with
charades and blind man's buff; but nothing ever happens, except the
yearly childbirth. The curious thing is that it is a genuinely happy
picture, or so Dickens is able to make it appear. The thought of
that kind of existence is satisfying to him. This alone would be
enough to tell one that more than a hundred years have passed since
Dickens's first book was written. No modern man could combine such
purposelessness with so much vitality.


V

By this time anyone who is a lover of Dickens, and who has read as
far as this, will probably be angry with me.


I have been discussing Dickens simply in terms of his 'message', and
almost ignoring his literary qualities. But every writer, especially
every novelist, has a 'message', whether he admits it or not, and
the minutest details of his work are influenced by it.
All art is
propaganda.
Neither Dickens himself nor the majority of Victorian
novelists would have thought of denying this. On the other hand,
not
all propaganda is art.
As I said earlier, Dickens is one of those
writers who are felt to be worth stealing. He has been stolen by
Marxists, by Catholics and, above all, by Conservatives. The
question is, What is there to steal? Why does anyone care about
Dickens?
Why do I care about Dickens?

That kind of question is never easy to answer. As a rule, an
aesthetic preference is either something inexplicable or it is so
corrupted by non-aesthetic motives as to make one wonder whether
the whole of literary criticism is not a huge network of humbug. In
Dickens's case the complicating factor is his familiarity.
He
happens to be one of those 'great authors' who are ladled down
everyone's throat in childhood. At the time this causes rebellion
and vomiting, but it may have different after-effects in later life.

For instance, nearly everyone feels a sneaking affection for the
patriotic poems that he learned by heart as a child, 'Ye Mariners of
England', the 'Charge of the Light Brigade' and so forth. What one
enjoys is not so much the poems themselves as the memories they call
up. And with Dickens the same forces of association are at work.
Probably there are copies of one or two of his books lying about in
an actual majority of English homes. Many children begin to know his
characters by sight before they can even read, for on the whole
Dickens was lucky in his illustrators. A thing that is absorbed as
early as that does not come up against any critical judgement. And
when one thinks of this,
one thinks of all that is bad and silly in
Dickens—the cast-iron 'plots', the characters who don't come off,
the longueurs, the paragraphs in blank verse, the awful pages of
'pathos'.
And then the thought arises, when I say I like Dickens, do
I simply mean that I like thinking about my childhood? Is Dickens
merely an institution?


If so, he is an institution that there is no getting away from. How
often one really thinks about any writer, even a writer one cares
for, is a difficult thing to decide; but I should doubt whether
anyone who has actually read Dickens can go a week without
remembering him in one context or another. Whether you approve of
him or not, he is there, like the Nelson Column.
At any moment some
scene or character, which may come from some book you cannot even
remember the name of, is liable to drop into your mind. Micawber's
letters! Winkle in the witness-box! Mrs. Gamp! Mrs. Wititterly and
Sir Tumley Snuffim! Todgers's! (George Gissing said that when he
passed the Monument it was never of the Fire of London that he
thought, always of Todgers's.) Mrs. Leo Hunter! Squeers! Silas Wegg
and the Decline and Fall-off of the Russian Empire! Miss Mills and
the Desert of Sahara! Wopsle acting Hamlet! Mrs. Jellyby! Mantalini,
Jerry Cruncher, Barkis, Pumblechook, Tracy Tupman, Skimpole, Joe
Gargery, Pecksniff—and so it goes on and on. It is not so much a
series of books, it is more like a world. And not a purely comic
world either, for part of what one remembers in Dickens is his
Victorian morbidness and necrophilia and the blood-and-thunder
scenes—the death of Sykes, Krook's spontaneous combustion, Fagin in
the condemned cell, the women knitting round the guillotine.
To a
surprising extent all this has entered even into the minds of people
who do not care about it. A music-hall comedian can (or at any rate
could quite recently) go on the stage and impersonate Micawber or
Mrs. Gamp with a fair certainty of being understood, although not
one in twenty of the audience had ever read a book of Dickens's
right through. Even people who affect to despise him quote him
unconsciously.


Dickens is a writer who can be imitated, up to a certain point. In
genuinely popular literature—for instance, the Elephant and Castle
version of Sweeny Todd—he has been plagiarized quite shamelessly.
What has been imitated, however, is simply a tradition that Dickens
himself took from earlier novelists and developed, the cult of
'character', i.e. eccentricity. The thing that cannot be imitated is
his fertility of invention, which is invention not so much of
characters, still less of 'situations', as of turns of phrase and
concrete details. The outstanding, unmistakable mark of Dickens's
writing is the unnecessary detail. Here is an example of what I
mean. The story given below is not particularly funny, but there is
one phrase in it that is as individual as a fingerprint. Mr. Jack
Hopkins, at Bob Sawyer's party, is telling the story of the child
who swallowed its sister's necklace:


Next day, child swallowed two beads; the day after that, he treated
himself to three, and so on, till in a week's time he had got
through the necklace—five-and-twenty beads in all. The sister, who
was an industrious girl and seldom treated herself to a bit of
finery, cried her eyes out at the loss of the necklace; looked high
and low for it; but I needn't say, didn't find it. A few days after-
wards, the family were at dinner—baked shoulder of mutton and
potatoes under it—the child, who wasn't hungry, was playing about
the room, when suddenly there was the devil of a noise, like a
small hailstorm. 'Don't do that, my boy', says the father. 'I ain't
a-doin' nothing', said the child. 'Well, don't do it again', said
the father. There was a short silence, and then the noise began
again, worse than ever. 'If you don't mind what I say, my boy', said
the father, 'you'll find yourself in bed, in something less than a
pig's whisper.' He gave the child a shake to make him obedient, and
such a rattling ensued as nobody ever heard before. 'Why dam' me,
it's in the child', said the father; 'he's got the croup in the
wrong place!' 'No, I haven't, father', said the child, beginning to
cry, 'it's the necklace; I swallowed it, father.' The father caught
the child up, and ran with him to the hospital, the beads in the
boy's stomach rattling all the way with the jolting; and the people
looking up in the air, and down in the cellars, to see where the
unusual sound came from. 'He's in the hospital now', said Jack
Hopkins, 'and he makes such a devil of a noise when he walks about,
that they're obliged to muffle him in a watchman's coat, for fear he
should wake the patients
.'

As a whole, this story might come out of any nineteenth-century
comic paper. But
the unmistakable Dickens touch, the thing that
nobody else would have thought of, is
the baked shoulder of mutton
and potatoes under it.
How does this advance the story? The answer
is that it doesn't. It is something totally unnecessary,
a florid
little squiggle on the edge of the page; only, it is by just these
squiggles that the special Dickens atmosphere is created.
The other
thing one would notice here is that Dickens's way of telling a story
takes a long time. An interesting example, too long to quote, is Sam
Weller's story of the obstinate patient in Chapter XLIV of The
Pickwick Papers
. As it happens, we have a standard of comparison
here, because Dickens is plagiarizing, consciously or unconsciously.
The story is also told by some ancient Greek writer.
I cannot now
find the passage, but I read it years ago as a boy at school, and it
runs more or less like this:

A certain Thracian, renowned for his obstinacy, was warned by his
physician that if he drank a flagon of wine it would kill him. The
Thracian thereupon drank the flagon of wine and immediately jumped
off the house-top and perished. 'For', said he, 'in this way I shall
prove that the wine did not kill me
.'

As the Greek tells it, that is the whole story—about six lines. As
Sam Weller tells it, it takes round about a thousand words.
Long
before getting to the point we have been told all about the
patient's clothes, his meals, his manners, even the newspapers he
reads, and about the peculiar construction of the doctor's carriage,
which conceals the fact that the coachman's trousers do not match
his coat. Then there is the dialogue between the doctor and the
patient. ''Crumpets is wholesome, sir,' said the patient. 'Crumpets
is not wholesome, sir,' says the doctor, wery fierce,' etc., etc. In
the end the original story had been buried under the details. And in
all of Dickens's most characteristic passages it is the same.
His
imagination overwhelms everything, like a kind of weed.
Squeers
stands up to address his boys, and immediately we are hearing about
Bolder's father who was two pounds ten short, and
Mobbs's stepmother
who took to her bed on hearing that Mobbs wouldn't eat fat and hoped
Mr. Squeers would flog him into a happier state of mind.
Mrs. Leo
Hunter writes a poem, 'Expiring Frog'; two full stanzas are given.
Boffin takes a fancy to pose as a miser, and instantly we are down
among the squalid biographies of eighteenth-century misers, with
names like Vulture Hopkins and the Rev. Blewberry Jones, and chapter
headings like 'The Story of the Mutton Pies' and 'The Treasures of a
Dunghill'.
Mrs. Harris, who does not even exist, has more detail
piled on to her than any three characters in an ordinary novel.
Merely in the middle of a sentence we learn, for instance, that her
infant nephew has been seen in a bottle at Greenwich Fair, along
with the pink-eyed lady, the Prussian dwarf and the living skeleton.
Joe Gargery describes how the robbers broke into the house of
Pumblechook, the corn and seed merchant—'and they took his till, and
they took his cashbox, and they drinked his wine, and they partook
of his wittles, and they slapped his face, and they pulled his nose,
and they tied him up to his bedpost, and they give him a dozen, and
they stuffed his mouth full of flowering annuals to prevent his
crying out.' Once again the unmistakable Dickens touch, the
flowering annuals;
but any other novelist would only have mentioned
about half of these outrages. Everything is piled up and up, detail
on detail, embroidery on embroidery. It is futile to object that
this kind of thing is rococo—one might as well make the same
objection to a wedding-cake. Either you like it or you do not like
it. Other nineteenth-century writers, Surtees, Barham, Thackeray,
even Marryat, have something of Dickens's profuse, overflowing
quality, but none of them on anything like the same scale. The
appeal of all these writers now depends partly on period-flavour
and
though Marryat is still officially a 'boy's writer' and Surtees has
a sort of legendary fame among hunting men, it is probable that they
are read mostly by bookish people.


Significantly, Dickens's most successful books (not his best books)
are The Pickwick Papers, which is not a novel, and Hard Times and
A Tale of Two Cities
, which are not funny. As a novelist his natural
fertility greatly hampers him, because the burlesque which he is
never able to resist, is constantly breaking into what ought to be
serious situations. There is a good example of this in the opening
chapter of Great Expectations. The escaped convict, Magwitch, has
just captured the six-year-old Pip in the churchyard. The scene
starts terrifyingly enough, from Pip's point of view. The convict,
smothered in mud and with his chain trailing from his leg, suddenly
starts up among the tombs, grabs the child, turns him upside down
and robs his pockets. Then he begins terrorizing him into bringing
foal and a file:

He held me by the arms in an upright position on the top of the
stone, and went on in these fearful terms:

'You bring me, tomorrow morning early, that file and them wittles.
You bring the lot to me, at that old Battery over yonder. You do it
and you never dare to say a word or dare to make a sign concerning
your having seen such a person as me, or any person sumever, and
you shall be let to live. You fail, or you go from my words in any
partickler, no matter how small it is, and your heart and liver
shall be tore out, roasted and ate. Now, I ain't alone, as you may
think I am. There's a young man hid with me, in comparison with
which young man I am a Angel. That young man hears the words I
speak. That young man has a secret way pecooliar to himself, of
getting at a boy, and at his heart, and at his liver. It is in wain
for a boy to attempt to hide himself from that young man. A boy may
lock his doors, may be warm in bed, may tuck himself up, may draw
the clothes over his head, may think himself comfortable and safe,
but that young man will softly creep his way to him and tear him
open. I am keeping that young man from harming you at the present
moment, but with great difficulty. I find it wery hard to hold that
young man off of your inside. Now, what do you say?
'

Here Dickens has simply yielded to temptation. To begin with, no
starving and hunted man would speak in the least like that.
Moreover, although the speech shows a remarkable knowledge of the
way in which a child's mind works, its actual words are quite out of
tune with what is to follow. It turns Magwitch into a sort of
pantomime wicked uncle, or, if one sees him through the child's
eyes, into an appalling monster. Later in the book he is to be
represented as neither, and his exaggerated gratitude, on which the
plot turns, is to be incredible because of just this speech. As
usual, Dickens's imagination has overwhelmed him. The picturesque
details were too good to be left out. Even with characters who are
more of a piece than Magwitch he is liable to be tripped up by some
seductive phrase. Mr. Murdstone, for instance, is in the habit of
ending David Copperfield's lessons every morning with a dreadful sum
in arithmetic. 'If I go into a cheesemonger's shop, and buy four
thousand double-Gloucester cheeses at fourpence halfpenny each,
present payment', it always begins. Once again the typical Dickens
detail, the double-Gloucester cheeses. But it is far too human a
touch for Murdstone; he would have made it five thousand cashboxes.
Every time this note is struck, the unity of the novel suffers. Not
that it matters very much, because
Dickens is obviously a writer
whose parts are greater than his wholes. He is all fragments, all
details—rotten architecture, but wonderful gargoyles
—and never
better than when he is building up some character who will later on
be forced to act inconsistently.

Of course it is not usual to urge against Dickens that he makes his
characters behave inconsistently. Generally he is accused of doing
just the opposite. His characters are supposed to be mere 'types',
each crudely representing some single trait and fitted with a kind
of label by which you recognize him. Dickens is 'only a
caricaturist'—that is the usual accusation, and it does him both
more and less than justice. To begin with, he did not think of
himself as a caricaturist, and was constantly setting into action
characters who ought to have been purely static. Squeers, Micawber,
Miss Mowcher,[Note, below] Wegg, Skimpole, Pecksniff and many others
are finally involved in 'plots' where they are out of place and
where they behave quite incredibly.
They start off as magic-lantern
slides and they end by getting mixed up in a third-rate movie.
Sometimes one can put one's finger on a single sentence in which the
original illusion is destroyed.
There is such a sentence in David
Copperfield
.
After the famous dinner-party (the one where the leg of
mutton was underdone), David is showing his guests out. He stops
Traddles at the top of the stairs:

[Note: Dickens turned Miss Mowcher into a sort of heroine because
the real woman whom he had caricatured had read the earlier chapters
and was bitterly hurt. He had previously meant her to play a
villainous part. But any action by such a character would seem
incongruous. (Author's footnote)]

'Traddles', said I, 'Mr. Micawber don't mean any harm, poor fellow:
but if I were you I wouldn't lend him anything.'

'My dear Copperfield', returned Traddles, smiling, 'I haven't got
anything to lend.'

'You have got a name, you know,' I said.


At the place where one reads it this remark jars a little though
something of the kind was inevitable sooner or later. The story is
a fairly realistic one, and David is growing up; ultimately he is
bound to see Mr. Micawber for what he is, a cadging scoundrel.
Afterwards, of course, Dickens's sentimentality overcomes him and
Micawber is made to turn over a new leaf. But from then on, the
original Micawber is never quite recaptured, in spite of desperate
efforts. As a rule, the 'plot' in which Dickens's characters get
entangled is not particularly credible, but at least it makes some
pretence at reality, whereas the world to which they belong is a
never-never land, a kind of eternity. But just here one sees that
'only a caricaturist' is not really a condemnation. The fact that
Dickens is always thought of as a caricaturist, although he was
constantly trying to be something else, is perhaps the surest
mark of his genius.
The monstrosities that he created are still
remembered as monstrosities, in spite of getting mixed up in
would-be probable melodramas. Their first impact is so vivid that
nothing that comes afterwards effaces it.
As with the people one
knew in childhood, one seems always to remember them in one
particular attitude, doing one particular thing.
Mrs. Squeers is
always ladling out brimstone and treacle, Mrs. Gummidge is always
weeping, Mrs. Gargery is always banging her husband's head a-
gainst the wall, Mrs. Jellyby is always scribbling tracts while her
children fall into the area—and there they all are, fixed up for
ever like little twinkling miniatures painted on snuffbox lids, com-
pletely fantastic and incredible, and yet somehow more solid and
infinitely more memorable
than the efforts of serious novelists.
Even by the standards of his time Dickens was an exceptionally
artificial writer. As Ruskin said, he 'chose to work in a circle of
stage fire.' His characters are even more distorted and simplified
than Smollett's. But there are no rules in novel-writing, and for
any work of art there is only one test worth bothering about—
survival. By this test Dickens's characters have succeeded,
even if the people who remember them hardly think of them as
human beings. They are monsters, but at any rate they exist.


But all the same there is a disadvantage in writing about monsters.
It amounts to this, that it is only certain moods that Dickens can
speak to. There are large areas of the human mind that he never
touches. There is no poetic feeling anywhere in his books, and no
genuine tragedy, and even sexual love is almost outside his scope.
Actually his books are not so sexless as they are sometimes declared
to be, and considering the time in which he was writing, he is
reasonably frank. But there is not a trace in him of the feeling
that one finds in Manon Lescaut, Salammbô, Carmen, Wuthering
Heights
. According to Aldous Huxley, D.H. Lawrence once said that
Balzac was 'a gigantic dwarf', and in a sense the same is true of
Dickens. There are whole worlds which he either knows nothing about
or does not wish to mention. Except in a rather roundabout way, one
cannot learn very much from Dickens. And to say this is to think
almost immediately of the great Russian novelists of the nineteenth
century. Why is it that
Tolstoy's grasp seems to be so much larger
than Dickens's—why is it that he seems able to tell you so much more
about yourself? It is not that he is more gifted, or even, in the
last analysis, more intelligent. It is because he is
writing about
people who are growing. His characters are struggling to make their
souls, whereas Dickens's are already finished and perfect.
In my own
mind Dickens's people are present far more often and far more
vividly than Tolstoy's, but always in a single unchangeable
attitude,
like pictures or pieces of furniture. You cannot hold an
imaginary conversation with a Dickens character as you can with,
say, Peter Bezoukhov. And this is not merely because of Tolstoy's
greater seriousness, for there are also comic characters that you
can imagine yourself talking to—Bloom, for instance, or Pecuchet, or
even Wells's Mr. Polly. It is because Dickens's characters have no
mental life. They say perfectly the thing that they have to say, but
they cannot be conceived as talking about anything else. They never
learn, never speculate. Perhaps the most meditative of his
characters is Paul Dombey, and his thoughts are mush. Does this mean
that Tolstoy's novels are 'better' than Dickens's? The truth is that
it is absurd to make such comparisons in terms of 'better' and
'worse'. If I were forced to compare Tolstoy with Dickens, I should
say that
Tolstoy's appeal will probably be wider in the long run,
because Dickens is scarcely intelligible outside the
English-speaking culture; on the other hand, Dickens is able to
reach simple people, which Tolstoy is not.
Tolstoy's characters can
cross a frontier, Dickens can be portrayed on a cigarette-card. But
one is
no more obliged to choose between them than between a sausage
and a rose.
Their purposes barely intersect.


VI


If Dickens had been merely a comic writer, the chances are that no
one would now remember his name. Or at best a few of his books
would survive in rather the same way as books like Frank Fairleigh,
Mr. Verdant Green and Mrs. Caudle's Curtain Lectures, as
a sort of
hangover of the Victorian atmosphere, a pleasant little whiff of
oysters and brown stout.
Who has not felt sometimes that it was 'a
pity' that Dickens ever deserted the vein of Pickwick for things
like Little Dorrit and Hard Times? What people always demand of a
popular novelist is that he shall write the same book over and over
again, forgetting that
a man who would write the same book twice
could not even write it once. Any writer who is not utterly lifeless
moves upon a kind of parabola, and the downward curve is implied in
the upper one.
Joyce has to start with the frigid competence of
Dubliners and end with the dream-language of Finnegan's Wake, but
Ulysses and Portrait of the Artist are part of the trajectory. The
thing that drove Dickens forward into a form of art for which he was
not really suited, and at the same time caused us to remember him,
was simply the fact that he was a moralist, the consciousness of
'having something to say'. He is always preaching a sermon, and that
is the final secret of his inventiveness. For you can only create if
you can care. Types like Squeers and Micawber could not have been
produced by a hack writer looking for something to be funny about.
A
joke worth laughing at always has an idea behind it, and usually a
subversive idea. Dickens is able to go on being funny because he is
in revolt against authority, and authority is always there to be
laughed at. There is always room for one more custard pie.


His radicalism is of the vaguest kind, and yet one always knows that
it is there. That is the difference between being a moralist and a
politician.
He has no constructive suggestions, not even a clear
grasp of the nature of the society he is attacking, only an
emotional perception that something is wrong, all he can finally
say is, 'Behave decently',
which, as I suggested earlier, is not
necessarily so shallow as it sounds.
Most revolutionaries are
potential Tories, because they imagine that everything can be
put right by altering the shape of society; once that change is
effected, as it sometimes is, they see no need for any other.
Dickens has not this kind of mental coarseness. The vagueness
of his discontent is the mark of its permanence. What he is out
against is not this or that institution, but, as Chesterton put it, 'an
expression on the human face.'
Roughly speaking, his morality is the
Christian morality, but in spite of his Anglican upbringing he was
essentially a Bible-Christian, as he took care to make plain when
writing his will. In any case he cannot properly be described as a
religious man. He 'believed', undoubtedly, but religion in the
devotional sense does not seem to have entered much into his
thoughts [Note, below]. Where he is Christian is in his quasi-
instinctive siding with the oppressed against the oppressors.
As a matter of course he is on the side of the underdog, always and
everywhere. To carry this to its logical conclusion
one has got to
change sides when the underdog becomes an upper-dog, and in fact
Dickens does tend to do so. He loathes the Catholic Church, for
instance, but as soon as the Catholics are persecuted (Barnaby
Rudge
) he is on their side. He loathes the aristocratic class even
more, but as soon as they are really overthrown (the revolutionary
chapters in A Tale of Two Cities) his sympathies swing round.

Whenever he departs from this emotional attitude he goes astray. A
well-known example is at the ending of David Copperfield, in which
everyone who reads it feels that something has gone wrong. What is
wrong is that the closing chapters are pervaded, faintly but not
noticeably, by the cult of success. It is the gospel according to
Smiles, instead of the gospel according to Dickens. The attractive,
out-at-elbow characters are got rid of, Micawber makes a fortune,
Heep gets into prison—both of these events are flagrantly
impossible—and even Dora is killed off to make way for Agnes.
If
you like, you can read Dora as Dickens's wife and Agnes as his
sister-in-law, but the essential point is that Dickens has 'turned
respectable' and done violence to his own nature. Perhaps that is
why Agnes is the most disagreeable of his heroines, the real legless
angel of Victorian romance, almost as bad as Thackeray's Laura.

[Note: From a letter to his youngest son (in 1868): 'You will
remember that you have never at home been harassed about religious
observances, or mere formalities. I have always been anxious not to
weary my children with such things, before they are old enough to
form opinions respecting them. You will therefore understand the
better that I now most solemnly impress upon you the truth and
beauty of the Christian Religion, as it came from Christ Himself,
and the impossibility of your going far wrong if you humbly but
heartily respect it..
.Never abandon the wholesome practice of saying
your own private prayers, night and morning. I have never abandoned
it myself, and I know the comfort of it.'
(Author's footnote)]

No grown-up person can read Dickens without feeling his limitations,
and yet there does remain his native generosity of mind, which acts
as a kind of anchor and nearly always keeps him where he belongs. It
is probably the central secret of his popularity.
A good-tempered
antinomianism rather of Dickens's type is one of the marks of
Western popular culture. One sees it in folk-stories and comic
songs, in dream-figures like Mickey Mouse and Pop-eye the Sailor
(both of them variants of Jack the Giant-killer), in the history of
working-class Socialism, in the popular protests (always ineffective
but not always a sham) against imperialism, in the impulse that
makes a jury award excessive damages when a rich man's car runs over
a poor man; it is the feeling that one is always on the wrong side
of the underdog, on the side of the weak against the strong. In one
sense it is a feeling that is fifty years out of date. The common
man is still living in the mental world of Dickens, but nearly every
modern intellectual has gone over to some or other form of
totalitarianism. From the Marxist or Fascist point of view, nearly
all that Dickens stands for can be written off as 'bourgeois
morality'. But in moral outlook no one could be more 'bourgeois'
than the English working classes. The ordinary people in the Western
countries have never entered, mentally, into the world of 'realism'
and power-politics.
They may do so before long, in which case
Dickens will be as out of date as the cab-horse. But in his own age
and ours he has been popular chiefly because he was able to express
in a comic, simplified and therefore memorable form the native
decency of the common man. And it is important that from this point
of view people of very different types can be described as 'common'.
In a country like England, in spite of its class-structure, there
does exist a certain cultural unity. All through the Christian ages,
and especially since the French Revolution, the Western world has
been haunted by the idea of freedom and equality; it is only an
idea, but it has penetrated to all ranks of society.
The most
atrocious injustices, cruelties, lies, snobberies exist everywhere,
but there are not many people who can regard these things with the
same indifference as, say, a Roman slave-owner. Even the millionaire
suffers from a vague sense of guilt, like a dog eating a stolen leg
of mutton. Nearly everyone, whatever his actual conduct may be,
responds emotionally to the idea of human brotherhood.
Dickens
voiced a code which was and on the whole still is believed in, even
by people who violate it. It is difficult otherwise to explain why
he could be both read by working people (a thing that has happened
to no other novelist of his stature) and buried in Westminster
Abbey.


When one reads any strongly individual piece of writing, one has the
impression of seeing a face somewhere behind the page.
It is not
necessarily the actual face of the writer. I feel this very strongly
with Swift, with Defoe, with Fielding, Stendhal, Thackeray,
Flaubert, though in several cases I do not know what these people
looked like and do not want to know. What one sees is the face that
the writer ought to have. Well, in the case of Dickens I see a face
that is not quite the face of Dickens's photographs, though it
resembles it. It is the face of a man of about forty, with a small
beard and a high colour.
He is laughing, with a touch of anger in
his laughter, but no triumph, no malignity. It is the face of a man
who is always fighting against something, but who fights in the open
and is not frightened, the face of a man who is generously angry—in
other words, of a nineteenth-century liberal, a free intelligence, a
type hated with equal hatred by all the smelly little orthodoxies
which are now contending for our souls.




CHARLES READE



Since Charles Reade's books are published in cheap editions one can
assume that he still has his following, but it is unusual to meet
anyone who has voluntarily read him. In most people his name seems
to evoke, at most, a vague memory of 'doing' The Cloister and the
Hearth
as a school holiday task. It is his bad luck to be remembered
by this particular book, rather as Mark Twain, thanks to the films,
is chiefly remembered by A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's
Court
. Reade wrote several dull books, and The Cloister and The
Hearth
is one of them. But he also wrote three novels which I
personally would back to outlive the entire works of Meredith and
George Eliot, besides some brilliant long-short stories such as A
Jack of all Trades
and The Autobiography of a Thief.


What is the attraction of Reade? At bottom it is the same charm
as one finds in R. Austin Freeman's detective stories or Lieu-
tenant-Commander Gould
's collections of curiosities—the charm
of useless knowledge.
Reade was a man of what one might call
penny-encyclopaedic learning. He possessed vast stocks of
disconnected information which a lively narrative gift allowed him
to cram into books which would at any rate pass as novels. If you
have the sort of mind that takes a pleasure in dates, lists,
catalogues, concrete details, descriptions of processes, junk-shop
windows and back numbers of the Exchange and Mart, the sort of mind
that likes knowing exactly how a medieval catapult worked or just
what objects a prison cell of the eighteen-forties contained,
then
you can hardly help enjoying Reade. He himself, of course, did not
see his work in quite this light. He prided himself on his accuracy
and
compiled his books largely from newspaper cuttings, but the
strange facts which he collected were subsidiary to what he would
have regarded as his 'purpose'. For
he was a social reformer in a
fragmentary way, and made vigorous attacks on such diverse evils as
blood-letting, the treadmill, private asylums, clerical celibacy and
tight-lacing.


My own favourite has always been Foul Play, which as it hap-
pens is not an attack on anything in particular. Like most
nineteenth-century novels Foul Play is too complicated to be
summarized, but its central story is that of a young clergyman,
Robert Penfold, who is unjustly convicted of forgery, is transported
to Australia, absconds in disguise, and is wrecked on a desert
island together with the heroine. Here, of course, Reade is in his
element.
Of all men who ever lived, he was the best fitted to write
a desert-island story. Some desert-island stories, of course, are
worse than others, but none is altogether bad when it sticks to the
actual concrete details of the struggle to keep alive. A list of the
objects in a shipwrecked man's possession is probably the surest
winner in fiction, surer even than a trial scene.
Nearly thirty
years after reading the book I can still remember more or less
exactly what things the three heroes of Ballantyne's Coral Island
possessed between them. (A telescope, six yards of whipcord, a
penknife, a brass ring and a piece of hoop iron.) Even a dismal book
like
Robinson Crusoe, so unreadable as a whole that few people even
know that the second part exists, becomes interesting when it
describes Crusoe's efforts to make a table, glaze earthenware and
grow a patch of wheat.
Reade, however, was an expert on desert
islands, or at any rate he was very well up in the geography
textbooks of the time. Moreover he was the kind of man who would
have been at home on a desert island himself. He would never, like
Crusoe, have been stumped by such an easy problem as that of
leavening bread and, unlike Ballantyne, he knew that civilized men
cannot make fire by rubbing sticks together.


The hero of Foul Play, like most of Reade's heroes, is a kind of
superman. He is hero, saint, scholar, gentleman, athlete, pugilist,
navigator, physiologist, botanist, blacksmith and carpenter
all
rolled into one, the sort of compendium of all the talents that
Reade honestly imagined to be the normal product of an English
university. Needless to say, it is only a month or two before this
wonderful clergyman has got the desert island running like a West
End hotel. Even before reaching the island, when the last survivors
of the wrecked ship are dying of thirst in an open boat, he has
shown his ingenuity by constructing a distilling apparatus with a
jar, a hot-water bottle and a piece of tubing.
But his best stroke
of all is the way in which he contrives to leave the island. He
himself, with a price on his head, would be glad enough to remain,
but the heroine, Helen Rollestone, who has no idea that he is a
convict, is naturally anxious to escape.
She asks Robert to turn his
'great mind' to this problem. The first difficulty, of course, is to
discover exactly where the island is. Luckily, however, Helen is
still wearing her watch, which is still keeping Sydney time.
By
fixing a stick in the ground and watching its shadow Robert notes
the exact moment of noon, after which it is a simple matter to work
out the longitude—for naturally a man of his calibre would know the
longitude of Sydney. It is equally natural that he can determine the
latitude within a degree or two by the nature of the vegetation.
But
the next difficulty is to send a message to the outside world. After
some thought
Robert writes a series of messages on pieces of
parchment made from seals' bladders, with ink obtained from
cochineal insects.
He has noticed that migrant birds often use the
island as a stopping-place, and he fixes on ducks as the likeliest
messengers, because every duck is liable to be shot sooner or later.
By a stratagem often used in India he captures a number of ducks,
ties a message to each of their legs and lets them go. Finally, of
course, one of the ducks takes refuge on a ship, and the couple are
rescued, but even then the story is barely half finished. There
follow enormous ramifications, plots and counterplots, intrigues,
triumphs and disasters, ending with the vindication of Robert, and
wedding bells.

In any of Reade's three best books, Foul Play, Hard Cash and It is
Never too Late to Mend
, it is not fair to say that the sole interest
is in the technical detail. His power of descriptive writing,
especially of describing violent action, is also very striking, and
on a serial-story level he is a wonderful contriver of plots. Simply

as a novelist it is impossible to take him seriously, because he has
no sense whatever of character or of probability
, but he himself had
the advantage of believing in even the absurdest details of his own
stories. He wrote of life as he saw it, and many Victorians saw it
in the same way: that is, as a series of tremendous melodramas,
with virtue triumphant every time. Of all the nineteenth-century
novelists who have remained readable, he is perhaps the only
one who is completely in tune with his own age.
For all his uncon-
ventionality, his 'purpose', his eagerness to expose abuses, he
never makes a fundamental criticism. Save for a few surface evils he
sees nothing wrong in an acquisitive society, with its equation of
money and virtue
, its pious millionaires and erastian clergymen.
Perhaps nothing gives one his measure better than the fact that in
introducing Robert Penfold, at the beginning of Foul Play, he
mentions that he is a scholar and a cricketer and only thirdly and
almost casually adds that he is a priest.

That is not to say that Reade's social conscience was not sound
so far as it went, and in several minor ways he probably helped to
educate public opinion. His attack on the prison system in It is
Never too Late to Mend
is relevant to this day, or was so till very
recently, and in his medical theories he is said to have been a long
way ahead of his time. What he lacked was any notion that the early
railway age, with the special scheme of values appropriate to it,
was not going to last for ever. This is a little surprising when one
remembers that he was the brother of Winwood Reade. However hastily
and unbalanced Winwood Reade's Martyrdom of Man may seem now, it is
a book that shows an astonishing width of vision, and it is probably
the unacknowledged grandparent of the 'outlines' so popular today.

Charles Reade might have written an 'outline' of phrenology,
cabinet-making or the habits of whales, but not of human history.
He
was simply a middle-class gentleman with a little more conscience
than most, a scholar who happened to prefer popular science to the
classics. Just for that reason he is one of the best 'escape'
novelists we have. Foul Play and Hard Cash would be good books to
send to a soldier enduring the miseries of trench warfare, for
instance. There are no problems in them, no genuine 'messages',
merely the fascination of a gifted mind functioning within very
narrow limits, and offering as complete a detachment from real life
as a game of chess or a jigsaw puzzle.



INSIDE THE WHALE


I


When Henry Miller's novel, Tropic of Cancer, appeared in 1935, it
was greeted with rather cautious praise, obviously conditioned in
some cases by a fear of seeming to enjoy pornography. Among the
people who praised it were T. S. Eliot, Herbert Read, Aldous Huxley,
John dos Passes, Ezra Pound—on the whole, not the writers who are in
fashion at this moment. And in fact the subject matter of the book,
and to a certain extent its mental atmosphere, belong to the
twenties rather than to the thirties.

Tropic of Cancer is a novel in the first person, or autobiography in
the form of a novel, whichever way you like to look at it. Miller
himself insists that it is straight autobiography, but the tempo and
method of telling the story are those of a novel. It
is a story of
the American Paris, but not along quite the usual lines, because the
Americans who figure in it happen to be people without money. During
the boom years, when dollars were plentiful and the exchange-value
of the franc was low, Paris was invaded by such a swarm of artists,
writers, students, dilettanti, sight-seers, debauchees, and plain
idlers as the world has probably never seen.
In some quarters of the
town the so-called artists must actually have outnumbered the
working population—indeed, it has been reckoned that in the late
twenties there were as many as 30,000 painters in Paris, most of
them impostors.
The populace had grown so hardened to artists that
gruff-voiced lesbians in corduroy breeches and young men in Grecian
or medieval costume could walk the streets without attracting a
glance
, and along the Seine banks at Notre Dame it was almost
impossible to pick one's way between the sketching-stools.
It was
the age of dark horses and neglected genii; the phrase on
everybody's lips was 'quand je serai lancé'. As it turned out,
nobody was 'lancé', the slump descended like another Ice Age, the
cosmopolitan mob of artists vanished, and the huge Montparnasse
cafés which only ten years ago were filled till the small hours by
hordes of shrieking poseurs have turned into darkened tombs in which
there are not even any ghosts.
It is this world—described in, among
other novels, Wyndham Lewis's Tarr—that Miller is writing about, but
he is dealing only with
the under side of it, the lumpen-proletarian
fringe which has been able to survive the slump because it is
composed partly of genuine artists and partly of genuine scoundrels.

The neglected genii, the paranoiacs who are always 'going to' write
the novel that will knock Proust into a cocked hat, are there, but
they are only genii in the rather rare moments when they are not
scouting about for the next meal. For the most part it is
a story of
bug-ridden rooms in working-men's hotels, of fights, drinking bouts,
cheap brothels, Russian refugees, cadging, swindling, and temporary
jobs. And the whole atmosphere of the poor quarters of Paris as a
foreigner sees them—the cobbled alleys, the sour reek of refuse, the
bistros with their greasy zinc counters and worn brick floors, the
green waters of the Seine, the blue cloaks of the Republican Guard,
the crumbling iron urinals, the peculiar sweetish smell of the Metro
stations, the cigarettes that come to pieces, the pigeons in the
Luxembourg Gardens
—it is all there, or at any rate the feeling of it
is there.

On the face of it no material could be less promising. When Tropic
of Cancer
was published the Italians were marching into Abyssinia
and Hitler's concentration camps were already bulging. The
intellectual foci of the world were Rome, Moscow, and Berlin. It did
not seem to be a moment at which a novel of outstanding value was
likely to be written about American dead-beats cadging drinks in the
Latin Quarter. Of course a novelist is not obliged to write directly
about contemporary history, but a novelist who simply disregards the
major public events of the moment is generally either a footler or a
plain idiot. From a mere account of the subject matter of Tropic of
Cancer
most people would probably assume it to be no more than a bit
of naughty-naughty left over from the twenties. Actually, nearly
everyone who read it saw at once that it was nothing of the kind,
but a very remarkable book. How or why remarkable? That question is
never easy to answer. It is better to begin by describing the
impression that Tropic of Cancer has left on my own mind.


When I first opened Tropic of Cancer and saw that it was full of
unprintable words, my immediate reaction was a refusal to be
impressed. Most people's would be the same, I believe. Neverthe-
less, after a lapse of time the atmosphere of the book, besides
innumerable details, seemed to linger in my memory in a peculiar
way.
A year later Miller's second book, Black Spring, was published.
By this time? Tropic of Cancer was much more vividly present in my
mind than it had been when I first read it. My first feeling about
Black Spring was that it showed a falling-off, and it is a fact that
it has not the same unity as the other book. Yet after another year
there were many passages in Black Spring that had also rooted
themselves in my memory. Evidently these books are of the sort to
leave a flavour behind them—books that 'create a world of their
own', as the saying goes. The books that do this are not necessarily
good books, they may be good bad books like Raffles or the Sherlock
Holmes stories, or perverse and morbid books like Wuthering Heights
or The House with the Green Shutters.
But now and again there
appears a novel which opens up a new world not by revealing what
is strange, but by revealing what is familiar. The truly remarkable
thing about Ulysses, for instance, is the commonplaceness of its
material. Of course there is much more in Ulysses than this, because
Joyce is a kind of poet and also an elephantine pedant, but his real
achievement has been to get the familiar on to paper. He dared—for
it is a matter of daring just as much as of technique—to expose the
imbecilities of the inner mind, and in doing so he discovered an
America which was under everybody's nose. Here is a whole world of
stuff which you supposed to be of its nature incommunicable, and
somebody has managed to communicate it. The effect is to break down,
at any rate momentarily, the solitude in which the human being
lives. When you read certain passages in Ulysses you feel that
Joyce's mind and your mind are one, that he knows all about you
though he has never heard your name, that there is some world outside
time and space in which you and he are together.
And though he does
not resemble Joyce in other ways, there is a touch of this quality
in Henry Miller.
Not everywhere, because his work is very uneven,
and sometimes, especially in Black Spring, tends to slide away into
mere verbiage or into the squashy universe of the surrealists. But
read him for five pages, ten pages, and you feel the peculiar relief
that comes not so much from understanding as from being understood.
'He knows all about me,' you feel; 'he wrote this specially for me'.

It is as though you could hear a voice speaking to you, a friendly
American voice, with no humbug in it, no moral purpose, merely an
implicit assumption that we are all alike. For the moment you have
got away from the lies and simplifications, the stylized, marionette-
like quality of ordinary fiction, even quite good fiction, and are deal-
ing with the recognizable experiences of human beings.


But what kind of experience? What kind of human beings? Miller is
writing about the man in the street, and it is incidentally rather a
pity that it should be a street full of brothers. That is the
penalty of leaving your native land. It means transferring your
roots into shallower soil. Exile is probably more damaging to a
novelist than to a painter or even a poet, because its effect is to
take him out of contact with working life and narrow down his range
to the street, the café, the church, the brothel and the studio. On
the whole, in Miller's books you are reading about people living the
expatriate life, people drinking, talking, meditating, and
fornicating,
not about people working, marrying, and bringing up
children; a pity, because he would have described the one set of
activities as well as the other. In Black Spring there is a
wonderful flashback of New York, the swarming Irish-infested New
York of the O. Henry period, but the Paris scenes are the best, and,
granted their utter worthlessness as social types, the drunks and
dead-beats of the cafés are handled with a feeling for character and
a mastery of technique that are unapproached in any at all recent
novel. All of them are not only credible but completely familiar;
you have the feeling that all their adventures have happened to
yourself.
Not that they are anything very startling in the way of
adventures.
Henry gets a job with a melancholy Indian student, gets
another job at a dreadful French school during a cold snap when the
lavatories are frozen solid
, goes on drinking bouts in Le Havre with
his friend Collins, the sea captain, goes to the brothels where
there are wonderful Negresses, talks with his friend Van Norden, the
novelist, who has got the great novel of the world in his head but
can never bring himself to begin writing it. His friend
Karl, on the
verge of starvation, is picked up by a wealthy widow who wishes to
marry him. There are interminable Hamlet-like conversations in which
Karl tries to decide which is worse, being hungry or sleeping with
an old woman. In great detail he describes his visits to the widow,
how he went to the hotel dressed in his best, how before going in he
neglected to urinate, so that the whole evening was one long
crescendo of torment etc., etc.
And after all, none of it is true,
the widow doesn't even exist—Karl has simply invented her in order
to make himself seem important.
The whole book is in this vein,
more or less. Why is it that these monstrous trivialities are so
engrossing? Simply because the whole atmosphere is deeply familiar,
because you have all the while the feeling that these things are
happening to you. And you have this feeling because
somebody has
chosen to drop the Geneva language of the ordinary novel and drag
the real-politik of the inner mind into the open. In Miller's case
it is not so much a question of exploring the mechanisms of the mind
as of owning up to everyday facts and everyday emotions.
For the
truth is that many ordinary people, perhaps an actual majority, do
speak and behave in just the way that is recorded here. The
callous
coarseness
with which the characters in Tropic of Cancer talk is
very rare in fiction, but it is extremely common in real life; again
and again I have heard just such conversations from people who were
not even aware that they were talking coarsely. It is worth noticing
that Tropic Of Cancer is not a young man's book.
Miller was in his
forties when it was published, and though since then he
has produced
three or four others, it is obvious that this first book had been
lived with for years. It is one of those books that are slowly
matured in poverty and obscurity, by people who know what they have
got to do and therefore are able to wait. The prose is astonishing,
and in parts of Black Spring is even better. Unfortunately I cannot
quote; unprintable words occur almost everywhere. But get hold of
Tropic of Cancer, get hold of Black Spring and read especially the
first hundred pages. They give you an idea of
what can still be
done, even at this late date, with English prose. In them, English
is treated as a spoken language, but spoken without fear, i.e.
without fear of rhetoric or of the unusual or poetical word. The
adjective has come back, after its ten years' exile. It is a
flowing, swelling prose, a prose with rhythms in it, something quite
different from the flat cautious statements and snack-bar dialects
that are now in fashion.


When a book like Tropic of Cancer appears, it is only natural that
the first thing people notice should be its obscenity. Given our
current notions of literary decency, it is not at all easy to
approach an unprintable book with detachment. Either one is shocked
and disgusted, or one is morbidly thrilled, or one is determined
above all else not to be impressed. The last is probably the
commonest reaction, with the result that unprintable books often get
less attention than they deserve. It is rather the fashion to say
that nothing is easier than to write an obscene book, that people
only do it in order to get themselves talked about and make money,
etc., etc. What makes it obvious that this is not the case is that
books which are obscene in the police-court sense are distinctly
uncommon. If there were easy money to be made out of dirty words, a
lot more people would be making it.
But, because 'obscene' books do
not appear very frequently, there is a tendency to lump them
together, as a rule quite unjustifiably. Tropic of Cancer has been
vaguely associated with two other books, Ulysses and Voyage au bout
de la nuit
, but in neither case is there much resemblance. What
Miller has in common with Joyce is
a willingness to mention the
inane, squalid facts of everyday life
. Putting aside differences of
technique, the funeral scene in Ulysses, for instance, would fit
into Tropic of Cancer; the whole chapter is a sort of confession, an
exposé of the frightful inner callousness of the human being. But
there the resemblance ends. As a novel, Tropic of Cancer is far
inferior to Ulysses.
Joyce is an artist, in a sense in which Miller
is not and probably would not wish to be, and in any case he is
attempting much more. He
is exploring different states of
consciousness, dream, reverie (the 'bronze-by-gold' chapter),
drunkenness, etc., and dovetailing them all into a huge complex
pattern
, almost like a Victorian 'plot'. Miller is simply a
hard-boiled person talking about life, an ordinary American
businessman with intellectual courage and a gift for words.
It is
perhaps significant that he looks exactly like everyone's idea of an
American businessman. As for the comparison with Voyage au bout de
la nuit
, it is even further from the point. Both books, use
unprintable words, both are in some sense autobiographical, but that
is all.
Voyage au bout de la nuit is a book-with-a-purpose, and its
purpose is to protest against the horror and meaninglessness of
modern life—actually, indeed, of life. It is a cry of unbearable
disgust, a voice from the cesspool.
Tropic of Cancer is almost
exactly the opposite. The thing has become so unusual as to seem
almost anomalous, but it is the book of a man who is happy. So is
Black Spring, though slightly less so, because tinged in places with
nostalgia.
With years of lumpenproletarian life behind him, hunger,
vagabondage, dirt, failure, nights in the open, battles with
immigration officers, endless struggles for a bit of cash, Miller
finds that he is enjoying himself. Exactly the aspects of life that
fill Céline with horror are the ones that appeal to him.
So far from
protesting, he is accepting. And the very word 'acceptance' calls up
his real affinity, another American, Walt Whitman.


But there is something rather curious in being Whitman in the
nineteen-thirties. It is not certain that if Whitman himself were
alive at the moment he would write anything in the least degree
resembling Leaves of Grass. For what he is saying, after all, is 'I
accept', and there is a radical difference between acceptance now
and acceptance then. Whitman was writing in a time of unexampled
prosperity, but more than that, he was writing in a country where
freedom was something more than a word. The democracy, equality,
and comradeship that he is always talking about are not remote
ideals, but something that existed in front of his eyes. In mid-
nineteenth-century America men felt themselves free and equal,
were free and equal, so far as that is possible outside a society of
pure communism. There was poverty and there were even class
distinctions, but except for the Negroes there was no permanently
submerged class. Everyone had inside him, like a kind of core, the
knowledge that he could earn a decent living, and earn it without
bootlicking.
When you read about Mark Twain's Mississippi raftsmen
and pilots, or Bret Harte's Western gold-miners, they seem more
remote than the cannibals of the Stone Age. The reason is simply
that they are free human beings. But it is the same even with the
peaceful domesticated America of the Eastern states, the America of
the Little Women, Helen's Babies, and Riding Down from Bangor.
Life
has a buoyant, carefree quality that you can feel as you read, like
a physical sensation in your belly.
It is this that Whitman is
celebrating, though actually he does it very badly, because he is
one of those writers who tell you what you ought to feel instead of
making you feel it. Luckily for his beliefs, perhaps, he died too
early to see the deterioration in American life that came with the
rise of large-scale industry and the exploiting of cheap immigrant
labour.


Miller's outlook is deeply akin to that of Whitman, and nearly
everyone who has read him has remarked on this. Tropic of Cancer
ends with an especially Whitmanesque passage, in which,
after the
lecheries, the swindles, the fights, the drinking bouts, and the
imbecilities, he simply sits down and watches the Seine flowing
past, in a sort of mystical acceptance of thing-as-it-is. Only, what
is he accepting? In the first place, not America, but the ancient
bone-heap of Europe, where every grain of soil has passed through
innumerable human bodies. Secondly, not an epoch of expansion and
liberty, but an epoch of fear, tyranny, and regimentation. To say 'I
accept' in an age like our own is to say that you accept
concentration camps, rubber truncheons, Hitler, Stalin, bombs,
aeroplanes, tinned food, machine guns, putsches, purges, slogans,
Bedaux belts, gas masks, submarines, spies, provocateurs, press
censorship, secret prisons, aspirins, Hollywood films, and political
murders.
Not only those things, of course, but those things among
others. And on the whole this is Henry Miller's attitude. Not quite
always, because at moments he shows signs of a fairly ordinary kind
of literary nostalgia. There is a long passage in the earlier part
of Black Spring, in praise of the Middle Ages, which as prose must
be one of the most remarkable pieces of writing in recent years, but
which displays an attitude not very different from that of
Chesterton. In Max and the White Phagocytes
there is an attack on
modern American civilization (breakfast cereals, cellophane, etc.)
from the usual angle of the literary man who hates industrialism.
But in general the attitude is 'Let's swallow it whole'. And hence
the seeming preoccupation with indecency and with the
dirty-handkerchief side of life. It is only seeming, for the truth
is that ordinary everyday life consists far more largely of horrors
than writers of fiction usually care to admit.
Whitman himself
'accepted' a great deal that his contemporaries found unmentionable.
For he is not only writing of the prairie, he also wanders through
the city and
notes the shattered skull of the suicide, the 'grey
sick faces of onanists'
, etc, etc. But unquestionably our own age,
at any rate in Western Europe, is less healthy and less hopeful than
the age in which Whitman was writing. Unlike Whitman, we live in a
shrinking world. The 'democratic vistas' have ended in barbed wire.
There is less feeling of creation and growth, less and less emphasis
on the cradle, endlessly rocking, more and more emphasis on the
teapot, endlessly stewing. To accept civilization as it is
practically means accepting decay. It has ceased to be a strenuous
attitude and become a passive attitude—even 'decadent'
, if that word
means anything.


But precisely because, in one sense, he is passive to experience,
Miller is able to get nearer to the ordinary man than is possible to
more purposive writers. For the ordinary man is also passive. Within
a narrow circle (home life, and perhaps the trade union or local
politics) he feels himself master of his fate, but against major
events he is as helpless as against the elements. So far from
endeavouring to influence the future, he simply lies down and lets
things happen to him. During the past ten years literature has
involved itself more and more deeply in politics, with the result
that there is now less room in it for the ordinary man than at any
time during the past two centuries. One can see the change in the
prevailing literary attitude by comparing the books written about
the Spanish civil war with those written about the war of 1914-18.
The immediately striking thing about the Spanish war books, at any
rate those written in English, is their shocking dullness and
badness. But what is more significant is that almost all of them,
right-wing or left-wing, are written from a political angle, by
cocksure partisans telling you what to think, whereas the books
about the Great War were written by common soldiers or junior
officers who did not even pretend to understand what the whole thing
was about. Books like All Quiet on the Western Front, Le Feu, A
Farewell to Arms
, Death of a Hero, Good-bye to all That, Memoirs of
an Infantry Officer
, and A Subaltern on the Somme were written not
by propagandists but by victims. They are saying, in effect, 'What
the hell is all this about? God knows. All we can do is to endure.'
And though he is not writing about war, nor, on the whole, about
unhappiness, this is nearer to Miller's attitude than the
omniscience which is now fashionable. The Booster, a short-lived
periodical of which he was part-editor, used to describe itself in
its advertisements as
'non-political, non-educational,
non-progressive, non-co-operative, non-ethical, non-literary,
non-consistent, non-contemporary,'
and Miller's own work could be
described in nearly the same terms. It is a
voice from the crowd,
from the underling, from the third-class carriage,
from the
ordinary, non-political, non-moral, passive man.


I have been using the phrase 'ordinary man' rather loosely, and I
have taken it for granted that the 'ordinary man' exists, a thing
now denied by some people. I do not mean that the people Miller is
writing about constitute a majority, still less that he is writing
about proletarians. No English or American novelist has as yet
seriously attempted that. And again, the people in Tropic of Cancer
fall short of being ordinary to the extent that they are
idle,
disreputable, and more or less 'artistic.'
As I have said already,
this a pity, but it is the necessary result of expatriation.
Miller's 'ordinary man' is neither the manual worker nor the
suburban householder, but
the derelict, the déclassé, the
adventurer, the American intellectual without roots and without
money.
Still, the experiences even of this type overlap fairly
widely with those of more normal people. Miller has been able to get
the most out of his rather limited material because he has had the
courage to identify with it. The ordinary man,
the 'average sensual
man,' has been given the power of speech, like Balaam's ass.


It will be seen that this is something out of date, or at any rate
out of fashion. The average sensual man is out of fashion.
Preoccupation with sex and truthfulness about the inner life are out
of fashion. American Paris is out of fashion. A book like Tropic of
Cancer, published at such a time, must be either a tedious
preciosity or something unusual, and I think a majority of the
people who have read it would agree that it is not the first. It is
worth trying to discover just what this escape from the current
literary fashion means. But to do that one has got to see it against
its background—that is, against the general development of English
literature in the twenty years since the Great War.



II


When one says that a writer is fashionable one practically always
means that he is admired by people under thirty. At the beginning of
the period I am speaking of, the years during and immediately after
the war, the writer who had the deepest hold upon the thinking young
was almost certainly Housman. Among people who were adolescent in
the years 1910-25, Housman had an influence which was enormous and
is now not at all easy to understand. In 1920, when I was about
seventeen, I probably knew the whole of the Shropshire Lad by heart.
I wonder how much impression the Shropshire Lad makes at this moment
on a boy of the same age and more or less the same cast of mind? No
doubt he has heard of it and even glanced into it; it might strike
him as cheaply clever—probably that would be about all. Yet these
are the poems that I and my contemporaries used to recite to
ourselves, over and over, in a kind of ecstasy, just as earlier
generations had recited Meredith's 'Love in a Valley,' Swinburne's
'Garden of Proserpine' etc., etc.


With rue my heart is laden
For golden friends I had,
For many a roselipt maiden
And many a lightfoot lad.

By brooks too broad for leaping
The lightfoot boys are laid;
The roselipt girls are sleeping
In fields where roses fade.

It just tinkles. But it did not seem to tinkle in 1920. Why does the
bubble always burst?
To answer that question one has to take account
of the external conditions that make certain writers popular at
certain times. Housman's poems had not attracted much notice when
they were first published. What was there in them that appealed so
deeply to a single generation, the generation born round about 1900?

In the first place, Housman is a 'country' poet. His poems are full
of the charm of buried villages, the nostalgia of place-names,
Clunton and Clunbury, Knighton, Ludlow, 'on Wenlock Edge', 'in
summer time on Bredon,' thatched roofs and the jingle of smithies,
the wild jonquils in the pastures, the 'blue, remembered hills.' War
poems apart, English verse of the 1910-25 period is mostly
'country.' The reason no doubt was that
the rentier-professional
class was ceasing once and for all to have any real relationship
with the soil;
but at any rate there prevailed then, far more than
now, a kind of snobbism of belonging to the country and despising
the town. England at that time was hardly more an agricultural
country than it is now, but before the light industries began to
spread themselves it was easier to think of it as one. Most
middle-class boys grew up within sight of a farm, and naturally it
was the picturesque side of farm life that appealed to them—the
ploughing, harvesting, stack-thrashing and so forth. Unless he has
to do it himself a boy is not likely to notice
the horrible drudgery
of hoeing turnip, milking cows with chapped teats at four o'clock in
the morning,
etc., etc. Just before, just after, and for that
matter, during the war was the great age of the 'Nature poet,' the
heyday of Richard Jefferies and W. H. Hudson. Rupert Brooke's
'Grantchester,' the star poem of 1913, is
nothing but an enormous
gush of 'country' sentiment, a sort of accumulated vomit from a
stomach stuffed with place-names
. Considered as a poem
'Grantchester' is something worse than worthless, but as an
illustration of what the thinking middle-class young of that period
felt it is a valuable document.

Housman, however, did not enthuse over the rambler roses in the
week-ending spirit of Brooke and the others. The 'country' motif is
there all the time, but mainly as a background. Most of the poems
have a quasi-human subject, a kind of idealized rustic, in reality
Strephon or Corydon brought up to date. This in itself had a deep
appeal. Experience shows that
overcivilized people enjoy reading
about rustics (key-phrase, 'close to the soil') because they imagine
them to be more primitive and passionate than themselves.
Hence the
'dark earth' novel of Sheila Kaye-Smith, etc. And at that time a
middle-class boy, with his 'country' bias, would identify with an
agricultural worker as he would never have done with a town worker.
Most boys had in their minds a vision of an
idealized ploughman,
gipsy, poacher, or gamekeeper, always pictured as a wild, free,
roving blade, living a life of rabbit-snaring, cockfighting, horses,
beer, and women.
Masefield's 'Everlasting Mercy,' another valuable
period-piece, immensely popular with boys round about the war years,
gives you this vision in a very crude form. But Housman's Maurices
and Terences could be taken seriously where Masefield's Saul Kane
could not; on this side of him, Housman was Masefield with a dash of
Theocritus. Moreover all his themes are adolescent—
murder, suicide,
unhappy love, early death. They deal with the simple, intelligible
disasters that give you the feeling of being up against the 'bedrock
facts' of life:


The sun burns on the half-mown hill,
By now the blood has dried;
And Maurice among the hay lies still
And my knife is in his side.


And again:

They hand us now in Shrewsbury jail
And whistles blow forlorn,
And trains all night groan on the rail
To men who die at morn.


It is all more or less in the same tune. Everything comes unstuck.
'Ned lies long in the churchyard and Tom lies long in jail'. And
notice also the exquisite self-pity—the 'nobody loves me' feeling:


The diamond drops adorning
The low mound on the lea,
These are the tears of morning,
That weeps, but not for thee
.


Hard cheese, old chap! Such poems might have been written expressly
for adolescents. And the unvarying sexual pessimism (the girl always
dies or marries somebody else) seemed like wisdom to boys who were
herded together in public schools and were half-inclined to think of
women as something unattainable. Whether Housman ever had the same
appeal for girls I doubt. In his poems the woman's point of view is
not considered,
she is merely the nymph, the siren, the treacherous
half-human creature who leads you a little distance and then gives
you the slip.


But Housman would not have appealed so deeply to the people who were
young in 1920 if it had not been for another strain in him, and that
was
his blasphemous, antinomian, 'cynical' strain. The fight that
always occurs between the generations was exceptionally bitter at
the end of the Great War; this was partly due to the war itself, and
partly it was an indirect result of the Russian Revolution, but an
intellectual struggle was in any case due at about that date. Owing
probably to the ease and security of life in England, which even the
war hardly disturbed, many people whose ideas were formed in the
eighties or earlier had carried them quite unmodified into the
nineteen-twenties. Meanwhile,
so far as the younger generation was
concerned, the official beliefs were dissolving like sand-castles.
The slump in religious belief, for instance, was spectacular. For
several years the old-young antagonism took on a quality of real
hatred. What was left of the war generation had crept out of the
massacre to find their elders still bellowing the slogans of 1914,
and a slightly younger generation of boys were writhing under
dirty-minded celibate schoolmasters. It was to these that Housman
appealed, with his implied sexual revolt and his personal grievance
against God.
He was patriotic, it was true, but in a harmless
old-fashioned way, to the tune of red coats and 'God save the Queen'
rather than steel helmets and 'Hang the Kaiser'. And he was
satisfyingly anti-Christian—he stood for a kind of bitter, defiant
paganism, the conviction that life is short and the gods are against
you, which exactly fitted the prevailing mood of the young; and all
in charming fragile verse that was composed almost entirely of words
of one syllable.


It will be seen that I have discussed Housman as though he were
merely a propagandist, an utterer of maxims and quotable 'bits'.
Obviously he was more than that.
There is no need to under-rate him
now because he was over-rated a few years ago. Although one gets
into trouble nowadays for saying so,
there are a number of his poems
('Into my heart an air that kills', for instance, and 'Is my team
ploughing?') that are not likely to remain long out of favour. But
at bottom it is always a writer's tendency, his 'purpose', his
'message', that makes him liked or disliked. The proof of this is
the
extreme difficulty of seeing any literary merit in a book that
seriously damages your deepest beliefs.
And no book is ever truly
neutral. Some or other tendency is always discernible, in verse as
much as in prose, even if it does no more than determine the form
and the choice of imagery. But poets who attain wide popularity,
like Housman, are as a rule definitely gnomic writers.


After the war, after Housman and the Nature poets, there appears a
group of writers of completely different tendency—
Joyce, Eliot,
Pound, Lawrence, Wyndham, Lewis, Aldous Huxley, Lytton Strachey
. So
far as the middle and late twenties go, these are 'the movement', as
surely as the Auden-Spender group have been 'the movement' during
the past few years. It is true that not all of the gifted writers of
the period can be fitted into the pattern.
E. M. Forster, for
instance, though he wrote his best book in 1923 or thereabouts, was
essentially, pre-war, and
Yeats does not seem in either of his
phases to belong to the twenties. Others who were still living,
Moore, Conrad, Bennett, Wells, Norman Douglas, had shot their bolt
before the war ever happened. On the other hand, a writer who should
be added to the group, though in the narrowly literary sense he
hardly 'belongs', is
Somerset Maugham. Of course the dates do not
fit exactly; most of these writers had already published books
before the war, but they can be classified as post-war in the same
sense that the younger men now writing are post-slump. Equally, of
course, you could read through most of the literary papers of the
time without grasping that these people are 'the movement'. Even
more then than at most times the big shots of literary journalism
were busy pretending that the age-before-last had not come to an
end. Squire ruled the London Mercury Gibbs and Walpole were the
gods of the lending libraries, there was
a cult of cheeriness and
manliness, beer and cricket, briar pipes and monogamy
, and it was at
all times possible to earn a few guineas by writing an article
denouncing 'high-brows'. But all the same it was the despised
highbrows who had captured the young.
The wind was blowing from
Europe, and long before 1930 it had blown the beer-and-cricket
school naked, except for their knighthoods.


But the first thing one would notice about the group of writers I
have named above is that they do not look like a group. Moreover
several of them would strongly object to being coupled with several
of the others. Lawrence and Eliot were in reality antipathetic,
Huxley worshipped Lawrence but was repelled by Joyce, most of the
others would have looked down on Huxley, Strachey, and Maugham, and
Lewis attacked everyone in turn; indeed, his reputation as a writer
rests largely on these attacks. And yet there is a certain
temperamental similarity, evident enough now, though it would not
have been so a dozen years ago. What it amounts to is pessimism of
outlook. But it is necessary to make clear what is meant by
pessimism.


If the keynote of the Georgian poets was 'beauty of Nature', the
keynote of the post-war writers would be 'tragic sense of life'
. The
spirit behind Housman's poems for instance, is not tragic, merely
querulous; it is hedonism disappointed. The same is true of Hardy,
though one ought to make an exception of The Dynasts. But the
Joyce-Eliot group come later in time, puritanism is not their main
adversary, they are able from the start to 'see through' most of the
things that their predecessors had fought for. All of them are
temperamentally hostile to the notion of 'progress'; it is felt that
progress not only doesn't happen, but ought not to happen
. Given
this general similarity, there are, of course, differences of
approach between the writers I have named as well as different
degrees of talent. Eliot's pessimism is partly the Christian
pessimism, which
implies a certain indifference to human misery,
partly a lament over the decadence of Western civilization
('We are
the hollow men, we are the stuffed men
', etc., etc.), a sort of
twilight-of-the-gods feeling, which finally leads him, in Sweeney
Agonistes
for instance, to achieve the difficult feat of making
modern life out to be worse than it is. With Strachey it is merely a
polite eighteenth-century scepticism mixed up with a taste for
debunking. With Maugham it is a kind of stoical resignation, the
stiff upper lip of the pukka sahib somewhere east of Suez, carrying
on with his job without believing in it, like an Antonine Emperor.
Lawrence at first sight does not seem to be a pessimistic writer,
because, like Dickens, he is a 'change-of-heart' man and constantly
insisting that life here and now would be all right if only you
looked at it a little differently. But what he is demanding is a
movement away from our mechanized civilization, which is not going
to happen. Therefore his exasperation with the present turns once
more into idealization of the past, this time a safely mythical
past, the Bronze Age. When Lawrence prefers the Etruscans (his
Etruscans) to ourselves it is difficult not to agree with him, and
yet, after all, it is a species of defeatism, because that is not
the direction in which the world is moving. The kind of life that
he is always pointing to, a life centring round the simple
mysteries—sex, earth, fire, water, blood—is merely a lost cause.
All
he has been able to produce, therefore, is a wish that things would
happen in a way in which they are manifestly not going to happen.
'A
wave of generosity or a wave of death', he says, but it is obvious
that there are no waves of generosity this side of the horizon. So
he flees to Mexico, and then dies at forty-five, a few years before
the wave of death gets going.
It will be seen that once again I am
speaking of these people as though they were not artists, as though
they were merely propagandists putting a 'message' across. And once
again it is obvious that all of them are more than that. It would be
absurd, for instance, to look on Ulysses as merely a show-up of
the
horror of modern life, the 'dirty Daily Mail era'
, as Pound put it.
Joyce actually is more of a 'pure artist' than most writers. But
Ulysses could not have been written by someone who was merely
dabbling with word-patterns; it is the product of a special vision
of life,
the vision of a Catholic who has lost his faith. What Joyce
is saying is 'Here is life without God. Just look at it!'
and his
technical innovations, important though they are, are primarily to
serve this purpose.


But what is noticeable about all these writers is that what
'purpose' they have is very much up in the air. There is no
attention to the urgent problems of the moment, above all no
politics in the narrower sense.
Our eyes are directed to Rome, to
Byzantium, to Montparnasse, to Mexico, to the Etruscans, to the
Subconscious, to the solar plexus
—to everywhere except the places
where things are actually happening. When one looks back at the
twenties,
nothing is queerer than the way in which every important
event in Europe escaped the notice of the English intelligentsia.

The Russian Revolution, for instance, all but vanishes from the
English consciousness between the death of Lenin and the Ukraine
famine—about ten years. Throughout those years
Russia means
Tolstoy, Dostoievsky, and exiled counts driving taxi-cabs. Italy
means picture-galleries, ruins, churches, and museums—but not
Black-shirts. Germany means films, nudism, and psychoanalysis—but
not Hitler
, of whom hardly anyone had heard till 1931. In 'cultured'
circles art-for-art's-saking extended practically to a worship of
the meaningless. Literature was supposed to consist solely in the
manipulation of words. To judge a book by its subject matter was the
unforgivable sin, and even to be aware of its subject matter was
looked on as a lapse of a taste. About 1928, in one of the three
genuinely funny jokes that Punch has produced since the Great War,
an intolerable youth is pictured informing his aunt that he intends
to 'write'. 'And what are you going to write about, dear?' asks the
aunt. 'My dear aunt,' says the youth crushingly, 'one doesn't write
about anything, one just writes.'
The best writers of the twenties
did not subscribe to this doctrine, their 'purpose' is in most
cases fairly overt, but it is usually 'purpose' along moral-
religious-cultural lines. Also, when translatable into political
terms,
it is in no case 'left'. In one way or another the
tendency of all the writers in this group is conservative. Lewis,
for instance, spent years in frenzied witch-smellings after
'Bolshevism', which he was able to detect in very unlikely places.

Recently he has changed some of his views, perhaps influenced by
Hitler's treatment of artists, but it is safe to bet that he will
not go very far leftward. Pound seems to have plumped definitely for
Fascism, at any rate the Italian variety. Eliot has remained aloof,
but if forced at the pistol's point to choose between Fascism and
some more democratic form of socialism, would probably choose
Fascism.
Huxley starts off with the usual despair-of-life, then,
under the influence of Lawrence's 'dark abdomen', tries something
called Life-Worship, and finally arrives at pacifism—a tenable
position, and at this moment an honourable one, but probably in the
long run involving rejection of socialism.
It is also noticeable
that most of the writers in this group have a certain tenderness for
the Catholic Church, though not usually of a kind that an orthodox
Catholic would accept.



The mental connexion between pessimism and a reactionary outlook is
no doubt obvious enough. What is perhaps less obvious is just why
the leading writers of the twenties were predominantly pessimistic.

Why always the sense of decadence, the skulls and cactuses, the
yearning after lost faith and impossible civilizations? Was it not,
after all, because these people were writing in an exceptionally
comfortable epoch? It is just in such times that 'cosmic despair'
can flourish. People with empty bellies never despair of the
universe, nor even think about the universe, for that matter.
The
whole period 1910-30 was a prosperous one, and even the war years
were physically tolerable if one happened to be a non-combatant in
one of the Allied countries.
As for the twenties, they were the
golden age of the rentier-intellectual, a period of irresponsibility
such as the world had never before seen. The war was over, the new
totalitarian states had not arisen, moral and religious taboos of
all descriptions had vanished, and the cash was rolling in.
'Disillusionment' was all the fashion. Everyone with a safe £500 a
year turned highbrow and began training himself in taedium vitae. It
was an age of eagles and of crumpets, facile despairs, backyard
Hamlets, cheap return tickets to the end of the night. In some of
the minor characteristic novels of the period, books like Told by an
Idiot, the despair-of-life reaches a Turkish-bath atmosphere of
self-pity. And even the best writers of the time can be convicted of
a too Olympian attitude, a too great readiness to wash their hands
of the immediate practical problem. They see life very compre-
hensively, much more so than those who come immediately before
or after them, but they see it through the wrong end of the
telescope.
Not that that invalidates their books, as books. The
first test of any work of art is survival, and it is a fact that a
great deal that was written in the period 1910-30 has survived and
looks like continuing to survive. One has only to think of Ulysses,
Of Human Bondage, most of Lawrence's early work, especially his
short stories, and virtually the whole of Eliot's poems up to about
1930, to wonder what is now being written that will wear so well.

But quite Suddenly, in the years 1930-5, something happens. The
literary climate changes. A new group of writers, Auden and Spender
and the rest of them, has made its appearance, and although
technically these writers owe something to their predecessors, their
'tendency' is entirely different.
Suddenly we have got out of the
twilight of the gods into a sort of Boy Scout atmosphere of bare
knees and community singing. The typical literary man ceases to be a
cultured expatriate with a leaning towards the Church, and becomes
an eager-minded schoolboy with a leaning towards Communism. If the
keynote of the writers of the twenties is 'tragic sense of life',
the keynote of the new writers is 'serious purpose'.


The differences between the two schools are discussed at some length
in Mr Louis MacNeice's book Modern Poetry. This book is, of course,
written entirely from the angle of the younger group and takes the
superiority of their standards for granted. According to Mr MacNeice:

The poets of New Signatures*, unlike Yeats and Eliot, are
emotionally partisan. Yeats proposed to turn his back on desire and
hatred; Eliot sat back and watched other people's emotions with
ennui and an ironical self-pity...
The whole poetry, on the other
hand, of Auden, Spender, and Day Lewis implies that
they have
desires and hatreds of their own and, further, that they think some
things ought to be desired and others hated.


[* Note: Published in 1932.(Author's footnote)]

And again:

The poets of New Signatures have swung back...to the Greek
preference for information or statement. Their first requirement is
to have something to say, and after that you must say it as well as
you can.


In other words, 'purpose' has come back, the younger writers have
'gone into politics'.
As I have pointed out already, Eliot & Co. are
not really so non-partisan as Mr MacNeice seems to suggest. Still,
it is broadly true that in the twenties the literary emphasis was
more on technique and less on subject matter than it is now.

The leading figures in this group are Auden, Spender, Day Lewis,
MacNeice, and there is a long string of writers of more or less the
same tendency, Isherwood, John Lehmann, Arthur Calder-Marshall,
Edward Upward, Alee Brown, Philip Henderson, and many others. As
before, I am lumping them together simply according to tendency.
Obviously there are very great variations in talent. But when one
compares these writers with the Joyce-Eliot generation, the
immediately striking thing is how much easier it is to form them
into a group. Technically they are closer together, politically they
are almost indistinguishable, and their criticisms of one another's
work have always been (to put it mildly) good-natured. The out-
standing writers of the twenties were of very varied origins,
few
of them had passed through the ordinary English educational mill
(incidentally, the best of them, barring Lawrence, were not
Englishmen), and most of them had had at some time to struggle
against poverty, neglect, and even downright persecution. On the
other hand, nearly all the younger writers fit easily into the
public-school-university-Bloomsbury pattern. The few who are of
proletarian origin are of the kind that is declassed early in life,
first by means of scholarships and then by the bleaching-tub of
London 'culture'.
It is significant that several of the writers in
this group have been not only boys but, subsequently, masters at
public schools. Some years ago
I described Auden as 'a sort of
gutless Kipling'. As criticism this was quite unworthy, indeed it
was merely a spiteful remark
, but it is a fact that in Auden's work,
especially his earlier work, an atmosphere of uplift—something
rather like Kipling's If or Newbolt's Play up, Play up, and Play the
Game!—never seems to be very far away. Take, for instance, a poem
like 'You're leaving now, and it's up to you boys'. It is pure
scoutmaster, the exact note of the ten-minutes' straight talk on the
dangers of self-abuse. No doubt there is an element of parody that
he intends, but there is also a deeper resemblance that he does not
intend. And of course the rather priggish note that is common to
most of these writers is a symptom, of release. By throwing 'pure
art' overboard they have freed themselves from the fear of being
laughed at and vastly enlarged their scope. The prophetic side of
Marxism, for example, is new material for poetry and has great
possibilities.


We are nothing
We have fallen
Into the dark and shall be destroyed.
Think though, that in this darkness
We hold the secret hub of an idea
Whose living sunlit wheel revolves in future years outside.


(Spender, Trial Of A Judge)

But at the same time, by being Marxized literature has moved no
nearer to the masses.
Even allowing for the time-lag, Auden and
Spender are somewhat farther from being popular writers than
Joyce and Eliot, let alone Lawrence. As before, there are many
contemporary writers who are outside the current, but there is not
much doubt about what is the current. For the middle and late
thirties, Auden Spender & Co. are 'the movement', just as Joyce,
Eliot & Co. were for the twenties. And the movement is in the
direction of some rather ill-defined thing called Communism. As
early as 1934 or 1935 it was considered eccentric in literary
circles not to be more or less 'left', and in another year or two
there had grown up a left-wing orthodoxy that made a certain set of
opinions absolutely de rigueur on certain subjects,
The idea had
begun to gain ground (vide Edward Upward and others) that a writer
must either be actively 'left' or write badly.
Between 1935 and 1939
the Communist Party had an almost irresistible fascination for any
writer under forty.
It became as normal to hear that so-and-so had
'joined' as it had been a few years earlier, when Roman Catholicism
was fashionable, to hear that So-and-so had 'been received'.
For
about three years, in fact, the central stream of English literature
was more or less directly under Communist control. How was it
possible for such a thing to happen? And at the same time, what is
meant by 'Communism'? It is better to answer the second question
first.


The Communist movement in Western Europe began, as a movement
for the violent overthrow of capitalism, and degenerated within a few
years into an instrument of Russian foreign policy. This was
probably inevitable when this revolutionary ferment that followed
the Great War had died down. So far as I know, the only
comprehensive history of this subject in English is Franz Borkenau's
book, The Communist International. What Borkenau's facts even more
than his deductions make clear is that
Communism could never have
developed along its present lines if any revolutionary feeling had
existed in the industrialized countries.
In England, for instance,
it is obvious that no such feeling has existed for years past. The
pathetic membership figures of all extremist parties show this
clearly. It is, only natural, therefore, that the English Communist
movement should be controlled by people who are mentally subservient
to Russia and have no real aim except to manipulate British foreign
policy in the Russian interest. Of course such an aim cannot be
openly admitted, and it is this fact that gives the Communist Party
its very peculiar character. The more vocal kind of Communist is
in effect a Russian publicity agent posing as an international
socialist.
It is a pose that is easily kept up at normal times, but
becomes difficult in moments of crisis, because of the fact that the
U.S.S.R. is no more scrupulous in its foreign policy than the rest
of the Great Powers. Alliances, changes of front etc., which only
make sense as part of the game of power politics have to be
explained and justified in terms of international socialism.
Every
time Stalin swaps partners, 'Marxism' has to be hammered into a new
shape. This entails sudden and violent changes of 'line', purges,
denunciations, systematic destruction of party literature, etc.,
etc. Every Communist is in fact liable at any moment to have to
alter his most fundamental convictions, or leave the party. The
unquestionable dogma of Monday may become the damnable heresy of
Tuesday, and so on.
This has happened at least three times during
the past ten years. It follows that in any Western country a
Communist Party is always unstable and usually very small. Its
long-term membership really consists of an inner ring of intel-
lectuals who have identified with the Russian bureaucracy, and
a slightly larger body of working-class people who feel a loyalty
towards Soviet Russia without necessarily understanding its
policies.
Otherwise there is only a shifting membership, one lot
coming and another going with each change of 'line'.

In 1930 the English Communist Party was a tiny, barely legal
organization whose main activity was libelling the Labour Party. But
by 1935 the face of Europe had changed, and left-wing politics
changed with it. Hitler had risen to power and begun to rearm, the
Russian five-year plans had succeeded, Russia had reappeared as a
great military power. As Hitler's three targets of attack were, to
all appearances, Great Britain, France, and the U.S.S.R., the three
countries were forced into a sort of uneasy rapprochement. This
meant that the English or French Communist was obliged to become
a good patriot and imperialist—that is, to defend the very things he
had been attacking for the past fifteen years.
The Comintern
slogans suddenly faded from red to pink. 'World revolution' and
'Social-Fascism' gave way to 'Defence of democracy' and 'Stop
Hitler'. The years 1935-9 were the period of anti-Fascism and the
Popular Front, the heyday of the Left Book Club, when red Duchesses
and 'broadminded' deans toured the battlefields of the Spanish war
and Winston Churchill was the blue-eyed boy of the Daily Worker.

Since then, of course, there has been yet another change of 'line'.
But what is important for my purpose is that it was during the
'anti-Fascist' phase that the younger English writers gravitated
towards Communism.

The Fascism-democracy dogfight was no doubt an attraction in itself,
but in any case their conversion was due at about that date.
It was
obvious that laissez-faire capitalism was finished and that there
had got to be some kind of reconstruction; in the world of 1935 it
was hardly possible to remain politically indifferent. But why did
these young men turn towards anything so alien as Russian Communism?
Why should writers be attracted by a form of socialism that makes
mental honesty impossible?
The explanation really lies in something
that had already made itself felt before the slump and before
Hitler: middle-class unemployment.


Unemployment is not merely a matter of not having a job. Most people
can get a job of sorts, even at the worst of times. The trouble was
that by about 1930 there was no activity, except perhaps scientific
research, the arts, and left-wing politics, that a thinking person
could believe in. The debunking of Western civilization had reached
its Climax and 'disillusionment' was immensely widespread. Who
now could take it for granted to go through life in the ordinary
middle-class way, as a soldier, a clergyman, a stockbroker, an
Indian Civil Servant, or what-not? And how many of the values
by which our grandfathers lived could not be taken seriously?

Patriotism, religion, the Empire, the family, the sanctity of
marriage, the Old School Tie, birth, breeding, honour, discipline—

anyone of ordinary education could turn the whole lot of
them inside out in three minutes. But what do you achieve, after
all, by getting rid of such primal things as patriotism and religion?
You have not necessarily got rid of the need for something
to believe in.
There had been a sort of false dawn a few years
earlier when numbers of young intellectuals, including several quite
gifted writers (Evelyn Waugh, Christopher Hollis, and others), had
fled into the Catholic Church. It is significant that these people
went almost invariably to the Roman Church and not, for instance, to
the C. of E., the Greek Church, or the Protestants sects.
They went,
that is, to the Church with a world-wide organization, the one with
a rigid discipline, the one with power and prestige behind it.

Perhaps it is even worth noticing that the only latter-day convert
of really first-rate gifts, Eliot, has embraced not Romanism but
Anglo-Catholicism, the ecclesiastical equivalent of Trotskyism. But
I do not think one need look farther than this for the reason why
the young writers of the thirties flocked into or towards the

Communist Party. It was simply something to believe in. Here was a
Church, an army, an orthodoxy, a discipline. Here was a Fatherland
and—at any rate since 1935 or thereabouts—a Fuehrer. All the
loyalties and superstitions that the intellect had seemingly
banished could come rushing back under the thinnest of disguises.
Patriotism, religion, empire, military glory—all in one word,
Russia. Father, king, leader, hero, saviour—all in one word, Stalin.
God—Stalin. The devil—Hitler. Heaven—Moscow. Hell—Berlin. All the
gaps were filled up.
So, after all, the 'Communism' of the English
intellectual is something explicable enough.
It is the patriotism of
the deracinated.


But there is one other thing that undoubtedly contributed to the
cult of Russia among the English intelligentsia during these years,
and that is
the softness and security of life in England itself.
With all its injustices, England is still the land of habeas corpus,

and the over-whelming majority of English people have no experience
of violence or illegality. If you have grown up in that sort of
atmosphere it is not at all easy to imagine what a despotic régime
is like. Nearly all the dominant writers of the thirties belonged to
the
soft-boiled emancipated middle class and were too young to have
effective memories of the Great War. To people of that kind such
things as
purges, secret police, summary executions, imprisonment
without trial etc., etc., are too remote to be terrifying. They can
swallow totalitarianism because they have no experience of anything
except liberalism.
Look, for instance, at this extract from Mr
Auden's poem 'Spain' (incidentally this poem is one of the few
decent things that have been written about the Spanish war):


To-morrow for the young, the poets exploding like bombs,
The walks by the lake, the weeks of perfect communion;
To-morrow the bicycle races
Through the suburbs on summer evenings. But to-day the struggle.

To-day the deliberate increase in the chances of death,
The conscious acceptance of guilt in the necessary murder;
To-day the expending of powers
On the flat ephemeral pamphlet and the boring meeting.


The second stanza is intended as a sort of thumb-nail sketch of a
day in the life of
a 'good party man'. In the-morning a couple of
political murders, a ten-minutes' interlude to stifle 'bourgeois'
remorse
, and then a hurried luncheon and a busy afternoon and
evening chalking walls and distributing leaflets. All very edifying.
But notice the phrase 'necessary murder'. It could only be written
by a person to whom murder is at most a word. Personally I would
not speak so lightly of murder. It so happens that I have seen the
bodies of numbers of murdered men—I don't mean killed in battle, I
mean murdered. Therefore I have some conception of what murder
means—the terror, the hatred, the howling relatives, the
post-mortems, the blood, the smells. To me, murder is something to
be avoided. So it is to any ordinary person. The Hitlers and Stalins
find murder necessary, but they don't advertise their callousness,
and they don't speak of it as murder; it is 'liquidation',
'elimination', or some other soothing phrase. Mr Auden's brand of
amoralism is only possible, if you are the kind of person who is
always somewhere else when the trigger is pulled. So much of
left-wing thought is a kind of playing with fire by people who don't
even know that fire is hot. The warmongering to which the English
intelligentsia gave themselves up in the period 1935-9 was largely
based on a sense of personal immunity. The attitude was very
different in France, where the military service is hard to dodge and
even literary men know the weight of a pack.


Towards the end of Mr Cyril Connolly's recent book, Enemies of
Promise
, there occurs an interesting and revealing passage. The
first part of the book, is, more or less, an evaluation of
present-day literature. Mr Connolly belongs exactly to the
generation of the writers of 'the movement', and with not many
reservations their values are his values. It is interesting to
notice that
among prose-writers he admires chiefly those
specialising in violence—the would-be tough American school,
Hemingway, etc.
The latter part of the book, however, is
autobiographical and consists of an account, fascinatingly accurate,
of life at a preparatory school and Eton in the years 1910-20. Mr
Connolly ends by remarking:


Were I to deduce anything from my feelings on leaving Eton, it might
be called the theory of permanent adolescence. It is the theory that
the experiences undergone by boys at the great public schools are so
intense as to dominate their lives and to arrest their development
.

When you read the second sentence in this passage, your natural
impulse is to look for the misprint. Presumably there is a 'not'
left out, or something. But no, not a bit of it! He means it! And
what is more, he is merely
speaking the truth, in an inverted
fashion. 'Cultured' middle-class life has reached a depth of
softness at which a public-school education—five years in a lukewarm
bath of snobbery—can actually be looked back upon as an eventful
period.
To nearly all the writers who have counted during the
thirties, what more has ever happened than Mr Connolly records in
Enemies Of Promise? It is the same pattern all the time;
public
school, university, a few trips abroad, then London. Hunger,
hardship, solitude, exile, war, prison, persecution, manual
labour—hardly even words. No wonder that the huge tribe known
as 'the right left people' found it so easy to condone the
purge-and-trap side of the Russian régime and the horrors of
the first Five-Year Plan. They were so gloriously incapable of
understanding what it all meant.


By 1937 the whole of the intelligentsia was mentally at war.
Left-wing thought had narrowed down to 'anti-Fascism', i.e. to a
negative, and a torrent of hate-literature
directed against Germany
and the politicians supposedly friendly to Germany was pouring from
the Press. The thing that, to me, was truly frightening about the
war in Spain was not such violence as I witnessed, nor even the
party feuds behind the lines, but the
immediate reappearance in
left-wing circles of the mental atmosphere of the Great War. The
very people who for twenty years had sniggered over their own
superiority to war hysteria were the ones who rushed straight back
into the mental slum of 1915. All the familiar wartime idiocies,
spy-hunting, orthodoxy-sniffing (Sniff, sniff. Are you a good
anti-Fascist?
), the retailing of atrocity stories
, came back into
vogue as though the intervening years had never happened. Before the
end of the Spanish war, and even before Munich, some of the better
of the left-wing writers were beginning to squirm. Neither Auden
nor, on the whole, Spender wrote about the Spanish war in quite the
vein that was expected of them. Since then there has been a change
of feeling and much dismay and confusion, because the actual course
of events has made nonsense of the left-wing orthodoxy of the last
few years. But then it did not need very great acuteness to see that
much of it was nonsense from the start.
There is no certainty,
therefore, that the next orthodoxy to emerge will be any better than
the last.

On the whole the literary history of the thirties seems to justify
the opinion that a writer does well to keep out of politics. For
any writer who accepts or partially accepts the discipline of a
political party is sooner or later faced with the alternative: toe
the line, or shut up. I
t is, of course, possible to toe the line and
go on writing—after a fashion.
Any Marxist can demonstrate with the
greatest of ease that 'bourgeois' liberty of thought is an illusion.

But when he has finished his demonstration there remains the
psychological fact that
without this 'bourgeois' liberty the
creative powers wither away.
In the future a totalitarian literature
may arise, but it will be quite different from anything we can now
imagine. Literature as we know it is an individual thing, demanding
mental honesty and a minimum of censorship. And this is even truer
of prose than of verse. It is probably not a coincidence that the
best writers of the thirties have been poets. The atmosphere of
orthodoxy is always damaging to prose, and above all it is
completely ruinous to the novel, the most anarchical of all forms of
literature.
How many Roman Catholics have been good novelists? Even
the handful one could name have usually been bad Catholics.
The
novel is practically a Protestant form of art; it is a product of
the free mind, of the autonomous individual.
No decade in the past
hundred and fifty years has been so barren of imaginative prose as
the nineteen-thirties. There have been good poems, good sociological
works, brilliant pamphlets, but practically no fiction of any value
at all. From 1933 onwards the mental climate was increasingly
against it. Anyone sensitive enough to be touched by the Zeitgeist
was also involved in politics. Not everyone, of course, was
definitely in the political racket, but practically everyone was on
its periphery and more or less mixed up in propaganda campaigns and
squalid controversies. Communists and near-Communists had a
disproportionately large influence in the literary reviews. It was a
time of
labels, slogans, and evasions. At the worst moments you were
expected to lock yourself up in a constipating little cage of lies;

at the best a sort of voluntary censorship (
'Ought I to say this? Is
it pro-Fascist?'
) was at work in nearly everyone's mind. It is
almost inconceivable that good novels should be written in such an
atmosphere. 'Good novels are not written by by orthodoxy-sniffers,
nor by people who are conscience-stricken about their own
unorthodoxy. Good novels are written by people who are not
frightened.
This brings me back to Henry Miller.


III


If this were a likely, moment for the launching of 'schools'
literature, Henry Miller might be the starting-point of a new
'school'. He does at any rate mark an unexpected swing of the
pendulum. In his books one gets right away from the 'political
animal' and back to a viewpoint not only individualistic but
completely passive—the view-point of a man who believes the
world-process to be outside his control and who in any case hardly
wishes to control it.

I first met Miller at the end of 1936, when I was passing through
Paris on my way to Spain. What most intrigued me about him was to
find that he felt no interest in the Spanish war whatever.
He merely
told me in forcible terms that to go to Spain at that moment was the
act of an idiot. He could understand anyone going there from purely
selfish motives, out of curiosity, for instance, but to mix oneself
up in such things from a sense of obligation was sheer stupidity. In
any case my Ideas about combating Fascism, defending democracy,
etc., etc., were all baloney. Our civilization was destined to be
swept away and replaced by something so different that we should
scarcely regard it as human—a prospect that did not bother him,
he
said. And some such outlook is implicit throughout his work.
Everywhere there is the sense of the approaching cataclysm, and
almost everywhere the implied belief that it doesn't matter. The
only political declaration which, so far as I know, he has ever made
in print is a purely negative one. A year or so ago an American
magazine, the Marxist Quarterly, sent out a questionnaire to various
American writers asking them to define their attitude on the subject
of war. Miller replied in terms of extreme pacifism, an individual
refusal to fight, with no apparent wish to convert others to the
same opinion—practically, in fact, a declaration of irresponsibility.


However, there is more than one kind of irresponsibility. As a rule,
writers who do not wish to identify themselves with the historical
process at the moment either ignore it or fight against it. If they
can ignore it, they are probably fools. If they can understand it
well enough to want to fight against it, they probably have enough
vision to realize that they cannot win.
Look, for instance, at a
poem like 'The Scholar Gipsy', with its railing against the 'strange
disease of modern life' and its magnificent defeatist simile* in the
final stanza. It expresses one of the normal literary attitudes,
perhaps actually the prevailing attitude during the last hundred
years. And on the other hand there are the 'progressives', the
yea-sayers, the Shaw-Wells type, always leaping forward to embrace
the ego-projections which they mistake for the future. On the whole
the writers of the twenties took the first line and the writers of
the thirties the second.
And at any given moment, of course, there
is a huge tribe of Barries and Deepings and Dells who simply don't
notice what is happening. Where
Miller's work is symptomatically
important is in its avoidance of any of these attitudes. He is
neither pushing the world-process forward nor trying to drag it
back
, but on the other hand he is by no means ignoring it. I should
say that
he believes in the impending ruin of Western Civilization
much more firmly than the majority of 'revolutionary' writers; only
he does not feel called upon to do anything about it. He is fiddling
While Rome is burning, and, unlike the enormous majority of people
who do this, fiddling with his face towards the flames.


In Max and the White Phagocytes there is one of those revealing
passages in which a writer tells you a great deal about himself
while talking about somebody else. The book includes a long essay on
the diaries of Anais Nin, which I have never read, except for a few
fragments, and which I believe have not been published. Miller
claims that they are the only true feminine writing that has ever
appeared, whatever that may mean. But the interesting passage is one
in which he compares Anais Nin—evidently a completely subjective,
introverted writer—to Jonah in the whale's belly. In passing
he
refers to an essay that Aldous Huxley wrote some years ago about El
Greco's picture, The Dream of Philip the Second. Huxley remarks that
the people in El Greco's pictures always look as though they were in
the bellies of whales, and professes to find something peculiarly
horrible in the idea of being in a 'visceral prison'. Miller retorts
that, on the contrary, there are many worse things than being
swallowed by whales,
and the passage makes it clear that he himself
finds the idea rather attractive. Here he is touching upon what is
probably a very widespread fantasy. It is perhaps worth noticing
that everyone, at least every English-speaking person, invariably
speaks of Jonah and the whale. Of course the creature that swallowed
Jonah was a fish, and was so described in the Bible (Jonah i. 17),
but children naturally confuse it with a whale, and this fragment of
baby-talk is habitually carried into later life—a sign, perhaps, of
the hold that the Jonah myth has upon our imaginations. For the fact
is that
being inside a whale is a very comfortable, cosy, homelike
thought.
The historical Jonah, if he can be so called, was glad
enough to escape, but in imagination, in day-dream, countless people
have envied him. It is, of course, quite obvious why.
The whale's
belly is simply a womb big enough for an adult. There you are, in
the dark, cushioned space that exactly fits you, with yards of
blubber between yourself and reality,
able to keep up an attitude of
the completest indifference, no matter what happens. A storm that
would sink all the battleships in the world would hardly reach you
as an echo. Even the whale's own movements would probably be
imperceptible to you. He might be wallowing among the surface waves
or shooting down into the blackness of the middle seas (a mile deep,
according to Herman Melville), but you would never notice the
difference.
Short of being dead, it is the final, unsurpassable
stage of irresponsibility. And however it may be with Anais Nin,
there is no question that Miller himself is inside the whale. All
his best and most characteristic passages are written from the
angle of Jonah, a willing Jonah.
Not that he is especially intro-
verted—quite the contrary. In his case the whale happens to be
transparent. Only he feels no impulse to alter or control the
process that he is undergoing. He has performed the essential
Jonah act of allowing himself to be swallowed, remaining passive,
accepting.

It will be seen what this amounts to.
It is a species of quietism,
implying either complete unbelief or else a degree of belief
amounting to mysticism.
The attitude is 'je m'en fous' or 'Though He
slay me, yet will I trust in Him', whichever way you like to look at
it; for practical purposes both are identical, the moral in either
case being
'Sit on your bum'. But in a time like ours, is this a
defensible attitude? Notice that it is almost impossible to refrain
from asking this question.
At the moment of writing, we are still in
a period in which it is taken for granted that books ought always to
be positive, serious, and 'constructive'. A dozen years ago this
idea would have been greeted with titters. ('My dear aunt, one
doesn't write about anything, one just writes.') Then the pendulum
swung away from the frivolous notion that art is merely technique,
but it swung a very long distance, to the point of asserting that a
book can only be 'good' if it is founded on a 'true' vision of life.
Naturally the people who believe this also believe that they are in
possession of the truth themselves. Catholic critics, for instance,
tend to claim that books are only 'good' when they are of Catholic
tendency. Marxist critics make the same claim more boldly for
Marxist books. For instance, Mr Edward Upward ('A Marxist
Interpretation of Literature,' in the Mind In Chains):

Literary criticism which aims at being Marxist must...proclaim that
no book written at the present time can be 'good' unless it is
written from a Marxist or near-Marxist viewpoint.


Various other writers have made similar or comparable statements.
Mr Upward italicizes 'at the present time' because, he realizes that
you cannot, for instance, dismiss Hamlet on the ground that
Shakespeare was not a Marxist.
Nevertheless his interesting essay
only glances very shortly at this difficulty. Much of the literature
that comes to us out of the past is permeated by and in fact founded
on beliefs (the belief in the immortality of the soul, for example)
which now seem to us false and in some cases contemptibly silly. Yet
it is 'good' literature, if survival is any test. Mr Upward would no
doubt answer that a belief which was appropriate several centuries
ago might be inappropriate and therefore stultifying now. But this
does not get one much farther, because it
assumes that in any age
there will be one body of belief which is the current approximation
to truth, and that the best literature of the time will be more or
less in harmony with it. Actually no such uniformity has ever
existed. In seventeenth-century England, for instance, there was a
religious and political cleavage which distinctly resembled the
left-right antagonism of to-day. Looking back, most modern people
would feel that the bourgeois-Puritan viewpoint was a better
approximation to truth than the Catholic-feudal one.
But it is
certainly not the case that all or even a majority of the best
writers of the time were puritans. And more than this, there exist
'good' writers whose world-view would in any age be recognized false
and silly. Edgar Allan Poe is an example. Poe's outlook is at best a
wild romanticism and at worst is not far from being insane in the
literal clinical sense.
Why is it, then that stories like The Black
Cat, The Tell-tale Heart, The Fall of the House of Usher
and so
forth, which might very nearly have been written by a lunatic, do
not convey a feeling of falsity? Because they are true within a
certain framework, they keep the rules of their own peculiar world,

like a Japanese picture. But it appears that to write successfully
about such a world you have got to believe in it. One sees the
difference immediately if one compares Poe's Tales with what is, in
my opinion, an insincere attempt to work up a similar atmosphere,
Julian Green's Minuit. The thing that immediately strikes one about
Minuit is that there is no reason why any of the events in it should
happen. Everything is completely arbitrary; there is no emotional
sequence. But this is exactly what one does not feel with Poe's
stories.
It seems therefore that for a creative writer possession of
the 'truth' is less important than emotional sincerity. Even Mr
Upward would not claim that a writer needs nothing beyond a Marxist
training. He also needs a talent. But talent, apparently, is a
matter of being able to care, of really believing in your beliefs,
whether they are true or false. The difference between, for
instance, Céline and Evelyn Waugh is a difference of emotional
intensity. It is the difference between genuine despair and a
despair that is at least partly a pretence. And with this there goes
another consideration which is perhaps less obvious: that there are
occasions when an 'untrue' belief is more likely to be sincerely
held than a 'true' one.


If one looks at the books of personal reminiscence written about the
war of 1914-18,
one notices that nearly all that have remained
readable after a lapse of time are written from a passive, negative
angle. They
are the records of something completely meaningless, a
nightmare happening in a void. That was not actually the truth about
the war, but it was the truth about the individual reaction. The
soldier advancing into a machine-gun barrage or standing waist-deep
in a flooded trench knew only that here was an appalling experience
in which he was all but helpless. He was likelier to make a good
book out of his helplessness and his ignorance than out of a
pretended power to see the whole thing in perspective.
As for the
books that were written during the war itself, the best of them were
nearly all the work of people who simply turned their backs and
tried not to notice that the war was happening.
Mr E. M. Forster has
described how in 1917 he read Prufrock and other of Eliot's early
poems, and how it
heartened him at such a time to get hold of poems
that were 'innocent of public-spiritedness':

They sang of private disgust and diffidence, and of people who
seemed genuine because they were unattractive or weak...Here was
a protest, and a feeble one, and the more congenial for being so
feeble...He who could turn aside to complain of ladies and drawing
rooms preserved a tiny drop of our self-respect, he carried on the
human heritage.


That is very well said. Mr MacNeice, in the book I have referred to
already, quotes this passage and somewhat smugly adds:


Ten years later less feeble protests were to be made by poets and
the human heritage carried on rather differently...The contemplation
of a world of fragments becomes boring and Eliot's successors are
more interested in tidying it up.


Similar remarks are scattered throughout Mr MacNeice's book. What
he wishes us to believe is that
Eliot's 'successors' (meaning Mr
MacNeice and his friends)
have in some way 'protested' more
effectively than Eliot did by publishing Prufrock at the moment when
the Allied armies were assaulting the Hindenburg Line. Just where
these 'protests' are to be found I do not know. But in the contrast
between
Mr Forster's comment and Mr MacNeice's lies all the dif-
ference between a man who knows what the 1914-18 war was like and
a man who barely remembers it. The truth is that in 1917 there was
nothing that a thinking and a sensitive person could do, except to
remain human, if possible. And a gesture of helplessness, even of
frivolity, might be the best way of doing that.
If I had been a
soldier fighting in the Great War, I would sooner have got hold of
Prufrock than The First Hundred Thousand or Horatio Bottomley's
Letters to the Boys in the Trenches. I should have felt, like Mr
Forster, that
by simply standing aloof and keeping touch with
pre-war emotions, Eliot was carrying on the human heritage. What a
relief it would have been at such a time, to read about the
hesitations of a middle-aged highbrow with a bald spot! So different
from bayonet-drill! After the bombs and the food-queues and the
recruiting-posters, a human voice! What a relief!


But, after all, the war of 1914-18 was only a heightened moment in
an almost continuous crisis. At this date it hardly even needs a war
to bring home to us the disintegration of our society and the
increasing helplessness of all, decent people. It is for this reason
that I think that the passive, non-co-operative attitude implied in
Henry Miller's work is justified. Whether or not it is an expression
of what people ought to feel, it probably comes somewhere near to
expressing what they do feel. Once again it is
the human voice among
the bomb-explosions, a friendly American voice, 'innocent of
public-spiritedness'.
No sermons, merely the subjective truth. And
along those lines, apparently, it is still possible for a good novel
to be written. Not necessarily an edifying novel, but a novel worth
reading and likely to be remembered after it is read.


While I have been writing this essay another European war has broken
out. It will either last several years and tear Western civilization
to pieces, or it will end inconclusively and prepare the way for yet
another war which will do the job once and for all. But war is only
'peace intensified'. What is quite obviously happening, war or no
war, is the break-up of laissez-faire capitalism and of the
liberal-Christian culture. Until recently the full implications of
this were not foreseen, because it was generally imagined that
socialism could preserve and even enlarge the atmosphere of
liberalism. It is now beginning to be realized how false this idea
was. Almost certainly we are moving into an age of totalitarian
dictatorships—an age in which freedom of thought will be at first a
deadly sin and later on a meaningless abstraction. The autonomous
individual is going to be stamped out of existence. But this means
that literature, in the form in which we know it, must suffer at
least a temporary death. The literature of liberalism is coming to
an end and the literature of totalitarianism has not yet appeared
and is barely imaginable.
As for the writer, he is sitting on a
melting iceberg; he is merely an anachronism, a hangover from the
bourgeois age, as surely doomed as the hippopotamus. Miller seems to
me a man out of the common because he saw and proclaimed this fact a
long while before most of his contemporaries—at a time, indeed, when
many of them were actually burbling about a renaissance of
literature. Wyndham Lewis had said years earlier that the major
history of the English language was finished, but he was basing this
on different and rather trivial reasons. But from now onwards the
all-important fact for the creative writers going to be that
this is
not a writer's world. That does not mean that he cannot help to
bring the new society into being, but he can take no part in the
process as a writer. For as a writer he is a liberal, and what is
happening is the destruction of liberalism.
It seems likely,
therefore, that in the remaining years of free speech any novel
worth reading will follow more or less along the lines that Miller
has followed—I do not mean in technique or subject matter, but in
implied outlook. The passive attitude will come back, and it will be
more consciously passive than before.
Progress and reaction have
both turned out to be swindles. Seemingly there is nothing left but
quietism—robbing reality of its terrors by simply submitting to it.
Get inside the whale—or rather, admit you are inside the whale (for
you are, of course). Give yourself over to the world-process, stop
fighting against it or pretending that you control it; simply accept
it, endure it, record it.
That seems to be the formula, that any
sensitive novelist is now likely to adopt. A novel on more positive,
'constructive' lines, and not emotionally spurious, is at present
very difficult to imagine.

But do I mean by this that Miller is a 'great author', a new hope
for English prose? Nothing of the kind. Miller himself would be the
last to claim or want any such thing. No doubt he will go on
writing—anybody who has once started always goes on writing—and
associated with him there are a number of writers of approximately
the same tendency, Lawrence Durrell, Michael Fraenkel and others,
almost amounting to a 'school'. But he himself seems to me
essentially a man of one book. Sooner or later I should expect him
to descend into unintelligibility, or into charlatanism: there are
signs of both in his later work.
His last book, Tropic Of Capricorn,
I have not even read. This was not because I did not want to read
it, but because the police and Customs authorities have so far
managed to prevent me from getting hold of it. But it would surprise
me if it came anywhere near Tropic of Cancer or the opening chapters
of Black Spring. Like certain other autobiographical novelists, he
had it in him to do just one thing perfectly, and he did it.
Considering what the fiction of the nineteen-thirties has been like,
that is something.


Miller's books are published by the Obelisk Press in Paris. What
will happen to the Obelisk Press, now that war has broken out and
Jack Kathane, the publisher, is dead, I do not know, but at any rate
the books are still procurable.
I earnestly counsel anyone who has
not done so to read at least Tropic of Cancer. With a little
ingenuity, or by paying a little over the published price, you can
get hold of it, and even if parts of it disgust you, it will stick
in your memory. It is also an 'important' book, in a sense different
from the sense in which that word is generally used.
As a rule
novels are spoken of as 'important' when they are either a 'terrible
indictment' of something or other or when they introduce some
technical innovation.
Neither of these applies to Tropic Of Cancer.
Its importance is merely symptomatic. Here, in my opinion, is the
only imaginative prose-writer of the slightest value who has
appeared among the English-speaking races for some years past.
Even if that is objected to as an overstatement, it will probably be
admitted that Miller is a writer out of the ordinary, worth more
than a single glance; and after all,
he is a completely negative,
unconstructive, amoral writer, a mere Jonah, a passive acceptor of
evil, a sort of Whitman among the corpses.
Symptomatically, that is
more significant than the mere fact that five thousand novels are
published in England every year and four thousand nine hundred of
them are tripe.
It is a demonstration of the impossibility of any
major literature until the world has shaken itself into its new
shape.




THE ART OF DONALD MCGILL



Who does not know the 'comics' of the cheap stationers' windows,
the penny or twopenny coloured post cards with their endless
succession of fat women in tight bathing-dresses and their crude
drawing and unbearable colours, chiefly hedge-sparrow's-egg tint
and Post Office red?


This question ought to be rhetorical, but it is curious fact that
many people seem to be unaware of the existence of these things,
or else to have a vague notion that they are something to be
found only at the seaside, like nigger minstrels or peppermint
rock. Actually they are on sale everywhere—they can be bought at
nearly any Woolworth's, for example—and they are evidently
produced in enormous numbers, new series constantly appearing.
They are not to be confused with the various other types of comic
illustrated post card, such as the sentimental ones dealing with
puppies and kittens or the Wendyish, sub-pornographic ones which
exploit the love affairs of children. They are a genre of their
own, specializing in very 'low' humour, the mother-in-law,
baby's-nappy, policemen's-boot type of joke, and distinguishable
from all the other kinds by having no artistic pretensions.
Some
half-dozen publishing houses issue them, though the people who
draw them seem not to be numerous at any one time.


I have associated them especially with the name of Donald McGill
because he is not only the most prolific and by far the best of
contemporary post card artists, but also the most representative,
the most perfect in the tradition. Who Donald McGill is, I do not
know. He is apparently a trade name, for at least one series of
post cards is issued simply as 'The Donald McGill Comics', but he
is also unquestionably a real person with a style of drawing
which is recognizable at a glance. Anyone who examines his post
cards in bulk will notice that many of them are not despicable
even as drawings, but it would be mere dilettantism to pretend
that they have any direct aesthetic value. A comic post card is
simply an illustration to a joke, invariably a 'low' joke, and it
stands or falls by its ability to raise a laugh. Beyond that it
has only 'ideological' interest. McGill is a clever draughtsman
with a real caricaturist's touch in the drawing of faces, but the
special value of his post cards is that they are so completely
typical. They represent, as it were, the norm of the comic post
card. Without being in the least imitative, they are exactly what
comic post cards have been any time these last forty years, and
from them the meaning and purpose of the whole genre can be
inferred.


Get hold of a dozen of these things, preferably McGill's—if you
pick out from a pile the ones that seem to you funniest, you will
probably find that most of them are McGill's—and spread them out
on a table. What do you see?

Your first impression is of overpowering vulgarity. This is quite
apart from the ever-present obscenity, and apart also from the
hideousness of the colours. They have an utter low-ness of mental
atmosphere which comes out not only in the nature of the jokes
but, even more, in the grotesque, staring, blatant quality of the
drawings. The designs, like those of a child, are full of heavy
lines and empty spaces, and all the figures in them, every
gesture and attitude, are deliberately ugly, the faces grinning
and vacuous, the women monstrously parodied, with bottoms like
Hottentots.
Your second impression, however, is of indefinable
familiarity. What do these things remind you of? What are they
so like? In the first place, of course, they remind you of the
barely different post cards which you probably gazed at in your
childhood. But more than this, what you are really looking at is
something as
traditional as Greek tragedy, a sort of sub-world of
smacked bottoms and scrawny mothers-in-law which is a part of
Western European consciousness. Not that the jokes, taken one by
one, are necessarily stale. Not being debarred from smuttiness,

comic post cards repeat themselves less often than the joke
columns in reputable magazines, but their basic subject-matter,
the kind of joke they are aiming at, never varies. A few are
genuinely witty, in a Max Millerish style.
Examples:

'I like seeing experienced girls home.'
'But I'm not experienced!'
'You're not home yet!'

'I've been struggling for years to get a fur coat. How did you
get yours?'
'I left off struggling.'

JUDGE: 'You are prevaricating, sir. Did you or did you not sleep
with this woman?'
Co-respondent: 'Not a wink, my lord!'


In general, however, they are not witty, but humorous, and it
must be said for McGill's post cards, in particular, that the
drawing is often a good deal funnier than the joke beneath it.
Obviously the outstanding characteristic of comic cards is their
obscenity,
and I must discuss that more fully later. But I give
here a rough analysis of their habitual subject-matter, with such
explanatory remarks as seem to be needed:

SEX.—More than half, perhaps three-quarters, of the jokes are
sex jokes, ranging from the harmless to the all but unprintable.
First favourite is probably the illegitimate baby. Typical
captions: 'Could you exchange this lucky charm for a baby's
feeding-bottle?'
'She didn't ask me to the christening, so I'm
not going to the wedding.' Also newlyweds, old maids, nude
statues and women in bathing-dresses.
All of these are ipso facto
funny, mere mention of them being enough to raise a laugh. The
cuckoldry joke is seldom exploited, and there are no references
to homosexuality.


Conventions of the sex joke:

(i) Marriage only benefits women. Every man is plotting seduction
and every woman is plotting marriage. No woman ever remained
unmarried voluntarily.


(ii) Sex-appeal vanishes at about the age of twenty-five.
Well-preserved and good-looking people beyond their first youth
are never represented. The amorous honeymooning couple reappear
as the grim-visaged wife and shapeless, moustachioed, red-nosed
husband
, no intermediate stage being allowed for.

HOME LIFE—Next to sex, the henpecked husband is the favourite
joke. Typical caption: 'Did they get an X-ray of your wife's jaw
at the hospital?'—'No, they got a moving picture instead.'


Conventions:

(i) There is no such thing as a happy marriage.

(ii) No man ever gets the better of a woman in argument.
Drunkenness—Both drunkenness and teetotalism are ipso facto
funny.


Conventions:

(i) All drunken men have optical illusions.

(ii) Drunkenness is something peculiar to middle-aged men.
Drunken youths or women are never represented.


W.C. JOKES—There is not a large number of these. Chamber pots
are ipso facto funny, and so are public lavatories. A typical post
card captioned 'A Friend in Need', shows a man's hat blown off
his head and disappearing down the steps of a ladies' lavatory.


INTER-WORKING-CLASS SNOBBERY—Much in these post cards
suggests that they are aimed at the better-off working class and
poorer middle class. There are many jokes turning on
malaprop-
isms, illiteracy, dropped aitches and the rough manners of slum
dwellers. Countless post cards show draggled hags of the
stage-charwoman type exchanging 'unladylike' abuse.
Typical
repartee:
'I wish you were a statue and I was a pigeon!' A
certain number produced since the war treat evacuation from the
anti-evacuee angle. There are the usual jokes about tramps,
beggars and criminals, and the comic maidservant appears fairly
frequently. Also the comic navvy, bargee, etc.; but there are no
anti-Trade-Union jokes. Broadly speaking,
everyone with much over
or much under £5 a week is regarded as laughable. The 'swell' is
almost as automatically a figure of fun as the slum-dweller.


STOCK FIGURES—Foreigners seldom or never appear. The chief
locality joke is the Scotsman, who is almost inexhaustible. The
lawyer is always a swindler, the clergyman always a nervous idiot
who says the wrong thing. The 'knut' or 'masher' still appears,
almost as in Edwardian days, in out-of-date looking
evening-clothes and an opera hat, or even spats and a knobby
cane. Another survival is
the Suffragette, one of the big jokes
of the pre-1914 period and too valuable to be relinquished. She
has reappeared, unchanged in physical appearance, as the Feminist
lecturer or Temperance fanatic.
A feature of the last few years
is the complete absence of anti-Jew post cards. The 'Jew joke',
always somewhat more ill-natured than the 'Scotch joke',
disappeared abruptly soon after the rise of Hitler.


POLITICS—Any contemporary event, cult or activity which has
comic possibilities (for example, 'free love', feminism, A.R.P.,
nudism) rapidly finds its way into the picture post cards, but
their general atmosphere is extremely old-fashioned. The implied
political outlook is a Radicalism appropriate to about the year
1900. At normal times they are not only not patriotic, but go in
for a mild guying of patriotism, with jokes about 'God save the
King', the Union Jack, etc. The European situation only began to
reflect itself in them at some time in 1939, and first did so
through the comic aspects of A.R.P. Even at this date few post
cards mention the war except in
A.R.P. jokes (fat woman stuck in
the mouth of Anderson shelter: wardens neglecting their duty
while young woman undresses at window she has forgotten to black
out, etc., etc
.) A few express anti-Hitler sentiments of a not
very vindictive kind. One, not McGill's, shows Hitler with the
usual hypertrophied backside, bending down to pick a flower.
Caption; 'What would you do, chums?' This is about as high a
flight of patriotism as any post card is likely to attain.
Unlike
the twopenny weekly papers, comic post cards are not the product
of any great monopoly company, and evidently they are not
regarded as having any importance in forming public opinion.
There is no sign in them of any attempt to induce an outlook
acceptable to the ruling class.

Here one comes back to the outstanding, all-important feature of
comic post cards—their obscenity. It is by this that everyone
remembers them, and it is also central to their purpose, though
not in a way that is immediately obvious.

A recurrent, almost dominant motif in comic post cards is the
woman with the stuck-out behind. In perhaps half of them, or more
than half, even when the point of the joke has nothing to do with
sex, the same female figure appears
, a plump 'voluptuous' figure
with the dress clinging to it as tightly as another skin and with
breasts or buttocks grossly over-emphasized according to which
way it is turned. There can be no doubt that these pictures lift
the lid off a very widespread repression
, natural enough in a
country whose women when young tend to be slim to the point of
skimpiness. But at the same time the McGill post card—and this
applies to all other post cards in this genre—is
not intended as
pornography but, a subtler thing, as a skit on pornography.
The
Hottentot figures of the women are
caricatures of the
Englishman's secret ideal
, not portraits of it. When one examines
McGill's post cards more closely, one notices that his
brand of
humour only has a meaning in relation to a fairly strict moral
code.
Whereas in papers like Esquire, for instance, or La Vie
Parisienne
, the imaginary background of the jokes is always
promiscuity, the utter breakdown of all standards, the background
of the McGill post card is marriage. The four leading jokes are
nakedness, illegitimate babies, old maids and newly married
couples, none of which would seem funny in a really dissolute or
even 'sophisticated' society.
The post cards dealing with hon-
eymoon couples always have the enthusiastic indecency of those
village weddings where it is still
considered screamingly funny
to sew bells to the bridal bed.
In one, for example, a young
bridegroom is shown getting out of bed the morning after his
wedding night. 'The first morning in our own little home,
darling!' he is saying; 'I'll go and get the milk and paper and
bring you up a cup of tea.' Inset is a picture of the front
doorstep; on it are four newspapers and four bottles of milk.
This is obscene, if you like, but it is not immoral. Its
implication—and this is just the implication the Esquire or the
New Yorker would avoid at all costs—is that marriage is something
profoundly exciting and important, the biggest event in the
average human being's life.


So also with jokes about nagging wives and tyrannous
mothers-in-law. They do at least imply a stable society in which
marriage is indissoluble and family loyalty taken for granted.
And bound up with this is something I noted earlier, the fact
there are no pictures, or hardly any, of good-looking people
beyond their first youth.
There is the 'spooning' couple and the
middle-aged, cat-and-dog couple, but nothing in between.
The
liaison, the illicit but more or less decorous love-affair which
used to be the stock joke of French comic papers, is not a post
card subject. And this
reflects, on a comic level, the
working-class outlook which takes it as a matter of course that
youth and adventure—almost, indeed, individual life—end with
marriage.
One of the few authentic class-differences, as opposed
to class-distinctions, still existing in England is that the
working classes age very much earlier. They do not live less
long, provided that they survive their childhood, nor do they
lose their physical activity earlier, but they do lose very early
their youthful appearance. This fact is observable everywhere,
but can be most easily verified by watching one of the higher age
groups registering for military service; the middle—and
upper-class members look, on average, ten years younger than the
others. It is usual to attribute this to the harder lives that
the working classes have to live, but it is doubtful whether any
such difference now exists as would account for it. More probably
the truth is that the
working classes reach middle age earlier
because they accept it earlier. For to look young after, say,
thirty is largely a matter of wanting to do so.
This
generalization is less true of the better-paid workers,
especially those who live in council houses and labour-saving
flats, but it is true enough even of them to point to a
difference of outlook. And in this, as usual,
they are more
traditional, more in accord with the Christian past than the
well-to-do women who try to stay young at forty by means of
physical-jerks, cosmetics and avoidance of child-bearing. The
impulse to cling to youth at all costs, to attempt to preserve
your sexual attraction,
to see even in middle age a future for
yourself and not merely for your children, is a thing of recent
growth and has only precariously established itself. It will
probably disappear again when our standard of living drops and
our birth-rate rises. 'Youth's a stuff will not endure' expresses
the normal, traditional attitude. It is this ancient wisdom that
McGill and his colleagues are reflecting, no doubt unconsciously,
when they allow for no transition stage between the honeymoon
couple and those glamourless figures, Mum and Dad.


I have said that at least half of McGill's post cards are sex
jokes, and a proportion, perhaps ten per cent, are far more
obscene than anything else that is now printed in England.
Newsagents are occasionally prosecuted for selling them, and

there would be many more prosecutions if the broadest jokes
were not invariably protected by double meanings.
A single ex-
ample will be enough to show how this is done.
In one post
card, captioned 'They didn't believe her', a young woman is
demonstrating, with her hands held apart, something about two
feet long to a couple of open-mouthed acquaintances. Behind her
on the wall is a stuffed fish in a glass case, and beside that is
a photograph of a nearly naked athlete. Obviously it is not the
fish that she is referring to, but this could never be proved.

Now, it is doubtful whether there is any paper in England that
would print a joke of this kind, and certainly there is no paper
that does so habitually. There is an immense amount of
pornography of a mild sort, countless illustrated papers cash-
ing in on women's legs, but
there is no popular literature
specializing in the 'vulgar', farcical aspect of sex. On the
other hand, jokes exactly like McGill's are the ordinary small
change of the revue and music-hall stage
, and are also to be
heard on the radio, at moments when the censor happens to be
nodding. In England the gap between what can be said and what
can be printed is rather exceptionally wide. Remarks and gestures
which hardly anyone objects to on the stage would raise a public
outcry if any attempt were made to reproduce them on paper.
(Compare Max Miller's stage patter with his weekly column in the
Sunday Dispatch) The comic post cards are the only existing
exception to this rule, the only medium in which really 'low'
humour is considered to be printable. Only in post cards and on
the variety stage can the
stuck-out behind, dog and lamp-post,
baby's nappy type of joke
be freely exploited. Remembering that,
one sees what
function these post cards, in their humble way, are
performing.

What they are doing is to
give expression to the Sancho Panza
view of life, the attitude to life that Miss Rebecca West once
summed up as 'extracting as much fun as possible from smacking
behinds in basement kitchens'. The Don Quixote-Sancho Panza
combination, which of course is simply the ancient dualism of
body and soul in fiction form
, recurs more frequently in the
literature of the last four hundred years than can be explained
by mere imitation. It comes up again and again, in endless
variations, Bouvard and Pécuchet, Jeeves and Wooster, Bloom and
Dedalus, Holmes and Watson (the Holmes-Watson variant is an
exceptionally subtle one, because the usual physical
characteristics of two partners have been transposed). Evidently

it corresponds to something enduring in our civilization, not in
the sense that either character is to be found in a 'pure' state
in real life, but in the sense that the two principles, noble
folly and base wisdom, exist side by side in nearly every human
being. If you look into your own mind, which are you, Don Quixote
or Sancho Panza? Almost certainly you are both. There is one part
of you that wishes to be a hero or a saint, but another part of
you is a little fat man who sees very clearly the advantages of
staying alive with a whole skin. He is your unofficial self, the
voice of the belly protesting against the soul. His tastes lie
towards safety, soft beds, no work, pots of beer and women with
'voluptuous' figures. He it is who punctures your fine attitudes
and urges you to look after Number One
, to be unfaithful to your
wife, to bilk your debts, and so on and so forth. Whether you
allow yourself to be influenced by him is a different question.
But it is simply a lie to say that he is not part of you, just as
it is a lie to say that Don Quixote is not part of you either,
though most of what is said and written consists of one lie or
the other, usually the first.


But though in varying forms he is one of the stock figures of
literature, in real life, especially
in the way society is
ordered, his point of view never gets a fair hearing. There is a
constant world-wide conspiracy to pretend that he is not there,
or at least that he doesn't matter. Codes of law and morals, or
religious systems, never have much room in them for a humorous
view of life. Whatever is funny is subversive, every joke is
ultimately a custard pie, and the reason why so large a
proportion of jokes centre round obscenity is simply that all
societies, as the price of survival, have to insist on a fairly
high standard of sexual morality. A dirty joke is not, of course,
a serious attack upon morality, but it is a sort of mental
rebellion, a momentary wish that things were otherwise. So also
with all other jokes, which always centre round cowardice,
laziness, dishonesty or some other quality which society cannot
afford to encourage. Society has always to demand a little more
from human beings than it will get in practice. It has to demand
faultless discipline and self-sacrifice, it must expect its
subjects to work hard, pay their taxes, and be faithful to their
wives, it must assume that men think it glorious to die on the
battlefield and women want to wear themselves out with
child-bearing. The whole of what one may call official literature
is founded on such assumptions. I never read the proclamations of
generals before battle, the speeches of Führers and prime
ministers, the solidarity songs of public schools and left-wing
political parties, national anthems, Temperance tracts, papal
encyclicals and sermons against gambling and contraception,
without seeming to hear in the background a chorus of raspberries
from all the millions of common men to whom these high sentiments
make no appeal.
Nevertheless the high sentiments always win in
the end, leaders who offer blood, toil, tears and sweat always
get more out of their followers than those who offer safety and a
good time.
When it comes to the pinch, human beings are heroic.
Women face childbed and the scrubbing brush, revolutionaries keep
their mouths shut in the torture chamber, battleships go down
with their guns still firing when their decks are awash. It is
only that the other element in man, the lazy, cowardly,
debt-bilking adulterer who is inside all of us, can never be
suppressed altogether and needs a hearing occasionally.


The comic post cards are one expression of his point of view, a
humble one, less important than the music halls, but still worthy
of attention. In a society which is still basically Christian
they naturally concentrate on sex jokes; in a totalitarian
society, if they had any freedom of expression at all, they would
probably concentrate on laziness or cowardice, but at any rate on
the unheroic in one form or another.
It will not do to condemn
them on the ground that they are vulgar and ugly. That is exactly
what they are meant to be. Their whole meaning and virtue is in
their unredeemed low-ness, not only in the sense of obscenity,
but lowness of outlook in every direction whatever. The slightest
hint of 'higher' influences would ruin them utterly. They stand
for the worm's-eye view of life, for the music-hall world where
marriage is a dirty joke or a comic disaster, where the rent is
always behind and the clothes are always up the spout, where the
lawyer is always a crook and the Scotsman always a miser, where
the newly-weds make fools of themselves on the hideous beds of
seaside lodging-houses and the drunken, red-nosed husbands roll
home at four in the morning to meet the linen-nightgowned wives
who wait for them behind the front door, poker in hand.
Their
existence, the fact that people want them, is symptomatically
important.
Like the music halls, they are a sort of saturnalia, a
harmless rebellion against virtue. They express only one tendency
in the human mind, but a tendency which is always there and will
find its own outlet, like water.
On the whole, human beings want
to be good, but not too good, and not quite all the time.
For:
there is a just man that perished in his righteousness, and there
is a wicked man that prolongeth his life in his wickedness. Be
not righteous overmuch; neither make thyself over wise; why
shouldst thou destroy thyself? Be not overmuch wicked, neither be
thou foolish: why shouldst thou die before thy time?


In the past the mood of the comic post card could enter into the
central stream of literature, and jokes barely different from
McGill's could casually be uttered between the murders in
Shakespeare's tragedies. That is no longer possible, and
a whole
category of humour, integral to our literature till 1800 or
thereabouts, has dwindled down to these ill-drawn post cards,
leading a barely legal existence in cheap stationers' windows.

The corner of the human heart that they speak for might easily
manifest itself in worse forms, and I for one should be sorry to
see them vanish.




THE LION AND THE UNICORN: SOCIALISM AND THE ENGLISH GENIUS


Part I

England Your England


i.

As I write, highly civilized human beings are flying overhead,
trying to kill me.

They do not feel any enmity against me as an individual, nor I
against them. They are 'only doing their duty', as the saying
goes. Most of them, I have no doubt, are kind-hearted law-abiding
men who would never dream of committing murder in private life.
On the other hand, if one of them succeeds in blowing me to
pieces with a well-placed bomb, he will never sleep any the worse
for it. He is serving his country, which has the power to absolve
him from evil.


One cannot see the modern world as it is unless one recognizes
the overwhelming strength of patriotism, national loyalty. In
certain circumstances it can break down, at certain levels of
civilization it does not exist, but as a positive force there is
nothing to set beside it. Christianity and international
Socialism are as weak as straw in comparison with it. Hitler and
Mussolini rose to power in their own countries very largely
because they could grasp this fact and their opponents could not.


Also, one must admit that the divisions between nation and nation
are founded on real differences of outlook. Till recently it was
thought proper to pretend that all human beings are very much
alike, but in fact anyone able to use his eyes knows that the
average of human behaviour differs enormously from country to
country. Things that could happen in one country could not happen
in another. Hitler's June purge, for instance, could not have
happened in England. And, as western peoples go, the English are
very highly differentiated. There is a sort of back-handed
admission of this in the dislike which nearly all foreigners feel
for our national way of life. Few Europeans can endure living in
England, and even Americans often feel more at home in Europe.


When you come back to England from any foreign country, you have
immediately the sensation of breathing a different air. Even in
the first few minutes dozens of small things conspire to give you
this feeling.
The beer is bitterer, the coins are heavier, the
grass is greener, the advertisements are more blatant. The crowds
in the big towns, with their mild knobby faces, their bad teeth
and gentle manners, are different from a European crowd. Then the
vastness of England swallows you up, and you lose for a while
your feeling that the whole nation has a single identifiable
character. Are there really such things as nations? Are we not
forty-six million individuals, all different? And the diversity
of it, the chaos! The clatter of clogs in the Lancashire mill
towns, the to-and-fro of the lorries on the Great North Road, the
queues outside the Labour Exchanges, the rattle of pin-tables in
the Soho pubs, the old maids hiking to Holy Communion through the
mists of the autumn morning—all these are not only fragments, but
characteristic fragments, of the English scene. How can one make
a pattern out of this muddle?


But talk to foreigners, read foreign books or newspapers, and you
are brought back to the same thought. Yes, there is something
distinctive and recognizable in English civilization. It is a
culture as individual as that of Spain.
It is somehow bound up
with solid breakfasts and gloomy Sundays, smoky towns and winding
roads, green fields and red pillar-boxes.
It has a flavour of its
own.
Moreover it is continuous, it stretches into the future and
the past, there is something in it that persists, as in a living
creature.
What can the England of 1940 have in common with the
England of 1840? But then, what have you in common with the child
of five whose photograph your mother keeps on the mantelpiece?
Nothing, except that you happen to be the same person.

And above all, it is your civilization, it is you. However much
you hate it or laugh at it, you will never be happy away from
it for any length of time. The suet puddings and the red
pillar-boxes have entered into your soul. Good or evil, it is
yours, you belong to it, and this side the grave you will never
get away from the marks that it has given you.


Meanwhile England, together with the rest of the world, is
changing. And like everything else it can change only in certain
directions, which up to a point can be foreseen. That is not to
say that the future is fixed, merely that certain alternatives
are possible and others not. A seed may grow or not grow, but at
any rate a turnip seed never grows into a parsnip. It is
therefore of the deepest importance to try and determine what
England is, before guessing what part England can play in the
huge events that are happening.


ii.

National characteristics are not easy to pin down, and when
pinned down they often turn out to be trivialities or seem to
have no connexion with one another.
Spaniards are cruel to
animals, Italians can do nothing without making a deafening
noise, the Chinese are addicted to gambling. Obviously such
things don't matter in themselves. Nevertheless, nothing is
causeless, and even the fact that Englishmen have bad teeth
can tell something about the realities of English life.

Here are a couple of generalizations about England that would be
accepted by almost all observers. One is that the
English are not
gifted artistically.
They are not as musical as the Germans or
Italians, painting and sculpture have never flourished in England
as they have in France. Another is that, as Europeans go, the

English are not intellectual. They have a horror of abstract
thought, they feel no need for any philosophy or systematic
'world-view'.
Nor is this because they are 'practical', as they
are so fond of claiming for themselves. One has only to look at
their methods of town planning and water supply, their obstinate
clinging to everything that is out of date and a nuisance, a
spelling system that defies analysis, and a system of weights and
measures that is intelligible only to the compilers of arithmetic
books, to see how little they care about mere efficiency. But
they have a certain power of acting without taking thought. Their
world-famed hypocrisy—their double-faced attitude towards the
Empire, for instance—is bound up with this. Also,
in moments of
supreme crisis the whole nation can suddenly draw together and
act upon a species of instinct, really a code of conduct which is
understood by almost everyone, though never formulated.
The
phrase that Hitler coined for the Germans, 'a sleep-walking
people', would have been better applied to the English.
Not that
there is anything to be proud of in being called a sleep-walker.

But here it is worth noting a minor English trait which is ex-
tremely well marked though not often commented on, and that is
a love of flowers. This is one of the first things that one
notices when one reaches England from abroad, especially if one
is coming from southern Europe. Does it not contradict the
English indifference to the arts? Not really, because it is found
in people who have no aesthetic feelings whatever. What it does
link up with, however, is another English characteristic which is
so much a part of us that we barely notice it, and that is
the
addiction to hobbies and spare-time occupations, the privateness
of English life. We are a nation of flower-lovers, but also a
nation of stamp-collectors, pigeon-fanciers, amateur carpenters,
coupon-snippers, darts-players, crossword-puzzle fans.
All the
culture that is most truly native centres round things which even
when they are communal are not official—the pub, the football
match,
the back garden, the fireside and the 'nice cup of tea'.
The liberty of the individual is still believed in
, almost as in
the nineteenth century. But
this has nothing to do with eco-
nomic liberty, the right to exploit others for profit. It is the
liberty to have a home of your own, to do what you like in your
spare time
, to choose your own amusements instead of having
them chosen for you from above. The most hateful of all names
in an English ear is Nosey Parker. It is obvious, of course, that
even
this purely private liberty is a lost cause. Like all other
modern people, the English are in process of being numbered,
labelled, conscripted, 'co-ordinated'. But the pull of their
impulses is in the other direction
, and the kind of regimentation
that can be imposed on them will be modified in consequence.
No party rallies, no Youth Movements, no coloured shirts, no
Jew-baiting or 'spontaneous' demonstrations. No Gestapo either,
in all probability.


But in all societies the common people must live to some extent
against the existing order. The genuinely popular culture of
England is something that goes on beneath the surface,
unofficially and more or less frowned on by the authorities. One
thing one notices if one looks directly at the common people,
especially in the big towns, is that
they are not puritanical.
They are inveterate gamblers, drink as much beer as their wages
will permit, are devoted to bawdy jokes, and use probably the
foulest language in the world.
They have to satisfy these tastes
in the face of astonishing, hypocritical laws (licensing laws,
lottery acts, etc. etc.) which are designed to interfere with
everybody but in practice allow everything to happen. Also, the
common people are without definite religious belief, and have
been so for centuries. The Anglican Church never had a real hold
on them, it was simply a preserve of the landed gentry, and the
Nonconformist sects only influenced minorities. And yet
they have
retained a deep tinge of Christian feeling, while almost forge-
tting the name of Christ. The power-worship
which is the new
religion of Europe, and which has infected the English
intelligentsia,
has never touched the common people. They have
never caught up with power politics. The 'realism' which is
preached in Japanese and Italian newspapers would horrify them.
One can learn a good deal about the spirit of England from the
comic coloured postcards that you see in the windows of cheap
stationers' shops. These things are a sort of diary upon which
the English people have unconsciously recorded themselves.
Their
old-fashioned outlook, their graded snobberies, their mixture of
bawdiness and hypocrisy, their extreme gentleness, their deeply
moral attitude to life
, are all mirrored there.

The gentleness of the English civilization is perhaps its most
marked characteristic. You notice it the instant you set foot on
English soil. It is a land where the bus conductors are good-
tempered and the policemen carry no revolvers. In no country
inhabited by white men is it easier to shove people off the
pavement. And with this goes something that is always
written off
by European observers as 'decadence' or hypocrisy, the English
hatred of war and militarism.
It is rooted deep in history, and
it is strong in the lower-middle class as well as the working
class. Successive wars have shaken it but not destroyed it. Well
within living memory it was common for 'the redcoats' to be booed
at in the streets and for the landlords of respectable public
houses to refuse to allow soldiers on the premises. In peace
time, even when there are two million unemployed, it is difficult
to fill the ranks of the tiny standing army, which is officered
by the country gentry and a specialized stratum of the middle
class, and manned by farm labourers and slum proletarians. The
mass of the people are without military knowledge or tradition,
and their attitude towards war is invariably defensive. N
o
politician could rise to power by promising them conquests or
military 'glory', no Hymn of Hate has ever made any appeal to
them.
In the last war the songs which the soldiers made up and
sang of their own accord were not vengeful but humorous and
mock-defeatist
[Note, below]. The only enemy they ever named
was the sergeant-major.


[Note: For example:

'I don't want to join the bloody Army,
I don't want to go unto the war;
I want no more to roam,
I'd rather stay at home,
Living on the earnings of a whore
.

But it was not in that spirit that they fought. (Author's
footnote.)]

In England all the boasting and flag-wagging, the 'Rule
Britannia' stuff, is done by small minorities. The patriotism of
the common people is not vocal or even conscious. They do not
retain among their historical memories the name of a single
military victory. English literature, like other literatures, is
full of battle-poems, but it is worth noticing that the ones that
have won for themselves a kind of popularity are always a tale of
disasters and retreats. There is no popular poem about Trafalgar
or Waterloo, for instance. Sir John Moore's army at Corunna,
fighting a desperate rearguard action before escaping overseas
(just like Dunkirk!) has more appeal than a brilliant victory.
The most stirring battle-poem in English is about a brigade of
cavalry which charged in the wrong direction. And of the last
war, the four names which have really engraved themselves on the
popular memory are Mons, Ypres, Gallipoli and Passchendaele,
every time a disaster.
The names of the great battles that
finally broke the German armies are simply unknown to the
general public.

The reason why the English anti-militarism disgusts foreign
observers is that it ignores the existence of the British Empire.
It looks like sheer hypocrisy. After all, the English have
absorbed a quarter of the earth and held on to it by means of a
huge navy. How dare they then turn round and say that war is
wicked?


It is quite true that the English are hypocritical about their
Empire. In the working class this hypocrisy takes the form of not
knowing that the Empire exists.
But their dislike of standing
armies is a perfectly sound instinct.
A navy employs
comparatively few people, and it is an external weapon which
cannot affect home politics directly. Military dictatorships
exist everywhere, but
there is no such thing as a naval
dictatorship.
What English people of nearly all classes loathe
from the bottom of their hearts is the swaggering officer type,
the jingle of spurs and the crash of boots. Decades before Hitler
was ever heard of, the word 'Prussian' had much the same
significance in England as 'Nazi' has today.
So deep does this
feeling go that for a hundred years past the officers of the
British army, in peace time, have always worn civilian clothes
when off duty.

One rapid but fairly sure guide to the social atmosphere of a
country is the parade-step of its army. A military parade is
really a kind of ritual dance, something like a ballet,
expressing a certain philosophy of life. The goose-step, for
instance, is one of the most horrible sights in the world, far
more terrifying than a dive-bomber. It is simply an affirmation
of naked power; contained in it, quite consciously and
intentionally, is the vision of a boot crashing down on a face.
Its ugliness is part of its essence, for what it is saying is
'Yes, I am ugly, and you daren't laugh at me'
, like the bully who
makes faces at his victim. Why is the goose-step not used in
England? There are, heaven knows, plenty of army officers who
would be only too glad to introduce some such thing. It is not
used because the people in the street would laugh.
Beyond a
certain point, military display is only possible in countries
where the common people dare not laugh at the army.
The Italians
adopted the goose-step at about the time when Italy passed
definitely under German control, and, as one would expect, they
do it less well than the Germans. The Vichy government, if it
survives, is bound to introduce a stiffer parade-ground
discipline into what is left of the French army.
In the British
army the drill is rigid and complicated, full of memories of the
eighteenth century, but without definite swagger; the march is
merely a formalized walk.
It belongs to a society which is ruled
by the sword, no doubt, but a sword which must never be taken out
of the scabbard.

And yet the gentleness of English civilization is mixed up with
barbarities and anachronisms. Our criminal law is as out-of-date
as the muskets in the Tower. Over against the Nazi Storm Trooper
you have got to set
that typically English figure, the hanging
judge, some gouty old bully with his mind rooted in the
nineteenth century, handing out savage sentences. In England
people are still hanged by the neck and flogged with the cat o'
nine tails.
Both of these punishments are obscene as well as
cruel, but there has never been any genuinely popular outcry
against them.
People accept them (and Dartmoor, and Borstal)
almost as they accept the weather. They are part of 'the law',
which is assumed to be unalterable.


Here one comes upon an all-important English trait: the respect
for constitutionalism and legality, the belief in 'the law' as
something above the State and above the individual, something
which is cruel and stupid, of course, but at any rate incorruptible.

It is not that anyone imagines the law to be just. Everyone knows
that there is one law for the rich and another for the poor. But
no one accepts the implications of this, everyone takes it for
granted that the law, such as it is, will be respected, and feels
a sense of outrage when it is not.
Remarks like 'They can't run
me in; I haven't done anything wrong', or 'They can't do that;
it's against the law', are part of the atmosphere of England. The
professed enemies of society have this feeling as strongly as
anyone else. One sees it in prison-books like Wilfred Macartney's
Walls Have Mouths or Jim Phelan's Jail Journey, in the solemn
idiocies that take place at the trials of conscientious
objectors, in letters to the papers from eminent Marxist
professors, pointing out that this or that is a 'miscarriage of
British justice'. Everyone believes in his heart that the law can
be, ought to be, and, on the whole, will be impartially
administered.
The totalitarian idea that there is no such thing
as law, there is only power, has never taken root.
Even the
intelligentsia have only accepted it in theory.


An illusion can become a half-truth, a mask can alter the
expression of a face. The familiar arguments to the effect
that democracy is 'just the same as' or 'just as bad as'
totalitarianism never take account of this fact. All such
arguments boil down to saying that half a loaf is the same as no
bread.
In England such concepts as justice, liberty and objective
truth are still believed in. They may be illusions, but they are
very powerful illusions. The belief in them influences conduct,

national life is different because of them. In proof of which,
look about you. Where are the rubber truncheons, where is the
castor oil? The sword is still in the scabbard, and while it
stays there corruption cannot go beyond a certain point. The
English electoral system, for instance, is an all but open fraud.
In a dozen obvious ways it is gerrymandered in the interest of
the moneyed class. But until some deep change has occurred in
the public mind, it cannot become completely corrupt.
You do not
arrive at the polling booth to find men with revolvers telling
you which way to vote, nor are the votes miscounted
, nor is there
any direct bribery. Even hypocrisy is a powerful safeguard.
The
hanging judge, that evil old man in scarlet robe and horse-hair
wig, whom nothing short of dynamite will ever teach what cen-
tury he is living in, but who
will at any rate interpret the law
according to the books and
will in no circumstances take a money
bribe
, is one of the symbolic figures of England. He is a symbol
of the strange mixture of reality and illusion, democracy and
privilege, humbug and decency, the subtle network of compro-
mises, by which the nation keeps itself in its familiar shape.


iii.

I have spoken all the while of 'the nation', 'England',
'Britain', as though forty-five million souls could somehow be
treated as a unit. But is not England notoriously two nations,
the rich and the poor?
Dare one pretend that there is anything in
common between people with £100,000 a year and people with £1 a
week?
And even Welsh and Scottish readers are likely to have been
offended because I have used the word 'England' oftener than
'Britain', as though the whole population dwelt in London and the
Home Counties and neither north nor west possessed a culture of
its own.


One gets a better view of this question if one considers the
minor point first. It is quite true that the so-called races of
Britain feel themselves to be very different from one another. A
Scotsman, for instance, does not thank you if you call him an
Englishman. You can see the hesitation we feel on this point by
the fact that we call our islands by no less than six different
names, England, Britain, Great Britain, the British Isles, the
United Kingdom and, in very exalted moments, Albion. Even the
differences between north and south England loom large
in our own
eyes. But somehow these differences fade away the moment that any
two Britons are confronted by a European. It is very rare to meet
a foreigner, other than an American, who can distinguish between
English and Scots or even English and Irish. To a Frenchman, the
Breton and the Auvergnat seem very different beings, and the
accent of Marseilles is a stock joke in Paris. Yet we speak of
'France' and 'the French', recognizing France as an entity, a
single civilization, which in fact it is. So also with ourselves.
Looked at from the outsider even the cockney and the York-
shireman have a strong family resemblance.


And even the distinction between rich and poor dwindles some-
what when one regards the nation from the outside. There is no
question about the inequality of wealth in England. It is grosser
than in any European country, and you have only to look down the
nearest street to see it. Economically, England is certainly two
nations, if not three or four. But at the same time the vast
majority of the people feel themselves to be a single nation
and
are conscious of resembling one another more than they resemble
foreigners. Patriotism is usually stronger than class-hatred, and
always stronger than any kind of internationalism. Except for a
brief moment in 1920 (the 'Hands off Russia' movement) the
British working class have never thought or acted interna-
tionally. For two and a half years they watched their comrades
in Spain slowly strangled, and never aided them by even
a single strike
[Note, below]. But when their own country (the
country of Lord Nuffield and Mr Montagu Norman) was in danger,
their attitude was very different. At the moment when it seemed
likely that England might be invaded, Anthony Eden appealed over
the radio for Local Defence Volunteers. He got a quarter of a
million men in the first twenty-four hours, and another million
in the subsequent month. One has only to compare these figures
with, for instance, the number of conscientious objectors to see
how vast is the strength of traditional loyalties compared with
new ones.


[Note: It is true that they aided them to a certain extent with
money. Still, the sums raised for the various aid-Spain funds
would not equal five per cent of the turnover of the football
pools during the same period. (Author's footnote.)]

In England patriotism takes different forms in different classes,
but it runs like a connecting thread through nearly all of them.
Only the Europeanized intelligentsia are really immune to it. As
a positive emotion it is stronger in the middle class than in the
upper class—the cheap public schools, for instance, are more
given to patriotic demonstrations than the expensive ones
—but the
number of definitely treacherous rich men, the Laval-Quisling
type, is probably very small. In the working class patriotism is
profound, but it is unconscious.
The working man's heart does not
leap when he sees a Union Jack. But the famous 'insularity' and
'xenophobia' of the English is far stronger in the working class
than in the bourgeoisie.
In all countries the poor are more
national than the rich, but the English working class are
outstanding in their abhorrence of foreign habits. Even when
they are obliged to live abroad for years they refuse either to
accustom themselves to foreign food or to learn foreign
languages.
Nearly every Englishman of working-class origin
considers it effeminate to pronounce a foreign word correctly.
During the war of 1914-18 the English working class were in
contact with foreigners to an extent that is rarely possible. The
sole result was that they brought back a hatred of all Europeans,
except the Germans, whose courage they admired. In four years
on French soil they did not even acquire a liking for wine.
The
insularity of the English, their refusal to take foreigners
seriously, is a folly that has to be paid for very heavily from
time to time. But it plays its part in the English mystique, and
the intellectuals who have tried to break it down have generally
done more harm than good. At bottom it is the same quality in the
English character that repels the tourist and keeps out the
invader.


Here one comes back to two English characteristics that I pointed
out, seemingly at random, at the beginning of the last chapter.
One is the lack of artistic ability. This is perhaps another way
of saying that the English are outside the European culture. For
there is one art in which they have shown plenty of talent,
namely literature. But this is also the only art that cannot
cross frontiers. Literature, especially poetry, and lyric poetry
most of all, is a kind of family joke, with little or no value
outside its own language-group. Except for Shakespeare
, the best
English poets are barely known in Europe, even as names. The only
poets who are widely read are Byron, who is admired for the wrong
reasons, and Oscar Wilde, who is pitied as a victim of English
hypocrisy. And linked up with this, though not very obviously, is
the lack of philosophical faculty, the absence in nearly all
Englishmen of any need for an ordered system of thought or even
for the use of logic.


Up to a point, the sense of national unity is a substitute for a
'world-view'. Just because patriotism is all but universal and
not even the rich are uninfluenced by it, there can be moments
when the whole nation suddenly swings together and does the
same thing, like a herd of cattle facing a wolf. There was such a
moment, unmistakably, at the time of the disaster in France.
After eight months of vaguely wondering what the war was about,
the people suddenly knew what they had got to do: first, to get
the army away from Dunkirk, and secondly to prevent invasion. It
was like the awakening of a giant. Quick! Danger! The Philistines
be upon thee, Samson!
And then the swift unanimous action—and,
then, alas, the prompt relapse into sleep.
In a divided nation
that would have been exactly the moment for a big peace movement
to arise. But does this mean that the instinct of the English
will always tell them to do the right thing? Not at all, merely
that it will tell them to do the same thing. In the 1931 General
Election, for instance, we all did the wrong thing in perfect
unison. We were as single-minded as the Gadarene swine. But I
honestly doubt whether we can say that we were shoved down the
slope against our will.

It follows that British democracy is less of a fraud than it
sometimes appears. A foreign observer sees only the huge
inequality of wealth, the unfair electoral system, the
governing-class control over the press, the radio and education,
and concludes that democracy is simply a polite name for
dictatorship. But this ignores the considerable agreement that
does unfortunately exist between the leaders and the led. However
much one may hate to admit it, it is almost certain that
between
1931 and 1940 the National Government represented the will of
the mass of the people. It tolerated slums, unemployment and a
cowardly foreign policy. Yes, but so did public opinion. It was a
stagnant period, and its natural leaders were mediocrities.


In spite of the campaigns of a few thousand left-wingers, it is
fairly certain that the bulk of the English people were behind
Chamberlain's foreign policy. More, it is fairly certain that
the
same struggle was going on in Chamberlain's mind as in the minds
of ordinary people.
His opponents professed to see in him a dark
and wily schemer, plotting to sell England to Hitler, but it is
far likelier that he was merely a stupid old man doing his best
according to his very dim lights. It is difficult otherwise to
explain the contradictions of his policy, his failure to grasp
any of the courses that were open to him.
Like the mass of the
people, he did not want to pay the price either of peace or of
war.
And public opinion was behind him all the while, in policies
that were completely incompatible with one another. It was be-
hind him when he went to Munich, when he tried to come to an
understanding with Russia, when he gave the guarantee to
Poland, when he honoured it, and when he prosecuted the war
half-heartedly.
Only when the results of his policy became
apparent did it turn against him; which is to say that it turned
against its own lethargy of the past seven years.
Thereupon the
people picked a leader nearer to their mood, Churchill, who was
at any rate able to grasp that wars are not won without fighting.
Later, perhaps, they will pick another leader who can grasp that
only Socialist nations can fight effectively.


Do I mean by all this that England is a genuine democracy? No,
not even a reader of the Daily Telegraph could quite swallow
that.

England is the most class-ridden country under the sun. It is
a land of snobbery and privilege, ruled largely by the old and
silly.
But in any calculation about it one has got to take into
account its emotional unity, the tendency of nearly all its
inhabitants to feel alike and act together in moments of su-
preme crisis.
It is the only great country in Europe that is not
obliged to drive hundreds of thousands of its nationals into
exile or the concentration camp. At this moment, after a year of
war, newspapers and pamphlets abusing the Government, praising
the enemy and clamouring for surrender are being sold on the
streets, almost without interference. And this is less from a
respect for freedom of speech than from a simple perception that
these things don't matter. It is safe to let a paper like Peace
News
be sold, because it is certain that ninety-five per cent of
the population will never want to read it. The nation is bound
together by an invisible chain. At any normal time the ruling
class will rob, mismanage, sabotage, lead us into the muck; but
let popular opinion really make itself heard, let them get a tug
from below that they cannot avoid feeling, and it is difficult
for them not to respond.
The left-wing writers who denounce the
whole of the ruling class as 'pro-Fascist' are grossly
over-simplifying.
Even among the inner clique of politicians who
brought us to our present pass, it is doubtful whether there were
any conscious traitors. The corruption that happens in England is
seldom of that kind. Nearly always it is more in the nature of
self-deception, of the right hand not knowing what the left hand
doeth. And being unconscious, it is limited. One sees this at its
most obvious in the English press. Is the English press honest or
dishonest? At normal times it is deeply dishonest. All the papers
that matter live off their advertisements, and the advertisers
exercise an indirect censorship over news. Yet I do not suppose
there is one paper in England that can be straightforwardly
bribed with hard cash.
In the France of the Third Republic all
but a very few of the newspapers could notoriously be bought over
the counter like so many pounds of cheese. Public life in England
has never been openly scandalous. It has not reached the pitch of
disintegration at which humbug can be dropped.


England is not the jewelled isle of Shakespeare's much-quoted
message, nor is it the inferno depicted by Dr Goebbels. More than
either it resembles a family,
a rather stuffy Victorian family,
with not many black sheep in it but with all its cupboards
bursting with skeletons. It has rich relations who have to be
kow-towed to and poor relations who are horribly sat upon, and
there is a deep conspiracy of silence about the source of the
family income. It is a family in which the young are generally
thwarted and most of the power is in the hands of irresponsible
uncles and bedridden aunts.
Still, it is a family. It has its private
language and its common memories, and at the approach of an
enemy it closes its ranks. A family with the wrong members in
control—that, perhaps, is as near as one can come to describing
England in a phrase.


iv.

Probably the battle of Waterloo was won on the playing-fields of
Eton, but the opening battles of all subsequent wars have been
lost there. One of the dominant facts in English life during the
past three quarters of a century has been
the decay of ability in
the ruling class.


In the years between 1920 and 1940 it
was happening with the
speed of a chemical reaction.
Yet at the moment of writing it is
still possible to speak of a ruling class. Like the knife which
has had two new blades and three new handles, the upper fringe of
English society is still almost what it was in the mid nineteenth
century.
After 1832 * the old land-owning aristocracy steadily
lost power, but instead of disappearing or becoming a fossil they
simply intermarried with the merchants, manufacturers and
financiers who had replaced them, and soon turned them into
accurate copies of themselves.
The wealthy ship owner or
cotton-miller set up for himself an alibi as a country gentleman,
while his sons learned the right mannerisms at public schools
which had been designed for just that purpose. England was ruled
by an aristocracy constantly recruited from parvenus. And
considering what energy the self-made men possessed, and
considering that they were buying their way into a class which
at any rate had a tradition of public service, one might have
expected that able rulers could be produced in some such way.

And yet somehow the ruling class decayed, lost its ability, its
daring, finally even its ruthlessness, until a time came when
stuffed shirts like Eden or Halifax could stand out as men of
exceptional talent. As for Baldwin, one could not even dignify
him with the name of stuffed shirt. He was simply a hole in the
air.
The mishandling of England's domestic problems during the
nineteen-twenties had been bad enough, but British foreign policy
between 1931 and 1939 is one of the wonders of the world. Why?
What had happened? What was it that at every decisive moment made
every British statesman do the wrong thing with so unerring an
instinct?


The underlying fact was that the whole position of the moneyed
class had long ceased to be justifiable. There they sat, at the
centre of a vast empire and a world-wide financial network,
drawing interest and profits and spending them—on what?
It
was fair to say that life within the British Empire was in many
ways better than life outside it. Still, the Empire was under-
developed,
India slept in the Middle Ages, the Dominions lay
empty, with foreigners jealously barred out, and
even England was
full of slums and unemployment.
Only half a million people, the
people in the country houses, definitely benefited from the
existing system. Moreover,
the tendency of small businesses to
merge together into large ones robbed more and more of the
moneyed class of their function and turned them into mere own-
ers, their work being done for them by salaried managers and
technicians. For long past there had been in England an entirely
functionless class, living on money that was invested they hardly
knew where, the 'idle rich', the people whose photographs you can
look at in the Tatler and the Bystander, always supposing that
you want to. The existence of these people was by any standard
unjustifiable. They were simply parasites, less useful to society
than his fleas are to a dog.


By 1920 there were many people who were aware of all this. By
1930 millions were aware of it. But the British ruling class
obviously could not admit to themselves that their usefulness was
at an end. Had they done that they would have had to abdicate.
For
it was not possible for them to turn themselves into mere
bandits, like the American millionaires, consciously clinging to
unjust privileges and beating down opposition by bribery and
tear-gas bombs.
After all, they belonged to a class with a
certain tradition, they had been to public schools where the duty
of dying for your country, if necessary, is laid down as the
first and greatest of the Commandments. They had to feel
themselves true patriots, even while they plundered their
countrymen. Clearly
there was only one escape for them—into
stupidity. They could keep society in its existing shape only by
being unable to grasp that any improvement was possible.
Difficult though this was, they achieved it, largely by fixing
their eyes on the past and refusing to notice the changes that
were going on round them.

There is much in England that this explains. It explains the
decay of country life, due to the keeping-up of a sham feudalism
which drives the more spirited workers off the land. It explains
the immobility of the public schools, which have barely altered
since the eighties of the last century. It explains the military
incompetence which has again and again startled the world.
Since
the fifties every war in which England has engaged has started
off with a series of disasters, after which the situation has
been saved by people comparatively low in the social scale. The
higher commanders, drawn from the aristocracy, could never
prepare for modern war, because in order to do so they would have
had to admit to themselves that the world was changing.
They have
always clung to obsolete methods and weapons, because they
inevitably saw each war as a repetition of the last. Before the
Boer War they prepared for the Zulu War, before the 1914 for the
Boer War, and before the present war for 1914. Even at this
moment hundreds of thousands of men in England are being trained
with the bayonet, a weapon entirely useless except for opening
tins.
It is worth noticing that the navy and, latterly, the air force,
have always been more efficient than the regular army. But
the navy is only partially, and the air force hardly at all, within
the ruling-class orbit.

It must be admitted that so long as things were peaceful the
methods of the British ruling class served them well enough.
Their own people manifestly tolerated them.
However unjustly
England might be organized, it was at any rate not torn by class
warfare or haunted by secret police. The Empire was peaceful as
no area of comparable size has ever been. Throughout its vast
extent, nearly a quarter of the earth, there were fewer armed men
than would be found necessary by a minor Balkan state.
As peo-
ple to live under, and looking at them merely from a liberal,
negative standpoint, the British ruling class had their points.
They were preferable to the truly modern men, the Nazis and
Fascists.
But it had long been obvious that they would be
helpless against any serious attack from the outside.

They could not struggle against Nazism or Fascism, because they
could not understand them. Neither could they have struggled
against Communism, if Communism had been a serious force in
western Europe. To understand Fascism they would have had to
study the theory of Socialism, which would have forced them to
realize that the economic system by which they lived was unjust,
inefficient and out-of-date. But it was exactly this fact that
they had trained themselves never to face. They dealt with
Fascism as the cavalry generals of 1914 dealt with the
machine-guns—by ignoring it.
After years of aggression and
massacres, they had grasped only one fact, that Hitler and
Mussolini were hostile to Communism. Therefore, it was argued,
they must be friendly to the British dividend-drawer. Hence the
truly frightening spectacle of Conservative M.P.s wildly cheering
the news that British ships, bringing food to the Spanish Re-
publican government, had been bombed by Italian aeroplanes.

Even when they had begun to grasp that Fascism was dangerous,
its essentially revolutionary nature, the huge military effort it was
capable of making, the sort of tactics it would use, were quite
beyond their comprehension. At the time of the Spanish Civil War,
anyone with as much political knowledge as can be acquired from
a sixpenny pamphlet on Socialism knew that, if Franco won, the
result would be strategically disastrous for England; and yet
generals and admirals who had given their lives to the study of
war were unable to grasp this fact. This vein of political
ignorance runs right through English official life, through
Cabinet ministers, ambassadors, consuls, judges, magistrates,
policemen.
The policeman who arrests the 'red' does not
understand the theories the 'red' is preaching; if he did his own
position as bodyguard of the moneyed class might seem less
pleasant to him.
There is reason to think that even military
espionage is hopelessly hampered by ignorance of the new eco-
nomic doctrines and the ramifications of the underground parties.

The British ruling class were not altogether wrong in thinking
that Fascism was on their side. It is a fact that any rich man,
unless he is a Jew, has less to fear from Fascism than from
either Communism or democratic Socialism. One ought never
to forget this, for nearly the whole of German and Italian
propaganda is designed to cover it up.
The natural instinct of
men like Simon, Hoare, Chamberlain etc. was to come to an
agreement with Hitler. But
—and here the peculiar feature of
English life that I have spoken of, the deep sense of national
solidarity, comes in—
they could only do so by breaking up the
Empire and selling their own people into semi-slavery. A truly
corrupt class would have done this without hesitation, as in
France. But things had not gone that distance in England.
Politicians who would make cringing speeches about 'the duty
of loyalty to our conquerors' are hardly to be found in English
public life. Tossed to and fro between their incomes and their
principles, it was impossible that men like Chamberlain should
do anything but make the worst of both worlds.


One thing that has always shown that the English ruling class
are morally fairly sound, is that in time of war they are ready
enough to get themselves killed.
Several dukes, earls and what
nots were killed in the recent campaign in Flanders. That could
not happen if these people were the cynical scoundrels that
they are sometimes declared to be. It is important not to
misunderstand their motives, or one cannot predict their actions.
What is to be expected of them is not treachery, or physical
cowardice, but stupidity, unconscious sabotage, an infallible
instinct for doing the wrong thing.
They are not wicked, or not
altogether wicked; they are merely unteachable. Only when their
money and power are gone will the younger among them begin to
grasp what century they are living in.


v.

The stagnation of the Empire in the between-war years affected
everyone in England, but it had an especially direct effect upon
two important sub-sections of the middle class. One was the
military and imperialist middle class, generally nicknamed the
Blimps, and the other the left-wing intelligentsia. These two
seemingly hostile types,
symbolic opposites—the half-pay colonel
with his bull neck and diminutive brain, like a dinosaur, the
highbrow with his domed forehead and stalk-like neck—are mentally
linked together and constantly interact upon one another
; in any
case they are born to a considerable extent into the same
families.


Thirty years ago the Blimp class was already losing its vitality.
The middle-class families celebrated by Kipling,
the prolific
lowbrow families whose sons officered the army and navy and
swarmed over all the waste places of the earth from the Yukon to
the Irrawaddy, were dwindling before 1914. The thing that had
killed them was the telegraph. In a narrowing world, more and
more governed from Whitehall, there was every year less room for
individual initiative.
Men like Clive, Nelson, Nicholson, Gordon
would find no place for themselves in the modern British Empire.
By 1920 nearly every inch of the colonial empire was in the grip
of Whitehall.
Well-meaning, over-civilized men, in dark suits and
black felt hats, with neatly rolled umbrellas crooked over the
left forearm, were imposing their constipated view of life on
Malaya and Nigeria, Mombasa and Mandalay. The one-time empire
builders were reduced to the status of clerks, buried deeper and
deeper under mounds of paper and red tape.
In the early twenties
one could see, all over the Empire, the
older officials, who had
known more spacious days, writhing impotently
under the changes
that were happening. From that time onwards it has been next door
to impossible to induce young men of spirit to take any part in
imperial administration. And what was true of the official world
was true also of the commercial. The great monopoly companies
swallowed up hosts of petty traders.
Instead of going out to
trade adventurously in the Indies one went to an office stool in
Bombay or Singapore.
And life in Bombay or Singapore was act-
ually duller and safer than life in London. Imperialist sentiment
remained strong in the middle class, chiefly owing to family
tradition, but the job of administering the Empire had ceased to
appeal. Few able men went east of Suez if there was any way of
avoiding it.

But the general weakening of imperialism, and to some ex-
tent of the whole British morale, that took place during the
nineteen-thirties, was partly the work of the left-wing
intelligentsia
, itself a kind of growth that had sprouted from
the stagnation of the Empire.

It should be noted that there is now no intelligentsia that is
not in some sense 'left'. Perhaps the last right-wing
intellectual was T. E. Lawrence. Since about 1930 everyone
describable as an 'intellectual' has lived in a state of chronic
discontent with the existing order. Necessarily so, because
society as it was constituted had no room for him. In an Empire
that was simply stagnant, neither being developed nor falling to
pieces, and in an England ruled by people whose chief asset was
their stupidity, to be 'clever' was to be suspect. If you had the
kind of brain that could understand the poems of T. S. Eliot or
the theories of Karl Marx, the higher-ups would see to it that
you were kept out of any important job.
The intellectuals could
find a function for themselves only in the literary reviews and
the left-wing political parties.

The mentality of the English left-wing intelligentsia can be
studied in half a dozen weekly and monthly papers. The
immediately striking thing about all these papers is their
generally negative, querulous attitude, their complete lack at
all times of any constructive suggestion. There is little in them
except the
irresponsible carping of people who have never been
and never expect to be in a position of power.
Another marked
characteristic is the
emotional shallowness of people who live in
a world of ideas and have little contact with physical reality.
Many intellectuals of the Left were flabbily pacifist up to 1935,
shrieked for war against Germany in the years 1935-9, and then
promptly cooled off when the war started.
It is broadly though
not precisely true that the people who were most 'anti-Fascist'
during the Spanish Civil War are most defeatist now. And
underlying this is the really important fact about so many of the
English intelligentsia—their
severance from the common culture of
the country.


In intention, at any rate, the English intelligentsia are
Europeanized.
They take their cookery from Paris and their
opinions from Moscow.
In the general patriotism of the country
they form a sort of island of dissident thought. England is
perhaps the only great country whose intellectuals are asham-
ed of their own nationality.
In left-wing circles it is always
felt that there is something slightly disgraceful in being an
Englishman and that it is a duty to snigger at every English
institution, from horse racing to suet puddings. It is a strange
fact, but it is unquestionably true that almost any English
intellectual would feel more ashamed of standing to attention
during 'God save the King' than of stealing from a poor box.
All
through the critical years many left-wingers were chipping away
at English morale, trying to spread an outlook that was sometimes
squashily pacifist, sometimes violently pro-Russian, but always
anti-British.
It is questionable how much effect this had, but it
certainly had some. If the English people suffered for several
years a real weakening of morale, so that the Fascist nations
judged that they were 'decadent' and that it was safe to plunge
into war, the intellectual sabotage from the Left was partly
responsible.
Both the New Statesman and the News Chronicle
cried out against the Munich settlement, but even they had
done something to make it possible. Ten years of systematic
Blimp-baiting affected even the Blimps themselves and made it
harder than it had been before to get intelligent young men to
enter the armed forces. Given the stagnation of the Empire, the
military middle class must have decayed in any case, but the
spread of a shallow Leftism hastened the process.


It is clear that the special position of the English intellect-
uals during the past ten years, as purely negative creatures,
mere anti-Blimps, was a by-product of ruling-class stupidity.
Society could not use them, and they had not got it in them to
see that devotion to one's country implies 'for better, for
worse'.
Both Blimps and highbrows took for granted, as though
it were a law of nature, the divorce between patriotism and
intelligence. If you were a patriot you read Blackwood's Magazine
and publicly thanked God that you were 'not brainy'. If you were
an intellectual you sniggered at the Union Jack and regarded
physical courage as barbarous.
It is obvious that this prepos-
terous convention cannot continue. The Bloomsbury highbrow,
with his mechanical snigger, is as out-of-date as the cavalry
colonel. A modern nation cannot afford either of them. Patriotism
and intelligence will have to come together again. It is the fact
that we are fighting a war, and a very peculiar kind of war, that
may make this possible.


vi.

One of the most important developments in England during the past
twenty years has been the upward and downward extension of the
middle class. It has happened on such a scale as to make the old
classification of society into capitalists, proletarians and
petit bourgeois (small property-owners) almost obsolete.

England is a country in which property and financial power are
concentrated in very few hands. Few people in modern England own
anything at all, except clothes, furniture and possibly a house.
The peasantry have long since disappeared, the independent
shopkeeper is being destroyed, the small businessman is
diminishing in numbers. But at the same time modern industry is
so complicated that it cannot get along without great numbers of
managers, salesmen, engineers, chemists and technicians of all
kinds, drawing fairly large salaries.
And these in turn call into
being a professional class of doctors, lawyers, teachers,
artists, etc. etc. The tendency of advanced capitalism has
therefore been to enlarge the middle class and not to wipe it out
as it once seemed likely to do.

But much more important than this is the spread of middle-class
ideas and habits among the working class. The British working
class are now better off in almost all ways than they were thirty
years ago. This is partly due to the efforts of the trade unions,
but partly to
the mere advance of physical science. It is not
always realized that within rather narrow limits the standard of
life of a country can rise without a corresponding rise in real
wages.
Up to a point, civilization can lift itself up by its
boot-tags. However unjustly society is organized, certain
technical advances are bound to benefit the whole community,
because certain kinds of goods are necessarily held in common.
A millionaire cannot, for example, light the streets for himself
while darkening them for other people. Nearly all citizens of
civilized countries now enjoy the use of good roads, germ-free
water, police protection, free libraries and probably free
education of a kind.
Public education in England has been meanly
starved of money, but it has nevertheless improved, largely owing
to the devoted efforts of the teachers, and the habit of reading
has become enormously more widespread. To an increasing extent
the rich and the poor read the same books, and they also see the
same films and listen to the same radio programmes. And the
differences in their way of life have been diminished by the
mass-production of cheap clothes and improvements in housing.
So far as outward appearance goes, the clothes of rich and poor,
especially in the case of women, differ far less than they did
thirty or even fifteen years ago. As to housing, England still
has slums which are a blot on civilization, but much building has
been done during the past ten years, largely by the local
authorities. The modern council house, with its bathroom and
electric light, is smaller than the stockbroker's villa, but it
is recognizably the same kind of house, which the farm labourer's
cottage is not. A person who has grown up in a council housing
estate is likely to be—indeed, visibly is—more middle class in
outlook than a person who has grown up in a slum.

The effect of all this is a general softening of manners. It is
enhanced by the fact that modern industrial methods tend always
to demand less muscular effort and therefore to leave people with
more energy when their day's work is done.
Many workers in the
light industries are less truly manual labourers than is a doctor
or a grocer. In tastes, habits, manners and outlook the working
class and the middle class are drawing together. The unjust
distinctions remain, but the real differences diminish.
The
old-style 'proletarian'—collarless, unshaven and with muscles
warped by heavy labour
—still exists, but he is constantly
decreasing in numbers; he
only predominates in the heavy-industry
areas of the north of England.


After 1918 there began to appear something that had never existed
in England before: people of indeterminate social class. In 1910
every human being in these islands could be 'placed' in an
instant by his clothes, manners and accent. That is no longer the
case. Above all, it is not the case in the new townships that
have developed as a result of cheap motor cars and the southward
shift of industry.
The place to look for the germs of the future
England is in light-industry areas and along the arterial roads.

In Slough, Dagenham, Barnet, Letchworth, Hayes—everywhere,
indeed, on the outskirts of great towns—the old pattern is
gradually changing into something new.
In those vast new
wildernesses of glass and brick the sharp distinctions of the
older kind of town, with its slums and mansions, or of the
country, with its manor-houses and squalid cottages, no longer
exist. There are wide gradations of income, but it is the same
kind of life that is being lived at different levels, in labour-
saving flats or council houses, along the concrete roads and
in the naked democracy of the swimming-pools. It is a rather
restless, cultureless life, centring round tinned food, Picture
Post, the radio and the internal combustion engine. It is a
civilization in which children grow up with an intimate knowledge
of magnetoes and in complete ignorance of the Bible.
To that
civilization belong the people who are most at home in and most
definitely of the modern world, the technicians and the
higher-paid skilled workers, the airmen and their mechanics, the
radio experts, film producers, popular journalists and industrial
chemists. They are the indeterminate stratum at which the older
class distinctions are beginning to break down.


This war, unless we are defeated, will wipe out most of the
existing class privileges. There are every day fewer people who
wish them to continue. Nor need we fear that as the pattern
changes life in England will lose its peculiar flavour. The new
red cities of Greater London are crude enough, but these things
are only the rash that accompanies a change. In whatever shape
England emerges from the war it will be deeply tinged with the
characteristics that I have spoken of earlier. The intellectuals
who hope to see it Russianized or Germanized will be disap-
pointed.
The gentleness, the hypocrisy, the thoughtlessness,
the reverence for law and the hatred of uniforms will remain,
along with the suet puddings and the misty skies. It needs some
very great disaster, such as prolonged subjugati
on by a foreign
enemy, to destroy a national culture. The Stock Exchange will be
pulled down, the horse plough will give way to the tractor, the
country houses will be turned into children's holiday camps, the
Eton and Harrow match will be forgotten, but
England will still
be England, an everlasting animal stretching into the future and
the past, and, like all living things, having the power to change
out of recognition and yet remain the same.



Part II

Shopkeepers at War


i.

I began this book to the tune of German bombs, and I begin this
second chapter in the added racket of the barrage. The yellow
gun flashes are lighting the sky, the splinters are rattling on the
housetops, and London Bridge is falling down, falling down,
falling down. Anyone able to read a map knows that we are in
deadly danger.
I do not mean that we are beaten or need be
beaten. Almost certainly the outcome depends on our own will. But
at this moment we are in the soup, full fathom five, and we have
been brought there by follies which we are still committing and
which will drown us altogether if we do not mend our ways
quickly.

What this war has demonstrated is that private capitalism, that
is, an economic system in which land, factories, mines and
transport are owned privately and operated solely for profit—does
not work. It cannot deliver the goods.
This fact had been known
to millions of people for years past, but nothing ever came of
it, because there was no real urge from below to alter the
system, and those at the top had trained themselves to be
impenetrably stupid on just this point. Argument and propaganda
got one nowhere. The lords of property simply sat on their
bottoms and proclaimed that all was for the best.
Hitler's
conquest of Europe, however, was a physical debunking of
capitalism. War, for all its evil, is at any rate an unanswerable
test of strength, like a try-your-grip machine. Great strength
returns the penny, and there is no way of faking the result.


When the nautical screw was first invented, there was a
controversy that lasted for years as to whether screw-steamers
or paddle-steamers were better. The paddle-steamers, like all
obsolete things, had their champions, who supported them by
ingenious arguments. Finally, however, a distinguished admiral
tied a screw-steamer and a paddle steamer of equal horse-power
stern to stern and set their engines running. That settled the
question once and for all. And it was something similar that
happened on the fields of Norway and of Flanders. Once and for
all it was proved that a planned economy is stronger than a
planless one.
But it is necessary here to give some kind of
definition to those much-abused words, Socialism and Fascism.

Socialism is usually defined as "common ownership of the means of
production". Crudely: the State, representing the whole nation,
owns everything, and everyone is a State employee. This does not
mean that people are stripped of private possessions such as
clothes and furniture, but it does mean that
all productive
goods, such as land, mines, ships and machinery, are the property
of the State. The State is the sole large-scale producer. It is
not certain that Socialism is in all ways superior to capitalism,
but it is certain that, unlike capitalism, it can solve the
problems of production and consumption. At normal times a
capitalist economy can never consume all that it produces, so
that there is always a wasted surplus (wheat burned in furnaces,
herrings dumped back into the sea etc etc) and always
unemployment. In time of war, on the other hand, it has
difficulty in producing all that it needs, because nothing is
produced unless someone sees his way to making a profit out of
it.
In a Socialist economy these problems do not exist. The State
simply calculates what goods will be needed and does its best to
produce them. Production is only limited by the amount of labour
and raw materials. Money, for internal purposes, ceases to be a
mysterious all-powerful thing and becomes a sort of coupon or
ration-ticket, issued in sufficient quantities to buy up such
consumption goods as may be available at the moment.


However, it has become clear in the last few years that "com-
mon ownership of the means of production" is not in itself a
sufficient definition of Socialism. One must also add the
following:
approximate equality of incomes (it need be no more
than approximate), political democracy, and abolition of all
hereditary privilege, especially in education. These are simply
the necessary safeguards against the reappearance of a class
system. Centralised ownership has very little meaning unless the
mass of the people are living roughly upon an equal level, and
have some kind of control over the government. "The State" may
come to mean no more than a self-elected political party, and
oligarchy and privilege can return, based on power rather than on
money.


But what then is Fascism?

Fascism, at any rate the German version, is a form of capitalism
that borrows from Socialism just such features as will make it
efficient for war purposes.
Internally, Germany has a good deal
in common with a Socialist state. Ownership has never been
abolished, there are still capitalists and workers, and—this is
the important point, and the real reason why rich men all over
the world tend to sympathise with Fascism—generally speaking the
same people are capitalists and the same people workers as before
the Nazi revolution. But at the same time
the State, which is
simply the Nazi Party
, is in control of everything. It controls
investment, raw materials, rates of interest, working hours,
wages. The factory owner still owns his factory, but he is for
practical purposes reduced to the status of a manager.
Everyone
is in effect a State employee, though the salaries vary very
greatly.
The mere efficiency of such a system, the elimination of
waste and obstruction, is obvious. In seven years it has built up
the most powerful war machine the world has ever seen.

But the idea underlying Fascism is irreconcilably different from
that which underlies Socialism.
Socialism aims, ultimately, at a
world-state of free and equal human beings. It takes the equality
of human rights for granted. Nazism assumes just the opposite.
The driving force behind the Nazi movement is the belief in human
inequality, the superiority of Germans to all other races
, the
right of Germany to rule the world. Outside the German Reich it
does not recognise any obligations.
Eminent Nazi professors have
"proved" over and over again that only Nordic man is fully human,
have even mooted the idea that non Nordic peoples (such as
ourselves) can interbreed with gorillas!
Therefore, while a
species of war-Socialism exists within the German state, its
attitude towards conquered nations is frankly that of an
exploiter.
The function of the Czechs, Poles, French, etc is
simply to produce such goods as Germany may need, and get in
return just as little as will keep them from open rebellion. If
we are conquered, our job will probably be to manufacture weapons
for Hitler's forthcoming wars with Russia and America. The Nazis
aim, in effect, at setting up a kind of caste system, with four
main castes corresponding rather closely to those of the Hindu
religion. At the top comes the Nazi party, second come the mass
of the German people, third come the conquered European
populations.
Fourth and last are to come the coloured peoples,
the "semi-apes" as Hitler calls them, who are to be reduced quite
openly to slavery.


However horrible this system may seem to us, it works. It works
because it is a planned system geared to a definite purpose,
world conquest, and not allowing any private interest, either of
capitalist or worker, to stand in its way. British capitalism
does not work, because it is a competitive system in which
private profit is and must be the main objective. It is a system
in which all the forces are pulling in opposite directions and
the interests of the individual are as often as not totally
opposed to those of the State.


All through the critical years British capitalism, with its
immense industrial plant and its unrivalled supply of skilled
labour, was unequal to the strain of preparing for war. To
prepare for war on the modern scale you have got to divert the
greater part of your national income to armaments, which means
cutting down on consumption goods.
A bombing plane, for in-
stance, is equivalent in price to fifty small motor cars, or eighty
thousand pairs of silk stockings, or a million loaves of bread.
Clearly you can't have many bombing planes without lowering the
national standard of life. It is guns or butter
, as Marshal
Goering remarked. But in Chamberlain's England the transition
could not be made. The rich would not face the necessary
taxation, and while the rich are still visibly rich it is not
possible to tax the poor very heavily either. Moreover, so long
as profit was the main object the manufacturer had no incentive
to change over from consumption goods to armaments. A
businessman's first duty is to his shareholders. Perhaps England
needs tanks, but perhaps it pays better to manufacture motor
cars.
To prevent war material from reaching the enemy is common
sense, but to sell in the highest market is a business duty.
Right at the end of August 1939 the British dealers were tumbling
over one another in their eagerness to sell Germany tin, rubber,
copper and shellac-and this in the clear, certain knowledge that
war was going to break out in a week or two. It was about as
sensible as selling somebody a razor to cut your throat with. But
it was "good business"
.

And now look at the results. After 1934 it was known that Germany
was rearming. After 1936 everyone with eyes in his head knew that
war was coming.
After Munich it was merely a question of how soon
the war would begin. In September 1939 war broke out. Eight
months later it was discovered that, so far as equipment went,
the British army was barely beyond the standard of 1918. We saw
our soldiers fighting their way desperately to the coast, with
one aeroplane against three, with rifles against tanks, with bay-
onets against tommy-guns. There were not even enough revolvers
to supply all the officers. After a year of war the regular army
was still short of 300,000 tin hats. There had even, previously,
been a shortage of uniforms—this in one of the greatest
woollen-goods producing countries in the world!


What had happened was that the whole moneyed class, unwilling
to face a change in their way of life, had shut their eyes to the
nature of Fascism and modern war. And false optimism was fed
to the general public by the gutter press, which lives on its
advertisements and is therefore interested in keeping trade
conditions normal. Year after year the Beaverbrook press assured
us in huge headlines that there will be no war, and as late as
the beginning of 1939 Lord Rothermere was describing Hitler as "a
great gentleman".
And while England in the moment of disaster
proved to be short of every war material except ships, it is not
recorded that there was any shortage of motor cars, fur coats,
gramophones, lipstick, chocolates or silk stockings.
And dare
anyone pretend that the same tug-of-war between private profit
and public necessity is not still continuing? England fights for
her life, but business must fight for profits. You can hardly
open a newspaper without seeing the two contradictory processes
happening side by side. On the very same page you will find the

Government urging you to save and the seller of some useless
luxury urging you to spend. Lend to Defend, but Guinness is Good
for You. Buy a Spitfire, but also buy Haig and Haig, Pond's Face
Cream and Black Magic Chocolates.


But one thing gives hope—the visible swing in public opinion. If
we can survive this war, the defeat in Flanders will turn out to
have been one of the great turning-points in English history. In
that spectacular disaster the working class, the middle class and
even a section of the business community could see the
utter
rottenness of private capitalism.
Before that the case against
capitalism had never been proved. Russia, the only definitely
Socialist country, was backward and far away.
All criticism broke
itself against the rat-trap faces of bankers and the brassy
laughter of stockbrokers. Socialism? Ha! ha! ha! Where's the
money to come from? Ha! ha! ha! The lords of property were firm
in their seats, and they knew it. But after the French collapse
there came something that could not be laughed away, something
that neither chequebooks nor policemen were any use against-the
bombing. Zweee—boom! What's that? Oh, only a bomb on the Stock
Exchange. Zweee—boom! Another acre of somebody's valuable
slum-property gone west. Hitler will at any rate go down in
history as the man who made the City of London laugh on the
wrong side of its face. For the first time in their lives the
comfortable were uncomfortable, the professional optimists had
to admit that there was something wrong. It was a great step
forward. From that time onwards the ghastly job of trying to
convince artificially stupefied people that a planned economy
might be better than a free-for-all in which the worst man
wins-that job will never be quite so ghastly again.


ii.

The difference between Socialism and capitalism is not primarily
a difference of technique. One cannot simply change from one
system to the other as one might install a new piece of machinery
in a factory, and then carry on as before, with the same people
in positions of control. Obviously there is also needed a
complete shift of power. New blood, new men, new ideas—in the
true sense of the word, a revolution.

I have spoken earlier of the soundness and homogeneity of
England, the patriotism that runs like a connecting thread
through almost all classes. After Dunkirk anyone who had eyes in
his head could see this. But it is absurd to pretend that the
promise of that moment has been fulfilled. Almost certainly the
mass of the people are now ready for the vast changes that are
necessary; but those changes have not even begun to happen.


England is a family with the wrong members in control. Almost
entirely we are governed by the rich, and by people who step into
positions of command by right of birth. Few if any of these
people are consciously treacherous, some of them are not even
fools, but as a class they are quite incapable of leading us to
victory. They could not do it, even if their material interests
did not constantly trip them up. As I pointed out earlier, they
have been artificially stupefied. Quite apart from anything else,
the rule of money sees to it that we shall be governed largely by
the old—that is, by people utterly unable to grasp what age they
are living in or what enemy they are fighting. Nothing was more
desolating at the beginning of this war than the way in which the
whole of the older generation conspired to pretend that it was
the war of 1914-18 over again.
All the old duds were back on the
job, twenty years older, with the skull plainer in their faces.

Ian Hay was cheering up the troops, Belloc was writing articles
on strategy, Maurois doing broadcasts, Bairnsfather drawing
cartoons.
It was like a tea-party of ghosts. And that state of
affairs has barely altered. The shock of disaster brought a few
able men like Bevin to the front, but in general we are still com-
manded by people who managed to live through the years 1931-9
without even discovering that Hitler was dangerous.
A generation
of the unteachable is hanging upon us like a necklace of corpses.


As soon as one considers any problem of this war—and it does not
matter whether it is the widest aspect of strategy or the tiniest
detail of home organisation—one sees that the necessary moves
cannot be made while the social structure of England remains what
it is. Inevitably, because of their position and upbringing, the
ruling class are fighting for their own privileges, which cannot
possibly be reconciled with the public interest. It is a mistake
to imagine that war aims, strategy, propaganda and industrial
organisation exist in watertight compartments. All are inter-
connected. Every strategic plan, every tactical method, even
every weapon will bear the stamp of the social system that
produced it. The British ruling class are fighting against
Hitler, whom they have always regarded and whom some of them
still regard as their protector against Bolshevism. That does not
mean that they will deliberately sell out; but it does mean that
at every decisive moment they are likely to falter, pull their
punches, do the wrong thing.


Until the Churchill Government called some sort of halt to the
process, they have done the wrong thing with an unerring instinct
ever since 1931. They helped Franco to overthrow the Spanish
Government, although anyone not an imbecile could have told them
that a Fascist Spain would be hostile to England. They fed Italy
with war materials all through the winter of 1939-40, although it
was obvious to the whole world that the Italians were going to
attack us in the spring. For the sake of a few hundred thousand
dividend drawers they are turning India from an ally into an
enemy. Moreover, so long as the moneyed classes remain in
control, we cannot develop any but a defensive strategy.
Every
victory means a change in the status quo. How can we drive the
Italians out of Abyssinia without rousing echoes among the
coloured peoples of our own Empire?
How can we even smash Hitler
without the risk of bringing the German Socialists and Communists
into power? The left-wingers who wail that "this is a capitalist
war" and that "British Imperialism" is fighting for loot have got
their heads screwed on backwards. The last thing the British
moneyed class wish for is to acquire fresh territory. It would
simply be an embarrassment. Their war aim (both unattainable
and unmentionable) is simply to hang on to what they have got.

Internally, England is still the rich man's Paradise. All talk of
"equality of sacrifice" is nonsense. At the same time as factory
workers are asked to put up with longer hours, advertisements for
"Butler. One in family, eight in staff" are appearing in the
press. The bombed-out populations of the East End go hungry and
homeless while wealthier victims simply step into their cars and
flee to comfortable country houses.
The Home Guard swells to a
million men in a few weeks, and is deliberately organised from
above in such a way that only people with private incomes can
hold positions of command. Even the rationing system is so
arranged that it hits the poor all the time, while people with
over £2,000 a year are practically unaffected by it.
Everywhere
privilege is squandering good will. In such circumstances even
propaganda becomes almost impossible.
As attempts to stir up
patriotic feeling, the red posters issued by the Chamberlain
Government at the beginning of the war broke all depth-records.
Yet they could not have been much other than they were, for
how
could Chamberlain and his followers take the risk of rousing
strong popular feeling against fascism?
Anyone who was genuinely
hostile to Fascism must also be opposed to Chamberlain himself
and to all the others who had helped Hitler into power. So also
with external propaganda. In all Lord Halifax's speeches
there is
not one concrete proposal for which a single inhabitant of Europe
would risk the top joint of his little finger.
For what war-aim
can Halifax, or anyone like him, conceivably have, except to put
the clock back to 1933?


It is only by revolution that the native genius of the English
people can be set free. Revolution does not mean red flags and
street fighting, it means a fundamental shift of power. Whether
it happens with or without bloodshed is largely an accident of
time and place. Nor does it mean the dictatorship of a single
class.
The people in England who grasp what changes are needed
and are capable of carrying them through are not confined to any
one class, though it is true that very few people with over
£2,000 a year are among them. What is wanted is a conscious open
revolt by ordinary people against inefficiency, class privilege
and the rule of the old.
It is not primarily a question of change
of government. British governments do, broadly speaking,
represent the will of the people, and if we alter our structure
from below we shall get the government we need. Ambassadors,
generals, officials and colonial administrators who are senile or
pro-Fascist are more dangerous than Cabinet ministers whose
follies have to be committed in public. Right through our
national life we have got to
fight against privilege, against the
notion that a half-witted public-schoolboy is better fitted for
command than an intelligent mechanic.
Although there are gifted
and honest individuals among them, we have got to break the grip
of the moneyed class as a whole.
England has got to assume its
real shape. The England that is only just beneath the surface, in
the factories and the newspaper offices, in the aeroplanes and
the submarines, has got to take charge of its own destiny.

In the short run, equality of sacrifice, "war-Communism", is
even more important than radical economic changes. It is very
necessary that industry should be nationalised, but it is more
urgently necessary that
such monstrosities as butlers and
"private incomes" should disappear forthwith.
Almost certainly
the main reason why the Spanish Republic could keep up the fight
for two and a half years against impossible odds was that there
were no gross contrasts of wealth. The people suffered horribly,
but they all suffered alike. When the private soldier had not a
cigarette, the general had not one either. Given equality of
sacrifice, the morale of a country like England would probably be
unbreakable.
But at present we have nothing to appeal to except
traditional patriotism, which is deeper here than elsewhere, but
is not necessarily bottomless. At some point or another you have
got to deal with the man who says "I should be no worse off under
Hitler". But what answer can you give him—that is, what answer
that you can expect him to listen to—while common soldiers risk
their lives for two and sixpence a day, and fat women ride about
in Rolls-Royce cars, nursing pekineses?


It is quite likely that this war will last three years. It will
mean
cruel overwork, cold dull winters, uninteresting food, lack
of amusements, prolonged bombing. It cannot but lower the gen-
eral standard of living, because the essential act of war is to
manufacture armaments instead of consumable goods. The work-
ing class will have to suffer terrible things. And they will suffer
them, almost indefinitely, provided that they know what they are
fighting for. They are not cowards, and they are not even
internationally minded. They can stand all that the Spanish
workers stood, and more. But they will want some kind of proof
that a better life is ahead for themselves and their children.
The one sure earnest of that is that when they are taxed and
overworked they shall see that the rich are being hit even
harder. And if the rich squeal audibly, so much the better.


We can bring these things about, if we really want to. It is not
true that public opinion has no power in England.
It never makes
itself heard without achieving something; it has been responsible
for most of the changes for the better during the past six months.
But we have moved with glacier-like slowness, and we have
learned only from disasters. It took the fall of Paris to get rid
of Chamberlain and the unnecessary suffering of scores of
thousands of people in the East End to get rid or partially rid
of Sir John Anderson. It is not worth losing a battle in order to
bury a corpse. For we are fighting against swift evil intelligences,
and time presses
, and:

              history to the defeated
    May say Alas! but cannot alter or pardon.

iii.

During the last six months there has been much talk of "the Fifth
Column"
. From time to time obscure lunatics have been jailed for
making speeches in favour of Hitler, and large numbers of German
refugees have been interned, a thing which has almost certainly
done us great harm in Europe.
It is of course obvious that the
idea of a large, organised army of Fifth Columnists suddenly
appearing on the streets with weapons in their hands, as in
Holland and Belgium, is ridiculous. Nevertheless a Fifth Column
danger does exist. One can only consider it if one also considers
in what way England might be defeated.


It does not seem probable that air bombing can settle a major
war. England might well be invaded and conquered, but the
invasion would be a dangerous gamble, and if it happened and
failed it would probably leave us more united and less
Blimp-ridden than before. Moreover, if England were overrun by
foreign troops the English people would know that they had been
beaten and would continue the struggle. It is doubtful whether
they could be held down permanently, or whether Hitler wishes to
keep an army of a million men stationed in these islands. A
government of ——,—— and —— (you can fill in the names) would
suit him better.
The English can probably not be bullied into
surrender, but they might quite easily be bored, cajoled or
cheated into it,
provided that, as at Munich, they did not know
that they were surrendering. It could happen most easily when the
war seemed to be going well rather than badly. The threatening
tone of so much of the German and Italian propaganda is a
psychological mistake. It only gets home on intellectuals. With
the general public the proper approach would be "Let's call it a
draw".
It is when a peace-offer along those lines is made that
the pro-Fascists will raise their voices.

But who are the pro-Fascists? The idea of a Hitler victory
appeals to the very rich, to the Communists, to Mosley's
followers, to the pacifists, and to certain sections among the
Catholics. Also, if things went badly enough on the Home Front,
the whole of the poorer section of the working class might swing
round to a position that was defeatist though not actively
pro-Hitler.

In this motley list one can see the daring of German propaganda,
its willingness to offer everything to everybody.
But the various
pro-Fascist forces are not consciously acting together, and they
operate in different ways.

The Communists must certainly be regarded as pro-Hitler, and are
bound to remain so unless Russian policy changes,
but they have
not very much influence. Mosley's Blackshirts, though now lying
very low, are a more serious danger, because of the footing they
probably possess in the armed forces. Still, even in its palmiest
days Mosley's following can hardly have numbered 50,000. Pacifism
is a psychological curiosity rather than a political movement.
Some of the extremer pacifists, starting out with a complete
renunciation of violence, have ended by warmly championing Hitler
and even toying with Antisemitism. This is interesting, but it is
not important. "Pure" pacifism, which is a by-product of naval
power, can only appeal to people in very sheltered positions.
Moreover, being negative and irresponsible, it does not inspire
much devotion. Of the membership of the Peace Pledge Union, less
than 15 per cent even pay their annual subscriptions. None of
these bodies of people, pacifists, Communists or Blackshirts,
could bring a large scale stop-the-war movement into being by
their own efforts. But they might help to make things very much
easier for a treacherous government negotiating surrender.
Like
the French Communists, they might become the half-conscious
agents of millionaires.

The real danger is from above.
One ought not to pay any atten-
tion to Hitler's recent line of talk about being the friend of the
poor man, the enemy of plutocracy, etc etc. Hitler's real self is
in Mein Kampf, and in his actions.
He has never persecuted the
rich, except when they were Jews or when they tried actively to
oppose him. He stands for a centralised economy which robs the
capitalist of most of his power but leaves the structure of
society much as before. The State controls industry, but there
are still rich and poor, masters and men. Therefore, as against
genuine Socialism, the moneyed class have always been on his
side. This was crystal clear at the time of the Spanish civil
war, and clear again at the time when France surrendered.
Hitler's puppet government are not working men, but a gang of
bankers, gaga generals and corrupt right wing politicians.

That kind of spectacular, conscious treachery is less likely to
succeed in England, indeed is far less likely even to be tried.
Nevertheless, to many payers of supertax this war is simply an
insane family squabble which ought to be stopped at all costs.
One need not doubt that a "peace" movement is on foot some-
where in high places; probably a shadow Cabinet has already been
formed.
These people will get their chance not in the moment of
defeat but in some stagnant period when boredom is reinforced by
discontent. They will not talk about surrender, only about peace;

and doubtless they will persuade themselves, and perhaps other
people, that they are acting for the best.
An army of unemployed
led by millionaires quoting the Sermon on the Mount—that is our
danger. But it cannot arise when we have once introduced a
reasonable degree of social justice. The lady in the Rolls-Royce
car is more damaging to morale than a fleet of Goering's bombing
planes.




PART III: THE ENGLISH REVOLUTION

i.

The English revolution started several years ago, and it began to
gather momentum when the troops came back from Dunkirk. Like all
else in England, it
happens in a sleepy, unwilling way, but it is
happening.
The war has speeded it up, but it has also increased,
and desperately, the necessity for speed.

Progress and reaction are ceasing to have anything to do with
party labels. If one wishes to name a particular moment, one can
say that the old distinction between Right and Left broke down
when Picture Post was first published. What are the politics of
Picture Post? Or of Cavalcade, or Priestley's broadcasts, or the
leading articles in the Evening Standard? None of the old
classifications will fit them. They merely point to the existence
of multitudes of unlabelled people who have grasped within the
last year or two that something is wrong. But since a classless,
ownerless society is generally spoken of as "Socialism", we can
give that name to the society towards which we are now moving.
The war and the revolution are inseparable. We cannot establish
anything that a western nation would regard as Socialism without
defeating Hitler; on the other hand we cannot defeat Hitler while
we remain economically and socially in the nineteenth century.

The past is fighting the future and we have two years, a year,
possibly only a few months, to see to it that the future wins.

We cannot look to this or to any similar government to put
through the necessary changes of its own accord. The initiative
will have to come from below. That means that there will have to
arise something that has never existed in England, a Socialist
movement that actually has the mass of the people behind it. But
one must start by recognising why it is that English Socialism
has failed.


In England there is only one Socialist party that has ever
seriously mattered, the
Labour Party. It has never been able to
achieve any major change, because except in purely domestic
matters it has never possessed a genuinely independent policy.
It was and is primarily a party of the trade unions, devoted to
raising wages and improving working conditions. This meant that
all through the critical years it was directly interested in the
prosperity of British capitalism. In particular it
was interested
in the maintenance of the British Empire, for the wealth of
England was drawn largely from Asia and Africa. The standard
of living of the trade union workers, whom the Labour Party
represented, depended indirectly on the sweating of Indian
coolies. At the same time the Labour Party was a Socialist
party, using Socialist phraseology, thinking in terms of an
old-fashioned anti-imperialism and more or less pledged to make
restitution to the coloured races. It had to stand for the
"independence" of India
, just as it had to stand for disarmament
and "progress" generally. Nevertheless everyone was aware that
this was nonsense. In the age of the tank and the bombing plane,
backward agricultural countries like India and the African
colonies can no more be independent than can a cat or a dog.
Had
any Labour government come into office with a clear majority and
then proceeded to grant India anything that could truly be called
independence,
India would simply have been absorbed by Japan, or
divided between Japan and Russia.


To a Labour government in power, three imperial policies would
have been open.
One was to continue administering the Empire
exactly as before, which meant dropping all pretensions to
Socialism. Another was to set the subject peoples "free", which
meant in practice
handing them over to Japan, Italy and other
predatory powers, and incidentally causing a catastrophic drop in
the British standard of living.
The third was to develop a
positive imperial policy, and aim at transforming the Empire into
a federation of Socialist states, like a looser and freer version
of the Union of Soviet Republics. But the Labour Party's history
and background made this impossible. It was a party of the trade
unions, hopelessly parochial in outlook, with little interest in
imperial affairs
and no contacts among the men who actually held
the Empire together. It would have had to hand the administration
of India and Africa and the whole job of imperial defence to men
drawn from a different class and traditionally hostile to Social-
ism. Overshadowing everything was the doubt whether a Labour
government which meant business could make itself obeyed.
For all the size of its following, the Labour Party had no
footing in the navy, little or none in the army or air force,
none whatever in the Colonial Services, and not even a sure
footing in the Home Civil Service. In England its position was
strong but not unchallengeable, and outside England all the key
points were in the hands of its enemies. Once in power, the same
dilemma would always have faced it: carry out your promises, and
risk revolt, or continue with the same policy as the Conserv-
atives, and stop talking about Socialism. The Labour leaders
never found a solution, and from 1935 onwards it was very
doubtful whether they had any wish to take office. They had
degenerated into a Permanent Opposition.


Outside the Labour Party there existed several extremist parties,
of whom the Communists were the strongest. The Communists had
considerable influence in the Labour Party in the years 1920-6
and 1935-9. Their chief importance, and that of the whole left
wing of the Labour movement, was the part they played in
alienating the middle classes from Socialism.

The history of the past seven years has made it perfectly clear
that Communism has no chance in western Europe. The appeal of
Fascism is enormously greater. In one country after another the
Communists have been rooted out by their more up-to-date ene-
mies, the Nazis. In the English-speaking countries they never had
a serious footing. The creed they were spreading could appeal
only to a rather rare type of person, found chiefly in the
middle-class intelligentsia, the type who has ceased to love his
own country but still feels the need of patriotism, and therefore
develops patriotic sentiments towards Russia.
By 1940, after
working for twenty years and spending a great deal of money, the
British Communists had barely 20,000 members, actually a smaller
number than they had started out with in 1920. The other Marxist
parties
were of even less importance. They had not the Russian
money and prestige behind them, and even more than the Commun-
ists they were tied to the nineteenth-century doctrine of the class
war.
They continued year after year to preach this out-of-date
gospel, and never drew any inference from the fact that it got
them no followers.

Nor did any strong native Fascist movement grow up. Material
conditions were not bad enough, and no leader who could be taken
seriously was forthcoming. One would have had to look a long time
to find a man more barren of ideas than Sir Oswald Mosley. He was
as hollow as a jug. Even the elementary fact that Fascism must
not offend national sentiment had escaped him. His entire
movement was imitated slavishly from abroad, the uniform and the
party programme from Italy and the salute from Germany, with the
Jew baiting tacked on as an afterthought, Mosley having actually
started his movement with Jews among his most prominent
followers. A man of the stamp of Bottomley or Lloyd George could
perhaps have brought a real British Fascist movement into
existence.
But such leaders only appear when the psychological
need for them exists.

After twenty years of stagnation and unemployment, the entire
English Socialist movement was unable to produce a version of
Socialism which the mass of the people could even find desirable.
The Labour Party stood for a timid reformism, the Marxists were
looking at the modern world through nineteenth-century
spectacles. Both ignored agriculture and imperial problems, and
both antagonised the middle classes.
The suffocating stupidity of
left-wing propaganda had frightened away whole classes of
necessary people, factory managers, airmen, naval officers,
farmers, white-collar workers, shopkeepers, policemen. All of
these people had been taught to think of Socialism as something
which menaced their livelihood, or as something seditious, alien,
"anti-British"
as they would have called it. Only the intellect-
uals, the least useful section of the middle class, gravitated
towards the movement.

A Socialist Party which genuinely wished to achieve anything
would have started by facing several facts which to this day are
considered
unmentionable in left-wing circles. It would have
recognised
that England is more united than most countries, that
the British workers have a great deal to lose besides their
chains,
and that the differences in outlook and habits between
class and class are rapidly diminishing. In general, it would
have recognised that the old-fashioned "proletarian revolution"
is an impossibility. But all through the between-war years no
Socialist programme that was both revolutionary and workable ever
appeared; basically, no doubt, because no one genuinely wanted
any major change to happen.
The Labour leaders wanted to go on
and on, drawing their salaries and periodically swapping jobs
with the Conservatives. The Communists wanted to go on and on,
suffering a comfortable martyrdom
, meeting with endless defeats
and afterwards putting the blame on other people.
The left-wing
intelligentsia wanted to go on and on, sniggering at the Blimps,
sapping away at middle-class morale, but still keeping their
favoured position as hangers-on of the dividend-drawers.
Labour
Party politics had become a variant of Conservatism, "revolu-
tionary" politics had become a game of make-believe.


Now, however, the circumstances have changed, the drowsy
years have ended.
Being a Socialist no longer means kicking
theoretically against a system which in practice you are fairly
well satisfied with.
This time our predicament is real. It is
"the Philistines be upon thee, Samson".
We have got to make our
words take physical shape, or perish.
We know very well that with
its present social structure England cannot survive, and we have
got to make other people see that fact and act upon it. We cannot
win the war without introducing Socialism, nor establish
Socialism without winning the war. At such a time it is possible,
as it was not in the peaceful years,
to be both revolutionary and
realistic.
A Socialist movement which can swing the mass of the
people behind it, drive the pro-Fascists out of positions of
control, wipe out the grosser injustices and let the working
class see that they have something to fight for, win over the
middle classes instead of antagonising them, produce a workable
imperial policy
instead of a mixture of humbug and Utopianism,
bring patriotism and intelligence into partnership
—for the first
time, a movement of such a kind becomes possible.


ii.

The fact that we are at war has turned Socialism from a textbook
word into a realisable policy.


The inefficiency of private capitalism has been proved all over
Europe. Its injustice has been proved in the East End of London.
Patriotism, against which the Socialists fought so long, has
become a tremendous lever in their hands. People who at any
other time would cling like glue to their miserable scraps of
privilege, will surrender them fast enough when their country is
in danger. War is the greatest of all agents of change. It speeds
up all processes, wipes out minor distinctions, brings realities
to the surface. Above all, war brings it home to the individual
that he is not altogether an individual.
It is only because they
are aware of this that men will die on the field of battle. At
this moment it is not so much a question of surrendering life as
of surrendering leisure, comfort, economic liberty, social
prestige. There are very few people in England who really want to
see their country conquered by Germany. If it can be made clear
that defeating Hitler means wiping out class privilege, the great
mass of middling people, the £6 a week to £2,000 a year class,
will probably be on our side. These people are quite
indispensable, because they include most of the technical
experts. Obviously the snobbishness and political ignorance of
people like airmen and naval officers will be a very great
difficulty.
But without those airmen, destroyer commanders, etc
etc we could not survive for a week. The only approach to them is
through their patriotism. An intelligent Socialist movement will
use their patriotism, instead of merely insulting it, as hitherto.

But do I mean that there will be no opposition? Of course not. It
would be childish to expect anything of the kind.

There will be a bitter political struggle, and there will be uncon-
scious and half-conscious sabotage everywhere. At some point
or other it may be necessary to use violence. It is easy to
imagine a pro-Fascist rebellion breaking out in, for instance,
India.
We shall have to fight against bribery, ignorance and
snobbery. The bankers and the larger businessmen, the land-
owners and dividend-drawers, the officials with their prehensile
bottoms, will obstruct for all they are worth. Even the middle
classes will writhe when their accustomed way of life is menaced.

But just because the English sense of national unity has never
disintegrated, because patriotism is finally stronger than
class-hatred, the chances are that the will of the majority will
prevail.
It is no use imagining that one can make fundamental
changes without causing a split in the nation; but the
treacherous minority will be far smaller in time of war than it
would be at any other time.

The swing of opinion is visibly happening, but it cannot be
counted on to happen fast enough of its own accord. This war is a
race between the consolidation of Hitler's empire and the growth
of democratic consciousness. Everywhere in England you can see a
ding-dong battle ranging to and fro—in Parliament and in the
Government, in the factories and the armed forces, in the pubs
and the air-raid shelters, in the newspapers and on the radio.
Every day there are tiny defeats, tiny victories. Morrison for
Home Security—a few yards forward. Priestley shoved off the air—a
few yards back. It is a struggle between the groping and the
unteachable, between the young and the old, between the living
and the dead. But it is very necessary that the discontent which
undoubtedly exists should take a purposeful and not merely
obstructive form. It is time for the people to define their
war-aims. What is wanted is a simple, concrete programme of
action,
which can be given all possible publicity, and round
which public opinion can group itself.

I suggest that the following six-point programme is the kind of
thing we need. The first three points deal with England's
internal policy, the other three with the Empire and the world:

1. Nationalisation of land, mines, railways, banks and major
industries.

2. Limitation of incomes, on such a scale that the highest tax
free income in Britain does not exceed the lowest by more than
ten to one.

3. Reform of the educational system along democratic lines.

4. Immediate Dominion status for India, with power to secede when
the war is over.

5. Formation of an Imperial General Council, in which the
coloured peoples are to be represented.

6. Declaration of formal alliance with China, Abyssinia and all
other victims of the Fascist powers.

The general tendency of this programme is unmistakable. It aims
quite frankly at turning this war into a revolutionary war and
England into a Socialist democracy. I have deliberately included
in it nothing that the simplest person could not understand and
see the reason for. In the form in which I have put it, it could
be printed on the front page of the Daily Mirror. But for the
purposes of this book a certain amount of amplification is
needed.

1. NATIONALISATION. One can "nationalise" industry by the stroke
of a pen, but the actual process is slow and complicated. What is
needed is that the ownership of all major industry shall be
formally vested in the State, representing the common people.
Once that is done it becomes possible to
eliminate the class of
mere owners who live not by virtue of anything they produce
but by the possession of title-deeds and share certificates.
State-ownership implies, therefore, that nobody shall live
without working.
How sudden a change in the conduct of industry
it implies is less certain. In a country like England we cannot
rip down the whole structure and build again from the bottom,
least of all in time of war. Inevitably the majority of industrial
concerns will continue with much the same personnel as
before, the one-time owners or managing directors carrying on
with their jobs as State employees. There is reason to think that
many of the smaller capitalists would actually welcome some such
arrangement. The resistance will come from the big capitalists,
the bankers, the landlords and the idle rich, roughly speaking
the class with over £2,000 a year—and even if one counts in all
their dependants there are not more than half a million of these
people in England. Nationalisation of agricultural land implies
cutting out the landlord and the tithe drawer, but not
necessarily interfering with the farmer. It is difficult to
imagine any reorganisation of English agriculture that would not
retain most of the existing farms as units, at any rate at the
beginning.
The farmer, when he is competent, will continue as a
salaried manager. He is virtually that already, with the added
disadvantage of having to make a profit and being permanently in
debt to the bank. With certain kinds of petty trading, and even
the small-scale ownership of land, the State will probably not
interfere at all. It would be a great mistake to start by
victimising the smallholder class, for instance. These people are
necessary, on the whole they are competent, and the amount of
work they do depends on the feeling that they are "their own
masters".
But the State will certainly impose an upward limit to
the ownership of land (probably fifteen acres at the very most),
and will never permit any ownership of land in town areas.


From the moment that all productive goods have been declared
the property of the State, the common people will feel, as they
cannot feel now, that the State is themselves. They will be ready
then to endure the sacrifices that are ahead of us, war or no
war. And even if the face of England hardly seems to change, on
the day that our main industries are formally nationalised the
dominance of a single class will have been broken. From then
onwards the emphasis will be shifted from ownership to
management, from privilege to competence.
It is quite possible
that State-ownership will in itself bring about less social
change than will be forced upon us by the common hardships of
war. But it is the necessary first step without which any real
reconstruction is impossible.

2. INCOMES. Limitation of incomes implies the fixing of a minimum
wage, which implies a managed internal currency based simply on
the amount of consumption goods available. And this again implies
a stricter rationing scheme than is now in operation. It is no
use at this stage of the world's history to suggest that all
human beings should have exactly equal incomes.
It has been shown
over and over again that without some kind of money reward there
is no incentive to undertake certain jobs.
On the other hand the
money reward need not be very large. In practice it is impossible
that earnings should be limited quite as rigidly as I have
suggested. There will always be anomalies and evasions. But there
is no reason why
ten to one should not be the maximum normal
variation.
And within those limits some sense of equality is
possible.
A man with £3 a week and a man with £1,500 a year can
feel themselves fellow creatures, which the Duke of Westminster
and the sleepers on the Embankment benches cannot.


3. EDUCATION. In wartime, educational reform must necessarily be
promise rather than performance. At the moment we are not in a
position to raise the school-leaving age or increase the teaching
staffs of the elementary schools. But there are certain immediate
steps that we could take towards a democratic educational system.
We could
start by abolishing the autonomy of the public schools
and the older universities and flooding them with State-aided
pupils chosen simply on grounds of ability. At present,
public-school education is partly a training in class prejudice
and partly a sort of tax that the middle classes pay to the upper
class in return for the right to enter certain professions.
It is
true that that state of affairs is altering. The middle classes
have begun to rebel against the expensiveness of education,
and
the war will bankrupt the majority of the public schools if it
continues for another year or two. The evacuation is also
producing certain minor changes. But there is a danger that some
of the older schools, which will be able to weather the financial
storm longest, will
survive in some form or another as festering
centres of snobbery. As for the 10,000 "private" schools that
England possesses, the vast majority of them deserve nothing
except suppression. They are simply commercial undertakings
, and
in many cases their educational level is actually lower than that
of the elementary schools. They merely
exist because of a
widespread idea that there is something disgraceful in being
educated by the public authorities.
The State could quell this
idea by declaring itself responsible for all education, even if
at the start this were no more than a gesture. We need gestures
as well as actions. It is all too obvious that our talk of "defend-
ing democracy" is nonsense while it is a mere accident of
birth that decides whether a gifted child shall or shall not get
the education it deserves.


4. INDIA. What we must offer India is not "freedom", which, as I
have said earlier, is impossible, but alliance, partnership-in a
word, equality. But we must also tell the Indians that they are
free to secede, if they want to. Without that there can be no
equality of partnership, and our claim to be defending the
coloured peoples against Fascism will never be believed. But it
is a mistake to imagine that if the Indians were free to cut
themselves adrift they would immediately do so. When a British
government offers them unconditional independence, they will
refuse it. For as soon as they have the power to secede the
chief reasons for doing so will have disappeared.


A complete severance of the two countries would be a disaster
for India no less than for England.
Intelligent Indians know this.
As things are
at present, India not only cannot defend itself, it
is hardly even capable of feeding itself. The whole administra-
tion of the country depends on a framework of experts (engin-
eers, forest officers, railwaymen, soldiers, doctors) who are
predominantly English
and could not be replaced within five or
ten years. Moreover, English is the chief lingua franca and
nearly the whole of the Indian intelligentsia is deeply
Anglicised. Any transference to foreign rule—for if the British
marched out of India the Japanese and other powers would
immediately march in—would mean an immense dislocation. Nei-
ther the Japanese, the Russians, the Germans nor the Italians
would be capable of administering India even at the low level of
efficiency that is attained by the British. They do not possess
the necessary supplies of technical experts or the knowledge of
languages and local conditions, and they probably could not win
the confidence of indispensable go-betweens such as the
Eurasians.
If India were simply "liberated", i.e. deprived of
British military protection, the first result would be a fresh
foreign conquest, and the second a series of enormous famines
which would kill millions of people within a few years.


What India needs is the power to work out its own constitution
without British interference, but in some kind of partnership
that ensures its military protection and technical advice. This
is unthinkable until there is a Socialist government in England.

For at least eighty years
England has artificially prevented the
development of India
, partly from fear of trade competition if
Indian industries were too highly developed, partly because
backward peoples are more easily governed than civilised ones. It
is a commonplace that the average Indian suffers far more from
his own countrymen than from the British. The petty Indian
capitalist exploits the town worker with the utmost ruthless-
ness, the peasant lives from birth to death in the grip of the
money-lender.
But all this is an indirect result of the British
rule, which aims half-consciously at keeping India as backward as
possible. The classes most loyal to Britain are the princes, the
landowners and the business community—in general, the reactionary
classes who are doing fairly well out of the status quo.. The
moment that England ceased to stand towards India in the relation
of an exploiter, the balance of forces would be altered. No need
then for the British to flatter the ridiculous Indian princes,
with their gilded elephants and cardboard armies, to prevent the
growth of the Indian trade unions, to play off Moslem against
Hindu, to protect the worthless life of the money-lender, to
receive the salaams of toadying minor officials, to prefer the
half-barbarous Gurkha to the educated Bengali.
Once check that
stream of dividends that flows from the bodies of Indian coolies
to the banking accounts of old ladies in Cheltenham, and the
whole sahib-native nexus, with its haughty ignorance on one
side and envy and servility on the other, can come to an end.

Englishmen and Indians can work side by side for the development
of India, and for the training of Indians in all the arts which,
so far, they have been systematically prevented from learning.
How many of the existing British personnel in India, commercial
or official, would fall in with such an arrangement—which would
mean ceasing once and for all to be "sahibs"—is a different
question. But, broadly speaking, more is to be hoped from the
younger men and from those officials (civil engineers, forestry
and agricultural experts, doctors, educationists) who have been
scientifically educated.
The higher officials, the provincial
governors, commissioners, judges, etc are hopeless; but they are
also the most easily replaceable.

That, roughly, is what would be meant by Dominion status if it
were offered to India by a Socialist government. It is an offer
of partnership on equal terms until such time as the world has
ceased to be ruled by bombing planes. But we must add to it the
unconditional right to secede. It is the only way of proving that
we mean what we say. And what applies to India applies, mutatis
mutandis
, to Burma, Malaya and most of our African possessions.


5 and 6 explain themselves. They are the necessary preliminary to
any claim that we are fighting this war for the protection of
peaceful peoples against Fascist aggression.

Is it impossibly hopeful to think that such a policy as this
could get a following in England? A year ago, even six months
ago, it would have been, but not now. Moreover-and this is the
peculiar opportunity of this moment—it could be given the
necessary publicity. There is now a considerable weekly press,
with a circulation of millions, which would be ready to popular-
ise—if not exactly the programme I have sketched above, at
any rate some policy along those lines.
There are even three
or four daily papers which would be prepared to give it a
sympathetic hearing. That is the distance we have travelled in
the last six months.

But is such a policy realisable? That depends entirely on
ourselves.

Some of the points I have suggested are of the kind that could be
carried out immediately, others would take years or decades and
even then would not be perfectly achieved. No political programme
is ever carried out in its entirety. But what matters is that
that or something like it should be our declared policy. It is
always the direction that counts.
It is of course quite hopeless
to expect the present Government to pledge itself to any policy
that implies turning this war into a revolutionary war. It is at
best a government of compromise, with Churchill riding two horses
like a circus acrobat. Before such measures as limitation of
incomes become even thinkable, there will have to be a complete
shift of power away from the old ruling class. If during this
winter the war settles into another stagnant period, we ought in
my opinion to agitate for a General Election, a thing which the
Tory Party machine will make frantic efforts to prevent. But even
without an election we can get the government we want, provided
that we want it urgently enough. A real shove from below will
accomplish it. As to who will be in that government when it
comes, I make no guess. I only know that the right men will be
there when the people really want them, for it is movements that
make leaders and not leaders movements.

Within a year, perhaps even within six months, if we are still
unconquered,
we shall see the rise of something that has never
existed before, a specifically English Socialist movement.
Hitherto there has been only the Labour Party, which was the
creation of the working class but did not aim at any fundamental
change, and Marxism, which was a German theory interpreted by
Russians and unsuccessfully transplanted to England. There was
nothing that really touched the heart of the English people.

Throughout its entire history the English Socialist movement has
never produced a song with a catchy tune—nothing like La
Marseillaise or La Cucuracha, for instance. When a Socialist
movement native to England appears,
the Marxists, like all others
with a vested interest in the past, will be its bitter enemies.
Inevitably they will denounce it as "Fascism". Already it is
customary among the more soft-boiled intellectuals of the Left
to declare that if we fight against the Nazis we shall "go Nazi"
ourselves.
They might almost equally well say that if we fight
against Negroes we shall turn black. To "go Nazi" we should have
to have the history of Germany behind us. Nations do not escape
from their past merely by making a revolution.
An English
Socialist government will transform the nation from top to
bottom, but it will still bear all over it the unmistakable marks
of our own civilisation, the peculiar civilisation which I
discussed earlier in this book.

It will not be doctrinaire, nor even logical. It will abolish the
House of Lords, but quite probably will not abolish the Monarchy.
It will leave anachronisms and loose ends everywhere, the judge
in his ridiculous horsehair wig and the lion and the unicorn on
the soldier's cap-buttons. It will not set up any explicit class
dictatorship.
It will group itself round the old Labour Party and
its mass following will be in the trade unions, but it will draw
into it most of the middle class and many of the younger sons of
the bourgeoisie.
Most of its directing brains will come from the
new indeterminate class of skilled workers, technical experts,
airmen, scientists, architects and journalists, the people who
feel at home in the radio and ferro-concrete age. But it will
never lose touch with the tradition of compromise and the belief
in a law that is above the State. It will shoot traitors, but it
will give them a solemn trial beforehand and occasionally it will
acquit them. It will crush any open revolt promptly and cruelly,
but it will interfere very little with the spoken and written
word. Political parties with different names will still exist,
revolutionary sects will still be publishing their newspapers and
making as little impression as ever. It will disestablish the
Church, but will not persecute religion. It will retain a vague
reverence for the Christian moral code, and from time to time
will refer to England as "a Christian country".
The Catholic
Church will war against it, but the Nonconformist sects and the
bulk of the Anglican Church will be able to come to terms with
it.
It will show a power of assimilating the past which will shock
foreign observers and sometimes make them doubt whether any
revolution has happened.


But all the same it will have done the essential thing. It will
have nationalised industry, scaled down incomes, set up a
classless educational system. Its real nature will be apparent
from the hatred which the surviving rich men of the world will
feel for it.
It will aim not at disintegrating the Empire but at
turning it into a federation of Socialist states, freed not so
much from the British flag as from the money-lender, the
dividend-drawer and the woodenheaded British official. Its
war strategy will be totally different from that of any prop-
erty-ruled state, because it will not be afraid of the revol-
utionary after-effects when any existing régime is brought
down. It will not have the smallest scruple about attacking
hostile neutrals or stirring up native rebellion in enemy
colonies. It will fight in such a way that even if it is beaten
its memory will be dangerous to the victor, as the memory of
the French Revolution was dangerous to Metternich's Europe.
The dictators will fear it
as they could not fear the existing
British régime, even if its military strength were ten times
what it is.

But at this moment, when the drowsy life of England has barely
altered, and the offensive contrast of wealth and poverty till
exists everywhere, even amid the bombs, why do I dare to say
that all these things "will" happen?


Because the time has come when one can predict the future
in terms of an "either—or". Either we turn this war into a
revolutionary war (I do not say that our policy will be exactly
what I have indicated above—merely that it will be along those
general lines) or we lose it, and much more besides. Quite soon
it will be possible to say definitely that our feet are set upon
one path or the other. But at any rate it is certain that with
our present social structure we cannot win.
Our real forces,
physical, moral or intellectual, cannot be mobilised.


iii.

Patriotism has nothing to do with Conservatism. It is actually
the opposite of Conservatism, since it is a devotion to something
that is always changing and yet is felt to be mystically the
same.
It is the bridge between the future and the past. No real
revolutionary has ever been an internationalist.

During the past twenty years the negative, fainéant outlook which
has been fashionable among English left-wingers, the sniggering
of the intellectuals at patriotism and physical courage, the
persistent effort to chip away English morale and spread a
hedonistic, what-do-I-get-out-of-it attitude to life, has done
nothing but harm. It would have been
harmful even if we had been
living in the squashy League of Nations universe that these
people imagined.
In an age of Fuehrers and bombing planes it was
a disaster. However little we may like it, toughness is the price
of survival.
A nation trained to think hedonistically cannot
survive amid peoples who work like slaves and breed like rabbits,
and whose chief national industry is war.
English Socialists of
nearly all colours have wanted to make a stand against Fascism,
but at the same time they have aimed at making their own
countrymen unwarlike. They have failed, because in England
traditional loyalties are stronger than new ones.
But in spite of
all the "anti-Fascist" heroics of the left-wing press, what
chance should we have stood when the real struggle with Fascism
came, if the average Englishman had been the kind of creature
that the New Statesman, the Daily Worker or even the News
Chronicle
wished to make him?

Up to 1935 virtually all English left-wingers were vaguely
pacifist. After 1935 the more vocal of them flung themselves
eagerly into the Popular Front movement, which was simply an
evasion of the whole problem posed by Fascism. It set out to be
"anti-Fascist" in a purely negative way—"against" Fascism without
being "for" any discoverable policy-and underneath it lay the
flabby idea that when the time came the Russians would do our
fighting for us. It is astonishing how this illusion fails to
die.
Every week sees its spate of letters to the press, pointing
out that if we had a government with no Tories in it the Russians
could hardly avoid coming round to our side. Or we are to publish
high-sounding war-aims (vide books like Unser Kampf, A Hundred
Million Allies, If We Choose
, etc), whereupon the European
populations will infallibly rise on our behalf. It is the same
idea all the time-look abroad for your inspiration, get someone
else to do your fighting for you. Underneath it lies the
frightful inferiority complex of the English intellectual, the
belief that the English are no longer a martial race, no longer
capable of enduring.


In truth there is no reason to think that anyone will do our
fighting for us yet awhile, except the Chinese, who have been
doing it for three years already. [Note: Written before the
outbreak of the war in Greece. (Author's footnote.)] The Russians
may be driven to fight on our side by the fact of a direct
attack, but they have made it clear enough that they will not
stand up to the German army if there is any way of avoiding it.
In any case they are not likely to be attracted by the spectacle
of a left-wing government in England. The present Russian régime
must almost certainly be hostile to any revolution in the West.

The subject peoples of Europe will rebel when Hitler begins to
totter, but not earlier. Our potential allies are not the Euro-
peans but on the one hand the Americans, who will need a year
to mobilise their resources even if Big Business can be brought
to heel, and on the other hand the coloured peoples, who cannot
be even sentimentally on our side till our own revolution has
started. For a long time, a year, two years, possibly three
years, England has got to be the shock-absorber of the world. We
have got to face bombing, hunger, overwork, influenza, boredom
and treacherous peace offers. Manifestly it is a time to stiffen
morale, not to weaken it. Instead of taking the mechanically
anti-British attitude which is usual on the Left, it is better to
consider what the world would really be like if the
English-speaking culture perished. For it is childish to suppose
that the other English-speaking countries, even the USA, will be
unaffected if Britain is conquered.

Lord Halifax, and all his tribe, believe that when the war is
over things will be exactly as they were before. Back to the
crazy pavement of Versailles, back to "democracy", i.e.
capitalism, back to dole queues and the Rolls-Royce cars, back to
the grey top hats and the sponge-bag trousers, in saecula
saeculorum. It is of course obvious that nothing of the kind is
going to happen. A feeble imitation of it might just possibly
happen in the case of a negotiated peace, but only for a short
while. laissez-faire capitalism is dead. [Note, below] The choice
lies between the kind of collective society that Hitler will set
up and the kind that can arise if he is defeated.

[Note: It is interesting to notice that Mr Kennedy, USA
Ambassador in London, remarked on his return to New York in
October 1940 that as a result of the war "democracy is finished".
By "democracy", of course, he meant private capitalism. (Author's
footnote.)]

If Hitler wins this war he will consolidate his rule over Europe,
Africa and the Middle East, and if his armies have not been too
greatly exhausted beforehand, he will wrench vast territories
from Soviet Russia. He will set up a graded caste-society in
which the German Herrenvolk ("master race" or "aristocratic
race") will rule over Slavs and other lesser peoples whose job it
will be to produce low-priced agricultural products. He will
reduce the coloured peoples once and for all to outright slavery.
The real quarrel of the Fascist powers with British imperialism
is that they know that it is disintegrating. Another twenty years
along the present line of development, and India will be a
peasant republic linked with England only by voluntary alliance.
The "semi-apes" of whom Hitler speaks with such loathing will be
flying aeroplanes and manufacturing machine-guns. The Fascist
dream of a slave empire will be at an end. On the other hand, if
we are defeated we simply hand over our own victims to new
masters who come fresh to the job and have not developed any
scruples.

But more is involved than the fate of the coloured peoples. Two
incompatible visions of life are fighting one another. "Between
democracy and totalitarianism," says Mussolini, "there can be no
compromise." The two creeds cannot even, for any length of time,
live side by side. So long as democracy exists, even in its very
imperfect English form, totalitarianism is in deadly danger. The
whole English-speaking world is haunted by the idea of human
equality, and though it would be simply a lie to say that either
we or the Americans have ever acted up to our professions, still,
the idea is there, and it is capable of one day becoming a
reality. From the English-speaking culture, if it does not
perish, a society of free and equal human beings will ultimately
arise. But it is precisely the idea of human equality—the
"Jewish" or "Judaeo-Christian" idea of equality—that Hitler came
into the world to destroy. He has, heaven knows, said so often
enough. The thought of a world in which black men would be as
good as white men and Jews treated as human beings brings him the
same horror and despair as the thought of endless slavery brings
to us.

It is important to keep in mind how irreconcilable these two
viewpoints are. Some time within the next year a pro-Hitler
reaction within the left-wing intelligentsia is likely enough.
There are premonitory signs of it already. Hitler's positive
achievement appeals to the emptiness of these people, and, in the
case of those with pacifist leanings, to their masochism. One
knows in advance more or less what they will say. They will start
by refusing to admit that British capitalism is evolving into
something different, or that the defeat of Hitler can mean any
more than a victory for the British and American millionaires.
And from that they will proceed to argue that, after all,
democracy is "just the same as" or "just as bad as"
totalitarianism. There is not much freedom of speech in England;
therefore there is no more than exists in Germany. To be on the
dole is a horrible experience; therefore it is no worse to be in
the torture-chambers of the Gestapo. In general, two blacks make
a white, half a loaf is the same as no bread.

But in reality, whatever may be true about democracy and
totalitarianism, it is not true that they are the same. It would
not be true, even if British democracy were incapable of evolving
beyond its present stage. The whole conception of the militarised
continental state, with its secret police, its censored
literature and its conscript labour, is utterly different from
that of the loose maritime democracy, with its slums and
unemployment, its strikes and party politics. It is the
difference between land power and sea power, between cruelty and
inefficiency, between lying and self-deception, between the SS
man and the rent-collector. And in choosing between them one
chooses not so much on the strength of what they now are as of
what they are capable of becoming. But in a sense it is
irrelevant whether democracy, at its higher or at its lowest, is
"better" than totalitarianism. To decide that one would have to
have access to absolute standards. The only question that matters
is where one's real sympathies will lie when the pinch comes. The
intellectuals who are so fond of balancing democracy against
totalitarianism and "proving" that one is as bad as the other are
simply frivolous people who have never been shoved up against
realities. They show the same shallow misunderstanding of Fascism
now, when they are beginning to flirt with it, as a year or two
ago, when they were squealing against it. The question is not,
"Can you make out a debating-society 'case' in favour of Hitler?"
The question is, "Do you genuinely accept that case? Are you
willing to submit to Hitler's rule? Do you want to see England
conquered, or don't you?" It would be better to be sure on that
point before frivolously siding with the enemy. For there is no
such thing as neutrality in war; in practice one must help one
side or the other.

When the pinch comes, no one bred in the western tradition can
accept the Fascist vision of life. It is important to realise
that now, and to grasp what it entails. With all its sloth,
hypocrisy and injustice, the English speaking civilisation is the
only large obstacle in Hitler's path. It is a living
contradiction of all the "infallible" dogmas of Fascism. That is
why all Fascist writers for years past have agreed that England's
power must be destroyed. England must be "exterminated", must be
"annihilated", must "cease to exist". Strategically it would be
possible for this war to end with Hitler in secure possession of
Europe, and with the British Empire intact and British sea-power
barely affected. But ideologically it is not possible; were
Hitler to make an offer along those lines, it could only be
treacherously, with a view to conquering England indirectly or
renewing the attack at some more favourable moment. England
cannot possibly be allowed to remain as a sort of funnel through
which deadly ideas from beyond the Atlantic flow into the police
states of Europe. And turning it round to our own point of view,
we see the vastness of the issue before us, the all-importance of
preserving our democracy more or less as we have known it. But to
preserve is always to extend. The choice before us is not so much
between victory and defeat as between revolution and apathy. If
the thing we are fighting for is altogether destroyed, it will
have been destroyed partly by our own act.

It could happen that England could introduce the beginnings of
Socialism, turn this war into a revolutionary war, and still be
defeated. That is at any rate thinkable. But, terrible as it
would be for anyone who is now adult, it would be far less deadly
than the "compromise peace" which a few rich men and their hired
liars are hoping for. The final ruin of England could only be
accomplished by an English government acting under orders from
Berlin. But that cannot happen if England has awakened
beforehand. For in that case the defeat would be unmistakable,
the struggle would continue, the idea would survive. The
difference between going down fighting, and surrendering without
a fight, is by no means a question of "honour" and schoolboy
heroics. Hitler said once that to accept defeat destroys the soul
of a nation. This sounds like a piece of claptrap, but it is
strictly true. The defeat of 1870 did not lessen the
world-influence of France. The Third Republic had more influence,
intellectually, than the France of Napoleon III. But the sort of
peace that Petain, Laval and Co have accepted can only be
purchased by deliberately wiping out the national culture. The
Vichy Government will enjoy a spurious independence only on
condition that it destroys the distinctive marks of French
culture: republicanism, secularism, respect for the intellect,
absence of colour prejudice. We cannot be utterly defeated if we
have made our revolution beforehand. We may see German troops
marching down Whitehall, but another process, ultimately deadly
to the German power-dream, will have been started. The Spanish
people were defeated, but the things they learned during those
two and a half memorable years will one day come back upon the
Spanish Fascists like a boomerang.

A piece of Shakespearean bombast was much quoted at the beginning
of the war. Even Mr Chamberlain quoted it once, if my memory does
not deceive me:

Come the four corners of the world in arms
And we shall shock them: naught shall make us rue
If England to herself do rest but true.
It is right enough, if you interpret it rightly. But England has
got to be true to herself. She is not being true to herself while
the refugees who have sought our shores are penned up in
concentration camps, and company directors work out subtle
schemes to dodge their Excess Profits Tax. It is goodbye to the
Tatler and the Bystander, and farewell to the lady in the
Rolls-Royce car. The heirs of Nelson and of Cromwell are not in
the House of Lords. They are in the fields and the streets, in
the factories and the armed forces, in the four-ale bar and the
suburban back garden; and at present they are still kept under by
a generation of ghosts. Compared with the task of bringing the
real England to the surface, even the winning of the war,
necessary though it is, is secondary. By revolution we become
more ourselves, not less. There is no question of stopping short,
striking a compromise, salvaging "democracy", standing still.
Nothing ever stands still. We must add to our heritage or lose
it, we must grow greater or grow less, we must go forward or
backward. I believe in England, and I believe that we shall go
forward.







IT is a sign of the speed at which events are moving that
Hurst and Blackett's unexpurgated edition of Mein Kampf,
published only a year ago, is edited from a pro-Hitler
angle. The obvious intention of the translator's preface and
notes is to tone down the book's ferocity and present Hitler
in as kindly a light as possible. For at that date Hitler
was still respectable. He had crushed the German labour
movement, and for that the property-owning classes were
willing to forgive him almost anything. Both Left and Right
concurred in the very shallow notion that National Socialism
was merely a version of Conservatism.

Then suddenly it turned out that Hitler was not respectable
after all. As one result of this, Hurst and Blackett's
edition was reissued in a new jacket explaining that all
profits would be devoted to the Red Cross. Nevertheless,
simply on the internal evidence of Mein Kampf, it is
difficult to believe that any real change has taken place in
Hitler's aims and opinions. When one compares his utterances
of a year or so ago with those made fifteen years earlier, a
thing that strikes one is the rigidity of his mind, the way
in which his world-view doesn't develop. It is the fixed
vision of a monomaniac and not likely to be much affected by
the temporary manoeuvres of power politics. Probably, in
Hitler's own mind, the Russo-German Pact represents no more
than an alteration of time-table. The plan laid down in Mein
Kampf was to smash Russia first, with the implied intention
of smashing England afterwards. Now, as it has turned out,
England has got to be dealt with first, because Russia was
the more easily bribed of the two. But Russia's turn will
come when England is out of the picture—that, no doubt, is
how Hitler sees it. Whether it will turn out that way is of
course a different question.

Suppose that Hitler's programme could be put into effect.
What he envisages, a hundred years hence, is a continuous
state of 250 million Germans with plenty of "living room"
(i.e. stretching to Afghanistan or thereabouts), a horrible
brainless empire in which, essentially, nothing ever happens
except the training of young men for war and the endless
breeding of fresh cannon-fodder. How was it that he was able
to put this monstrous vision across? It is easy to say that
at one stage of his career he was financed by the heavy
industrialists, who saw in him the man who would smash the
Socialists and Communists. They would not have backed him,
however, if he had not talked a great movement into
existence already. Again, the situation in Germany, with its
seven million unemployed, was obviously favourable for
demagogues. But Hitler could not have succeeded against his
many rivals if it had not been for the attraction of his own
personality, which one can feel even in the clumsy writing
of Mein Kampf, and which is no doubt overwhelming when one
hears his speeches. I should like to put it on record that I
have never been able to dislike Hitler. Ever since he came
to power—till then, like nearly everyone, I had been
deceived into thinking that he did not matter—I have
reflected that I would certainly kill him if I could get
within reach of him, but that I could feel no personal
animosity. The fact is that there is something deeply
appealing about him. One feels it again when one sees his
photographs—and I recommend especially the photograph at the
beginning of Hurst and Blackett's edition, which shows
Hitler in his early Brownshirt days. It is a pathetic,
dog-like face, the face of a man suffering under intolerable
wrongs. In a rather more manly way it reproduces the
expression of innumerable pictures of Christ crucified, and
there is little doubt that that is how Hitler sees himself.
The initial, personal cause of his grievance against the
universe can only be guessed at; but at any rate the
grievance is here. He is the martyr, the victim, Prometheus
chained to the rock, the self-sacrificing hero who fights
single-handed against impossible odds. If he were killing a
mouse he would know how to make it seem like a dragon. One
feels, as with Napoleon, that he is fighting against
destiny, that he can't win, and yet that he somehow deserves
to. The attraction of such a pose is of course enormous;
half the films that one sees turn upon some such theme.

Also he has grasped the falsity of the hedonistic attitude
to life. Nearly all western thought since the last war,
certainly all "progressive" thought, has assumed tacitly
that human beings desire nothing beyond ease, security and
avoidance of pain. In such a view of life there is no room,
for instance, for patriotism and the military virtues. The
Socialist who finds his children playing with soldiers is
usually upset, but he is never able to think of a substitute
for the tin soldiers; tin pacifists somehow won't do.
Hitler, because in his own joyless mind he feels it with
exceptional strength, knows that human beings don't only
want comfort, safety, short working-hours, hygiene,
birth-control and, in general, common sense; they also, at
least intermittently, want struggle and self-sacrifice, not
to mention drums, flags and loyalty-parades. However they
may be as economic theories, Fascism and Nazism are
psychologically far sounder than any hedonistic conception
of life. The same is probably true of Stalin's militarised
version of Socialism. All three of the great dictators have
enhanced their power by imposing intolerable burdens on
their peoples. Whereas Socialism, and even capitalism in a
more grudging way, have said to people "I offer you a good
time," Hitler has said to them "I offer you struggle, danger
and death," and as a result a whole nation flings itself at
his feet. Perhaps later on they will get sick of it and
change their minds, as at the end of the last war. After a
few years of slaughter and starvation "Greatest happiness of
the greatest number" is a good slogan, but at this moment
"Better an end with horror than a horror without end" is a
winner. Now that we are fighting against the man who coined
it, we ought not to underrate its emotional appeal.



WELLS, HITLER AND THE WORLD STATE (1941)



"In March or April, say the wiseacres, there is to be a
stupendous knockout blow at Britain...What Hitler has to do
it with, I cannot imagine. His ebbing and dispersed military
resources are now probably not so very much greater than the
Italians' before they were put to the test in Greece and
Africa."

"The German air power has been largely spent. It is behind
the times and its first-rate men are mostly dead or
disheartened or worn out."

"In 1914 the Hohenzollern army was the best in the world.
Behind that screaming little defective in Berlin there is
nothing of the sort...Yet our military 'experts' discuss the
waiting phantom. In their imaginations it is perfect in its
equipment and invincible in discipline. Sometimes it is to
strike a decisive 'blow' through Spain and North Africa and
on, or march through the Balkans, march from the Danube to
Ankara, to Persia, to India, or 'crush Russia', or 'pour'
over the Brenner into Italy. The weeks pass and the phantom
does none of these things—for one excellent reason. It does
not exist to that extent. Most of such inadequate guns and
munitions as it possessed must have been taken away from it
and fooled away in Hitler's silly feints to invade Britain.
And its raw jerry-built discipline is wilting under the
creeping realisation that the Blitzkrieg is spent, and the
war is coming home to roost."

These quotations are not taken from the Cavalry Quarterly
but from a series of newspaper articles by Mr H.G. Wells,
written at the beginning of this year and now reprinted in a
book entitled Guide to the New World. Since they were
written, the German army has overrun the Balkans and
reconquered Cyrenaica, it can march through Turkey or Spain
at such time as may suit it, and it has undertaken the
invasion of Russia. How that campaign will turn out I do not
know, but it is worth noticing that the German general
staff, whose opinion is probably worth something, would not
have begun it if they had not felt fairly certain of
finishing it within three months. So much for the idea that
the German army is a bogey, its equipment inadequate, its
morale breaking down, etc etc.

What has Wells to set against the "screaming little
defective in Berlin"? The usual rigmarole about a World
State, plus the Sankey Declaration, which is an attempted
definition of fundamental human rights, of anti-totalitarian
tendency. Except that he is now especially concerned with
federal world control of air power, it is the same gospel as
he has been preaching almost without interruption for the
past forty years, always with an air of angry surprise at
the human beings who can fail to grasp anything so obvious.

What is the use of saying that we need federal world control
of the air? The whole question is how we are to get it. What
is the use of pointing out that a World State is desirable?
What matters is that not one of the five great military
powers would think of submitting to such a thing. All
sensible men for decades past have been substantially in
agreement with what Mr Wells says; but the sensible men have
no power and, in too many cases, no disposition to sacrifice
themselves. Hitler is a criminal lunatic, and Hitler has an
army of millions of men, aeroplanes in thousands, tanks in
tens of thousands. For his sake a great nation has been
willing to overwork itself for six years and then to fight
for two years more, whereas for the commonsense, essentially
hedonistic world-view which Mr Wells puts forward, hardly a
human creature is willing to shed a pint of blood. Before
you can even talk of world reconstruction, or even of peace,
you have got to eliminate Hitler, which means bringing into
being a dynamic not necessarily the same as that of the
Nazis, but probably quite as unacceptable to "enlightened"
and hedonistic people. What has kept England on its feet
during the past year? In part, no doubt, some vague idea
about a better future, but chiefly the atavistic emotion of
patriotism, the ingrained feeling of the English-speaking
peoples that they are superior to foreigners. For the last
twenty years the main object of English left-wing
intellectuals has been to break this feeling down, and if
they had succeeded, we might be watching the SS men
patrolling the London streets at this moment. Similarly, why
are the Russians fighting like tigers against the German
invasion? In part, perhaps, for some half-remembered ideal
of Utopian Socialism, but chiefly in defence of Holy Russia
(the "sacred soil of the Fatherland", etc etc), which Stalin
has revived in an only slightly altered form. The energy
that actually shapes the world springs from emotions—racial
pride, leader-worship, religious belief, love of war—which
liberal intellectuals mechanically write off as
anachronisms, and which they have usually destroyed so
completely in themselves as to have lost all power of
action.

The people who say that Hitler is Antichrist, or
alternatively, the Holy Ghost, are nearer an understanding
of the truth than the intellectuals who for ten dreadful
years have kept it up that he is merely a figure out of
comic opera, not worth taking seriously. All that this idea
really reflects is the sheltered conditions of English life.
The Left Book Club was at bottom a product of Scotland Yard,
just as the Peace Pledge Union is a product of the navy. One
development of the last ten years has been the appearance of
the "political book", a sort of enlarged pamphlet combining
history with political criticism, as an important literary
form. But the best writers in this line—Trotsky, Rauschning,
Rosenberg, Silone, Borkenau, Koestler and others—have none
of them been Englishmen, and nearly all of them have been
renegades from one or other extremist party, who have seen
totalitarianism at close quarters and known the meaning of
exile and persecution. Only in the English-speaking
countries was it fashionable to believe, right up to the
outbreak of war, that Hitler was an unimportant lunatic and
the German tanks made of cardboard. Mr Wells, it will be
seen from the quotations I have given above, believes
something of the kind still. I do not suppose that either
the bombs or the German campaign in Greece have altered his
opinion. A lifelong habit of thought stands between him and
an understanding of Hitler's power.

Mr Wells, like Dickens, belongs to the non-military middle
class. The thunder of guns, the jingle of spurs, the catch
in the throat when the old flag goes by, leave him
manifestly cold. He has an invincible hatred of the
fighting, hunting, swashbuckling side of life, symbolised in
all his early books by a violent propaganda against horses.
The principal villain of his Outline of History is the
military adventurer, Napoleon. If one looks through nearly
any book that he has written in the last forty years one
finds the same idea constantly recurring: the supposed
antithesis between the man of science who is working towards
a planned World State and the reactionary who is trying to
restore a disorderly past. In novels, Utopias, essays,
films, pamphlets, the antithesis crops up, always more or
less the same. On the one side science, order, progress,
internationalism, aeroplanes, steel, concrete, hygiene: on
the other side war, nationalism, religion, monarchy,
peasants, Greek professors, poets, horses. History as he
sees it is a series of victories won by the scientific man
over the romantic man. Now, he is probably right in assuming
that a "reasonable", planned form of society, with
scientists rather than witch-doctors in control, will
prevail sooner or later, but that is a different matter from
assuming that it is just round the corner. There survives
somewhere or other an interesting controversy which took
place between Wells and Churchill at the time of the Russian
Revolution. Wells accuses Churchill of not really believing
his own propaganda about the Bolsheviks being monsters
dripping with blood etc, but of merely fearing that they
were going to introduce an era of common sense and
scientific control, in which flag-wavers like Churchill
himself would have no place. Churchill's estimate of the
Bolsheviks, however, was nearer the mark than Wells's. The
early Bolsheviks may have been angels or demons, according
as one chooses to regard them, but at any rate they were not
sensible men. They were not introducing a Wellsian Utopia
but a Rule of the Saints, which, like the English Rule of
the Saints, was a military despotism enlivened by witchcraft
trials. The same misconception reappears in an inverted form
in Wells's attitude to the Nazis. Hitler is all the
war-lords and witch doctors in history rolled into one.
Therefore, argues Wells, he is an absurdity, a ghost from
the past, a creature doomed to disappear almost immediately.
But unfortunately the equation of science with common sense
does not really hold good. The aeroplane, which was looked
forward to as a civilising influence but in practice has
hardly been used except for dropping bombs, is the symbol of
that fact. Modern Germany is far more scientific than
England, and far more barbarous. Much of what Wells has
imagined and worked for is physically there in Nazi Germany.
The order, the planning, the State encouragement of science,
the steel, the concrete, the aeroplanes, are all there, but
all in the service of ideas appropriate to the Stone Age.
Science is fighting on the side of superstition. But
obviously it is impossible for Wells to accept this. It
would contradict the world-view on which his own works are
based. The war-lords and the witch-doctors must fail, the
common-sense World State, as seen by a nineteenth-century
liberal whose heart does not leap at the sound of bugles,
must triumph. Treachery and defeatism apart, Hitler cannot
be a danger. That he should finally win would be an
impossible reversal of history, like a Jacobite restoration.

But is it not a sort of parricide for a person of my age
(thirty-eight) to find fault with H.G. Wells? Thinking
people who were born about the beginning of this century are
in some sense Wells's own creation. How much influence any
mere writer has, and especially a "popular" writer whose
work takes effect quickly, is questionable, but I doubt
whether anyone who was writing books between 1900 and 1920,
at any rate in the English language, influenced the young so
much. The minds of all of us, and therefore the physical
world, would be perceptibly different if Wells had never
existed. Only, just the singleness of mind, the one-sided
imagination that made him seem like an inspired prophet in
the Edwardian age, make him a shallow, inadequate thinker
now. When Wells was young, the antithesis between science
and reaction was not false. Society was ruled by
narrow-minded, profoundly incurious people, predatory
businessmen, dull squires, bishops, politicians who could
quote Horace but had never heard of algebra. Science was
faintly disreputable and religious belief obligatory.
Traditionalism, stupidity, snobbishness, patriotism,
superstition and love of war seemed to be all on the same
side; there was need of someone who could state the opposite
point of view. Back in the nineteen-hundreds it was a
wonderful experience for a boy to discover H.G. Wells. There
you were, in a world of pedants, clergymen and golfers, with
your future employers exhorting you to "get on or get out",
your parents systematically warping your sexual life, and
your dull-witted schoolmasters sniggering over their Latin
tags; and here was this wonderful man who could tell you
about the inhabitants of the planets and the bottom of the
sea, and who knew that the future was not going to be what
respectable people imagined. A decade or so before
aeroplanes were technically feasible Wells knew that within
a little while men would be able to fly. He knew that
because he himself wanted to be able to fly, and therefore
felt sure that research in that direction would continue. On
the other hand, even when I was a little boy, at a time when
the Wright brothers had actually lifted their machine off
the ground for fifty-nine seconds, the generally accepted
opinion was that if God had meant us to fly He would have
given us wings. Up to 1914 Wells was in the main a true
prophet. In physical details his vision of the new world has
been fulfilled to a surprising extent.

But because he belonged to the nineteenth century and to a
non-military nation and class, he could not grasp the
tremendous strength of the old world which was symbolised in
his mind by fox-hunting Tories. He was, and still is, quite
incapable of understanding that nationalism, religious
bigotry and feudal loyalty are far more powerful forces than
what he himself would describe as sanity. Creatures out of
the Dark Ages have come marching into the present, and if
they are ghosts they are at any rate ghosts which need a
strong magic to lay them. The people who have shown the best
understanding of Fascism are either those who have suffered
under it or those who have a Fascist streak in themselves. A
crude book like The Iron Heel, written nearly thirty years
ago, is a truer prophecy of the future than either Brave New
World or The Shape Of Things To Come. If one had to choose
among Wells's own contemporaries a writer who could stand
towards him as a corrective, one might choose Kipling, who
was not deaf to the evil voices of power and military
"glory". Kipling would have understood the appeal of Hitler,
or for that matter of Stalin, whatever his attitude towards
them might be. Wells is too sane to understand the modern
world. The succession of lower-middle-class novels which are
his greatest achievement stopped short at the other war and
never really began again, and since 1920 he has squandered
his talents in slaying paper dragons. But how much it is,
after all, to have any talents to squander.


LOOKING BACK ON THE SPANISH WAR (1942)
1.

First of all the physical memories, the sounds, the smells
and the surfaces of things.

It is curious that more vividly than anything that came
afterwards in the Spanish war I remember the week of
so-called training that we received before being sent to the
front—the huge cavalry barracks in Barcelona with its
draughty stables and cobbled yards, the icy cold of the pump
where one washed, the filthy meals made tolerable by
pannikins of wine, the Trousered militia-women chopping
firewood, and the roll-call in the early mornings where my
prosaic English name made a sort of comic interlude among
the resounding Spanish ones, Manuel Gonzalez, Pedro Aguilar,
Ramon Fenellosa, Roque Ballaster, Jaime Domenech, Sebastian
Viltron, Ramon Nuvo Bosch. I name those particular men
because I remember the faces of all of them. Except for two
who were mere riff-raff and have doubtless become good
Falangists by this time, it is probable that all of them are
dead. Two of them I know to be dead. The eldest would have
been about twenty-five, the youngest sixteen.

One of the essential experiences of war is never being able
to escape from disgusting smells of human origin. Latrines
are an overworked subject in war literature, and I would not
mention them if it were not that the latrine in our barracks
did its necessary bit towards puncturing my own illusions
about the Spanish civil war. The Latin type of latrine, at
which you have to squat, is bad enough at its best, but
these were made of some kind of polished stone so slippery
that it was all you could do to keep on your feet. In
addition they were always blocked. Now I have plenty of
other disgusting things in my memory, but I believe it was
these latrines that first brought home to me the thought, so
often to recur: 'Here we are, soldiers of a revolutionary
army, defending Democracy against Fascism, fighting a war
which is about something, and the detail of our lives is
just as sordid and degrading as it could be in prison, let
alone in a bourgeois army.' Many other things reinforced
this impression later; for instance, the boredom and animal
hunger of trench life, the squalid intrigues over scraps of
food, the mean, nagging quarrels which people exhausted by
lack of sleep indulge in.

The essential horror of army life (whoever has been a
soldier will know what I mean by the essential horror of
army life) is barely affected by the nature of the war you
happen to be fighting in. Discipline, for instance, is
ultimately the same in all armies. Orders have to be obeyed
and enforced by punishment if necessary, the relationship of
officer and man has to be the relationship of superior and
inferior. The picture of war set forth in books like All
Quiet on the Western Front is substantially true. Bullets
hurt, corpses stink, men under fire are often so frightened
that they wet their trousers. It is true that the social
background from which an army springs will colour its
training, tactics and general efficiency, and also that the
consciousness of being in the right can bolster up morale,
though this affects the civilian population more than the
troops. (People forget that a soldier anywhere near the
front line is usually too hungry, or frightened, or cold,
or, above all, too tired to bother about the political
origins of the war.) But the laws of nature are not
suspended for a 'red' army any more than for a 'white' one.
A louse is a louse and a bomb is a bomb, even though the
cause you are fighting for happens to be just.

Why is it worth while to point out anything so obvious?
Because the bulk of the British and American intelligentsia
were manifestly unaware of it then, and are now. Our
memories are short nowadays, but look back a bit, dig out
the files of New Masses or the Daily Worker, and just have a
look at the romantic warmongering muck that our left-wingers
were spilling at that time. All the stale old phrases! And
the unimaginative callousness of it! The sang-froid with
which London faced the bombing of Madrid! Here I am not
bothering about the counter-propagandists of the Right, the
Lunns, Garvins et hoc genus; they go without saying. But
here were the very people who for twenty years had hooted
and jeered at the 'glory' of war, at atrocity stories, at
patriotism, even at physical courage, coming out with stuff
that with the alteration of a few names would have fitted
into the Daily Mail of 1918. If there was one thing that the
British intelligentsia were committed to, it was the
debunking version of war, the theory that war is all corpses
and latrines and never leads to any good result. Well, the
same people who in 1933 sniggered pityingly if you said that
in certain circumstances you would fight for your country,
in 1937 were denouncing you as a Trotsky-Fascist if you
suggested that the stories in New Masses about freshly
wounded men clamouring to get back into the fighting might
be exaggerated. And the Left intelligentsia made their
swing-over from 'War is hell' to 'War is glorious' not only
with no sense of incongruity but almost without any
intervening stage. Later the bulk of them were to make other
transitions equally violent. There must be a quite large
number of people, a sort of central core of the
intelligentsia, who approved the 'King and Country'
declaration in 1935, shouted for a' firm line against
Germany' in 1937, supported the People's Convention in 1940,
and are demanding a Second Front now.

As far as the mass of the people go, the extraordinary
swings of opinion which occur nowadays, the emotions which
can be turned on and off like a tap, are the result of
newspaper and radio hypnosis. In the intelligentsia I should
say they result rather from money and mere physical safety.
At a given moment they may be 'pro-war' or 'anti-war', but
in either case they have no realistic picture of war in
their minds. When they enthused over the Spanish war they
knew, of course, that people were being killed and that to
be killed is unpleasant, but they did feel that for a
soldier in the Spanish Republican army the experience of war
was somehow not degrading. Somehow the latrines stank less,
discipline was less irksome. You have only to glance at the
New Statesman to see that they believed that; exactly
similar blah is being written about the Red Army at this
moment. We have become too civilized to grasp the obvious.
For the truth is very simple. To survive you often have to
fight, and to fight you have to dirty yourself. War is evil,
and it is often the lesser evil. Those who take the sword
perish by the sword, and those who don't take the sword
perish by smelly diseases. The fact that such a platitude is
worth writing down shows what the years of rentier
capitalism have done to us.

2.

In connexion with what I have just said, a footnote, on
atrocities.

I have little direct evidence about the atrocities in the
Spanish civil war. I know that some were committed by the
Republicans, and far more (they are still continuing) by the
Fascists. But what impressed me then, and has impressed me
ever since, is that atrocities are believed in or
disbelieved in solely on grounds of political predilection.
Everyone believes in the atrocities of the enemy and
disbelieves in those of his own side, without ever bothering
to examine the evidence. Recently I drew up a table of
atrocities during the period between 1918 and the present;
there was never a year when atrocities were not occurring
somewhere or other, and there was hardly a single case when
the Left and the Right believed in the same stories
simultaneously. And stranger yet, at any moment the
situation can suddenly reverse itself and yesterday's
proved-to-the-hilt atrocity story can become a ridiculous
lie, merely because the political landscape has changed.

In the present war we are in the curious situation that our
'atrocity campaign' was done largely before the war started,
and done mostly by the Left, the people who normally pride
themselves on their incredulity. In the same period the
Right, the atrocity-mongers of 1914-18, were gazing at Nazi
Germany and flatly refusing to see any evil in it. Then as
soon as war broke out it was the pro-Nazis of yesterday who
were repeating horror stories, while the anti-Nazis suddenly
found themselves doubting whether the Gestapo really
existed. Nor was this solely the result of the Russo-German
Pact. It was partly because before the war the Left had
wrongly believed that Britain and Germany would never fight
and were therefore able to be anti-German and anti-British
simultaneously; partly also because official war-propaganda,
with its disgusting hypocrisy and self-righteousness, always
tends to make thinking people sympathize with the enemy.
Part of the price we paid for the systematic lying of
1914-17 was the exaggerated pro-German reaction which
followed. During the years 1918-33 you were hooted at in
left-wing circles if you suggested that Germany bore even a
fraction of responsibility for the war. In all the
denunciations of Versailles I listened to during those years
I don't think I ever once heard the question, 'What would
have happened if Germany had won?' even mentioned, let alone
discussed. So also with atrocities. The truth, it is felt,
becomes untruth when your enemy utters it. Recently I
noticed that the very people who swallowed any and every
horror story about the Japanese in Nanking in 1937 refused
to believe exactly the same stories about Hong Kong in 1942.
There was even a tendency to feel that the Nanking
atrocities had become, as it were, retrospectively untrue
because the British Government now drew attention to them.

But unfortunately the truth about atrocities is far worse
than that they are lied about and made into propaganda. The
truth is that they happen. The fact often adduced as a
reason for scepticism—that the same horror stories come up
in war after war—merely makes it rather more likely that
these stories are true. Evidently they are widespread
fantasies, and war provides an opportunity of putting them
into practice. Also, although it has ceased to be
fashionable to say so, there is little question that what
one may roughly call the 'whites' commit far more and worse
atrocities than the 'reds'. There is not the slightest
doubt, for instance, about the behaviour of the Japanese in
China. Nor is there much doubt about the long tale of
Fascist outrages during the last ten years in Europe. The
volume of testimony is enormous, and a respectable
proportion of it comes from the German press and radio.
These things really happened, that is the thing to keep
one's eye on. They happened even though Lord Halifax said
they happened. The raping and butchering in Chinese cities,
the tortures in the cellars of the Gestapo, the elderly
Jewish professors flung into cesspools, the machine-gunning
of refugees along the Spanish roads—they all happened, and
they did not happen any the less because the Daily Telegraph
has suddenly found out about them when it is five years too
late.

3.

Two memories, the first not proving anything in particular,
the second, I think, giving one a certain insight into the
atmosphere of a revolutionary period:

Early one morning another man and I had gone out to snipe at
the Fascists in the trenches outside Huesca. Their line and
ours here lay three hundred yards apart, at which range our
aged rifles would not shoot accurately, but by sneaking out
to a spot about a hundred yards from the Fascist trench you
might, if you were lucky, get a shot at someone through a
gap in the parapet. Unfortunately the ground between was a
flat beet field with no cover except a few ditches, and it
was necessary to go out while it was still-dark and return
soon after dawn, before the light became too good. This time
no Fascists appeared, and we stayed too long and were caught
by the dawn. We were in a ditch, but behind us were two
hundred yards of flat ground with hardly enough cover for a
rabbit. We were still trying to nerve ourselves to make a
dash for it when there was an uproar and a blowing of
whistles in the Fascist trench. Some of our aeroplanes were
coming over. At this moment, a man presumably carrying a
message to an officer, jumped out of the trench and ran
along the top of the parapet in full view. He was
half-dressed and was holding up his trousers with both hands
as he ran. I refrained from shooting at him. It is true that
I am a poor shot and unlikely to hit a running man at a
hundred yards, and also that I was thinking chiefly about
getting back to our trench while the Fascists had their
attention fixed on the aeroplanes. Still, I did not shoot
partly because of that detail about the trousers. I had come
here to shoot at 'Fascists'; but a man who is holding up his
trousers isn't a 'Fascist', he is visibly a fellow-creature,
similar to yourself, and you don't feel like shooting at
him.

What does this incident demonstrate? Nothing very much,
because it is the kind of thing that happens all the time in
all wars. The other is different. I don't suppose that in
telling it I can make it moving to you who read it, but I
ask you to believe that it is moving to me, as an incident
characteristic of the moral atmosphere of a particular
moment in time.

One of the recruits who joined us while I was at the
barracks was a wild-looking boy from the back streets of
Barcelona. He was ragged and barefooted. He was also
extremely dark (Arab blood, I dare say), and made gestures
you do not usually see a European make; one in
particular—the arm outstretched, the palm vertical—was a
gesture characteristic of Indians. One day a bundle of
cigars, which you could still buy dirt cheap at that time,
was stolen out of my bunk. Rather foolishly I reported this
to the officer, and one of the scallywags I have already
mentioned promptly came forward and said quite untruly that
twenty-five pesetas had been stolen from his bunk. For some
reason the officer instantly decided that the brown-faced
boy must be the thief. They were very hard on stealing in
the militia, and in theory people could be shot for it. The
wretched boy allowed himself to be led off to the guardroom
to be searched. What most struck me was that he barely
attempted to protest his innocence. In the fatalism of his
attitude you could see the desperate poverty in which he had
been bred. The officer ordered him to take his clothes off.
With a humility which was horrible to me he stripped himself
naked, and his clothes were searched. Of course neither the
cigars nor the money were there; in fact he had not stolen
them. What was most painful of all was that he seemed no
less ashamed after his innocence had been established. That
night I took him to the pictures and gave him brandy and
chocolate. But that too was horrible—I mean the attempt to
wipe out an injury with money. For a few minutes I had half
believed him to be a thief, and that could not be wiped out.

Well, a few weeks later at the front I had trouble with one
of the men in my section. By this time I was a 'cabo', or
corporal, in command of twelve men. It was static warfare,
horribly cold, and the chief job was getting sentries to
stay awake at their posts. One day a man suddenly refused to
go to a certain post, which he said quite truly was exposed
to enemy fire. He was a feeble creature, and I seized hold
of him and began to drag him towards his post. This roused
the feelings of the others against me, for Spaniards, I
think, resent being touched more than we do. Instantly I was
surrounded by a ring of shouting men:' Fascist! Fascist! Let
that man go! This isn't a bourgeois army. Fascist!' etc.,
etc. As best I could in my bad Spanish I shouted back that
orders had got to be obeyed, and the row developed into one
of those enormous arguments by means of which discipline is
gradually hammered out in revolutionary armies. Some said I
was right, others said I was wrong. But the point is that
the one who took my side the most warmly of all was the
brown-faced boy. As soon as he saw what was happening he
sprang into the ring and began passionately defending me.
With his strange, wild, Indian gesture he kept exclaiming,
'He's the best corporal we've got!' (No hay cabo como el!)
Later on he applied for leave to exchange into my section.

Why is this incident touching to me? Because in any normal
circumstances it would have been impossible for good
feelings ever to be re-established between this boy and
myself. The implied accusation of theft would not have been
made any better, probably somewhat worse, by my efforts to
make amends. One of the effects of safe and civilized life
is an immense oversensitiveness which makes all the primary
emotions seem somewhat disgusting. Generosity is as painful
as meanness, gratitude as hateful as ingratitude. But in
Spain in 1936 we were not living in a normal time. It was a
time when generous feelings and gestures were easier than
they ordinarily are. I could relate a dozen similar
incidents, not really communicable but bound up in my own
mind with the special atmosphere of the time, the shabby
clothes and the gay-coloured revolutionary posters, the
universal use of the word 'comrade', the anti-Fascist
ballads printed on flimsy paper and sold for a penny, the
phrases like 'international proletarian solidarty',
pathetically repeated by ignorant men who believed them to
mean something. Could you feel friendly towards somebody,
and stick up for him in a quarrel, after you had been
ignominiously searched in his presence for property you were
supposed to have stolen from him? No, you couldn't; but you
might if you had both been through some emotionally widening
experience. That is one of the by-products of revolution,
though in this case it was only the beginnings of a
revolution, and obviously foredoomed to failure.

4.

The struggle for power between the Spanish Republican
parties is an unhappy, far-off thing which I have no wish to
revive at this date. I only mention it in order to say:
believe nothing, or next to nothing, of what you read about
internal affairs on the Government side. It is all, from
whatever source, party propaganda—that is to say, lies. The
broad truth about the war is simple enough. The Spanish
bourgeoisie saw their chance of crushing the labour
movement, and took it, aided by the Nazis and by the forces
of reaction all over the world. It is doubtful whether more
than that will ever be established.

I remember saying once to Arthur Koestler, 'History stopped
in 1936', at which he nodded in immediate understanding. We
were both thinking of totalitarianism in general, but more
particularly of the Spanish civil war. Early in life I have
noticed that no event is ever correctly reported in a
newspaper, but in Spain, for the first time, I saw newspaper
reports which did not bear any relation to the facts, not
even the relationship which is implied in an ordinary lie. I
saw great battles reported where there had been no fighting,
and complete silence where hundreds of men had been killed.
I saw troops who had fought bravely denounced as cowards and
traitors, and others who had never seen a shot fired hailed
as the heroes of imaginary victories; and I saw newspapers
in London retailing these lies and eager intellectuals
building emotional superstructures over events that had
never happened. I saw, in fact, history being written not in
terms of what happened but of what ought to have happened
according to various 'party lines'. Yet in a way, horrible
as all this was, it was unimportant. It concerned secondary
issues—namely, the struggle for power between the Comintern
and the Spanish left-wing parties, and the efforts of the
Russian Government to prevent revolution in Spain. But the
broad picture of the war which the Spanish Government
presented to the world was not untruthful. The main issues
were what it said they were. But as for the Fascists and
their backers, how could they come even as near to the truth
as that? How could they possibly mention their real aims?
Their version of the war was pure fantasy, and in the
circumstances it could not have been otherwise.

The only propaganda line open to the Nazis and Fascists was
to represent themselves as Christian patriots saving Spain
from a Russian dictatorship. This involved pretending that
life in Government Spain was just one long massacre (vide
the Catholic Herald or the Daily Mail—but these were child's
play compared with the Continental Fascist press), and it
involved immensely exaggerating the scale of Russian
intervention. Out of the huge pyramid of lies which the
Catholic and reactionary press all over the world built up,
let me take just one point—the presence in Spain of a
Russian army. Devout Franco partisans all believed in this;
estimates of its strength went as high as half a million.
Now, there was no Russian army in Spain. There may have been
a handful of airmen and other technicians, a few hundred at
the most, but an army there was not. Some thousands of
foreigners who fought in Spain, not to mention millions of
Spaniards, were witnesses of this. Well, their testimony
made no impression at all upon the Franco propagandists, not
one of whom had set foot in Government Spain. Simultaneously
these people refused utterly to admit the fact of German or
Italian intervention at the same time as the Germany and
Italian press were openly boasting about the exploits of
their' legionaries'. I have chosen to mention only one
point, but in fact the whole of Fascist propaganda about the
war was on this level.

This kind of thing is frightening to me, because it often
gives me the feeling that the very concept of objective
truth is fading out of the world. After all, the chances are
that those lies, or at any rate similar lies, will pass into
history. How will the history of the Spanish war be written?
If Franco remains in power his nominees will write the
history books, and (to stick to my chosen point) that
Russian army which never existed will become historical
fact, and schoolchildren will learn about it generations
hence. But suppose Fascism is finally defeated and some kind
of democratic government restored in Spain in the fairly
near future; even then, how is the history of the war to be
written? What kind of records will Franco have left behind
him? Suppose even that the records kept on the Government
side are recoverable—even so, how is a true history of the
war to be written? For, as I have pointed out already, the
Government, also dealt extensively in lies. From the
anti-Fascist angle one could write a broadly truthful
history of the war, but it would be a partisan history,
unreliable on every minor point. Yet, after all, some kind
of history will be written, and after those who actually
remember the war are dead, it will be universally accepted.
So for all practical purposes the lie will have become
truth.

I know it is the fashion to say that most of recorded
history is lies anyway. I am willing to believe that history
is for the most part inaccurate and biased, but what is
peculiar to our own age is the abandonment of the idea that
history could be truthfully written. In the past people
deliberately lied, or they unconsciously coloured what they
wrote, or they struggled after the truth, well knowing that
they must make many mistakes; but in each case they believed
that 'facts' existed and were more or less discoverable. And
in practice there was always a considerable body of fact
which would have been agreed to by almost everyone. If you
look up the history of the last war in, for instance, the
Encyclopaedia Britannica, you will find that a respectable
amount of the material is drawn from German sources. A
British and a German historian would disagree deeply on many
things, even on fundamentals, but there would still be that
body of, as it were, neutral fact on which neither would
seriously challenge the other. It is just this common basis
of agreement, with its implication that human beings are all
one species of animal, that totalitarianism destroys. Nazi
theory indeed specifically denies that such a thing as 'the
truth' exists. There is, for instance, no such thing as
'Science'. There is only 'German Science', 'Jewish Science',
etc. The implied objective of this line of thought is a
nightmare world in which the Leader, or some ruling clique,
controls not only the future but the past. If the Leader
says of such and such an event, 'It never happened'—well, it
never happened. If he says that two and two are five—well,
two and two are five. This prospect frightens me much more
than bombs—and after our experiences of the last few years
that is not a frivolous statement.

But is it perhaps childish or morbid to terrify oneself with
visions of a totalitarian future? Before writing off the
totalitarian world as a nightmare that can't come true, just
remember that in 1925 the world of today would have seemed a
nightmare that couldn't come true. Against that shifting
phantasmagoric world in which black may be white tomorrow
and yesterday's weather can be changed by decree, there are
in reality only two safeguards. One is that however much you
deny the truth, the truth goes on existing, as it were,
behind your back, and you consequently can't violate it in
ways that impair military efficiency. The other is that so
long as some parts of the earth remain unconquered, the
liberal tradition can be kept alive. Let Fascism, or
possibly even a combination of several Fascisms, conquer the
whole world, and those two conditions no longer exist. We in
England underrate the danger of this kind of thing, because
our traditions and our past security have given us a
sentimental belief that it all comes right in the end and
the thing you most fear never really happens. Nourished for
hundreds of years on a literature in which Right invariably
triumphs in the last chapter, we believe half-instinctively
that evil always defeats itself in the long run. Pacifism,
for instance, is founded largely on this belief. Don't
resist evil, and it will somehow destroy itself. But why
should it? What evidence is there that it does? And what
instance is there of a modern industrialized state
collapsing unless conquered from the outside by military
force?

Consider for instance the re-institution of slavery. Who
could have imagined twenty years ago that slavery would
return to Europe? Well, slavery has been restored under our
noses. The forced-labour camps all over Europe and North
Africa where Poles, Russians, Jews and political prisoners
of every race toil at road-making or swamp-draining for
their bare rations, are simple chattel slavery. The most one
can say is that the buying and selling of slaves by
individuals is not yet permitted. In other ways—the
breaking-up of families, for instance—the conditions are
probably worse than they were on the American cotton
plantations. There is no reason for thinking that this state
of affairs will change while any totalitarian domination
endures. We don't grasp its full implications, because in
our mystical way we feel that a régime founded on slavery
must collapse. But it is worth comparing the duration of the
slave empires of antiquity with that of any modern state.
Civilizations founded on slavery have lasted for such
periods as four thousand years.

When I think of antiquity, the detail that frightens me is
that those hundreds of millions of slaves on whose backs
civilization rested generation after generation have left
behind them no record whatever. We do not even know their
names. In the whole of Greek and Roman history, how many
slaves' names are known to you? I can think of two, or
possibly three. One is Spartacus and the other is Epictetus.
Also, in the Roman room at the British Museum there is a
glass jar with the maker's name inscribed on the bottom,
'felix fecit'. I have a mental picture of poor Felix (a Gaul
with red hair and a metal collar round his neck), but in
fact he may not have been a slave; so there are only two
slaves whose names I definitely know, and probably few
people can remember more. The rest have gone down into utter
silence.

5.

The backbone of the resistance against Franco was the
Spanish working class, especially the urban trade union
members. In the long run—it is important to remember that it
is only in the long run—the working class remains the most
reliable enemy of Fascism, simply because the working-class
stands to gain most by a decent reconstruction of society.
Unlike other classes or categories, it can't be permanently
bribed.

To say this is not to idealize the working class. In the
long struggle that has followed the Russian Revolution it is
the manual workers who have been defeated, and it is
impossible not to feel that it was their own fault. Time
after time, in country after country, the organized
working-class movements have been crushed by open, illegal
violence, and their comrades abroad, linked to them in
theoretical solidarity, have simply looked on and done
nothing; and underneath this, secret cause of many
betrayals, has lain the fact that between white and coloured
workers there is not even lip-service to solidarity. Who can
believe in the class-conscious international proletariat
after the events of the past ten years? To the British
working class the massacre of their comrades in Vienna,
Berlin, Madrid, or wherever it might be seemed less
interesting and less important than yesterday's football
match. Yet this does not alter the fact that the working
class will go on struggling against Fascism after the others
have caved in. One feature of the Nazi conquest of France
was the astonishing defections among the intelligentsia,
including some of the left-wing political intelligentsia.
The intelligentsia are the people who squeal loudest against
Fascism, and yet a respectable proportion of them collapse
into defeatism when the pinch comes. They are far-sighted
enough to see the odds against them, and moreover they can
be bribed—for it is evident that the Nazis think it worth
while to bribe intellectuals. With the working class it is
the other way about. Too ignorant to see through the trick
that is being played on them, they easily swallow the
promises of Fascism, yet sooner or later they always take up
the struggle again. They must do so, because in their own
bodies they always discover that the promises of Fascism
cannot be fulfilled. To win over the working class
permanently, the Fascists would have to raise the general
standard of living, which they are unable and probably
unwilling to do. The struggle of the working class is like
the growth of a plant. The plant is blind and stupid, but it
knows enough to keep pushing upwards towards the light, and
it will do this in the face of endless discouragements. What
are the workers struggling for? Simply for the decent life
which they are more and more aware is now technically
possible. Their consciousness of this aim ebbs and flows. In
Spain, for a while, people were acting consciously, moving
towards a goal which they wanted to reach and believed they
could reach. It accounted for the curiously buoyant feeling
that life in Government Spain had during the early months of
the war. The common people knew in their bones that the
Republic was their friend and Franco was their enemy. They
knew that they were in the right, because they were fighting
for something which the world owed them and was able to give
them.

One has to remember this to see the Spanish war in its true
perspective. When one thinks of the cruelty, squalor, and
futility of War—and in this particular case of the
intrigues, the persecutions, the lies and the
misunderstandings—there is always the temptation to say:
'One side is as bad as the other. I am neutral'. In
practice, however, one cannot be neutral, and there is
hardly such a thing as a war in which it makes no difference
who wins. Nearly always one stands more or less for
progress, the other side more or less for reaction. The
hatred which the Spanish Republic excited in millionaires,
dukes, cardinals, play-boys, Blimps, and what-not would in
itself be enough to show one how the land lay. In essence it
was a class war. If it had been won, the cause of the common
people everywhere would have been strengthened. It was lost,
and the dividend-drawers all over the world rubbed their
hands. That was the real issue; all else was froth on its
surface.

6.

The outcome of the Spanish war was settled in London, Paris,
Rome, Berlin—at any rate not in Spain. After the summer of
1937 those with eyes in their heads realized that the
Government could not win the war unless there were some
profound change in the international set-up, and in deciding
to fight on Negrin and the others may have been partly
influenced by the expectation that the world war which
actually broke out in 1939 was coming in 1938. The
much-publicized disunity on the Government side was not a
main cause of defeat. The Government militias were hurriedly
raised, ill-armed and unimaginative in their military
outlook, but they would have been the same if complete
political agreement had existed from the start. At the
outbreak of war the average Spanish factory-worker did not
even know how to fire a rifle (there had never been
universal conscription in Spain), and the traditional
pacifism of the Left was a great handicap. The thousands of
foreigners who served in Spain made good infantry, but there
were very few experts of any kind among them. The Trotskyist
thesis that the war could have been won if the revolution
had not been sabotaged was probably false. To nationalize
factories, demolish churches, and issue revolutionary
manifestoes would not have made the armies more efficient.
The Fascists won because they were the stronger; they had
modern arms and the others hadn't. No political strategy
could offset that.

The most baffling thing in the Spanish war was the behaviour
of the great powers. The war was actually won for Franco by
the Germans and Italians, whose motives were obvious enough.
The motives of France and Britain are less easy to
understand. In 1936 it was clear to everyone that if Britain
would only help the Spanish Government, even to the extent
of a few million pounds' worth of arms, Franco would
collapse and German strategy would be severely dislocated.
By that time one did not need to be a clairvoyant to foresee
that war between Britain and Germany was coming; one could
even foretell within a year or two when it would come. Yet
in the most mean, cowardly, hypocritical way the British
ruling class did all they could to hand Spain over to Franco
and the Nazis. Why? Because they were pro-Fascist, was the
obvious answer. Undoubtedly they were, and yet when it came
to the final showdown they chose to Stand up to Germany. It
is still very uncertain what plan they acted on in backing
Franco, and they may have had no clear plan at all. Whether
the British ruling class are wicked or merely stupid is one
of the most difficult questions of our time, and at certain
moments a very important question. As to the Russians, their
motives in the Spanish war are completely inscrutable. Did
they, as the pinks believed, intervene in Spain in order to
defend Democracy and thwart the Nazis? Then why did they
intervene on such a niggardly scale and finally leave Spain
in the lurch? Or did they, as the Catholics maintained,
intervene in order to foster revolution in Spain? Then why
did they do all in their power to crush the Spanish
revolutionary movements, defend private property and hand
power to the middle class as against the working class? Or
did they, as the Trotskyists suggested, intervene simply in
order to prevent a Spanish revolution? Then why not have
backed Franco? Indeed, their actions are most easily
explained if one assumes that they were acting on several
contradictory motives. I believe that in the future we shall
come to feel that Stalin's foreign policy, instead of being
so diabolically clever as it is claimed to be, has been
merely opportunistic and stupid. But at any rate, the
Spanish civil war demonstrated that the Nazis knew what they
were doing and their opponents did not. The war was fought
at a low technical level and its major strategy was very
simple. That side which had arms would win. The Nazis and
the Italians gave arms to the Spanish Fascist friends, and
the western democracies and the Russians didn't give arms to
those who should have been their friends. So the Spanish
Republic perished, having' gained what no republic missed'.

Whether it was right, as all left-wingers in other countries
undoubtedly did, to encourage the Spaniards to go on
fighting when they could not win is a question hard to
answer. I myself think it was right, because I believe that
it is better even from the point of view of survival to
fight and be conquered than to surrender without fighting.
The effects on the grand strategy of the struggle against
Fascism cannot be assessed yet. The ragged, weaponless
armies of the Republic held out for two and a half years,
which was undoubtedly longer than their enemies expected.
But whether that dislocated the Fascist timetable, or
whether, on the other hand, it merely postponed the major
war and gave the Nazis extra time to get their war machine
into trim, is still uncertain.

7.

I never think of the Spanish war without two memories coming
into my mind. One is of the hospital ward at Lerida and the
rather sad voices of the wounded militiamen singing some
song with a refrain that ended—

Una resolucion,
Luchar hast' al fin!

Well, they fought to the end all right. For the last
eighteen months of the war the Republican armies must have
been fighting almost without cigarettes, and with precious
little food. Even when I left Spain in the middle of 1937,
meat and bread were scarce, tobacco a rarity, coffee and
sugar almost unobtainable.

The other memory is of the Italian militiaman who shook my
hand in the guardroom, the day I joined the militia. I wrote
about this man at the beginning of my book on the Spanish
war [Homage to Catalonia], and do not want to repeat what I
said there. When I remember—oh, how vividly!—his shabby
uniform and fierce, pathetic, innocent face, the complex
side-issues of the war seem to fade away and I see clearly
that there was at any rate no doubt as to who was in the
right. In spite of power politics and journalistic lying,
the central issue of the war was the attempt of people like
this to win the decent life which they knew to be their
birthright. It is difficult to think of this particular
man's probable end without several kinds of bitterness.
Since I met him in the Lenin Barracks he was probably a
Trotskyist or an Anarchist, and in the peculiar conditions
of our time, when people of that sort are not killed by the
Gestapo they are usually killed by the G.P.U. But that does
not affect the long-term issues. This man's face, which I
saw only for a minute or two, remains with me as a sort of
visual reminder of what the war was really about. He
symbolizes for me the flower of the European working class,
harried by the police of all countries, the people who fill
the mass graves of the Spanish battlefields and are now, to
the tune of several millions, rotting in forced-labour
camps.

When one thinks of all the people who support or have
supported Fascism, one stands amazed at their diversity.
What a crew! Think of a programme which at any rate for a
while could bring Hitler, Petain, Montagu Norman, Pavelitch,
William Randolph Hearst, Streicher, Buchman, Ezra Pound,
Juan March, Cocteau, Thyssen, Father Coughlin, the Mufti of
Jerusalem, Arnold Lunn, Antonescu, Spengler, Beverley
Nichols, Lady Houston, and Marinetti all into the same boat!
But the clue is really very simple. They are all people with
something to lose, or people who long for a hierarchical
society and dread the prospect of a world of free and equal
human beings. Behind all the ballyhoo that is talked about
'godless' Russia and the 'materialism' of the working class
lies the simple intention of those with money or privileges
to cling to them. Ditto, though it contains a partial truth,
with all the talk about the worthlessness of social
reconstruction not accompanied by a 'change of heart'. The
pious ones, from the Pope to the yogis of California, are
great on the' change of heart', much more reassuring from
their point of view than a change in the economic system.
Petain attributes the fall of France to the common people's
'love of pleasure'. One sees this in its right perspective
if one stops to wonder how much pleasure the ordinary French
peasant's or working-man's life would contain compared with
Pétain's own. The damned impertinence of these politicians,
priests, literary men, and what-not who lecture the
working-class socialist for his 'materialism'! All that the
working man demands is what these others would consider the
indispensable minimum without which human life cannot be
lived at all. Enough to eat, freedom from the haunting
terror of unemployment, the knowledge that your children
will get a fair chance, a bath once a day, clean linen
reasonably often, a roof that doesn't leak, and short enough
working hours to leave you with a little energy when the day
is done. Not one of those who preach against 'materialism'
would consider life livable without these things. And how
easily that minimum could be attained if we chose to set our
minds to it for only twenty years! To raise the standard of
living of the whole world to that of Britain would not be a
greater undertaking than the war we have just fought. I
don't claim, and I don't know who does, that that wouldn't
solve anything in itself. It is merely that privation and
brute labour have to be abolished before the real problems
of humanity can be tackled. The major problem of our time is
the decay of the belief in personal immortality, and it
cannot be dealt with while the average human being is either
drudging like an ox or shivering in fear of the secret
police. How right the working classes are in their
'materialism'! How right they are to realize that the belly
comes before the soul, not in the scale of values but in
point of time! Understand that, and the long horror that we
are enduring becomes at least intelligible. All the
considerations are likely to make one falter—the siren
voices of a Pétain or of a Gandhi, the inescapable fact that
in order to fight one has to degrade oneself, the equivocal
moral position of Britain, with its democratic phrases and
its coolie empire, the sinister development of Soviet
Russia, the squalid farce of left-wing politics—all this
fades away and one sees only the struggle of the gradually
awakening common people against the lords of property and
their hired liars and bumsuckers. The question is very
simple. Shall people like that Italian soldier be allowed to
live the decent, fully human life which is now technically
achievable, or shan't they? Shall the common man be pushed
back into the mud, or shall he not? I myself believe,
perhaps on insufficient grounds, that the common man will
win his fight sooner or later, but I want it to be sooner
and not later—some time within the next hundred years, say,
and not some time within the next ten thousand years. That
was the real issue of the Spanish war, and of the last war,
and perhaps of other wars yet to come.

I never saw the Italian militiaman again, nor did I ever
learn his name. It can be taken as quite certain that he is
dead. Nearly two years later, when the war was visibly lost,
I wrote these verses in his memory:

The Italian soldier shook my hand
Beside the guard-room table;
The strong hand and the subtle hand
Whose palms are only able

To meet within the sound of guns,
But oh! what peace I knew then
In gazing on his battered face
Purer than any woman's!

For the flyblown words that make me spew
Still in his ears were holy,
And he was born knowing what I had learned
Out of books and slowly.
The treacherous guns had told their tale And we both had
bought it, But my gold brick was made of gold—Oh! who ever
would have thought it?
Good luck go with you, Italian soldier!
But luck is not for the brave;
What would the world give back to you?
Always less than you gave.

Between the shadow and the ghost,
Between the white and the red,
Between the bullet and the lie,
Where would you hide your head?

For where is Manuel Gonzalez,
And where is Pedro Aguilar,
And where is Ramon Fenellosa?
The earthworms know where they are.

Your name and your deeds were forgotten
Before your bones were dry,
And the lie that slew you is buried
Under a deeper lie;

But the thing that I saw in your face
No power can disinherit:
No bomb that ever burst
Shatters the crystal spirit.

RUDYARD KIPLING (1942)
It was a pity that Mr. Eliot should be so much on the
defensive in the long essay with which he prefaces this
selection of Kipling's poetry, but it was not to be avoided,
because before one can even speak about Kipling one has to
clear away a legend that has been created by two sets of
people who have not read his works. Kipling is in the
peculiar position of having been a byword for fifty years.
During five literary generations every enlightened person
has despised him, and at the end of that time nine-tenths of
those enlightened persons are forgotten and Kipling is in
some sense still there. Mr. Eliot never satisfactorily
explains this fact, because in answering the shallow and
familiar charge that Kipling is a 'Fascist', he falls into
the opposite error of defending him where he is not
defensible. It is no use pretending that Kipling's view of
life, as a whole, can be accepted or even forgiven by any
civilized person. It is no use claiming, for instance, that
when Kipling describes a British soldier beating a 'nigger'
with a cleaning rod in order to get money out of him, he is
acting merely as a reporter and does not necessarily approve
what he describes. There is not the slightest sign anywhere
in Kipling's work that he disapproves of that kind of
conduct—on the contrary, there is a definite strain of
sadism in him, over and above the brutality which a writer
of that type has to have. Kipling is a jingo imperialist, he
is morally insensitive and aesthetically disgusting. It is
better to start by admitting that, and then to try to find
out why it is that he survives while the refined people who
have sniggered at him seem to wear so badly.

And yet the 'Fascist' charge has to be answered, because the
first clue to any understanding of Kipling, morally or
politically, is the fact that he was not a Fascist. He was
further from being one than the most humane or the most
'progressive' person is able to be nowadays. An interesting
instance of the way in which quotations are parroted to and
fro without any attempt to look up their context or discover
their meaning is the line from 'Recessional', 'Lesser breeds
without the Law'. This line is always good for a snigger in
pansy-left circles. It is assumed as a matter of course that
the 'lesser breeds' are 'natives', and a mental picture is
called up of some pukka sahib in a pith helmet kicking a
coolie. In its context the sense of the line is almost the
exact opposite of this. The phrase 'lesser breeds' refers
almost certainly to the Germans, and especially the
pan-German writers, who are 'without the Law' in the sense
of being lawless, not in the sense of being powerless. The
whole poem, conventionally thought of as an orgy of
boasting, is a denunciation of power politics, British as
well as German. Two stanzas are worth quoting (I am quoting
this as politics, not as poetry):

If, drunk with sight of power, we loose
Wild tongues that have not Thee in awe,
Such boastings as the Gentiles use,
Or lesser breeds without the Law—Lord God of hosts, be with
us yet,
Lest we forget—lest we forget!

For heathen heart that puts her trust
In reeking tube and iron shard,
All valiant dust that builds on dust,
And guarding, calls not Thee to guard,
For frantic boast and foolish word—Thy mercy on Thy People,
Lord!
Much of Kipling's phraseology is taken from the Bible, and
no doubt in the second stanza he had in mind the text from
Psalm CXXVII: 'Except the lord build the house, they labour
in vain that build it; except the Lord keep the city, the
watchman waketh but in vain.' It is not a text that makes
much impression on the post-Hitler mind. No one, in our
time, believes in any sanction greater than military power;
no one believes that it is possible to overcome force except
by greater force. There is no 'Law', there is only power. I
am not saying that that is a true belief, merely that it is
the belief which all modern men do actually hold. Those who
pretend otherwise are either intellectual cowards, or
power-worshippers under a thin disguise, or have simply not
caught up with the age they are living in. Kipling's outlook
is pre-fascist. He still believes that pride comes before a
fall and that the gods punish hubris. He does not foresee
the tank, the bombing plane, the radio and the secret
police, or their psychological results.

But in saying this, does not one unsay what I said above
about Kipling's jingoism and brutality? No, one is merely
saying that the nineteenth-century imperialist outlook and
the modern gangster outlook are two different things.
Kipling belongs very definitely to the period 1885-1902. The
Great War and its aftermath embittered him, but he shows
little sign of having learned anything from any event later
than the Boer War. He was the prophet of British Imperialism
in its expansionist phase (even more than his poems, his
solitary novel, The Light that Failed, gives you the
atmosphere of that time) and also the unofficial historian
of the British Army, the old mercenary army which began to
change its shape in 1914. All his confidence, his bouncing
vulgar vitality, sprang out of limitations which no Fascist
or near-Fascist shares.

Kipling spent the later part of his life in sulking, and no
doubt it was political disappointment rather than literary
vanity that account for this. Somehow history had not gone
according to plan. After the greatest victory she had ever
known, Britain was a lesser world power than before, and
Kipling was quite acute enough to see this. The virtue had
gone out of the classes he idealized, the young were
hedonistic or disaffected, the desire to paint the map red
had evaporated. He could not understand what was happening,
because he had never had any grasp of the economic forces
underlying imperial expansion. It is notable that Kipling
does not seem to realize, any more than the average soldier
or colonial administrator, that an empire is primarily a
money-making concern. Imperialism as he sees it is a sort of
forcible evangelizing. You turn a Gatling gun on a mob of
unarmed 'natives', and then you establish 'the Law', which
includes roads, railways and a court-house. He could not
foresee, therefore, that the same motives which brought the
Empire into existence would end by destroying it. It was the
same motive, for example, that caused the Malayan jungles to
be cleared for rubber estates, and which now causes those
estates to be handed over intact to the Japanese. The modern
totalitarians know what they are doing, and the
nineteenth-century English did not know what they were
doing. Both attitudes have their advantages, but Kipling was
never able to move forward from one into the other. His
outlook, allowing for the fact that after all he was an
artist, was that of the salaried bureaucrat who despises the
'box-wallah' and often lives a lifetime without realizing
that the 'box-wallah' calls the tune.

But because he identifies himself with the official class,
he does possess one thing which 'enlightened' people seldom
or never possess, and that is a sense of responsibility. The
middle-class Left hate him for this quite as much as for his
cruelty and vulgarity. All left-wing parties in the highly
industrialized countries are at bottom a sham, because they
make it their business to fight against something which they
do not really wish to destroy. They have internationalist
aims, and at the same time they struggle to keep up a
standard of life with which those aims are incompatible. We
all live by robbing Asiatic coolies, and those of us who are
'enlightened' all maintain that those coolies ought to be
set free; but our standard of living, and hence our
'enlightenment', demands that the robbery shall continue. A
humanitarian is always a hypocrite, and Kipling's
understanding of this is perhaps the central secret of his
power to create telling phrases. It would be difficult to
hit off the one-eyed pacifism of the English in fewer words
than in the phrase, 'making mock of uniforms that guard you
while you sleep'. It is true that Kipling does not
understand the economic aspect of the relationship between
the highbrow and the blimp. He does not see that the map is
painted red chiefly in order that the coolie may be
exploited. Instead of the coolie he sees the Indian Civil
Servant; but even on that plane his grasp of function, of
who protects whom, is very sound. He sees clearly that men
can only be highly civilized while other men, inevitably
less civilized, are there to guard and feed them.

How far does Kipling really identify himself with the
administrators, soldiers and engineers whose praises he
sings? Not so completely as is sometimes assumed. He had
travelled very widely while he was still a young man, he had
grown up with a brilliant mind in mainly philistine
surroundings, and some streak in him that may have been
partly neurotic led him to prefer the active man to the
sensitive man. The nineteenth-century Anglo-Indians, to name
the least sympathetic of his idols, were at any rate people
who did things. It may be that all that they did was evil,
but they changed the face of the earth (it is instructive to
look at a map of Asia and compare the railway system of
India with that of the surrounding countries), whereas they
could have achieved nothing, could not have maintained
themselves in power for a single week, if the normal
Anglo-Indian outlook had been that of, say, E.M. Forster.
Tawdry and shallow though it is, Kipling's is the only
literary picture that we possess of nineteenth-century
Anglo-India, and he could only make it because he was just
coarse enough to be able to exist and keep his mouth shut in
clubs and regimental messes. But he did not greatly resemble
the people he admired. I know from several private sources
that many of the Anglo-Indians who were Kipling's
contemporaries did not like or approve of him. They said, no
doubt truly, that he knew nothing about India, and on the
other hand, he was from their point of view too much of a
highbrow. While in India he tended to mix with 'the wrong'
people, and because of his dark complexion he was wrongly
suspected of having a streak of Asiatic blood. Much in his
development is traceable to his having been born in India
and having left school early. With a slightly different
background he might have been a good novelist or a
superlative writer of music-hall songs. But how true is it
that he was a vulgar flag-waver, a sort of publicity agent
for Cecil Rhodes? It is true, but it is not true that he was
a yes-man or a time-server. After his early days, if then,
he never courted public opinion. Mr. Eliot says that what is
held against him is that he expressed unpopular views in a
popular style. This narrows the issue by assuming that
'unpopular' means unpopular with the intelligentsia, but it
is a fact that Kipling's 'message' was one that the big
public did not want, and, indeed, has never accepted. The
mass of the people, in the nineties as now, were
anti-militarist, bored by the Empire, and only unconsciously
patriotic. Kipling's official admirers are and were the
'service' middle class, the people who read Blackwood's. In
the stupid early years of this century, the blimps, having
at last discovered someone who could be called a poet and
who was on their side, set Kipling on a pedestal, and some
of his more sententious poems, such as 'If', were given
almost biblical status. But it is doubtful whether the
blimps have ever read him with attention, any more than they
have read the Bible. Much of what he says they could not
possibly approve. Few people who have criticized England
from the inside have said bitterer things about her than
this gutter patriot. As a rule it is the British working
class that he is attacking, but not always. That phrase
about 'the flannelled fools at the wicket and the muddied
oafs at the goal' sticks like an arrow to this day, and it
is aimed at the Eton and Harrow match as well as the Cup-Tie
Final. Some of the verses he wrote about the Boer War have a
curiously modern ring, so far as their subject-matter goes.
'Stellenbosch', which must have been written about 1902,
sums up what every intelligent infantry officer was saying
in 1918, or is saying now, for that matter.

Kipling's romantic ideas about England and the Empire might
not have mattered if he could have held them without having
the class-prejudices which at that time went with them. If
one examines his best and most representative work, his
soldier poems, especially Barrack-Room Ballads, one notices
that what more than anything else spoils them is an
underlying air of patronage. Kipling idealizes the army
officer, especially the junior officer, and that to an
idiotic extent, but the private soldier, though lovable and
romantic, has to be a comic. He is always made to speak in a
sort of stylized Cockney, not very broad but with all the
aitches and final "g's" carefully omitted. Very often the
result is as embarrassing as the humorous recitation at a
church social. And this accounts for the curious fact that
one can often improve Kipling's poems, make them less
facetious and less blatant, by simply going through them and
transplanting them from Cockney into standard speech. This
is especially true of his refrains, which often have a truly
lyrical quality. Two examples will do (one is about a
funeral and the other about a wedding):

So it's knock out your pipes and follow me!
And it's finish up your swipes and follow me!
Oh, hark to the big drum calling,
Follow me—follow me home!
and again:

Cheer for the Sergeant's wedding—Give them one cheer more!
Grey gun-horses in the lando,
And a rogue is married to a whore!
Here I have restored the aitches, etc. Kipling ought to have
known better. He ought to have seen that the two closing
lines of the first of these stanzas are very beautiful
lines, and that ought to have overriden his impulse to make
fun of a working-man's accent. In the ancient ballads the
lord and the peasant speak the same language. This is
impossible to Kipling, who is looking down a distorting
class-perspective, and by a piece of poetic justice one of
his best lines is spoiled—for 'follow me 'ome' is much
uglier than 'follow me home'. But even where it makes no
difference musically the facetiousness of his stage Cockney
dialect is irritating. However, he is more often quoted
aloud than read on the printed page, and most people
instinctively make the necessary alterations when they quote
him.

Can one imagine any private soldier, in the nineties or now,
reading Barrack-Room Ballads and feeling that here was a
writer who spoke for him? It is very hard to do so. Any
soldier capable of reading a book of verse would notice at
once that Kipling is almost unconscious of the class war
that goes on in an army as much as elsewhere. It is not only
that he thinks the soldier comic, but that he thinks him
patriotic, feudal, a ready admirer of his officers and proud
to be a soldier of the Queen. Of course that is partly true,
or battles could not be fought, but 'What have I done for
thee, England, my England?' is essentially a middle-class
query. Almost any working man would follow it up immediately
with 'What has England done for me?' In so far as Kipling
grasps this, he simply sets it down to 'the intense
selfishness of the lower classes' (his own phrase). When he
is writing not of British but of 'loyal' Indians he carries
the 'Salaam, sahib' motif to sometimes disgusting lengths.
Yet it remains true that he has far more interest in the
common soldier, far more anxiety that he shall get a fair
deal, than most of the 'liberals' of his day or our own. He
sees that the soldier is neglected, meanly underpaid and
hypocritically despised by the people whose incomes he
safeguards. 'I came to realize', he says in his posthumous
memoirs, 'the bare horrors of the private's life, and the
unnecessary torments he endured'. He is accused of
glorifying war, and perhaps he does so, but not in the usual
manner, by pretending that war is a sort of football match.
Like most people capable of writing battle poetry, Kipling
had never been in battle, but his vision of war is
realistic. He knows that bullets hurt, that under fire
everyone is terrified, that the ordinary soldier never knows
what the war is about or what is happening except in his own
corner of the battlefield, and that British troops, like
other troops, frequently run away:

I 'eard the knives be'ind me, but I dursn't face my man,
Nor I don't know where I went to, 'cause I didn't stop to
see,
Till I 'eard a beggar squealin' out for quarter as 'e ran,
An' I thought I knew the voice an'—it was me!
Modernize the style of this, and it might have come out of
one of the debunking war books of the nineteen-twenties. Or
again:

An' now the hugly bullets come peckin' through the dust,
An' no one wants to face 'em, but every beggar must;
So, like a man in irons, which isn't glad to go,
They moves 'em off by companies uncommon stiff an' slow.
Compare this with:

Forward the Light Brigade!
Was there a man dismayed?
No! though the soldier knew
Someone had blundered.
If anything, Kipling overdoes the horrors, for the wars of
his youth were hardly wars at all by our standards. Perhaps
that is due to the neurotic strain in him, the hunger for
cruelty. But at least he knows that men ordered to attack
impossible objectives are dismayed, and also that fourpence
a day is not a generous pension.

How complete or truthful a picture has Kipling left us of
the long-service, mercenary army of the late nineteenth
century? One must say of this, as of what Kipling wrote
about nineteenth-century Anglo-India, that it is not only
the best but almost the only literary picture we have. He
has put on record an immense amount of stuff that one could
otherwise only gather from verbal tradition or from
unreadable regimental histories. Perhaps his picture of army
life seems fuller and more accurate than it is because any
middle-class English person is likely to know enough to fill
up the gaps. At any rate, reading the essay on Kipling that
Mr. Edmund Wilson has just published or is just about to
publish [Note, below], I was struck by the number of things
that are boringly familiar to us and seem to be barely
intelligible to an American. But from the body of Kipling's
early work there does seem to emerge a vivid and not
seriously misleading picture of the old pre-machine-gun
army—the sweltering barracks in Gibraltar or Lucknow, the
red coats, the pipeclayed belts and the pillbox hats, the
beer, the fights, the floggings, hangings and crucifixions,
the bugle-calls, the smell of oats and horsepiss, the
bellowing sergeants with foot-long moustaches, the bloody
skirmishes, invariably mismanaged, the crowded troopships,
the cholera-stricken camps, the 'native' concubines, the
ultimate death in the workhouse. It is a crude, vulgar
picture, in which a patriotic music-hall turn seems to have
got mixed up with one of Zola's gorier passages, but from it
future generations will be able to gather some idea of what
a long-term volunteer army was like. On about the same level
they will be able to learn something of British India in the
days when motor-cars and refrigerators were unheard of. It
is an error to imagine that we might have had better books
on these subjects if, for example, George Moore, or Gissing,
or Thomas Hardy, had had Kipling's opportunities. That is
the kind of accident that cannot happen. It was not possible
that nineteenth-century England should produce a book like
War And Peace, or like Tolstoy's minor stories of army life,
such as Sebastopol or The Cossacks, not because the talent
was necessarily lacking but because no one with sufficient
sensitiveness to write such books would ever have made the
appropriate contacts. Tolstoy lived in a great military
empire in which it seemed natural for almost any young man
of family to spend a few years in the army, whereas the
British Empire was and still is demilitarized to a degree
which continental observers find almost incredible.
Civilized men do not readily move away from the centres of
civilization, and in most languages there is a great dearth
of what one might call colonial literature. It took a very
improbable combination of circumstances to produce Kipling's
gaudy tableau, in which Private Ortheris and Mrs. Hauksbee
pose against a background of palm trees to the sound of
temple bells, and one necessary circumstance was that
Kipling himself was only half civilized.

[Note: Published in a volume of Collected Essays, The Wound
and the Bow. Author's footnote 1945]

Kipling is the only English writer of our time who has added
phrases to the language. The phrases and neologisms which we
take over and use without remembering their origin do not
always come from writers we admire. It is strange, for
instance, to hear the Nazi broadcasters referring to the
Russian soldiers as 'robots', thus unconsciously borrowing a
word from a Czech democrat whom they would have killed if
they could have laid hands on him. Here are half a dozen
phrases coined by Kipling which one sees quoted in
leaderettes in the gutter press or overhears in saloon bars
from people who have barely heard his name. It will be seen
that they all have a certain characteristic in common:

East is East, and West is West.
The white man's burden.
What do they know of England who only England know?
The female of the species is more deadly than the male.
Somewhere East of Suez.
Paying the Dane-geld.
There are various others, including some that have outlived
their context by many years. The phrase 'killing Kruger with
your mouth', for instance, was current till very recently.
It is also possible that it was Kipling who first let loose
the use of the word 'Huns' for Germans; at any rate he began
using it as soon as the guns opened fire in 1914. But what
the phrases I have listed above have in common is that they
are all of them phrases which one utters semi-derisively (as
it might be 'For I'm to be Queen o' the May, mother, I'm to
be Queen o' the May'), but which one is bound to make use of
sooner or later. Nothing could exceed the contempt of the
New Statesman, for instance, for Kipling, but how many times
during the Munich period did the New Statesman find itself
quoting that phrase about paying the Dane-geld? [Note,
below.] The fact is that Kipling, apart from his snack-bar
wisdom and his gift for packing much cheap picturesqueness
into a few words ('palm and pine'—'east of Suez'—'the road
to Mandalay'), is generally talking about things that are of
urgent interest. It does not matter, from this point of
view, that thinking and decent people generally find
themselves on the other side of the fence from him. 'White
man's burden' instantly conjures up a real problem, even if
one feels that it ought to be altered to 'black man's
burden'. One may disagree to the middle of one's bones with
the political attitude implied in 'The Islanders', but one
cannot say that it is a frivolous attitude. Kipling deals in
thoughts which are both vulgar and permanent. This raises
the question of his special status as a poet, or
verse-writer.

[Note: On the first page of his recent book, Adam and Eve,
Mr. Middleton Murry quotes the well-known lines:

There are nine and sixty ways
Of constructing tribal lays,
And every single one of them is right.
He attributes these lines to Thackeray. This is probably
what is known as a 'Freudian error.' A civilized person
would prefer not to quote Kipling—i.e. would prefer not to
feel that it was Kipling who had expressed his thought for
him. (Author's footnote 1945.)]

Mr. Eliot describes Kipling's metrical work as 'verse' and
not 'poetry', but adds that it is 'great verse', and further
qualifies this by saying that a writer can only be described
as a 'great verse-writer' if there is some of his work 'of
which we cannot say whether it is verse or poetry'.
Apparently Kipling was a versifier who occasionally wrote
poems, in which case it was a pity that Mr. Eliot did not
specify these poems by name. The trouble is that whenever an
aesthetic judgement on Kipling's work seems to be called
for, Mr. Eliot is too much on the defensive to be able to
speak plainly. What he does not say, and what I think one
ought to start by saying in any discussion of Kipling, is
that most of Kipling's verse is so horribly vulgar that it
gives one the same sensation as one gets from watching a
third-rate music-hall performer recite 'The Pigtail of Wu
Fang Fu' with the purple limelight on his face, and yet
there is much of it that is capable of giving pleasure to
people who know what poetry means. At his worst, and also
his most vital, in poems like 'Gunga Din' or 'Danny Deever',
Kipling is almost a shameful pleasure, like the taste for
cheap sweets that some people secretly carry into middle
life. But even with his best passages one has the same sense
of being seduced by something spurious, and yet
unquestionably seduced. Unless one is merely a snob and a
liar it is impossible to say that no one who cares for
poetry could get any pleasure out of such lines as:

For the wind is in the palm trees, and the temple bells they
say,
'Come you back, you British soldier, come you back to
Mandalay!'
and yet those lines are not poetry in the same sense as
'Felix Randal' or 'When icicles hang by the wall' are
poetry. One can, perhaps, place Kipling more satisfactorily
than by juggling with the words 'verse' and 'poetry', if one
describes him simply as a good bad poet. He is as a poet
what Harriet Beecher Stowe was as a novelist. And the mere
existence of work of this kind, which is perceived by
generation after generation to be vulgar and yet goes on
being read, tells one something about the age we live in.

There is a great deal of good bad poetry in English, all of
it, I should say, subsequent to 1790. Examples of good bad
poems—I am deliberately choosing diverse ones—are 'The
Bridge of Sighs', 'When all the world is young, lad', 'The
Charge of the Light Brigade', Bret Harte's 'Dickens in
Camp', 'The Burial of Sir John Moore', 'Jenny Kissed Me',
'Keith of Ravelston', 'Casabianca'. All of these reek of
sentimentality, and yet—not these particular poems, perhaps,
but poems of this kind, are capable of giving true pleasure
to people who can see clearly what is wrong with them. One
could fill a fair-sized anthology with good bad poems, if it
were not for the significant fact that good bad poetry is
usually too well known to be worth reprinting.

It is no use pretending that in an age like our own, 'good'
poetry can have any genuine popularity. It is, and must be,
the cult of a very few people, the least tolerated of the
arts. Perhaps that statement needs a certain amount of
qualification. True poetry can sometimes be acceptable to
the mass of the people when it disguises itself as something
else. One can see an example of this in the folk-poetry that
England still possesses, certain nursery rhymes and mnemonic
rhymes, for instance, and the songs that soldiers make up,
including the words that go to some of the bugle-calls. But
in general ours is a civilization in which the very word
'poetry' evokes a hostile snigger or, at best, the sort of
frozen disgust that most people feel when they hear the word
'God'. If you are good at playing the concertina you could
probably go into the nearest public bar and get yourself an
appreciative audience within five minutes. But what would be
the attitude of that same audience if you suggested reading
them Shakespeare's sonnets, for instance? Good bad poetry,
however, can get across to the most unpromising audiences if
the right atmosphere has been worked up beforehand. Some
months back Churchill produced a great effect by quoting
Clough's 'Endeavour' in one of his broadcast speeches. I
listened to this speech among people who could certainly not
be accused of caring for poetry, and I am convinced that the
lapse into verse impressed them and did not embarrass them.
But not even Churchill could have got away with it if he had
quoted anything much better than this.

In so far as a writer of verse can be popular, Kipling has
been and probably still is popular. In his own lifetime some
of his poems travelled far beyond the bounds of the reading
public, beyond the world of school prize-days, Boy Scout
sing-songs, limp-leather editions, poker-work and calendars,
and out into the yet vaster world of the music halls.
Nevertheless, Mr. Eliot thinks it worth while to edit him,
thus confessing to a taste which others share but are not
always honest enough to mention. The fact that such a thing
as good bad poetry can exist is a sign of the emotional
overlap between the intellectual and the ordinary man. The
intellectual is different from the ordinary man, but only in
certain sections of his personality, and even then not all
the time. But what is the peculiarity of a good bad poem? A
good bad poem is a graceful monument to the obvious. It
records in memorable form—for verse is a mnemonic device,
among other things—some emotion which very nearly every
human being can share. The merit of a poem like 'When all
the world is young, lad' is that, however sentimental it may
be, its sentiment is 'true' sentiment in the sense that you
are bound to find yourself thinking the thought it expresses
sooner or later; and then, if you happen to know the poem,
it will come back into your mind and seem better than it did
before. Such poems are a kind of rhyming proverb, and it is
a fact that definitely popular poetry is usually gnomic or
sententious. One example from Kipling will do:

White hands cling to the bridle rein,
Slipping the spur from the booted heel;
Tenderest voices cry 'Turn again!'
Red lips tarnish the scabbarded steel:
Down to Gehenna or up to the Throne,
He travels the fastest who travels alone.
There is a vulgar thought vigorously expressed. It may not
be true, but at any rate it is a thought that everyone
thinks. Sooner or later you will have occasion to feel that
he travels the fastest who travels alone, and there the
thought is, ready made and, as it were, waiting for you. So
the chances are that, having once heard this line, you will
remember it.

One reason for Kipling's power as a good bad poet I have
already suggested—his sense of responsibility, which made it
possible for him to have a world-view, even though it
happened to be a false one. Although he had no direct
connexion with any political party, Kipling was a
Conservative, a thing that does not exist nowadays. Those
who now call themselves Conservatives are either Liberals,
Fascists or the accomplices of Fascists. He identified
himself with the ruling power and not with the opposition.
In a gifted writer this seems to us strange and even
disgusting, but it did have the advantage of giving Kipling
a certain grip on reality. The ruling power is always faced
with the question, 'In such and such circumstances, what
would you do?', whereas the opposition is not obliged to
take responsibility or make any real decisions. Where it is
a permanent and pensioned opposition, as in England, the
quality of its thought deteriorates accordingly. Moreover,
anyone who starts out with a pessimistic, reactionary view
of life tends to be justified by events, for Utopia never
arrives and 'the gods of the copybook headings', as Kipling
himself put it, always return. Kipling sold out to the
British governing class, not financially but emotionally.
This warped his political judgement, for the British ruling
class were not what he imagined, and it led him into abysses
of folly and snobbery, but he gained a corresponding
advantage from having at least tried to imagine what action
and responsibility are like. It is a great thing in his
favour that he is not witty, not 'daring', has no wish to
épater les bourgeois. He dealt largely in platitudes, and
since we live in a world of platitudes, much of what he said
sticks. Even his worst follies seem less shallow and less
irritating than the 'enlightened' utterances of the same
period, such as Wilde's epigrams or the collection of
cracker-mottoes at the end of Man and Superman.


MARK TWAIN—THE LICENSED JESTER (1943)
Mark Twain has crashed the lofty gates of the Everyman
library, but only with Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn,
already fairly well known under the guise of 'children's
books' (which they are not). His best and most
characteristic books, Roughing It, The Innocents at Home,
and even Life on the Mississippi, are little remembered in
this country, though no doubt in America the patriotism
which is everywhere mixed up with literary judgement keeps
them alive.

Although Mark Twain produced a surprising variety of books,
ranging from a namby-pamby 'life' of Joan of Arc to a
pamphlet so obscene that it has never been publicly printed,
all that is best in his work centres about the Mississippi
river and the wild mining towns of the West. Born in 1835
(he came of a Southern family, a family just rich enough to
own one or perhaps two slaves), he had had his youth and
early manhood in the golden age of America, the period when
the great plains were opened up, when wealth and opportunity
seemed limitless, and human beings felt free, indeed were
free, as they had never been before and may not be again for
centuries. Life On The Mississippi and the two other books
that I have mentioned are a ragbag of anecdotes, scenic
descriptions and social history both serious and burlesque,
but they have a central theme which could perhaps be put
into these words: 'This is how human beings behave when they
are not frightened of the sack.' In writing these books Mark
Twain is not consciously writing a hymn to liberty.
Primarily he is interested in 'character', in the fantastic,
almost lunatic variations which human nature is capable of
when economic pressure and tradition are both removed from
it. The raftsmen, Mississippi pilots, miners and bandits
whom he describes are probably not much exaggerated, but
they are as different from modern men, and from one another,
as the gargoyles of a medieval cathedral. They could develop
their strange and sometimes sinister individuality because
of the lack of any outside pressure. The State hardly
existed, the churches were weak and spoke with many voices,
and land was to be had for the taking. If you disliked your
job you simply hit the boss in the eye and moved further
west; and moreover, money was so plentiful that the smallest
coin in circulation was worth a shilling. The American
pioneers were not supermen, and they were not especially
courageous. Whole towns of hardy gold miners let themselves
be terrorized by bandits whom they lacked the public spirit
to put down. They were not even free from class
distinctions. The desperado who stalked through the streets
of the mining settlement, with a Derringer pistol in his
waistcoat pocket and twenty corpses to his credit, was
dressed in a frock coat and shiny top-hat, described himself
firmly as a 'gentleman' and was meticulous about table
manners. But at least it was not the case that a man's
destiny was settled from his birth. The 'log cabin to White
House' myth was true while the free land lasted. In a way,
it was for this that the Paris mob had stormed the Bastille,
and when one reads Mark Twain, Bret Harte and Whitman it is
hard to feel that their effort was wasted.

However, Mark Twain aimed at being something more than a
chronicler of the Mississippi and the Gold Rush. In his own
day he was famous all over the world as a humorist and comic
lecturer. In New York, London, Berlin, Vienna, Melbourne and
Calcutta vast audiences rocked with laughter over jokes
which have now, almost without exception, ceased to be
funny. (It is worth noticing that Mark Twain's lectures were
only a success with Anglo-Saxon and German audiences. The
relatively grown-up Latin races—whose own humour, he
complained, always centred round sex and politics—never
cared for them.) But in addition, Mark Twain had some
pretensions to being a social critic, even a species of
philosopher. He had in him an iconoclastic, even
revolutionary vein which he obviously wanted to follow up
and yet somehow never did follow up. He might have been a
destroyer of humbugs and a prophet of democracy more
valuable than Whitman, because healthier and more humorous.
Instead he became that dubious thing a 'public figure',
flattered by passport officials and entertained by royalty,
and his career reflects the deterioration in American life
that set in after the Civil War.

Mark Twain has sometimes been compared with his
contemporary, Anatole France. This comparison is not so
pointless as it may sound. Both men were the spiritual
children of Voltaire, both had an ironical, sceptical view
of life, and a native pessimism overlaid by gaiety; both
knew that the existing social order is a swindle and its
cherished beliefs mostly delusions. Both were bigoted
atheists and convinced (in Mark Twain's case this was
Darwin's doing) of the unbearable cruelty of the universe.
But there the resemblance ends. Not only is the Frenchman
enormously more learned, more civilized, more alive
aesthetically, but he is also more courageous. He does
attack the things he disbelieves in; he does not, like Mark
swain, always take refuge behind the amiable mask of the
'public figure' and the licensed jester. He is ready to risk
the anger of the Church and to take the unpopular side in a
controversy—in the Dreyfus case, for example. Mark Twain,
except perhaps in one short essay 'What is Man?', never
attacks established beliefs in a way that is likely to get
him into trouble. Nor could he ever wean himself from the
notion, which is perhaps especially an American notion, that
success and virtue are the same thing.

In Life on the Mississippi there is a queer little
illustration of the central weakness of Mark Twain's
character. In the earlier part of this mainly
autobiographical book the dates have been altered. Mark
Twain describes his adventures as a Mississippi pilot as
though he had been a boy of about seventeen at the time,
whereas in fact he was a young man of nearly thirty. There
is a reason for this. The same part of the book describes
his exploits in the Civil War, which were distinctly
inglorious. Moreover, Mark Twain started by fighting, if he
can be said to have fought, on the Southern side, and then
changed his allegiance before the war was over. This kind of
behaviour is more excusable in a boy than in a man, whence
the adjustment of the dates. It is also clear enough,
however, that he changed sides because he saw that the North
was going to win; and this tendency to side with the
stronger whenever possible, to believe that might must be
right, is apparent throughout his career. In Roughing It
there is an interesting account of a bandit named Slade,
who, among countless other outrages, had committed
twenty-eight murders. It is perfectly clear that Mark Twain
admires this disgusting scoundrel. Slade was successful;
therefore he was admirable. This outlook, no less common
today, is summed up in the significant American expression
'to Make Good.'

In the money-grubbing period that followed the Civil War it
was hard for anyone of Mark Twain's temperament to refuse to
be a success. The old, simple, stump-whittling,
tobacco-chewing democracy which Abraham Lincoln typified was
perishing: it was now the age of cheap immigrant labour and
the growth of Big Business. Mark Twain mildly satirized his
contemporaries in The Gilded Age, but he also gave himself
up to the prevailing fever, and made and lost vast sums of
money. He even for a period of years deserted writing for
business; and he squandered his time on buffooneries, not
merely lecture tours and public banquets, but, for instance,
the writing of a book like A Connecticut Yankee in King
Arthur's Court, which is a deliberate flattery of all that
is worst and most vulgar in American life. The man who might
have been a kind of rustic Voltaire became the world's
leading after-dinner speaker, charming alike for his
anecdotes and his power to make businessmen feel themselves
public benefactors.

It is usual to blame Mark Twain's wife for his failure to
write the books he ought to have written, and it is evident
that she did tyrannize over him pretty thoroughly. Each
morning, Mark Twain would show her what he had written the
day before, and Mrs. Clemens (Mark Twain's real name was
Samuel Clemens) would go over it with the blue pencil,
cutting out everything that she thought unsuitable. She
seems to have been a drastic blue-penciller even by
nineteenth-century standards. There is an account in W.D.
Howells's book My Mark Twain of the fuss that occurred over
a terrible expletive that had crept into Huckleberry Finn.
Mark Twain appealed to Howells, who admitted that it was
'just what Huck would have said', but agreed with Mrs.
Clemens that the word could not possibly be printed. The
word was 'hell'. Nevertheless, no writer is really the
intellectual slave of his wife. Mrs. Clemens could not have
stopped Mark Twain writing any book he really wanted to
write. She may have made his surrender to society easier,
but the surrender happened because of that flaw in his own
nature, his inability to despise success.

Several of Mark Twain's books are bound to survive, because
they contain invaluable social history. His life covered the
great period of American expansion. When he was a child it
was a normal day's outing to go with a picnic lunch and
watch the hanging of an Abolitionist, and when he died the
aeroplane was ceasing to be a novelty. This period in
America produced relatively little literature, and but for
Mark Twain our picture of a Mississippi paddle-steamer, or a
stage-coach crossing the plains, would be much dimmer than
it is. But most people who have studied his work have come
away with a feeling that he might have done something more.
He gives all the while a strange impression of being about
to say something and then funking it, so that Life on the
Mississippi and the rest of them seem to be haunted by the
ghost of a greater and much more coherent book.
Significantly, he starts his autobiography by remarking that
a man's inner life is indescribable. We do not know what he
would have said—it is just possible that the unprocurable
pamphlet, 1601, would supply a clue but we may guess that it
would have wrecked his reputation and reduced his income to
reasonable proportions.





Fifty Essays

by George Orwell




       Richest Passages

1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10

11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18

19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26

27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34

35  36  37  38  39  40  41  42

43  44  45  46  47  48  49  50

51  52  53  54  55  56  57  58